Andreas Brunklaus

Genotype–phenotype associations in SCN1A-related epilepsies

Objective: Most mutations in SCN1A-related epilepsies are novel and when an infant presents with febrile seizures (FS) it is uncertain if they will have simple FS, FS+, or develop a severe epilepsy such as Dravet syndrome. Our objective was to examine whether the nature of a SCN1A mutation affects the epilepsy phenotype. Methods: We retrospectively evaluated clinical and genetic data from 273 individuals with SCN1A mutations identified in our laboratory and reviewed data from 546 published cases. We examined whether the mutation class or distribution or nature of amino acid substitution correlated with the epilepsy phenotype, using the Grantham Score (GS) as a measure of physicochemical difference between amino acids. Results: Compared to missense mutations, truncating mutations were associated with earlier mean onset of prolonged seizures (7.4 vs 8.8 months; p = 0.040), myoclonic seizures (16.4 vs 19.4 months; p = 0.041), and atypical absence seizures (19.1 vs 30.6 months; p = 0.001). The median GS was higher in patients with Dravet syndrome compared to polymorphisms (94 vs 58; p = 0.029) and orthologs (94 vs 45; p < 0.001). A high GS was correlated with early onset of seizures (rs = −0.235; p = 0.008). Missense mutations occurred most frequently in the voltage and ion-pore regions where changes in amino acid polarity were greater in the Dravet group compared to the genetic epilepsy with febrile seizures plus group (3.6 vs 2.7; p = 0.031). Conclusions: These findings help define the clinical significance of specific SCN1A mutations based on mutation class and amino acid property and location.

Prognostic, clinical and demographic features in SCN1A mutation-positive Dravet syndrome.

Dravet syndrome is a severe infantile onset epileptic encephalopathy associated with mutations in the sodium channel alpha 1 subunit gene SCN1A. To date no large studies have systematically examined the prognostic, clinical and demographic features of the disease. We prospectively collected data on a UK cohort of individuals with Dravet syndrome during a 5-year study period and analysed demographic information based on UK population and birth figures. From structured referral data we examined a range of clinical characteristics including epilepsy phenotype, seizure precipitants, electroencephalography data, imaging studies, mutation class and response to medication. Predictors of developmental outcome were determined by logistic regression. We identified 241 cases with SCN1A mutation-positive Dravet syndrome, 207 of which were UK-based. The incidence of mutation-positive Dravet syndrome is at least 1:40 900 UK births. Clinical features predicting a worse developmental outcome included status epilepticus (odds ratio = 3.1; confidence interval = 1.5-6.3; P = 0.003), interictal electroencephalography abnormalities in the first year of life (odds ratio = 5.7; confidence interval = 1.9-16.8; P = 0.002) and motor disorder (odds ratio = 3.3; confidence interval = 1.7-6.4; P < 0.001). No significant effect was seen for seizure precipitants, magnetic resonance imaging abnormalities or mutation class (truncating versus missense). Abnormal magnetic resonance imaging was documented in 11% of cases, principally with findings of non-specific brain atrophy or hippocampal changes. Sodium valproate, benzodiazepines and topiramate were reported as being the most helpful medications at the time of referral. Aggravation of seizures was reported for carbamazepine and lamotrigine. The identification of factors influencing prognosis both aids counselling and encourages early, syndrome-specific therapy. Prevention of status epilepticus with regular medication and emergency protocols is important and may influence developmental outcome.

