Aline Muyle

Rapid de novo evolution of X chromosome dosage compensation in Silene latifolia, a plant with young sex chromosomes.

Evidence for dosage compensation in Silene latifolia, a plant with 10-million-year-old sex chromosomes, reveals that dosage compensation can evolve rapidly in young XY systems and is not an animal-specific phenomenon.

Evolution of sex-biased gene expression in a dioecious plant

Separate sexes and sex-biased gene expression have repeatedly evolved in animals and plants, but the underlying changes in gene expression remain unknown. Here, we studied a pair of plant species, one in which separate sexes and sex chromosomes evolved recently and one which maintained hermaphrodite flowers resembling the ancestral state, to reconstruct expression changes associated with the evolution of dioecy. We found that sex-biased gene expression has evolved in autosomal and sex-linked genes in the dioecious species. Most expression changes relative to hermaphrodite flowers occurred in females rather than males, with higher and lower expression in females leading to female-biased and male-biased expression, respectively. Expression changes were more common in genes located on the sex chromosomes than the autosomes and led to feminization of the X chromosome and masculinization of the Y chromosome. Our results support a scenario in which sex-biased gene expression evolved during the evolution of dioecy to resolve intralocus sexual conflicts over the allocation of resources.

The Evolution of Sex Chromosomes and Dosage Compensation in Plants

Plant sex chromosomes can be vastly different from those of the few historical animal model organisms from which most of our understanding of sex chromosome evolution is derived. Recently, we have seen several advancements from studies on green algae, brown algae, and land plants that are providing a broader understanding of the variable ways in which sex chromosomes can evolve in distant eukaryotic groups. Plant sex-determining genes are being identified and, as expected, are completely different from those in animals. Species with varying levels of differentiation between the X and Y have been found in plants, and these are hypothesized to be representing different stages of sex chromosome evolution. However, we are also finding that sex chromosomes can remain morphologically unchanged over extended periods of time. Where degeneration of the Y occurs, it appears to proceed similarly in plants and animals. Dosage compensation (a phenomenon that compensates for the consequent loss of expression from the Y) has now been documented in a plant system, its mechanism, however, remains unknown. Research has also begun on the role of sex chromosomes in sexual conflict resolution, and it appears that sex-biased genes evolve similarly in plants and animals, although the functions of these genes remain poorly studied. Because the difficulty in obtaining sex chromosome sequences is increasingly being overcome by methodological developments, there is great potential for further discovery within the field of plant sex chromosome evolution.

SEX-DETector: A Probabilistic Approach to Study Sex Chromosomes in Non-Model Organisms

We propose a probabilistic framework to infer autosomal and sex-linked genes from RNA-seq data of a cross for any sex chromosome type (XY, ZW, and UV). Sex chromosomes (especially the non-recombining and repeat-dense Y, W, U, and V) are notoriously difficult to sequence. Strategies have been developed to obtain partially assembled sex chromosome sequences. Most of them remain difficult to apply to numerous non-model organisms, either because they require a reference genome, or because they are designed for evolutionarily old systems. Sequencing a cross (parents and progeny) by RNA-seq to study the segregation of alleles and infer sex-linked genes is a cost-efficient strategy, which also provides expression level estimates. However, the lack of a proper statistical framework has limited a broader application of this approach. Tests on empirical Silene data show that our method identifies 20–35% more sex-linked genes than existing pipelines, while making reliable inferences for downstream analyses. Approximately 12 individuals are needed for optimal results based on simulations. For species with an unknown sex-determination system, the method can assess the presence and type (XY vs. ZW) of sex chromosomes through a model comparison strategy. The method is particularly well optimized for sex chromosomes of young or intermediate age, which are expected in thousands of yet unstudied lineages. Any organisms, including non-model ones for which nothing is known a priori, that can be bred in the lab, are suitable for our method. SEX-DETector and its implementation in a Galaxy workflow are made freely available.

