Ana Luisa Velasco

Electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nucleus in control of seizures : long-term studies

Summary: Five patients with chronic incapacitating seizures averaging 15–5,000/month were selected for study. All patients had more than one seizure type and had received maximal doses of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs). The centromedian thalamic nucleus (CM) was stimulated electrically through bilateral multicontact platinum electrodes stereotaxically placed in CM and connected to internalized pulse generators. Electrophysiologic confirmation of electrode position included thalamically elicited recruiting responses and EEG desynchronization recorded at the scalp. Stimulation parameters were adjusted individually in the range of 450–800‐μA intensity, 65 pps, 0.09 ms, in 1‐min trains, alternating right and left side stimulation and with 4‐min intervals delivered for 2 h/day. Quantitative evaluation included frequency of seizures/month, number of maximal interictal paroxysmal discharges, and frequency of background activities counted in selected scalp EEG samples, taken throughout the observation period (7–33 months). Significance of changes was evaluated by parametric Students t test. Generalized tonic‐clonic seizures (GTC) decreased dramatically, almost disappearing in all cases (p < 0.001), with a significant reduction in interictal paroxysmal discharges (p < 0.01) and a tendency toward an increase in EEG back‐ground frequency. Other generalized seizures (atypical absences) decreased significantly, but there was no change in the number of complex partial seizures (CPS). CM stimulation is useful in control of GTC, but its beneficial effect on other seizure types has not been established.

Subacute and Chronic Electrical Stimulation of the Hippocampus on Intractable Temporal Lobe Seizures: Preliminary Report

Recent animal experiments show that the application of an electrical stimulus to the amygdala or hippocampus following the kindling stimulus produced a significant and long-lasting suppressive effect on this experimental model of epilepsy. This is a preliminary report on the development of a surgical neuromodulatory procedure by chronic electrical stimulation of the hippocampus (CHCS) for control of intractable temporal lobe seizures in patients in whom anterior temporal lobectomy is not advisable, i.e., patients with bilateral temporal foci or a unilateral focus spreading to surrounding cerebral regions of the dominant hemisphere. This work was divided in two main consecutive stages. In the first stage, we demonstrated that subacute hippocampal stimulation (SAHCS) blocks intractable temporal lobe epileptogenesis with no additional damage to the stimulated tissue, and in a second stage, we attempt to demonstrate that CHCS may produce a sustained, long-lasting antiepileptic condition without additional undesirable effects on language and memory. In addition, taking advantage of this unique and ethically permissible situation, we attempt to determine whether or not the antiepileptic effects of SAHCS and CHCS are due to inhibition of the stimulation of hippocampal tissue by means of a number of electrophysiological, single photon computed tomography (SPECT) perfusion, and autoradiographic techniques.SAHCS during 3-4 weeks prior to anterior temporal lobectomy applied to a critical area located either at the anterior Pes hippocampus close to the amygdala or at the parahippocampal gyrus close to the entorhinal cortex abolished clinical seizures and significantly decreased the number of interictal spikes at focus after 5-6 days. Microscopy analysis of the stimulated tissue showed no evident histopathological differences between stimulated vs. non-stimulated hippocampal tissues. Additionally, CHCS persistently blocked temporal lobe epileptogenesis for 3-4 months with no apparent additional undesirable effects on short memory. Also, inhibition of the stimulated hippocampus seems to be one of the possible mechanisms underlying the beneficial antiepileptic effects of SAHCS and CHCS. This was revealed by increased threshold and decreased duration of the afterdischarges induced by hippocampal stimulation, flattening of the hippocampal-evoked response recovery cycles, SPECT hypoperfusion of the hippocampal region, and increased hippocampal benzodiazepine receptor binding. Future studies increasing the number and time of follow-up of patients under hippocampal stimulation are necessary before considering CHCS a reliable procedure for controlling intractable temporal lobe seizures.

