Alberta A.H.J. Thiadens

Progressive Loss of Cones in Achromatopsia: An Imaging Study Using Spectral-Domain Optical Coherence Tomography

PURPOSE Achromatopsia (ACHM) is a congenital autosomal recessive cone disorder with a presumed stationary nature and only a few causative genes. Animal studies suggest that ACHM may be a good candidate for corrective gene therapy. Future implementation of this therapy in humans requires the presence of viable cone cells in the retina. In this study the presence of cone cells in ACHM was determined, as a function of age. METHODS The appearance and thickness of all retinal layers were evaluated by spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) in 40 ACHM patients (age range, 4-70 years) with known mutations in the CNGB3, CNGA3, and PDE6C genes. A comparison was made with 55 healthy age-matched control subjects. RESULTS The initial feature of cone cell decay was loss of inner and outer segments with disruption of the ciliary layer on OCT, which was observed as early as 8 years of age. Cone cell loss further progressed with age and occurred in 8 (42%) of 19 patients below 30 years and in 20 (95%) of 21 of those aged 30+ years. Retinal thickness was significantly thinner in the fovea of all patients (126 μm in ACHM vs. 225 μm in the control; P < 0.001) and correlated with age (β = 0.065; P = 0.011). Foveal hypoplasia was present in 24 (80%) of 30 patients and in 1 of 55 control subjects. CONCLUSIONS ACHM is not a stationary disease. The first signs of cone cell loss occur in early childhood. If intervention becomes available in the future, the present results imply that it should be applied in the first decade.

Genetic etiology and clinical consequences of complete and incomplete achromatopsia.

OBJECTIVE To investigate the genetic causes of complete and incomplete achromatopsia (ACHM) and assess the association between disease-causing mutations, phenotype at diagnosis, and visual prognosis. DESIGN Clinic-based, longitudinal, multicenter study. PARTICIPANTS Probands with complete ACHM (n = 35), incomplete ACHM (n = 26), or nonspecific ACHM (n = 2) and their affected relatives (n = 18) from various ophthalmogenetic clinics in The Netherlands. METHODS Ophthalmologic clinical data were assessed over a life time and were registered from medical charts and updated by ophthalmologic examination. Mutations in the CNGB3, CNGA3, and GNAT2 genes were analyzed by direct sequencing. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Genetic mutations and clinical course of ACHM. RESULTS CNGB3 mutations were identified in 55 of 63 (87%) of probands and all caused premature truncation of the protein. The most common mutation was p.T383IfsX13 (80%); among the 4 other mutations was the novel frameshift mutation p.G548VfsX35. CNGA3 mutations were detected in 3 of 63 (5%) probands; all caused an amino acid change of the protein. No mutations were found in the GNAT2 gene. The ACHM subtype, visual acuity, color vision, and macular appearance were equally distributed among the CNGB3 genotypes, but were more severely affected among CNGA3 genotypes. Visual acuity deteriorated from infancy to adulthood in 12% of patients, leading to 0.10 in 61%, and even lower than 0.10 in 20% of patients. CONCLUSIONS In this well-defined cohort of ACHM patients, the disease seemed much more genetically homogeneous than previously described. The CNGB3 gene was by far the most important causal gene, and T383IfsX13 the most frequent mutation. The ACHM subtype did not associate with a distinct genetic etiology, nor were any other genotype-phenotype correlations apparent. The distinction between complete and incomplete subtypes of ACHM has no clinical value, and the assumption of a stationary nature is misleading.