Mating systems and selection efficacy: a test using chloroplastic sequence data in Angiosperms

Selfing is assumed to reduce selection efficacy, especially purifying selection. This can be tested using molecular data, for example by comparing the Dn/Ds ratio between selfing and outcrossing lineages. So far, little evidence of relaxed selection against weakly deleterious mutations (as inferred by a higher Dn/Ds ratio) in selfers as compared to outcrossers has been found, contrary to the pattern often observed between asexual and sexual lineages. However, few groups have been studied to date. To further test this hypothesis, we compiled and analysed chloroplastic sequence data sets in several plant groups. We found a general trend towards relaxed selection in selfers in our data sets but with weak statistical support. Simulations suggested that the results were compatible with weak‐to‐moderate Dn/Ds ratio differences in selfing lineages. Simple theoretical predictions also showed that the ability to detect relaxed selection in selfers could strongly depend on the distribution of the effects of deleterious mutations on fitness. Our results are compatible with a recent origin of selfing lineages whereby deleterious mutations potentially have a strong impact on population extinction or with a more ancient origin but without a marked effect of deleterious mutations on the extinction dynamics.

Hallmarks of early sex-chromosome evolution in the dioecious plant Mercurialis annua revealed by de novo genome assembly, genetic mapping and transcriptome analysis

The evolution of sex chromosomes involves the suppression of recombination around a sex-determining locus, and the subsequent divergence in DNA sequence between the two homologous sex chromosomes. Dioecious plants offer the opportunity to study independent early stages of this process, because of multiple, recent transitions between hermaphroditism and dioecy. Here, we present data from de novo genome assembly and annotation, genetic mapping and transcriptome analysis of the diploid dioecious herb Mercurialis annua, revealing several of the typical hallmarks of early sex-chromosome evolution. Until now only a single sex-linked PCR marker has been published. Our analysis identified a single linkage group, LG10, as the likely sex chromosome, with a region containing 69 sex-linked transcripts with a clearly lower male than female recombination, high X/Y divergence and multiple incidences of premature stop codons on the Y allele. We found many genes with sex-biased expression. Female-biased genes were randomly distributed across the genome, but male-biased genes were slightly enriched on the Y chromosome. Interestingly, Y-linked genes had reduced expression compared with X-linked genes, a pattern consistent with Y chromosome degeneration. M. annua has been a powerful model for the study of rapid sexual-system transitions in plants; our results here establish it as a model for the study of the early stages of sex-chromosome evolution.Abstract Suppressed recombination around a sex-determining locus allows divergence between homologous sex chromosomes and the functionality of their genes. Here, we reveal patterns of the earliest stages of sex-chromosome evolution in the diploid dioecious herb Mercurialis annua on the basis of cytological analysis, de novo genome assembly and annotation, genetic mapping, exome resequencing of natural populations, and transcriptome analysis. Both genetic mapping and exome resequencing of individuals across the species range independently identified the largest linkage group, LG1, as the sex chromosome. Although the sex chromosomes of M. annua are karyotypically homomorphic, we estimate that about a third of the Y chromosome has ceased recombining, a region containing 568 transcripts and spanning 22.3 cM in the corresponding female map. Patterns of gene expression hint at the possible role of sexually antagonistic selection in having favored suppressed recombination. In total, the genome assembly contained 34,105 expressed genes, of which 10,076 were assigned to linkage groups. There was limited evidence of Y-chromosome degeneration in terms of gene loss and pseudogenization, but sequence divergence between the X and Y copies of many sex-linked genes was higher than between M. annua and its dioecious sister species M. huetii with which it shares a sex-determining region. The Mendelian inheritance of sex in interspecific crosses, combined with the other observed pattern, suggest that the M. annua Y chromosome has at least two evolutionary strata: a small old stratum shared with M. huetii, and a more recent larger stratum that is probably unique to M. annua and that stopped recombining about one million years ago. Article summary Plants that evolved separate sexes (dioecy) recently are ideal models for studying the early stages of sex-chromosome evolution. Here, we use karyological, whole genome and transcriptome data to characterize the homomorphic sex chromosomes of the annual dioecious plant Mercurialis annua. Our analysis reveals many typical hallmarks of dioecy and sex-chromosome evolution, including sex-biased gene expression and high X/Y sequence divergence, yet few premature stop codons in Y-linked genes and very little outright gene loss, despite 1/3 of the sex chromosome having ceased recombination in males. Our results confirm that the M. annua species complex is a fertile system for probing early stages in the evolution of sex chromosomes.

