Yigal Dror

Distinct routes of lineage development reshape the human blood hierarchy across ontogeny

Adjusting hematopoietic hierarchy In adults, more than 300 billion blood cells are replenished daily. This output arises from a cellular hierarchy where stem cells differentiate into a series of multilineage progenitors, culminating in unilineage progenitors that generate over 10 different mature blood cell types. Notta et al. mapped the lineage potential of nearly 3000 single cells from 33 different cell populations of stem and progenitor cells from fetal liver, cord blood, and adult bone marrow (see the Perspective by Cabezas-Wallscheid and Trumpp). Prenatally, stem cell and progenitor populations were multilineage with few unilineage progenitors. In adults, multilineage cell potential was only seen in stem cell populations. Science, this issue p. 10.1126/science.aab2116; see also p. 126 As humans age, progenitor cells take over from stem cells the task of producing a steady supply of blood cells. [Also see Perspective by Cabezas-Wallscheid and Trumpp] INTRODUCTION The hematopoietic road map is a compilation of the various lineage differentiation routes that a stem cell takes to make blood. This program produces greater than 10 blood cell fates and is responsible for generating more than 300 billion cells daily. On several occasions over the past six decades, the murine road map has been reconceived due to new information overturning dogma. However, the human road map has changed little. In the human model, blood differentiation initiates at the level of multipotent stem cells and passes through a series of increasingly lineage-restricted oligopotent and, finally, unipotent progenitor intermediates. One critical oligopotent intermediate is the common myeloid progenitor (CMP), believed to be the origin of all myeloid (My), erythroid (Er), and megakaryocyte (Mk) cells. Although murine studies challenge the existence of oligopotent progenitors, a comprehensive analysis of human My-Er-Mk differentiation is lacking. Moreover, whether the pool of oligopotent intermediates is fixed across human development (fetal to adult) is unknown. RATIONALE The differentiation road map taken by human hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) is fundamental to our understanding of blood homeostasis, hematopoietic malignancies, and regenerative medicine. RESULTS We mapped the cellular origins of My, Er, and Mk lineages across three time points in human blood development: fetal liver (FL), neonatal cord blood (CB), and adult bone marrow (BM). Using a cell-sorting scheme based on markers linked to Er and Mk lineage specification (CD71 and CD110), we found that previously described populations of multipotent progenitors (MPPs), CMPs, and megakaryocyte-erythroid progenitors (MEPs) were heterogeneous and could be further purified. Nearly 3000 single cells from 11 cellular subsets from the CD34+ compartment of FL, CB, and BM (33 subsets in total) were evaluated for their My, Er, and Mk lineage potential using an optimized single-cell assay. In FL, the ratio of cells with multilineage versus unilineage potential remained constant in both the stem cell (CD34+CD38–) and progenitor cell (CD34+CD38+) enriched compartments. By contrast, in BM, nearly all multipotent cells were restricted to the stem cell compartment, whereas unilineage progenitors dominated the progenitor cell compartment. Oligopotent progenitors were only a negligible component of the human blood hierarchy in BM, leading to the inference that multipotent cells differentiate into unipotent cells directly by adulthood. Mk/Er activity predominantly originated from the stem cell compartment at all developmental time points. In CB and BM, most Mks emerged as part of mixed clones from HSCs/MPPs, indicating that Mks directly branch from a multipotent cell and not from oligopotent progenitors like CMP. In FL, an almost pure Mk/Er progenitor was identified in the stem cell compartment, although less potent Mk/Er progenitors were also present in the progenitor compartment. In a hematological condition of HSC loss (aplastic anemia), Mk/Er but not My progenitors were more severely depleted, pinpointing a close physiological connection between HSC and the Mk/Er lineage. CONCLUSION Our data indicate that there are distinct road maps of blood differentiation across human development. Prenatally, Mk/Er lineage branching occurs throughout the cellular hierarchy. By adulthood, both Mk/Er activity and multipotency are restricted to the stem cell compartment, whereas the progenitor compartment is composed of unilineage progenitors forming a “two-tier” system, with few intervening oligopotent intermediates. Roadmaps of human blood stem cell differentiation. The classical model envisions that oligopotent progenitors such as CMP are an essential intermediate stage from which My/Er/Mk differentiation originates. The redefined model proposes a developmental shift in the progenitor cell architecture from the fetus, where many stem and progenitor cell types are multipotent, to the adult, where the stem cell compartment is multipotent but the progenitors are unipotent. The grayed planes represent theoretical tiers of differentiation. In a classical view of hematopoiesis, the various blood cell lineages arise via a hierarchical scheme starting with multipotent stem cells that become increasingly restricted in their differentiation potential through oligopotent and then unipotent progenitors. We developed a cell-sorting scheme to resolve myeloid (My), erythroid (Er), and megakaryocytic (Mk) fates from single CD34+ cells and then mapped the progenitor hierarchy across human development. Fetal liver contained large numbers of distinct oligopotent progenitors with intermingled My, Er, and Mk fates. However, few oligopotent progenitor intermediates were present in the adult bone marrow. Instead, only two progenitor classes predominate, multipotent and unipotent, with Er-Mk lineages emerging from multipotent cells. The developmental shift to an adult “two-tier” hierarchy challenges current dogma and provides a revised framework to understand normal and disease states of human hematopoiesis.

