Ying Yan

Performance of electrolyte measurements assessed by a trueness verification program

Abstract Background: In this study, we analyzed frozen sera with known commutabilities for standardization of serum electrolyte measurements in China. Methods: Fresh frozen sera were sent to 187 clinical laboratories in China for measurement of four electrolytes (sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium). Target values were assigned by two reference laboratories. Precision (CV), trueness (bias), and accuracy [total error (TEa)] were used to evaluate measurement performance, and the tolerance limit derived from the biological variation was used as the evaluation criterion. Results: About half of the laboratories used a homogeneous system (same manufacturer for instrument, reagent and calibrator) for calcium and magnesium measurement, and more than 80% of laboratories used a homogeneous system for sodium and potassium measurement. More laboratories met the tolerance limit of imprecision (coefficient of variation [CVa]) than the tolerance limits of trueness (biasa) and TEa. For sodium, calcium, and magnesium, the minimal performance criterion derived from biological variation was used, and the pass rates for total error were approximately equal to the bias (<50%). For potassium, the pass rates for CV and TE were more than 90%. Compared with the non homogeneous system, the homogeneous system was superior for all three quality specifications. Conclusions: The use of commutable proficiency testing/external quality assessment (PT/EQA) samples with values assigned by reference methods can monitor performance and provide reliable data for improving the performance of laboratory electrolyte measurement. The homogeneous systems were superior to the non homogeneous systems, whereas accuracy of assigned values of calibrators and assay stability remained challenges.

Serum triglyceride measurements: the commutability of reference materials and the accuracy of results

Abstract Background We aimed to evaluate the commutability of external quality assessment (EQA) materials, aqueous solutions, and commercial reference materials (calibrators and controls), and the accuracy of routine systems for serum triglyceride measurements. Methods According to the clinical and laboratory standards institute (CLSI) EP14-A3 protocol, we analyzed 43 fresh patient specimens and 32 processed materials including lyophilized samples, human serum pools, liquid reagents, swine sera and aqueous solutions by 14 routine methods (evaluated methods) and an isotope dilution liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry method (ID-LC/MS/MS) (comparative method). The accuracy of the routine method was evaluated by analyzing the absolute bias, relative bias, and the bias at three medical decision levels based on CLSI EP9-A3. Results Frozen serum samples and swine sera were commutable for all of the assays. The EQA/PT materials, commercial calibrators and control materials showed matrix effects differently on routine methods. The aqueous glycerol solutions were generally noncommutable for routine method. All except one routine analytical systems met the National Cholesterol Education Program (NCEP) recommended analytical performance guideline analytical quality criteria for total error. Conclusions Matrix effects and calibration biases existed in measurements of serum triglyceride. Continued efforts are needed to improve the accuracy and comparability of routine measurements.

A candidate reference method for serum calcium measurement by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry.

BACKGROUND Calcium is an important serum ion which is frequently assayed in clinical laboratories. Since quality assurance requires reference methods, the establishment of a candidate reference method for serum calcium measurement is important. METHOD An inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) method was developed. Serum samples were spiked gravimetrically with aluminum internal standard, digested with 69% ultrapure nitric acid and diluted to test concentration. Then the (44)Ca/(27)Al ratios were measured by ICP-MS in hydrogen mode. The method was calibrated using 5% nitric acid matrix calibrators and the calibration function was established with bracketing method. RESULTS The correlation coefficients between the measured (44)Ca/(27)Al ratios and the analyte concentrations ratios were all >0.9999. The coefficients of variation of the measurements were 0.27% and 0.16% for two spiked serum. The analytical recovery was 100.24%. The accuracy of the measurement was also verified through measurement of certified reference materials. Comparison with recognized reference method and international inter-laboratory comparisons gave satisfied results. CONCLUSION New ICP-MS method is specific, precise, simple, and low in cost, and may be used as a candidate reference method in the standardization of serum calcium measurement.

Commutability of control materials for external quality assessment of serum apolipoprotein A-I measurement

Abstract Background: The aim of the current study was to evaluate the commutability of commercial control materials and human serum pools and to investigate the suitability of the materials for the external quality assessment (EQA) of serum apolipoprotein A-I (apo A-I) measurement. Methods: The Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI) EP14-A3 protocol was used for the commutability study. Apo A-I concentrations in two levels of commercial control materials used in EQA program, two fresh-frozen human serum pools (FSPs) and two frozen human serum pools prepared from residual clinical specimens (RSPs) were measured along with 50 individual samples using nine commercial assays. Measurement results of the 50 individual samples obtained with different assays were pairwise analyzed by Deming regression, and 95% prediction intervals (PIs) were calculated. The commutability of the processed materials was evaluated by comparing the measurement results of the materials with the limits of the PIs. Results: The FSP-1 was commutable for all the 36 assay pairs, and FSP-2 was commutable for 30 pairs; RSP-1 and RSP-2 showed commutability for 27/36 and 22/36 assay pairs, respectively, whereas the two EQA materials were commutable only for 4/36 and 5/36 assay pairs, respectively. Conclusions: Non-commutability of the tested EQA materials has been observed among current apo A-I assays. EQA programs need either to take into account the commutability-related biases in the interpretation of the EQA results or to use more commutable materials. Frozen human serum pools were commutable for most of the assays.