Genomic imprinting mediates dosage compensation in a young plant XY system

Sex chromosomes have repeatedly evolved from a pair of autosomes. Consequently, X and Y chromosomes initially have similar gene content, but ongoing Y degeneration leads to reduced expression and eventual loss of Y genes1. The resulting imbalance in gene expression between Y genes and the rest of the genome is expected to reduce male fitness, especially when protein networks have components from both autosomes and sex chromosomes. A diverse set of dosage compensating mechanisms that alleviates these negative effects has been described in animals2–4. However, the early steps in the evolution of dosage compensation remain unknown, and dosage compensation is poorly understood in plants5. Here, we describe a dosage compensation mechanism in the evolutionarily young XY sex determination system of the plant Silene latifolia. Genomic imprinting results in higher expression from the maternal X chromosome in both males and females. This compensates for reduced Y expression in males, but results in X overexpression in females and may be detrimental. It could represent a transient early stage in the evolution of dosage compensation. Our finding has striking resemblance to the first stage proposed by Ohno6 for the evolution of X inactivation in mammals.A study finds a novel mechanism of plant dosage compensation, where genomic imprinting results in higher expression of maternal X chromosomes, by examining the evolutionarily young XY sex determination system of Silene latifolia.

Maternal X chromosome upregulation in both sexes initiates dosage compensation evolution

This preprint has been reviewed and recommended by Peer Community In Evolutionary Biology (http://dx.doi.org/10.24072/pci.evolbiol.100044). Sex chromosomes have repeatedly evolved from a pair of autosomes1. Consequently, X and Y chromosomes initially have similar gene content, but ongoing Y degeneration leads to reduced Y gene expression and eventual Y gene loss. The resulting imbalance in gene expression between Y genes and the rest of the genome is expected to reduce male fitness, especially when protein networks have components from both autosomes and sex chromosomes. A diverse set of dosage compensating mechanisms that alleviates these negative effects has been described in animals2–4. However, the early steps in the evolution of dosage compensation remain unknown and dosage compensation is poorly understood in plants5. Here we show a novel dosage compensation mechanism in the evolutionarily young XY sex determination system of the plant Silene latifolia. Genomic imprinting results in higher expression from the maternal X chromosome in both males and females. This compensates for reduced Y expression in males but results in X overexpression in females and may be detrimental. It could represent a transient early stage in the evolution of dosage compensation. Our finding has striking resemblance to the first stage proposed by Ohno for the evolution of X inactivation in mammals.When sex chromosomes evolve, Y genes become less expressed than their X counterpart. This degeneration is compensated through various mechanisms in different animal species, that reestablish ancestral expression levels in males or balance males and females. This phenomenon, called dosage compensation, has been observed for some genes in the plant Silene latifolia. However, the mechanism involved remains unknown. Using an outgroup without sex chromosomes as a reference, we show that the maternal X chromosome is hyperexpressed in both sexes in S. latifolia. This compensates for the lower Y expression in males. However, the paternal X chromosome in females maintained its ancestral expression levels, causing global hyperexpression of sex chromosomes in females, which is likely to be suboptimal. Because S. latifolia sex chromosomes have evolved fairly recently, our findings provide insights into the first steps of dosage compensation evolution, in addition to revealing a link between dosage compensation and imprinting.

Dioecy in plants: an evolutionary dead end? Insights from a population genomics study in the Silene genus