Outcome and Prognostic Features in Opsoclonus-Myoclonus Syndrome From Infancy to Adult Life

OBJECTIVE: Opsoclonus-myoclonus syndrome (OMS) is a serious and often chronically disabling neurologic illness with onset in early childhood. Our aim was to identify long-term neurologic sequelae of OMS and predictors for disease outcome. METHODS: We retrospectively assessed the case records of 101 patients diagnosed with OMS over a 53-year period. Clinical data were obtained from medical record review; we documented age at onset, severity of symptoms, response to treatment, and neurocognitive sequelae. RESULTS: Overall, 21% of the patients had a neuroblastoma detected; however, in those born after 1990, this figure rose to 40%. Sixty-one percent of the patients had a chronic-relapsing course, 32% experienced several acute exacerbations, and 7% had a monophasic course. At the most recent review, 60% had residual motor problems, 66% speech abnormalities, 51% learning disability, and 46% behavior problems. One-third of the patients had normal intellectual outcome and cessation of symptoms. A severe initial presentation predicted a chronic disease course (odds ratio [OR]: 2.77 [95% confidence interval (CI): 1.47–5.23]; P = .002) and later learning disability (OR: 2.03 [95% CI: 1.08–3.79]; P = .026). Those with cognitive impairment were younger at disease onset (15.0 vs 19.5 months; P = .029). A chronic-relapsing disease course was associated with motor (P < .001), speech (P = .001), cognitive (P < .001), and behavior (P = .006) problems. CONCLUSIONS: OMS is a chronic and debilitating illness; those with severe initial symptoms and those who are very young at disease onset are at increased risk of developing long-term sequelae. It is important for affected children to be identified early, because they might benefit from targeted immunomodulating therapy in specialist centers.

Dravet syndrome—From epileptic encephalopathy to channelopathy

Mutations in the gene encoding the α1 subunit of the voltage gated sodium channel (SCN1A) are associated with several epilepsy syndromes, ranging from relatively mild phenotypes found in families with genetic epilepsy with febrile seizures plus (GEFS+) to the severe infant‐onset epilepsy Dravet syndrome. Evidence has emerged of the consequences of SCN1α dysfunction in different neuronal networks across the brain pointing toward a channelopathy model causing the neurologic features of Dravet syndrome that is beyond purely seizure related damage. A genetic change will present according to its severity, the genetic background of the individual, and environmental factors, and will affect a variety of neuronal networks according to channel distribution. This already‐vulnerable system may be susceptible to secondary aggravating events such as status epilepticus. The channelopathy model implies that pharmacologic treatment and the restoration of impaired γ‐aminobutyric acid (GABA)ergic neurotransmission might not only help prevent seizures but might affect the comorbidities of the syndrome. This critical review explores recent evidence relating to the pathogenicity of SCN1A mutations in Dravet syndrome and the effect these have on the wider disease phenotype and discusses whether knowledge of specific genotypes can influence clinical practice. Genetic technology is currently advancing at unprecedented speed and will increase our knowledge of new genes and interacting genetic networks. Clinicians and geneticists will have to work in close collaboration to guarantee good delivery and counseling of genetic testing results.

The clinical utility of an SCN1A genetic diagnosis in infantile‐onset epilepsy

Aim  Genetic testing in the epilepsies is becoming an increasingly accessible clinical tool. Mutations in the sodium channel alpha 1 subunit (SCN1A) gene are most notably associated with Dravet syndrome. This is the first study to assess the impact of SCN1A testing on patient management from both carer and physician perspectives.

Genotype phenotype associations across the voltage-gated sodium channel family

Mutations in genes encoding voltage-gated sodium channels have emerged as the most clinically relevant genes associated with epilepsy, cardiac conduction defects, skeletal muscle channelopathies and peripheral pain disorders. Geneticists in partnership with neurologists and cardiologists are often asked to comment on the clinical significance of specific mutations. We have reviewed the evidence relating to genotype phenotype associations among the best known voltage-gated sodium channel related disorders. Comparing over 1300 sodium channel mutations in central and peripheral nervous system, heart and muscle, we have identified many similarities in the genetic and clinical characteristics across the voltage-gated sodium channel family. There is evidence, that the level of impairment a specific mutation causes can be anticipated by the underlying physico-chemical property change of that mutation. Across missense mutations those with higher Grantham scores are associated with more severe phenotypes and truncating mutations underlie the most severe phenotypes. Missense mutations are clustered in specific areas and are associated with distinct phenotypes according to their position in the protein. Inherited mutations tend to be less severe than de novo mutations which are usually associated with greater physico-chemical difference. These findings should lead to a better understanding of the clinical significance of specific voltage-gated sodium channel mutations, aiding geneticists and physicians in the interpretation of genetic variants and counselling individuals and their families.