Causes and consequences of inherited cone disorders

Hereditary cone disorders (CDs) are characterized by defects of the cone photoreceptors or retinal pigment epithelium underlying the macula, and include achromatopsia (ACHM), cone dystrophy (COD), cone-rod dystrophy (CRD), color vision impairment, Stargardt disease (STGD) and other maculopathies. Forty-two genes have been implicated in non-syndromic inherited CDs. Mutations in the 5 genes implicated in ACHM explain ∼93% of the cases. On the contrary, only 21% of CRDs (17 genes) and 25% of CODs (8 genes) have been elucidated. The fact that the large majority of COD and CRD-associated genes are yet to be discovered hints towards the existence of unknown cone-specific or cone-sensitive processes. The ACHM-associated genes encode proteins that fulfill crucial roles in the cone phototransduction cascade, which is the most frequently compromised (10 genes) process in CDs. Another 7 CD-associated proteins are required for transport processes towards or through the connecting cilium. The remaining CD-associated proteins are involved in cell membrane morphogenesis and maintenance, synaptic transduction, and the retinoid cycle. Further novel genes are likely to be identified in the near future by combining large-scale DNA sequencing and transcriptomics technologies. For 31 of 42 CD-associated genes, mammalian models are available, 14 of which have successfully been used for gene augmentation studies. However, gene augmentation for CDs should ideally be developed in large mammalian models with cone-rich areas, which are currently available for only 11 CD genes. Future research will aim to elucidate the remaining causative genes, identify the molecular mechanisms of CD, and develop novel therapies aimed at preventing vision loss in individuals with CD in the future.

Clinical course, genetic etiology, and visual outcome in cone and cone-rod dystrophy

OBJECTIVE To evaluate the clinical course, genetic etiology, and visual prognosis in patients with cone dystrophy (CD) and cone-rod dystrophy (CRD). DESIGN Clinic-based, longitudinal, multicenter study. PARTICIPANTS Consecutive probands with CD (N = 98), CRD (N = 83), and affected relatives (N = 41 and N = 17, respectively) from various ophthalmogenetic clinics in The Netherlands, Belgium, and the United Kingdom. METHODS Data on best-corrected Snellen visual acuity, color vision, ophthalmoscopy, fundus photography, Goldmann perimetry, and full-field standard electroretinogram (ERG) from all patients were registered from medical charts over a mean follow-up of 19 years. The ABCA4, CNGB3, KCNV2, PDE6C, and RPGR genes were analyzed by direct sequencing in autosomal recessive (AR) and X-linked (XL), respectively. Genotyping was not undertaken for autosomal-dominant cases. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES The 10-year progression of all clinical parameters and cumulative lifetime risk of low vision and legal blindness were assessed. RESULTS The mean age onset for CD was 16 years (standard deviation, 11), and of CRD 12 years (standard deviation, 11; P = 0.02). The pattern of inheritance was AR in 92% of CD and 90% of CRD. Ten years after diagnosis, 35% of CD and 51% of CRD had a bulls eye maculopathy; 70% of CRD showed absolute peripheral visual field defects and 37% of CD developed rod involvement on ERG. The mean age of legal blindness was 48 (standard error [SE], 3.1) years in CD, and 35 (SE, 1.1; P<0.001) years in CRD. ABCA4 mutations were found in 8 of 90 (9%) of AR-CD, and in 17 of 65 (26%) of AR-CRD. Other mutations were detected in CNGB3 (3/90; 3%), KCNV2 (4/90; 4%), and in PDE6C (1/90; 1%). The RPGR gene was mutated in the 2 XL-CD and in 4 of 5 (80%) of XL-CRD. ABCA4 mutations as well as age of onset <20 years were significantly associated with a faster progression to legal blindness (P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS Although CD had a slightly more favorable clinical course than CRD, both disorders progressed to legal blindness in the majority of patients. Mutations in the ABCA4 gene and early onset of disease were independent prognostic parameters for visual loss. Our data may serve as an aid in counseling patients with progressive cone disorders.

Comprehensive analysis of the achromatopsia genes CNGA3 and CNGB3 in progressive cone dystrophy.

OBJECTIVE To investigate whether the major achromatopsia genes (CNGA3 and CNGB3) play a role in the cause of progressive cone dystrophy (CD). DESIGN Prospective multicenter study. PARTICIPANTS Probands (N = 60) with autosomal recessive (ar) CD from various ophthalmogenetic clinics in The Netherlands. METHODS All available ophthalmologic data from the arCD probands were registered from medical charts and updated by an additional ophthalmologic examination. Mutations in the CNGA3 and CNGB3 genes were analyzed by direct sequencing. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES CNGA3 and CNGB3 mutations and clinical course in arCD probands. RESULTS In 3 arCD probands (3/60; 5%) we found 2 mutations in the CNGB3 gene. Two of these probands had compound heterozygous mutations (p.R296YfsX9/p.R274VfsX12 and p.R296YfsX9/c.991-3T>g). The third proband revealed homozygous missense mutations (p.R403Q) with 2 additional variants in the CNGA3 gene (p.E228K and p.V266M). These probands did not have a congenital nystagmus, but had a progressive deterioration of visual acuity, color vision, and photopic electroretinogram, with onset in the second decade. In 6 other unrelated probands, we found 6 different heterozygous amino acid changes in the CNGA3 (N = 4) and CNGB3 (N = 2) gene. CONCLUSIONS The CNGB3 gene accounts for a small fraction of the later onset progressive form of cone photoreceptor disorders, and CNGA3 may have an additive causative effect. Our data indicate that these genes are involved in a broader spectrum of cone dysfunction, and it remains intriguing why initial cone function can be spared despite similar gene defects. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S) The author(s) have no proprietary or commercial interest in any materials discussed in this article.

