Francisco Velasco

A patient with a resistant major depression disorder treated with deep brain stimulation in the inferior thalamic peduncle

OBJECTIVE AND IMPORTANCE: The present report explored the effect of electrical stimulation on the inferior thalamic peduncle in a patient with resistant major depression disorder (MDD). CLINICAL PRESENTATION: This report refers to a 49-year-old woman with a history of recurrent episodes of major depression for 20 years (12 episodes and 2 hospitalizations), fulfilling Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edition, revised, criteria for MDD; in addition, the patient met criteria for borderline personality disorder and bulimia. Her longest episode of depression with suicidal ideation began 5 years before surgery. The patient’s symptom array responded poorly to different combinations of antidepressants, cognitive therapy, and electroconvulsive therapy, which induced improvement only for short periods of time. Immediately before surgery, her Global Assessment of Functioning score was 20 and her Hamilton Depression Scale score ranged from 33 to 42. The patient was proposed for surgery for MDD. INTERVENTION: The patient had bilateral eight-contact electrodes stereotactically implanted for stimulation of areas at and around the inferior thalamic peduncle. Electrode position was corroborated by unilateral electrical stimulation searching for recruiting responses and regional direct current shifts in the electroencephalogram. Recording electrodes were replaced by tetrapolar electrodes for deep brain stimulation and connected to an internalized stimulation system for continuous bipolar stimulation at 130 Hz, 0.45 milliseconds, 2.5 V. Bimonthly follow-up included psychiatric and neuropsychological evaluations performed over the course of 24 months. After 8 months of ON stimulation, the patient entered a double-blind protocol with stimulators turned OFF. Improvement of depression measured by the Hamilton Depression Scale score was evident after initial placement of electrodes without electrical stimulation. Depression relapsed partially at the end of the first week. Electrical stimulation further improved depression, normalizing depression scores and neuropsychological performance. Patient depression scores ranked between 2 and 8 during 8 months of ON stimulation without antidepressant medication. After stimulation was turned OFF, spontaneous fluctuations in patient symptoms reflected by Hamilton Depression Scale and Global Assessment of Functioning scores were documented; these fluctuations disappeared after stimulation was turned on by Month 20. CONCLUSION: Complicated patients with comorbid conditions are common referrals to psychosurgery services. In this report, we present promising results of electrical stimulation of the inferior thalamic peduncle to treat recurrent unipolar depression in a patient with MDD and borderline personality disorder who responded poorly to treatment.

Electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nucleus in the treatment of convulsive seizures: a preliminary report.

Summary: Five patients with clinical and EEG primary generalized or multifocal uncontrollable seizures underwent stereotaxic implantation of electrodes in both centromedian thalamic nuclei (CM). Each electrode consisted of a semiflexible array of three platinum‐iridium wires, isolated except at their tips, which were separated by 4 mm. Bipolar, biphasic rectangular pulses were delivered in trains of 1 min every 5 min, alternating right and left side for sessions 2 h/day. Patients were followed for 3 months with charting of clinical seizures, daily 4‐h EEG recordings from scalp and depth for 5 days and weekly thereafter. Baseline and 3‐month evaluation of psychological performance through selected Beta R, Wechsler memory scale, visual discrimination, MMPI, and Zungs rated depression scale. Tests were evaluated for significant changes by the parametric students / test and Mann Whitney nonparametric test. Clinical seizures were significantly reduced by electrical stimulation (ES), as were EEG interictal spikes and EEG slow waves. Psychological performance improved beyond that expected by reduction in seizure activity. ESCM induced a local after‐discharge (AD) that progressively developed in time and intensity, and the beneficial effects outlasted ES for periods of weeks to months, suggesting that a state of hy‐perexcitability of stimulated tissue, similar to “kindling,” was created by chronic ES.

Electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nucleus in control of seizures : long-term studies

Summary: Five patients with chronic incapacitating seizures averaging 15–5,000/month were selected for study. All patients had more than one seizure type and had received maximal doses of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs). The centromedian thalamic nucleus (CM) was stimulated electrically through bilateral multicontact platinum electrodes stereotaxically placed in CM and connected to internalized pulse generators. Electrophysiologic confirmation of electrode position included thalamically elicited recruiting responses and EEG desynchronization recorded at the scalp. Stimulation parameters were adjusted individually in the range of 450–800‐μA intensity, 65 pps, 0.09 ms, in 1‐min trains, alternating right and left side stimulation and with 4‐min intervals delivered for 2 h/day. Quantitative evaluation included frequency of seizures/month, number of maximal interictal paroxysmal discharges, and frequency of background activities counted in selected scalp EEG samples, taken throughout the observation period (7–33 months). Significance of changes was evaluated by parametric Students t test. Generalized tonic‐clonic seizures (GTC) decreased dramatically, almost disappearing in all cases (p < 0.001), with a significant reduction in interictal paroxysmal discharges (p < 0.01) and a tendency toward an increase in EEG back‐ground frequency. Other generalized seizures (atypical absences) decreased significantly, but there was no change in the number of complex partial seizures (CPS). CM stimulation is useful in control of GTC, but its beneficial effect on other seizure types has not been established.

Acute and Chronic Electrical Stimulation of the Centromedian Thalamic Nucleus: Modulation of Reticulo-Cortical Systems and Predictor Factors for Generalized Seizure Control

The present report recapitulates the clinical and electrophysiologic studies we have performed on patients with certain forms of medically intractable epilepsy to investigate the basic mechanisms and predictor factors for seizure control of the electrical stimulation of the thalamic centromedian nucleus (CM) procedure. Acute electrical stimulation of CM reveals that in humans, as in other animals, CM represents a thalamic relay of a reticulo-cortical system that participates crucially in wakefulness and attentive processes and in regulation of cortical excitability, as well as in the physiopathology of genuine generalized epileptic seizures. For example, unilateral, threshold, low-frequency (6/sec) stimulation of CM produced electrocortical incremental responses, while high-frequency (60/sec) stimulation of CM produced electroencephalogram (EEG) desynchronization and electronegative DC shifts with no behavioral counterparts. In contrast, combined suprathreshold low-frequency (3/sec) stimulation of CM on one side and of mesencephalic reticular stimulation on the other produced generalized spike-wave complex discharges accompanied by the symptoms of a typical absence attack, including motionless stare, eye blinking, and unresponsiveness of patients to a series of flashes under a simple response task. Chronic bilateral, threshold, high-frequency (60/sec) stimulation of CM significantly decreased the number of primary and secondary generalized tonic-clonic seizures and atypical absence attacks and the amount of interictal generalized EEG discharges in both. In addition, it improved the psychological performance of patients and normalized the EEG by increasing the frequency of background EEG activity. In contrast, chronic stimulation of CM reduced neither the number of complex partial seizures nor the epileptic EEG activities localized in the temporal region. Good outcomes of the chronic CM stimulation procedure were achieved depending on correct selection of patients and accuracy of ventriculographic stereotactic targets, as well as on periodic clinical and EEG evaluation and electrophysiologic monitoring of CM electrical stimulation reliability. However, the presence of 3- to 6-month long-lasting effects of CM stimulation made statistical evaluation of ON-OFF effects of CM stimulation under placebo, double-masked randomized experiments difficult.