Shwachman syndrome: Phenotypic manifestations of sibling sets and isolated cases in a large patient cohort are similar

OBJECTIVES With the use of clinical data from a large international cohort, we evaluated and compared affected siblings and isolated cases. STUDY DESIGN Data from 116 families were collected, and patients conforming to our predetermined diagnostic criteria were analyzed. Phenotypic manifestations of affected siblings and singletons were compared with the use of t tests, Wilcoxon scores, and chi2 analysis. RESULTS Eighty-eight patients (33 female, 55 male; median age 5.20 years) fulfilled our predetermined diagnostic criteria for Shwachman syndrome; 63 patients were isolated cases, and 25 affected siblings were from 12 multiplex families. Steatorrhea was present in 86% (57 of 66), and 91% (78 of 86) displayed a low serum trypsinogen concentration. Patients older than 4 years more often had pancreatic sufficiency. Neutropenia occurred in 98%, anemia in 42%, and thrombocytopenia in 34%. Myelodysplasia or cytogenetic abnormalities were reported in 7 patients. Short stature with normal nutritional status was a prominent feature. CONCLUSIONS Clinical features among patients with Shwachman syndrome varied between patients and with age. Similarities in phenotype between isolated cases and affected sibling sets support the hypothesis that Shwachman syndrome is a single disease entity.

Shwachman–Diamond Syndrome

Shwachman-Diamond syndrome (SDS) is an inherited marrow failure disorder with varying cytopenia, pancreatic dysfunction, and metaphyseal dysostosis. SDS is also characterized by a risk of myelodysplasia and leukemia in up to one third of the patients. Over the last 5 years, major advances have been made in understanding the bone marrow phenotype. The gene associated with the disease, SBDS, has recently been identified. Herein we provide an update on the clinical features, the hematopoietic defects, and the genetics of the disease as they are currently understood. We also review the diagnostic and therapeutic approaches to the hematological complications in the syndrome.

Stable long-term risk of leukaemia in patients with severe congenital neutropenia maintained on G-CSF therapy

In severe congenital neutropenia (SCN), long‐term therapy with granulocyte colony‐stimulating factor (G‐CSF) has reduced mortality from sepsis, revealing an underlying predisposition to myelodysplastic syndrome and acute myeloid leukaemia (MDS/AML). We have reported the early pattern of evolution to MDS/AML, but the long‐term risk remains uncertain. We updated a prospective study of 374 SCN patients on long‐term G‐CSF enrolled in the Severe Chronic Neutropenia International Registry. Long‐term, the annual risk of MDS/AML attained a plateau (2·3%/year after 10 years). This risk now appears similar to, rather than higher than, the risk of AML in Fanconi anaemia and dyskeratosis congenita.

LYMPHOPROLIFERATIVE DISORDERS AFTER ORGAN TRANSPLANTATION IN CHILDREN

BACKGROUND After organ transplant, patients are at risk of posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorders (PTLD). The purpose of this study was to analyze 26 pediatric cases of PTLD observed at our institution between 1988 and 1996, and to evaluate the validity of the Society for Hematopathology Workshop (SHPW) 1997 classification in our patient population. METHODS Charts were reviewed for analysis of incidence, clinical course, and outcome. Tissue samples were classified by a pathologist according to SHPW recommendations. RESULTS By morphology, 20 were monomorphic, 5 polymorphic, and 1 hyperplastic. Assessment of lineage by morphology, molecular studies, and immunophenotyping did not correlate in six cases. By immunophenotyping, 12 were B cell, 4 T cell, 8 mixed B/T cells, and 2 undetermined. The 20 patients evaluable for treatment efficacy were treated with various therapeutic combinations, including immunosuppressive drug reduction, acyclovir/ganciclovir, interferon-alpha, immunoglobulins, surgery, and local irradiation. No patient received systemic chemotherapy. Thirteen patients achieved complete remission and 3, partial; 1 died 5 days after starting therapy, and 3 of progressive disease. Adverse prognostic factors included low platelet or neutrophil counts; stage III-IV and SHPW morphology were marginally significant. CONCLUSIONS The majority of patients eligible for treatment can be cured with immunosuppressive drug reduction and antiviral drugs, along with surgery and irradiation when indicated. Systemic chemotherapy or innovative approaches may have a role in unresponsive cases. Morphologic SHPW grouping is feasible and seems to have clinical relevance. However, correlation with clonality and immunophenotyping is not always possible, necessitating modifications including segregation of descriptive morphology from clonality and cell origin.

Shwachman-Diamond syndrome.