Heterozygous Deep-Intronic Variants and Deletions in ABCA4 in Persons with Retinal Dystrophies and One Exonic ABCA4 Variant

Variants in ABCA4 are responsible for autosomal‐recessive Stargardt disease and cone‐rod dystrophy. Sequence analysis of ABCA4 exons previously revealed one causative variant in each of 45 probands. To identify the “missing” variants in these cases, we performed multiplex ligation‐dependent probe amplification‐based deletion scanning of ABCA4. In addition, we sequenced the promoter region, fragments containing five deep‐intronic splice variants, and 15 deep‐intronic regions containing weak splice sites. Heterozygous deletions spanning ABCA4 exon 5 or exons 20–22 were found in two probands, heterozygous deep‐intronic variants were identified in six probands, and a deep‐intronic variant was found together with an exon 20–22 deletion in one proband. Based on ophthalmologic findings and characteristics of the identified exonic variants present in trans, the deep‐intronic variants V1 and V4 were predicted to be relatively mild and severe, respectively. These findings are important for proper genetic counseling and for the development of variant‐specific therapies.

Maternal Uniparental Isodisomy of Chromosome 6 Reveals a TULP1 Mutation as a Novel Cause of Cone Dysfunction

PURPOSE The majority of the genetic causes of autosomal recessive (ar) cone dystrophy (CD) and cone-rod dystrophy (CRD) are currently unknown. We used a high-resolution homozygosity mapping approach in a cohort of patients with CD or CRD to identify new genes for ar cone disorders. DESIGN Case series. PARTICIPANTS A cohort of 159 patients with ar CD and 91 patients with CRD. METHODS The genomes of 83 patients with ar CD and 73 patients with CRD were analyzed for homozygous regions using single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) microarrays. One patient showed homozygosity of SNPs across chromosome 6, and segregation analysis was performed using microsatellite markers. Direct sequencing of all retinal disease genes on chromosome 6 revealed a novel pathogenic TULP1 mutation in this patient. A cohort of 159 individuals with CD and 91 individuals with CRD was screened for this particular mutation using the restriction enzyme HhaI. The medical history of patients carrying the TULP1 mutation was reviewed and additional ophthalmic examinations were performed, including electroretinography (ERG), perimetry, optical coherence tomography (OCT), fundus autofluorescence (FAF), and fundus photography. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES TULP1 mutations, age at diagnosis, visual acuity, fundus appearance, color vision defects, visual field, ERG, FAF, and OCT findings. RESULTS In 1 patient, homozygosity mapping and subsequent segregation analysis revealed maternal uniparental disomy (UPD) of chromosome 6. A novel homozygous missense mutation (p.Arg420Ser) was identified in TULP1, whereas no mutations were detected in other retinal disease genes on chromosome 6. The mutation affects a highly conserved amino acid residue in the Tubby domain and is predicted to be pathogenic. The same homozygous mutation was also identified in an additional, unrelated patient with CRD. Both patients carrying the p.Arg420Ser mutation presented with a bulls eye maculopathy. The first patient had progressive loss of visual acuity with a relatively preserved ERG, whereas the second patient developed loss of visual acuity, peripheral degeneration, and severely reduced ERG responses in a cone-rod pattern. CONCLUSIONS Maternal UPD of chromosome 6 unmasked a mutation in the TULP1 gene as a novel cause of cone dysfunction. This expands the disease spectrum of TULP1 mutations from Leber congenital amaurosis and early-onset retinitis pigmentosa to cone-dominated disease. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S) The author(s) have no proprietary or commercial interest in any materials discussed in this article.