Predictors in the Treatment of Difficult-to-control Seizures by Electrical Stimulation of the Centromedian Thalamic Nucleus

OBJECTIVEnTo evaluate the efficacy of chronic electrical stimulation of centromedian thalamic nuclei (ESCM) in the treatment of difficult-to-control seizures.nnnMETHODSnThirteen patients underwent ESCM for periods ranging from 12 to 94 months (mean, 41.2 mo) with electrodes stereotactically placed in both centromedian nuclei and connected to internalized stimulation systems. Electrode placement was guided by ventriculography and confirmed with magnetic resonance imaging before stimulation systems were internalized. Anatomic and electrophysiological confirmation of the electrodes position was accomplished by plotting electrode position on anatomic sections of Schaltenbrand and Baileys atlas, and testing cortical recruiting responses and electroencephalogram desynchronization elicited by acute low- or high-frequency stimulation, respectively.nnnRESULTSnImprovement was highly significant for generalized tonicoclonic seizures and atypical absences. Better results were obtained for Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. These results were accompanied by a significant decrease in generalized spike-wave and secondary synchronous discharges, as well as focal spikes in the frontal regions. In contrast, ESCM reduced neither complex partial seizures nor focal spikes in temporal regions. Outcomes using ESCM for generalized epilepsy were better in patients in whom anatomic and electrophysiological confirmation of electrode placement was correct than in those in whom the target was missed bilaterally (P < 0.001). The effect was sustained during the observation period and was better for longer-term than for shorter-term stimulation periods.nnnCONCLUSIONnESCM is an efficient and safe procedure for controlling certain seizure types, if patient selection and stereotactic placement are satisfactory.

Acute and Chronic Electrical Stimulation of the Centromedian Thalamic Nucleus: Modulation of Reticulo-Cortical Systems and Predictor Factors for Generalized Seizure Control

The present report recapitulates the clinical and electrophysiologic studies we have performed on patients with certain forms of medically intractable epilepsy to investigate the basic mechanisms and predictor factors for seizure control of the electrical stimulation of the thalamic centromedian nucleus (CM) procedure. Acute electrical stimulation of CM reveals that in humans, as in other animals, CM represents a thalamic relay of a reticulo-cortical system that participates crucially in wakefulness and attentive processes and in regulation of cortical excitability, as well as in the physiopathology of genuine generalized epileptic seizures. For example, unilateral, threshold, low-frequency (6/sec) stimulation of CM produced electrocortical incremental responses, while high-frequency (60/sec) stimulation of CM produced electroencephalogram (EEG) desynchronization and electronegative DC shifts with no behavioral counterparts. In contrast, combined suprathreshold low-frequency (3/sec) stimulation of CM on one side and of mesencephalic reticular stimulation on the other produced generalized spike-wave complex discharges accompanied by the symptoms of a typical absence attack, including motionless stare, eye blinking, and unresponsiveness of patients to a series of flashes under a simple response task. Chronic bilateral, threshold, high-frequency (60/sec) stimulation of CM significantly decreased the number of primary and secondary generalized tonic-clonic seizures and atypical absence attacks and the amount of interictal generalized EEG discharges in both. In addition, it improved the psychological performance of patients and normalized the EEG by increasing the frequency of background EEG activity. In contrast, chronic stimulation of CM reduced neither the number of complex partial seizures nor the epileptic EEG activities localized in the temporal region. Good outcomes of the chronic CM stimulation procedure were achieved depending on correct selection of patients and accuracy of ventriculographic stereotactic targets, as well as on periodic clinical and EEG evaluation and electrophysiologic monitoring of CM electrical stimulation reliability. However, the presence of 3- to 6-month long-lasting effects of CM stimulation made statistical evaluation of ON-OFF effects of CM stimulation under placebo, double-masked randomized experiments difficult.