About 15,000 angiosperm species (∼6%) have separate sexes, a phenomenon known as dioecy. Early work reported a lower species richness in dioecious compared to non-dioecious sister clades, which was taken to suggest that dioecy might be an evolutionary dead end. More recently, phylogenetic analyses using different methodologies have challenged this conclusion. Here, we used a population genomics approach to look for evidence of evolutionary handicaps of dioecy in the Silene genus at the molecular level. We obtained RNA-seq data of individuals from several populations in 13 closely related species with different breeding systems: seven dioecious, three hermaphroditic and three gynodioecious species. We show that dioecy is associated with increased genetic diversity and a higher selection efficacy both against deleterious and for beneficial mutations while controlling for differences in population size. We conclude that, in the Silene genus, dioecious species bear no sign of mutational burden or upcoming extinction. On the contrary, dioecious species harbor a higher potential for adaptation than their non-dioecious relatives. Our results do not support the evolutionary dead end hypothesis and re-open the question why dioecy is rare in angiosperms. Significance statement Dioecy (=separate sexes) is much rarer in flowering plants compared to animals and other organisms. The “dead-end hypothesis” states that dioecious plant populations might experience evolutionary handicaps such as low seed dispersal (as only 50% of the individuals, the females, contribute), which might cause high genetic drift, low adaptation and ultimately extinction. Here we tested this hypothesis by focusing on the genus Silene and by comparing the population genetics of 13 dioecious and non-dioecious species. We found that dioecious Silene species exhibit lower genetic drift and more adaptation compared to their non-dioecious relatives. Our results thus reject the dead-end hypothesis and re-open the question of why dioecy is rare in flowering plants.

A probabilistic method for identifying sex-linked genes using RNA-seq-derived genotyping data

Data deposition: During the review process, the SEX-DETector galaxy workflow and associated test datasets are made available on the public galaxy.prabi.fr server. The data as well as the tool interface are visible to anonymous users, but to use them, you should register for an account (“user Register”), and import the data library “SEX-DETector” (“Shared Data Data Libraries”) into your history. More instructions can be found in the “readme” file in this library. The user manual for SEX-DETector is available here: https://lbbe.univ-lyon1.fr/Download-5251.html?lang=en. Paper submitted as a Genome Resource. We propose a probabilistic framework to infer autosomal and sex-linked genes from RNA-seq data of a cross for any sex chromosome type (XY, ZW, UV). Sex chromosomes (especially the nonrecombining and repeat-dense Y, W, U and V) are notoriously difficult to sequence. Strategies have been developed to obtain partially assembled sex chromosome sequences. However, most of them remain difficult to apply to numerous non-model organisms, either because they require a reference genome, or because they are designed for evolutionarily old systems. Sequencing a cross (parents and progeny) by RNA-seq to study the segregation of alleles and infer sex-linked genes is a cost-efficient strategy, which also provides expression level estimates. However, the lack of a proper statistical framework has limited a broader application of this approach. Tests on empirical data show that our method identifies many more sex-linked genes than existing pipelines, while making reliable inferences for downstream analyses. Simulations suggest few individuals are needed for optimal results. For species with unknown sex-determination system, the method can assess the presence and type (XY versus ZW) of sex chromosomes through a model comparison strategy. The method is particularly well optimised for sex chomosomes of young or intermediate age, which are expected in thousands of yet unstudied lineages. Any organism, including non-model ones for which nothing is known a priori, that can be bred in the lab, is suitable for our method. SEX-DETector is made freely available to the community through a Galaxy workflow.The genetic basis of sex determination remains unknown for the vast majority of organisms with separate sexes. A key question is whether a species has sex chromosomes (SC). SC presence indicates genetic sex determination, and their sequencing may help identifying the sex-determining genes and understanding the molecular mechanisms of sex determination. Identifying SC, especially homomorphic SC, can be difficult. Sequencing SC is also very challenging, in particular the repeat-rich non-recombining regions. A novel approach for identifying sex-linked genes and SC consisting of using RNA-seq to genotype male and female individuals and study sex-linkage has recently been proposed. This approach entails a modest sequencing effort and does not require prior genomic or genetic resources, and is thus particularly suited to study non-model organisms. Applying this approach to many organisms is, however, difficult due to the lack of an appropriate statistically-grounded pipeline to analyse the data. Here we propose a model-based method to infer sex-linkage using a maximum likelihood framework and genotyping data from a full-sib family, which can be obtained for most organisms that can be grown in the lab and for economically important animals/plants. Our method works on any type of SC (XY, ZW, UV) and has been embedded in a pipeline that includes a genotyper specifically developed for RNA-seq data. Validation on empirical and simulated data indicates that our pipeline is particularly relevant to study SC of recent or intermediate age but can return useful information in old systems as well; it is available as a Galaxy workflow.