Andrea Mazzucato

Genomic analyses provide insights into the history of tomato breeding

The histories of crop domestication and breeding are recorded in genomes. Although tomato is a model species for plant biology and breeding, the nature of human selection that altered its genome remains largely unknown. Here we report a comprehensive analysis of tomato evolution based on the genome sequences of 360 accessions. We provide evidence that domestication and improvement focused on two independent sets of quantitative trait loci (QTLs), resulting in modern tomato fruit ∼100 times larger than its ancestor. Furthermore, we discovered a major genomic signature for modern processing tomatoes, identified the causative variants that confer pink fruit color and precisely visualized the linkage drag associated with wild introgressions. This study outlines the accomplishments as well as the costs of historical selection and provides molecular insights toward further improvement.

Genetic diversity, structure and marker-trait associations in a collection of Italian tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) landraces

The study of phenotypic and genetic diversity in landrace collections is important for germplasm conservation. In addition, the characterisation of very diversified materials with molecular markers offers a unique opportunity to define significant marker-trait associations of biological and agronomic interest. Here, 50 tomato landraces (mainly collected in central Italy), nine vintage and modern cultivars, and two wild outgroups were grown at two locations in central Italy and characterised for 15 morpho-physiological traits and 29 simple sequence repeat (SSR) loci. The markers were selected to include a group of loci in regions harbouring reported quantitative trait loci (QTLs) that affect fruit size and/or shape (Q-SSRs) and a group of markers that have not been mapped or shown to have a priori known linkage (NQ-SSRs). As revealed by univariate and multivariate analyses of morphological data, the landraces grouped according to vegetative and reproductive traits, with emphasis on fruit size, shape and final destination of the product. Compared to the low molecular polymorphism reported in tomato modern cultivars, our data reveal a high level of molecular diversity in landraces. Such diversity has allowed the inference of the existence of a genetic structure that was factored into the association analysis. As the proportion of significant associations is higher between the Q-SSR subset of markers and the subset of traits related to fruit size and shape than for all of the other combinations, we conclude that this approach is valid for establishing true-positive marker-trait relationships in tomato.

Tomato fruit set driven by pollination or by the parthenocarpic fruit allele are mediated by transcriptionally regulated gibberellin biosynthesis

We investigated the role of gibberellins (GAs) in the phenotype of parthenocarpic fruit (pat), a recessive mutation conferring parthenocarpy in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.). Novel phenotypes that parallel those reported in plants repeatedly treated with gibberellic acid or having a GA-constitutive response indicate that the pat mutant probably expresses high levels of GA. The retained sensitivity to the GA-biosynthesis inhibitor paclobutrazol reveals that this condition is dependent on GA biosynthesis. Expression analysis of genes encoding key enzymes involved in GA biosynthesis shows that in normal tomato ovaries, the GA20ox1 transcript is in low copy number before anthesis and only pollination and fertilization increase its transcription levels and, thus, GA biosynthesis. In the unpollinated ovaries of the pat mutant, this mechanism is de-regulated and GA20ox1 is constitutively expressed, indicating that a high GA concentration could play a part in the parthenocarpic phenotype. The levels of endogenous GAs measured in the floral organs of the pat mutant support such a hypothesis. Collectively, the data indicate that transcriptional regulation of GA20ox1 mediates pollination-induced fruit set in tomato and that parthenocarpy in pat results from the mis-regulation of this mechanism. As genes involved in the control of GA synthesis (LeT6, LeT12 and LeCUC2) and response (SPY) are also altered in the pat ovary, it is suggested that the pat mutation affects a regulatory gene located upstream of the control of fruit set exerted by GAs.

Inheritance of parental genomes in progenies of Poa pratensis L. from sexual and apomictic genotypes as assessed by RAPD markers and flow cytometry

Abstract Moving gene(s) responsible for the apomictic trait into crop plants that naturally reproduce through a sexual process would open up new areas in plant breeding and agricultural systems. Kentucky bluegrass (Poa pratensis L.) is one of the most important forage and turf grasses in temperate climates. It reproduces through facultative aposporous parthenogenesis, but the reproductive behaviour ranges naturally from nearly obligate apomixis to complete sexuality. In addition to apomictic reproduction, sexual hybridization may take place. Selfing may also occur, and occasionally reduced egg cells may develop through parthenogenesis generating (poly)haploids. The inheritance of parental genomes was assessed in Kentucky bluegrass progenies by employing RAPD markers in combination with flow cytometry (FCM). Nine progenies from different crosses carried out between completely sexual and highly apomictic genotypes were evaluated in order to probe the reproductive behaviour of the mother plants and to distinguish the different classes of aberrant plants. Not only were maternals and balanced BII hybrids recorded, but so were (poly)triploid BIII hybrids, selfs, and (poly)haploids. The application of these techniques demonstrated that FCM analysis accurately distinguishes the n, 2n, and 3n ploidy levels of progenies, and that RAPD markers unequivocally recognize progenies of apomictic and hybrid origin. The occurrence of aneusomaty was documented in one of the selected sexual genotypes, whose crossed progeny plants manifested two distinct classes of ploidy. The nomenclature BI was adopted to refer to hybrids with a hypodiploid nuclear condition. On the whole, the FCM analysis confirmed most of the RAPD data. The combined evaluation of DNA markers and DNA contents proved to be an efficient screening tool for scoring maternal plants, assessing the genetic origin of aberrant plants, and quantifying the inheritance of parental genomes in Kentucky bluegrass. Hybrid populations from sexual×apomictic matings that segregate for the mode of reproduction represent a valuable basis for attempting to identify molecular markers linked to the apomixis gene(s).