Effect of Chronic Electrical Stimulation of the Centromedian Thalamic Nuclei on Various Intractable Seizure Patterns: I. Clinical Seizures and Paroxysmal EEG Activity

Twenty‐three patients with various intractable seizure patterns were divided into four groups based on their most frequent seizure type and their clinical and EEG response to chronic electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nuclei (ESCM): group A, generalized tonic‐clonic (GTC, n = 9); group B, partial motor (Rasmussen type) (n = 3); group C, complex partial seizures (CPS, n = 5); and group D, generalized tonic seizures (Lennox‐Gastaut type) (n = 6). CM were radiologically and electrophysiologically localized by means of stereotaxic landmarks and by thalamically induced scalp recruitinglike responses and desynchronization. ESCM consisted of daily 2‐h stimulation sessions for 3 months. Each stimulus consisted of a 1‐min train of square pulses with a 4‐min interstimulus interval, alternating right and left CM. Each pulse was 1.0 ms in duration at 60/s frequency and 8–15 V (400–1,250 μ‐A) amplitude. Voltage (V), current flow (μA) and impedance (kΩ) at the electrode tips were kept constant. A significant decrease in the number of seizures per month and paroxysmal EEG waves per 10‐s epochs occurred in group A patients between the baseline period (BL) and the ESCM period. These changes persisted for >3 months after discontinuation of ESCM (poststimulation period, Post). Post was accompanied by a significant decrease in the number of paroxysmal EEG discharges. A substantial decrease in seizures and paroxysmal discharges was also observed in patients of group B. In contrast, patients of groups C and D showed no significant changes from BL to ESCM and Post periods, except for a significant decrease in the number of seizures in group D patients from BL to Post periods.

Electrical stimulation of the prelemniscal radiation in the treatment of Parkinson's disease: an old target revised with new techniques.

OBJECTIVEIn the treatment of tremor and rigidity in patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD), the prelemniscal radiation (RAPRL), a subthalamic bundle of fibers, is an exquisite target that can be visualized easily on ventriculograms. We sought to evaluate the effect of electrical stimulation of the RAPRL on symptoms and signs of PD in a long-term trial and to determine the localization of the stimulated area by means of stereotactic magnetic resonance imaging studies. METHODSTen patients with PD predominantly on one side had tetrapolar electrodes stereotactically oriented through a frontal parasagittal approach to the RAPRL contralateral to the most prominent symptoms. Preoperative and postoperative evaluations at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months after surgery were performed using conventional PD scales and quantitative evaluations of tremor amplitude and reaction time. Stereotactic high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging studies with the electrodes in place were used for anatomic localization. RESULTSIn all patients, temporary suppression of tremor occurred when the electrodes reached the target. The most effective stimulation was obtained when the pair of contacts was placed in the RAPRL. Long-term stimulation at 130 Hz, 0.09 to 0.450 milliseconds, and 1.5 to 3.0 V produced significant improvement in tremor and rigidity and mild improvement in bradykinesia. CONCLUSIONThe RAPRL is an effective target for the alleviation of tremor and rigidity in patients with PD by either lesioning or neuromodulation; however, neuromodulation has the advantage of not inducing an increase in bradykinesia. The stimulated area seems to be independent of the subthalamic nucleus.

Electrocortical and behavioral responses produced by acute electrical stimulation of the human centromedian thalamic nucleus

Incremental, desynchronizing and spike-wave electrocortical responses and concomitant symptoms to acute electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nucleus (CM) were studied in 12 patients with intractable complex partial and tonic-clonic generalized seizures. Low-frequency (6/s), 320-800 microA stimulation of the caudal-basal and central portions of CM elicited incremental recruiting and augmenting-like responses with a bilateral regional scalp distribution, with emphasis at the ipsilateral frontal (recruiting) and central (augmenting) regions, while ventral-basal CM stimulation elicited primary-like responses with a focal distribution at the ipsilateral parietal region. High-frequency (60/s), 320-800 microA stimulation of caudal-basal and central, but not ventral-basal CM, elicited EEG desynchronization and a slow negative shift of the EEG baseline with scalp distribution similar to that showed by recruiting- and augmenting-like responses. Neither incremental nor desynchronization EEG responses were accompanied by evident patient sensory or motor responses. Low-frequency (3/s), high-intensity (30 V = 2400 microA) combined stimulation of the right CM and left non-specific mesencephalic ascending pathways elicited a response similar to the typical absence attack with all EEG and clinical ingredients: S1, S2, P1 and W components of the individual spike-wave complex and generalized spike-wave discharges followed by sleep spindle EEG afterdischarges, accompanied by motionless stare, 3/s eye blinking, lip smacking and total failure to respond to visual stimuli in patients under a simple responding task.