Effect of Chronic Electrical Stimulation of the Centromedian Thalamic Nuclei on Various Intractable Seizure Patterns: I. Clinical Seizures and Paroxysmal EEG Activity

Twenty‐three patients with various intractable seizure patterns were divided into four groups based on their most frequent seizure type and their clinical and EEG response to chronic electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nuclei (ESCM): group A, generalized tonic‐clonic (GTC, n = 9); group B, partial motor (Rasmussen type) (n = 3); group C, complex partial seizures (CPS, n = 5); and group D, generalized tonic seizures (Lennox‐Gastaut type) (n = 6). CM were radiologically and electrophysiologically localized by means of stereotaxic landmarks and by thalamically induced scalp recruitinglike responses and desynchronization. ESCM consisted of daily 2‐h stimulation sessions for 3 months. Each stimulus consisted of a 1‐min train of square pulses with a 4‐min interstimulus interval, alternating right and left CM. Each pulse was 1.0 ms in duration at 60/s frequency and 8–15 V (400–1,250 μ‐A) amplitude. Voltage (V), current flow (μA) and impedance (kΩ) at the electrode tips were kept constant. A significant decrease in the number of seizures per month and paroxysmal EEG waves per 10‐s epochs occurred in group A patients between the baseline period (BL) and the ESCM period. These changes persisted for >3 months after discontinuation of ESCM (poststimulation period, Post). Post was accompanied by a significant decrease in the number of paroxysmal EEG discharges. A substantial decrease in seizures and paroxysmal discharges was also observed in patients of group B. In contrast, patients of groups C and D showed no significant changes from BL to ESCM and Post periods, except for a significant decrease in the number of seizures in group D patients from BL to Post periods.

Electrical stimulation of the prelemniscal radiation in the treatment of Parkinson's disease: an old target revised with new techniques.

OBJECTIVEIn the treatment of tremor and rigidity in patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD), the prelemniscal radiation (RAPRL), a subthalamic bundle of fibers, is an exquisite target that can be visualized easily on ventriculograms. We sought to evaluate the effect of electrical stimulation of the RAPRL on symptoms and signs of PD in a long-term trial and to determine the localization of the stimulated area by means of stereotactic magnetic resonance imaging studies. METHODSTen patients with PD predominantly on one side had tetrapolar electrodes stereotactically oriented through a frontal parasagittal approach to the RAPRL contralateral to the most prominent symptoms. Preoperative and postoperative evaluations at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months after surgery were performed using conventional PD scales and quantitative evaluations of tremor amplitude and reaction time. Stereotactic high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging studies with the electrodes in place were used for anatomic localization. RESULTSIn all patients, temporary suppression of tremor occurred when the electrodes reached the target. The most effective stimulation was obtained when the pair of contacts was placed in the RAPRL. Long-term stimulation at 130 Hz, 0.09 to 0.450 milliseconds, and 1.5 to 3.0 V produced significant improvement in tremor and rigidity and mild improvement in bradykinesia. CONCLUSIONThe RAPRL is an effective target for the alleviation of tremor and rigidity in patients with PD by either lesioning or neuromodulation; however, neuromodulation has the advantage of not inducing an increase in bradykinesia. The stimulated area seems to be independent of the subthalamic nucleus.

Electrocortical and behavioral responses produced by acute electrical stimulation of the human centromedian thalamic nucleus

Incremental, desynchronizing and spike-wave electrocortical responses and concomitant symptoms to acute electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nucleus (CM) were studied in 12 patients with intractable complex partial and tonic-clonic generalized seizures. Low-frequency (6/s), 320-800 microA stimulation of the caudal-basal and central portions of CM elicited incremental recruiting and augmenting-like responses with a bilateral regional scalp distribution, with emphasis at the ipsilateral frontal (recruiting) and central (augmenting) regions, while ventral-basal CM stimulation elicited primary-like responses with a focal distribution at the ipsilateral parietal region. High-frequency (60/s), 320-800 microA stimulation of caudal-basal and central, but not ventral-basal CM, elicited EEG desynchronization and a slow negative shift of the EEG baseline with scalp distribution similar to that showed by recruiting- and augmenting-like responses. Neither incremental nor desynchronization EEG responses were accompanied by evident patient sensory or motor responses. Low-frequency (3/s), high-intensity (30 V = 2400 microA) combined stimulation of the right CM and left non-specific mesencephalic ascending pathways elicited a response similar to the typical absence attack with all EEG and clinical ingredients: S1, S2, P1 and W components of the individual spike-wave complex and generalized spike-wave discharges followed by sleep spindle EEG afterdischarges, accompanied by motionless stare, 3/s eye blinking, lip smacking and total failure to respond to visual stimuli in patients under a simple responding task.