Cone-rod dystrophy can be a manifestation of Danon disease

BackgroundDanon disease is a neuromuscular disorder with variable expression in the eye. We describe a family with Danon disease and cone-rod dystrophy (CRD).MethodsAffected males of one family with Danon were invited for an extensive ophthalmologic examination, including color vision testing, fundus photography, Goldmann perimetry, full-field electroretinogram (ERG), and SD-OCT. Previous ophthalmologic data were retrieved from medical charts. The LAMP2 and RPGR gene were analyzed by direct sequencing.ResultsTwo siblings had no ocular phenotype. The third sibling and a cousin developed CRD leading to legal blindness. Visual acuity deteriorated progressively over time, color vision was severely disturbed, and ERG showed reduced photopic and scotopic responses. SD-OCT revealed thinning of the photoreceptor and RPE layer. Visual fields demonstrated central scotoma. The causal mutation was p.Gly384Arg in LAMP2; no mutations were found in RPGR.ConclusionsThis is the first description of CRD in Danon disease. The retinal phenotype was a late onset but severe dystrophy characterized by loss of photoreceptors and RPE cells. With this report, we highlight the importance of a comprehensive ophthalmologic examination in the clinical work-up of Danon disease.

Accuracy of Four Commonly Used Color Vision Tests in the Identification of Cone Disorders

Abstract Purpose: To determine which color vision test is most appropriate for the identification of cone disorders. Methods: In a clinic-based study, four commonly used color vision tests were compared between patients with cone dystrophy (n = 37), controls with normal visual acuity (n = 35), and controls with low vision (n = 39) and legal blindness (n = 11). Mean outcome measures were specificity, sensitivity, positive predictive value and discriminative accuracy of the Ishihara test, Hardy-Rand-Rittler (HRR) test, and the Lanthony and Farnsworth Panel D-15 tests. Results: In the comparison between cone dystrophy and all controls, sensitivity, specificity and predictive value were highest for the HRR and Ishihara tests. When patients were compared to controls with normal vision, discriminative accuracy was highest for the HRR test (c-statistic for PD-axes 1, for T-axis 0.851). When compared to controls with poor vision, discriminative accuracy was again highest for the HRR test (c-statistic for PD-axes 0.900, for T-axis 0.766), followed by the Lanthony Panel D-15 test (c-statistic for PD-axes 0.880, for T-axis 0.500) and Ishihara test (c-statistic 0.886). Discriminative accuracies of all tests did not further decrease when patients were compared to controls who were legally blind. Conclusions: The HRR, Lanthony Panel D-15 and Ishihara all have a high discriminative accuracy to identify cone disorders, but the highest scores were for the HRR test. Poor visual acuity slightly decreased the accuracy of all tests. Our advice is to use the HRR test since this test also allows for evaluation of all three color axes and quantification of color defects.

Mutations in the polyglutamylase gene TTLL5, expressed in photoreceptor cells and spermatozoa, are associated with cone-rod degeneration and reduced male fertility

Hereditary retinal degenerations encompass a group of genetic diseases characterized by extreme clinical variability. Following next-generation sequencing and autozygome-based screening of patients presenting with a peculiar, recessive form of cone-dominated retinopathy, we identified five homozygous variants [p.(Asp594fs), p.(Gln117*), p.(Met712fs), p.(Ile756Phe), and p.(Glu543Lys)] in the polyglutamylase-encoding gene TTLL5, in eight patients from six families. The two male patients carrying truncating TTLL5 variants also displayed a substantial reduction in sperm motility and infertility, whereas those carrying missense changes were fertile. Defects in this polyglutamylase in humans have recently been associated with cone photoreceptor dystrophy, while mouse models carrying truncating mutations in the same gene also display reduced fertility in male animals. We examined the expression levels of TTLL5 in various human tissues and determined that this gene has multiple viable isoforms, being highly expressed in testis and retina. In addition, antibodies against TTLL5 stained the basal body of photoreceptor cells in rat and the centrosome of the spermatozoon flagellum in humans, suggesting a common mechanism of action in these two cell types. Taken together, our data indicate that mutations in TTLL5 delineate a novel, allele-specific syndrome causing defects in two as yet pathogenically unrelated functions, reproduction and vision.