Characterization of genes controlling stamen identity and development in a parthenocarpic tomato mutant indicates a role for the DEFICIENS ortholog in the control of fruit set.

The development of the ovary into a fruit depends on pollination and fertilization. It has been proposed that the restriction of ovary growth before pollination is because of the stamens acting as negative regulators. Accordingly, the silencing of genes responsible for stamen identity has been correlated with parthenocarpy in different species. The tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) parthenocarpic fruit (pat) mutation associates autonomous ovary development with homeotic transformation of the anthers and aberrancy of ovules in the ovary. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that stamen aberrations and parthenocarpy in pat are driven by cues coming from the altered expression of class B MADS box genes. The data showed that the Pat locus is not allelic to either of the two tomato mutations putatively involved in the B function, stamenless (sl)-2 and pistillate (pi) or to genes encoding class B transcription factors. Whereas pat pi double mutants were not recovered because of tight linkage, pat sl-2 double mutants showed mainly epistatic effects. The developmental regulation of the Sl DEFICIENS (DEF) gene in the wild-type (WT) at anthesis as well as its differential transcription in the pat ovary suggest that it plays a role in the control of ovary growth. Accordingly, when compared with the WT, the gene was also differentially expressed in the parthenocarpic fruit-2 (pat-2) mutant, that is not allelic to pat and has normal ovule development. Altogether the results indicate that in tomato SlDEF plays a role in the control of ovary growth and that the pat mutation is located upstream of this regulatory cascade.

Constitutive co-suppression of the GA 20-oxidase1 gene in tomato leads to severe defects in vegetative and reproductive development.

To dissect the role of gibberellins in tomato development, we have constitutively down-regulated the gene GA 20-oxidase1 (GA20ox1). Plants co-suppressed for GA20ox1 (referred to as CO-6 plants) showed vegetative defects typical of GA deficiency such as darker and mis-shaped leaves and dwarfism. CO-6 plants flowered as the controls, although their flowers had subtle defects in the pedicel and in organ insertion. Analysis of male development revealed defects before, during and after meiosis, and a final pollen viability of 22%. The development of female organs and gametes appeared normal. Pollination experiments indicated that the pollen produced by CO-6 plants was able to fertilize control ovaries, but the analysis of the progeny showed that the construct was not transmitted. Ovaries of CO-6 plants showed high fruit set and normal fruit development when pollinated with control pollen. However these fruits were completely seedless due to a stenospermocarpic behaviour that was evidenced by callose layering in the endothelium between 7 and 15 days after pollination. We conclude that GA20ox1 in tomato exerts specific developmental roles that are not redundantly shared with other members of this gene family. For reproductive male development, silencing of this gene is detrimental for pollen production and either gametophytically lethal or severely hampering seed germination. In the pistil, the co-suppression construct does not affect the progamic phase, nor fruit set and growth, but it interferes with seed development after fertilization leading to seed abortion.

Biochemical and molecular markers for investigating the mode of reproduction in the facultative apomict Poa pratensis L.

Isozymes and random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers were used for precocious identification of non-maternal plants in progenies of the facultative apomict Poa pratensis. Four progenies obtained from controlled crosses that showed different degrees of apomixis on isozyme analysis of phospho-gluco-isomerases, esterases and peroxidases were chosen for RAPD analysis to generate genomic fingerprints using species-specific primers. At an advanced vegetative stage, a morphological analysis was also performed and characteristics related to growth habit and leaf morphology were observed and recorded. On the basis of the isozyme and RAPD electrophoretic pattern and the morphological appearance, each plant was classified as maternal or aberrant. All three classes of genetic markers employed were able to identify plants that exhibited aberrant traits in the four progenies. Overall, the results of RAPD analysis supported those of isozyme and morphology studies. However, in each progeny, some plants which both isozyme and morphological analyses distinguished as of maternal origin were aberrant according to RAPD analysis. Therefore, the RAPD method proved the most precise screening technique. The greater cost of the molecular approach was offset by its higher accuracy. The use of either three isozyme systems or six primers for PCR amplification seems to be sufficient for reliable estimation of the degree of apomixis. Histological analyses were carried out and the aposporic development of the plant material studied.