Commutability of external quality assessment materials for serum sodium and potassium measurements

Abstract Background The commutability of electrolyte trueness verification materials (ETVs) and commercial general chemistry materials (GCs) was evaluated to investigate their suitability for use in an external quality assessment (EQA) program for serum sodium and potassium measurements. Methods Eighty fresh individual human samples (40 for sodium measurements and 40 for potassium measurements), six ETVs and three GCs were analyzed by five routine methods (validated methods) and by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry reference methods (comparative methods) for the determination of sodium and potassium. The commutability was analyzed according to Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI) EP14-A3 protocol and difference in bias approach, respectively. The linearity, bias and imprecision of the routine methods were also assessed according to CLSI guidelines. Results According to EP14-A3 protocol, ETVs were commutable for all assays, and GCs were commutable for 3/5 assays for sodium. ETVs were commutable in most assays except Cobas C501, while GCs showed no commutability except in case of AU5821 for potassium. According to a difference in bias approach, the commutability of ETVs was inconclusive for most routine assays for both sodium and potassium, and GCs were inconclusive for sodium and non-commutable for potassium in most routine assays. The routine methods exhibited excellent linearities and precisions. The majority and minority of relative biases between the routine and reference methods were beyond the bias limits for sodium and potassium, respectively. Conclusions Superiority in the commutability of ETVs over GCs was observed among the sodium and potassium assays whichever evaluation approach was applied.

Evaluation of serum alkaline phosphatase measurement through the 4-year trueness verification program in China

Abstract Background Alkaline phosphatase (ALP) is critical for various diseases. The International Federation of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine had recommended the new reference procedure in 2011, but many manufacturers did not trace results to the higher procedure. Since 2012, the National Center for Clinical Laboratories (NCCL) in China has organized the trueness verification program (TV) with commutable materials. The present study summarizes the 4-year TV program to give an overview of the measurement standardization for ALP results. Methods Commutable serum-based materials with different concentrations were prepared and sent to participating laboratories. The target values were assigned by the reference lab network. Results The analytical performance was evaluated according to three indexes: trueness (bias), imprecision (CV) and accuracy (total error [TE]). The number of participating laboratories increased from 115 in 2012 to 287 in 2016. The pass rates of precision for homogeneous and heterogeneous systems were all above 85% over the 4 years; however, the pass rates of bias were much lower (<50%). Among the homogeneous systems, Roche Cobas/Modular had an obvious negative bias, whereas the mean positive bias for Beckman AU was prominent. As to the heterogeneous systems, the pass rates of bias for Sichuan Maccura (57.1%–78.6%) were higher than Roche Cobas/Modular (4.4%–33.9%) and Beckman AU (35.7%–64.8%). Conclusions The PT/EQA program with commutable materials can be used to assess the trueness against target values assigned by reference procedures. For ALP, homogeneous systems did not perform better than heterogeneous systems. The bias for ALP performance was notable and was the main obstacle to its standardization in China.

Determination of serum calcium levels by 42Ca isotope dilution inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

Abstract Background: Serum calcium level is an important clinical index that reflects pathophysiological states. However, detection accuracy in laboratory tests is not ideal; as such, a high accuracy method is needed. Methods: We developed a reference method for measuring serum calcium levels by isotope dilution inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ID ICP-MS), using 42Ca as the enriched isotope. Serum was digested with 69% ultrapure nitric acid and diluted to a suitable concentration. The 44Ca/42Ca ratio was detected in H2 mode; spike concentration was calibrated by reverse IDMS using standard reference material (SRM) 3109a, and sample concentration was measured by a bracketing procedure. We compared the performance of ID ICP-MS with those of three other reference methods in China using the same serum and aqueous samples. Results: The relative expanded uncertainty of the sample concentration was 0.414% (k=2). The range of repeatability (within-run imprecision), intermediate imprecision (between-run imprecision), and intra-laboratory imprecision were 0.12%–0.19%, 0.07%–0.09%, and 0.16%–0.17%, respectively, for two of the serum samples. SRM909bI, SRM909bII, SRM909c, and GBW09152 were found to be within the certified value interval, with mean relative bias values of 0.29%, −0.02%, 0.10%, and −0.19%, respectively. The range of recovery was 99.87%–100.37%. Results obtained by ID ICP-MS showed a better accuracy than and were highly correlated with those of other reference methods. Conclusions: ID ICP-MS is a simple and accurate candidate reference method for serum calcium measurement and can be used to establish and improve serum calcium reference system in China.

A candidate reference method for serum potassium measurement by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

Abstract Background: Potassium is an important serum ion that is frequently assayed in clinical laboratories. Quality assurance requires reference methods; thus, the establishment of a candidate reference method for serum potassium measurements is important. Methods: An inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) method was developed. Serum samples were gravimetrically spiked with an aluminum internal standard, digested with 69% ultrapure nitric acid, and diluted to the required concentration. The 39K/27Al ratios were measured by ICP-MS in hydrogen mode. The method was calibrated using 5% nitric acid matrix calibrators, and the calibration function was established using the bracketing method. Results: The correlation coefficients between the measured 39K/27Al ratios and the analyte concentration ratios were >0.9999. The coefficients of variation were 0.40%, 0.68%, and 0.22% for the three serum samples, and the analytical recovery was 99.8%. The accuracy of the measurement was also verified by measuring certified reference materials, SRM909b and SRM956b. Comparison with the ion selective electrode routine method and international inter-laboratory comparisons gave satisfied results. Conclusions: The new ICP-MS method is specific, precise, simple, and low-cost, and it may be used as a candidate reference method for standardizing serum potassium measurements.