Stimulation of the central median thalamic nucleus for epilepsy

Electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nucleus (ESCM) has been used in cases of difficult to control seizures with multifocal onset in frontal and temporal lobes, as well as in cases of seizures with no evidence of focal onset, such as Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. The stimulation program consists of 1 min stimulation on one side, 4 min interval OFF stimulation and 1 min stimulation on the other side, alternating from one side to the other for 24 h, at 60–130 Hz, 2.5–5.0 V, 0.21–0.45 ms. 49 cases have been treated and followed for periods of 6 months to 15 years. Results indicate that ESCM is highly efficient to control generalized tonic clonic seizures (GTC), atypical absences (AA) and tonic seizures (TS) and less efficient to control complex partial seizures (CxP).

Epileptiform EEG activities of the centromedian thalamic nuclei in patients with intractable partial motor, complex partial, and generalized seizures

Summary: Centromedian thalamic nuclei (CM) epileptiform EEG activities were recorded in patients with intractable partial motor, complex partial, and generalized seizures through implanted recording‐stimulating electrodes, used for seizure control. CM epileptiform activities showed either little or no correlation to focal surface cortical and amygdaloid activities in patients with partial motor and complex partial seizures: CM paroxysmal discharges were correlated to focal epileptiform ictal activities only during the contraversive movements of partial motor and complex partial seizures. In contrast, CM epileptiform activities were consistently correlated to widespread surface cortical activities and clinical symptoms of fully developed nonconvulsive and convulsive tonic‐clonic generalized seizures; i.e., unilateral CM double spike‐wave complex discharges significantly preceded (p < 0.001) the contralateral CM and bilateral surface cortical discharges and symptoms of nonconvulsive generalized seizures. Unilateral CM fast‐slow‐fast paroxysmal discharges significantly preceded (p < 0.005) those of the contralateral CM and bilateral surface cortical regions and symptoms of the convulsive tonic‐clonic generalized seizures. Individual spike‐wave complexes from the frontal region preceded (p < 0.001 and p < 0.005) those at CM and other cortical regions during the nonconvulsive and clonic generalized attacks. No correlations between CM and cortical epileptiform activities were found, however, in the case of abortive, subclinical thalamocortical EEG discharges.

Effect of Chronic Electrical Stimulation of the Centromedian Thalamic Nuclei on Various Intractable Seizure Patterns: II. Psychological Performance and Background EEG Activity

We studied the effect of electrical stimulation of centromedian thalamic nuclei (ESCM) on seizure control and paroxysmal EEG activity in 23 patients. We report the effect of chronic ESCM on psychological performance and background EEG activity of patients with various intractable seizure patterns. In each patient, a simple specifically designed neuropsychological scales (one for adults and one for children) was administered at the end of the baseline (BL), ESCM, and poststimulation (Post) periods; and 14 consecutive EEG recordings during these periods were performed to determine the degree of neuropsychological improvement and the temporal course of EEG changes. A significant increase in psychological scores and the number of background EEG waves per 10 s was noted in groups A (generalized tonic‐clonic seizures, GTC), C (complex partial seizures, CPS), and D (generalized tonic seizures) and the total group of patients from BL to ESCM and from BL to Post periods. Group B patients showed a substantial increase (partial motor seizures) during the same periods. Improvement on psychological performance correlated better with age and baseline degree of deterioration than with the nature of the particular psychological improvement in any given subtest. The improvement in EEG background rhythm was most noticeable at the end of ESCM and at the beginning of the Post periods. Complete normalization of neuropsychologic scores and EEG rhythms was rare, but improvement was significant for both. Psychological scores increased from BL 14 ± 2 to ESCM 21 ± 2 and Post 23 ± 2 (normal expected 26), and EEG background rhythm increased from BL 42 ± 2 to ESCM 62 ± 2 and Post 54 ± 2 EEG waves/10 s. (normal expected >80).