Comorbidities and predictors of health‐related quality of life in Dravet syndrome

Purpose:  Health‐related quality of life (HRQOL) has emerged as a widely accepted measure to evaluate how chronic disease impacts on an individual’s physical, social, and mental well‐being. There is a paucity of data focusing on HRQOL in specific epilepsy syndromes and their associated needs. In this study our aim was to describe the comorbidities and disease‐related predictors for HRQOL in Dravet syndrome, an epileptic encephalopathy, with defined genetic etiology. We anticipate that this will help us to better recognize and understand the needs of children and families and aid treatment planning in this severe epilepsy syndrome.

Epileptic activity is a surrogate for an underlying etiology and stopping the activity has a limited impact on developmental outcome

The concept of epileptic encephalopathy is important in clinical practice, but its relevance to an individual must be assessed in the appropriate context. Except in rare situations, epileptic activity is a surrogate for an underlying etiology, and stopping the activity has a limited impact on developmental outcome. Labeling a group of epilepsies as “the epileptic encephalopathies,” risks minimizing the impact of epileptic activity on cognition and behavior more widely in epilepsy. Similarly, describing the encephalopathy associated with many infantile onset epilepsies as “epileptic” may be misleading. Finally, concentrating on the epileptic activity alone and not considering the wider consequences of the underlying etiology on cognitive and behavioral development, may focus research efforts and the search for improved therapies on too narrow a target. Therefore, epileptic encephalopathies should not be considered as a specific group of epilepsies but, rather, the concept of epileptic encephalopathy should be applicable to all types of epilepsies and epilepsy syndromes, whenever it is relevant in the clinical course of a particular individual, at any age.

Health-related quality-of-life and behavioural outcome in survivors of childhood meningitis.

Objective: To describe behavioural and health-related quality-of-life (HRQoL) outcomes in survivors of childhood meningitis and identify variables predictive of psychosocial outcome. Methods: Psychosocial outcomes were measured via parent and teacher report using the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) and the Paediatric Quality of Life Inventory (PedsQL Core & Fatigue versions). Participants were 334 consecutive survivors admitted to a regional childrens hospital (1991–2007). One hundred and twelve of 346 (34%) returned postal questionnaires and file review confirmed diagnosis in 100 cases. Results: At a mean of 8 years post-illness 32% of parents and 19% of teachers reported clinically significant behavioural difficulties on the SDQ; along with significantly lowered HRQoL on PedsQL measures. Later sequelae such as learning disability and hearing/visual impairment, along with socioeconomic status, independently predicted behavioural and HRQoL outcome on regression analysis. Acute disease complications were associated with later occurrence of epilepsy, learning disability and visual impairment, but not directly with psychosocial outcomes at time of follow-up. Conclusions: Survivors with these sequelae should be screened for emotional and behavioural difficulties during key developmental transitions such as school entry. These findings strongly support recent UK clinical guidelines (NICE and SIGN) proposing that parents be made aware of possible psychological complications on discharge.

Dravet syndrome and its mimics: Beyond SCN1A

Dravet syndrome (DS) is a severe developmental and epileptic encephalopathy characterized by the onset of prolonged febrile and afebrile seizures in infancy, and evolving to drug‐resistant epilepsy with accompanying cognitive, behavioral, and motor impairment. Most cases are now known to be caused by pathogenic variants in the sodium channel gene SCN1A, but several other genes have also been implicated. This review examines current understanding of the role of non‐SCN1A genes in DS, and what is known about phenotypic similarities and differences. We discuss whether these are best thought of as minority causes of DS, or as similar but distinct conditions.