Stimulation of the central median thalamic nucleus for epilepsy

Electrical stimulation of the centromedian thalamic nucleus (ESCM) has been used in cases of difficult to control seizures with multifocal onset in frontal and temporal lobes, as well as in cases of seizures with no evidence of focal onset, such as Lennox-Gastaut syndrome. The stimulation program consists of 1 min stimulation on one side, 4 min interval OFF stimulation and 1 min stimulation on the other side, alternating from one side to the other for 24 h, at 60–130 Hz, 2.5–5.0 V, 0.21–0.45 ms. 49 cases have been treated and followed for periods of 6 months to 15 years. Results indicate that ESCM is highly efficient to control generalized tonic clonic seizures (GTC), atypical absences (AA) and tonic seizures (TS) and less efficient to control complex partial seizures (CxP).

Subcortical correlates of the somatic, auditory and visual vertex activities. II. Referential EEG responses

A systematic analysis of polarity, amplitude and latency of the referential EEG responses correlated to surface somatic (SVA), auditory (AVA) and visual (VVA) vertex activities (VA) was done in various subcortical structures of a non-specific system of the same group of patients with electrodes implanted and reported in a previous work. These structures included the caudal and rostral mesencephalic reticular formations (cttc and rttc), the subthalamic region (Sth), the centro-median (Ce), parafascicular (Pf), ventrolateral (VL), dorsolateral (DL) and reticularis (Rt) thalamic nuclei; the orbito-frontal cortex (GO), the anterior commissure (Acm), the pallidum medialis and lateralis (Pm and Pl), the putamen (Pt) and the amygdala (Am). Subcortical SVA, AVA and VVA were formed by 4 consecutive components O, A, B and C correlated to components P1, N1, P2 and N2 of the surface VA. Components A and B of the subcortical SVA reversed polarity 4 times when recorded in structures arranged in a caudo-rostral order: between rttc-Ce and VL, between Rt and GO, between GO and Acm and between Acm and Am. Components A and B of subcortical AVA and VVA reversed polarity two times each: AVA between cttc and rttc and between GO and Acm; while VVA between GO and Acm and between Acm and Pm. Components A and B of SVA and VVA attained maximal amplitudes and minimal latencies at GO. From here, their amplitude decreased and latency increased with distance along other structures rostrally and caudally located. Components A and B of AVA attained maximal amplitudes and minimal latencies at cttc.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cortical Stimulation and Epileptic Seizure: A Study of the Potential Risk in Primates

OBJECTIVE The recent successful development of chronic stimulation of the motor cortex as a treatment for neuropathic and central pain does not exclude the possibility of eventual side effects, such as epileptic seizure or a lowering of the epileptic threshold. This study evaluates the behavioral and electroencephalographic impact of this treatment in three normal monkeys. RESULTS None of the monkeys presented epileptic behavior or abnormal electroencephalographic activity at parameters of stimulation currently used in clinical series, i.e., frequency and pulse duration of approximately 40 Hz and 90 microseconds, respectively, and an intensity just under the threshold for inducing muscle twitch in painful areas. Higher intensities did, however, induce reversible epileptic seizure. There was, nonetheless, no modification of the epileptic threshold, because even after these seizures, intermittent light stimulation elicited no abnormal electroencephalographic activity. CONCLUSION It thus seems that motor cortex stimulation does not induce epileptic complications when the classic clinical criteria of stimulation are respected. Nevertheless, it would be wise to subject candidates for implantation to intermittent light stimulation before and after a period of stimulation to ascertain the innocuousness of the cortical stimulation.