Shwachman‐Diamond syndrome (SDS) is an inherited marrow failure disorder with varying cytopenia, pancreatic dysfunction, and metaphyseal dysostosis. SDS is also characterized by a risk of myelodysplasia and leukemia in up to one third of the patients. Over the last 5 years, major advances have been made in understanding the bone marrow phenotype. The gene associated with the disease, SBDS, has recently been identified. Herein we provide an update on the clinical features, the hematopoietic defects, and the genetics of the disease as they are currently understood. We also review the diagnostic and therapeutic approaches to the hematological complications in the syndrome.

Draft consensus guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of Shwachman-Diamond syndrome

Shwachman‐Diamond syndrome (SDS) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterized by pancreatic exocrine insufficiency and bone marrow failure, often associated with neurodevelopmental and skeletal abnormalities. Mutations in the SBDS gene have been shown to cause SDS. The purpose of this document is to provide draft guidelines for diagnosis, evaluation of organ and system abnormalities, and treatment of hematologic, pancreatic, dietary, dental, skeletal, and neurodevelopmental complications. New recommendations regarding diagnosis and management are presented, reflecting advances in understanding the genetic basis and clinical manifestations of the disease based on the consensus of experienced clinicians from Canada, Europe, and the United States. Whenever possible, evidence‐based conclusions are made, but as with other rare diseases, the data on SDS are often anecdotal. The authors welcome comments from readers.

Immune function in patients with Shwachman–Diamond syndrome

Shwachman–Diamond syndrome (SDS) is an inherited multisystem disorder characterized by exocrine pancreatic dysfunction and varying degrees of cytopenia. In addition, various immunological abnormalities have been noted. To clarify the issue of immunological competence or incompetence in SDS, we prospectively studied immune function in 11 patients with SDS. Seven suffered from recurrent bacterial infections and six from recurrent viral infections. Varying degrees of impairment were readily identified. All patients had neutropenia; total lymphocyte counts, however, were normal in all except one patient. Nine patients had B‐cell defects comprising one or more of the following abnormalities: low IgG or IgG subclasses, low percentage of circulating B lymphocytes, decreased in vitro B‐lymphocyte proliferation and a lack of specific antibody production. Seven out of nine patients studied had at least one T‐cell abnormality comprising a low percentage of total circulating T lymphocytes or CD3+/CD4+ cell subpopulations or decreased in vitro T‐lymphocyte proliferation. Five out of six patients studied had decreased percentages of circulating natural killer cells. Moreover, neutrophil chemotaxis was significantly low in all the patients studied. These data point to a major immunodeficiency component in SDS that places patients at heightened risk of infections, even if neutrophil numbers are protective. This finding broadens the definition of the syndrome substantially: it suggests that the SDS marrow defect occurs at the level of an early haematological–lymphocytic stem cell or that a combined marrow and thymic stromal defect accounts for the aberrant function of haematopoietic and lymphopoietic lineages.

Neutrophil elastase mutations and risk of leukaemia in severe congenital neutropenia.

Severe congenital neutropenia (SCN) is a heterogeneous bone marrow failure syndrome predisposing to myelodysplastic syndrome and acute myeloid leukaemia (MDS/AML). We studied 82 North American and Australian SCN patients enrolled in the Severe Chronic Neutropenia International Registry who were on long‐term treatment with granulocyte colony‐stimulating factor and for whom the neutrophil elastase (ELA2) gene was sequenced. There was no significant difference in the risk of MDS/AML in patients with mutant versus wild‐type ELA2: the respective cumulative incidences at 15 years were 36% and 25% (P = 0·96). Patients with either mutant or wild‐type ELA2 should be followed closely for leukaemic transformation.

Clonal evolution in marrows of patients with Shwachman-Diamond syndrome: A prospective 5-year follow-up study

OBJECTIVES Shwachman-Diamond syndrome (SDS) is characterized by varying degrees of marrow failure. Retrospective studies suggested a high propensity for malignant myeloid transformation into myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) and acute myeloid leukemia (AML). The studys aims were to determine the cellular and molecular characteristics as well as the clinical course of malignant myeloid transformation and clonal marrow disease in patients with SDS. METHODS This is a longitudinal prospective study of 14 patients recruited for annual hematological evaluations. Results of baseline and serial hematological assessments for up to 5 years are reported. RESULTS Clonal marrow cytogenetic abnormalities (CMCA) were detected in 4 patients (29%) on first testing or at follow-up. The abnormalities were del(20q) in two patients, i(7q) in one, and combined del(20q) and i(7q) in one. The following tests did not distinguish patients with CMCA from other SDS patients: severity of peripheral cytopenia, fetal hemoglobin levels, percentage of marrow CD34+ cells, colony growth from marrow CD34+ cells, cluster-to-colony ratio, marrow stromal function, percentage of marrow apoptosis cells, and granulocyte colony-stimulating factor receptor expression. RAS and p53 mutation analysis and AML blast colony assays were uniformly negative. No patients showed progression into more advanced stages of MDS or into AML. In one patient, the abnormal clone became undetectable after 2 years of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS We conclude that although CMCA in SDS is high, progression into advanced stages of MDS or to overt AML may be slow and difficult to predict. Treatment should be cautious since some abnormal clones can regress.