A TILLING allele of the tomato Aux/IAA9 gene offers new insights into fruit set mechanisms and perspectives for breeding seedless tomatoes

Parthenocarpy is a desired trait in fruit crops; it enables fruit set under environmental conditions suboptimal for pollination, and seedless fruits represent a valuable consumer product. We employed TILLING-based screening of a mutant tomato population to find genetic lesions in Aux/IAA9, a negative regulator of the auxin response involved in the control of fruit set. We identified three mutations located in the coding region of this gene, including two single-base substitutions and one single-base deletion, which leads to a frame shift and premature stop codon. The transcription of IAA9 was strongly reduced in the frame-shift mutant, and partial loss of mutated protein activity was evidenced by an in vitro transactivation assay. Whereas missense mutations were predicted to be tolerated and did not cause mutant phenotypes, the frame-shift mutation-induced phenotypes expected for a loss of IAA9 function, including altered axillary shoot growth, reduced leaf compoundness and a strong tendency to produce parthenocarpic fruits. Mutant flowers showed pleiotropic anther cone defects, a phenotype frequently associated with parthenocarpy in tomato and other species. Mutant fruits were larger than those of the seeded control, with higher brix values and similar firmness. Fruit set was higher in the mutant than in wild type in the greenhouse, but lower in the open field. Facultative expression of parthenocarpy indicated that the mutant is suitable for hybrid seed production and for increasing seeds of parental lines. The results highlight the utility of this novel IAA9 allele for exploiting parthenocarpy by breeding tomato adapted to pollination-limiting growth conditions.

Exploring a Tomato Landraces Collection for Fruit-Related Traits by the Aid of a High-Throughput Genomic Platform.

During its evolution and domestication Solanum lycopersicum has undergone various genetic ‘bottlenecks’ and extreme inbreeding of limited genotypes. In Europe the tomato found a secondary centre for diversification, which resulted in a wide array of fruit shape variation given rise to a range of landraces that have been cultivated for centuries. Landraces represent a reservoir of genetic diversity especially for traits such as abiotic stress resistance and high fruit quality. Information about the variation present among tomato landrace populations is still limited. A collection of 123 genotypes from different geographical areas was established with the aim of capturing a wide diversity. Eighteen morphological traits were evaluated, mainly related to the fruit. About 45% of morphological variation was attributed to fruit shape, as estimated by the principal component analysis, and the dendrogram of relatedness divided the population in subgroups mainly on the basis of fruit weight and locule number. Genotyping was carried out using the tomato array platform SolCAP able to interrogate 7,720 SNPs. In the whole collection 87.1% markers were polymorphic but they decreased to 44–54% when considering groups of genotypes with different origin. The neighbour-joining tree analysis clustered the 123 genotypes into two main branches. The STRUCTURE analysis with K = 3 also divided the population on the basis of fruit size. A genomic-wide association strategy revealed 36 novel markers associated to the variation of 15 traits. The markers were mapped on the tomato chromosomes together with 98 candidate genes for the traits analyzed. Six regions were evidenced in which candidate genes co-localized with 19 associated SNPs. In addition, 17 associated SNPs were localized in genomic regions lacking candidate genes. The identification of these markers demonstrated that novel variability was captured in our germoplasm collection. They might also provide a viable indirect selection tool in future practical breeding programs.

Phenotypic and genetic characterization of the pistillate mutation in tomato

Many floral phenotypes have been described in decades of tomato genetics, but for very few of them the underlying genes have been identified so far. Because the increasing availability of genome sequence data will facilitate forward genetics in tomato, novel descriptive and map information will help the attribution of genes to phenotypes. In this contribution, we present our work on pistillate (pi), a genotype that directly recalls mutations affecting class B MADS-box genes, but that has not been further characterized after the first description. Plants homozygous for the pi allele appear with Mendelian proportions and, compared to wild-type, show delayed flowering, a frequently modified sympodial segment, higher occurrence of compound inflorescences, and reversion of the floral meristem to vegetative identity. In pi mutant flowers, the most striking aberration is the homeotic transformation of stamens into carpels. Ultrastructural analysis also reveals more or less subtle sepaloid features in the three inner floral whorls, mainly based on the presence, distribution and amount of glandular and non glandular trichomes. In the ovary, a ‘flower within flower’ phenotype was seldom observed; in one instance such phenotype was coupled with the setting of a parthenocarpic fruit, that reiterated the differentiation of a new flower. Mapping experiments positioned PI on the distal end of the long arm of chromosome 3. This position was not compatible with any class B or E MADS box gene; differently, the PI genetic window contained the FALSIFLORA (FA) gene, the tomato orthologue of LEAFY (LFY). The pi defects in flowering time and inflorescence development are in agreement with a direct involvement of the floral meristem identity gene. The class B- and E-like phenotypes shown by pi mutant plants are likely an indirect consequence because FA, as LFY, is reported as a positive regulator of homeotic MADS-box genes. Because fa mutant plants do not form complete flowers, the pi mutation deserves a particular interest, producing four-whorled, although modified, flowers useful to study the functional linkage between flower induction and flower organ identity specification.