Andrew Rutman

Ciliary beat pattern is associated with specific ultrastructural defects in primary ciliary dyskinesia

Abstract Background The main symptoms of primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) are nasal rhinorrhea or blockage and moist-sounding cough. Diagnosis can be difficult and is based on an abnormal ciliary beat frequency, accompanied by specific abnormalities of the ciliary axoneme. It is unknown whether determining ciliary beat pattern related to specific ultrastructural ciliary defects might help in the diagnosis of PCD. Objective We sought to determine ciliary beat pattern and beat frequency (CBF) associated with the 5 common ultrastructural defects responsible for PCD. Methods Nasal brushings were performed on 56 children with PCD. Ciliary movement was recorded using digital high-speed video imaging to assess beat frequency and pattern. Electron microscopy was performed. Results In patients with an isolated outer dynein arm or with an outer and inner dynein arm defect, 55% and 80% of cilia were immotile, respectively. Cilia that moved were only flickering. Mean CBF (± 95% CI) was 2.3 Hz (± 1.2) and 0.8 Hz(± 0.8), respectively. Cilia with an isolated inner dynein arm or a radial spoke defect had similar beat patterns. Cilia appeared stiff, had a reduced amplitude, and failed to bend along their length. Immotile cilia were present in 10% of cilia with an inner dynein arm defect and in 30% of radial spoke defects. Mean CBF was 9.3 Hz (± 2.6) and 6.0 Hz (± 3.1), respectively. The ciliary transposition defect produced a large circular beat pattern (mean CBF, 10.7 Hz [± 1.1]). No cilia were immotile. Conclusions Different ultrastructural defects responsible for PCD result in predictable beat patterns. Recognition of these might help in the diagnostic evaluation of patients suspected of having PCD.

DNAI2 Mutations Cause Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia with Defects in the Outer Dynein Arm

Primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) is a genetically heterogeneous disorder characterized by chronic destructive airway disease and randomization of left/right body asymmetry. Males often have reduced fertility due to impaired sperm tail function. The complex PCD phenotype results from dysfunction of cilia of the airways and the embryonic node and the structurally related motile sperm flagella. This is associated with underlying ultrastructural defects that frequently involve the outer dynein arm (ODA) complexes that generate cilia and flagella movement. Applying a positional and functional candidate-gene approach, we identified homozygous loss-of-function DNAI2 mutations (IVS11+1G > A) in four individuals from a family with PCD and ODA defects. Further mutational screening of 105 unrelated PCD families detected two distinct homozygous mutations, including a nonsense (c.787C > T) and a splicing mutation (IVS3-3T > G) resulting in out-of-frame transcripts. Analysis of protein expression of the ODA intermediate chain DNAI2 showed sublocalization throughout respiratory cilia. Electron microscopy showed that mutant respiratory cells from these patients lacked DNAI2 protein expression and exhibited ODA defects. High-resolution immunofluorescence imaging demonstrated absence of the ODA heavy chains DNAH5 and DNAH9 from all DNAI2 mutant ciliary axonemes. In addition, we demonstrated complete or distal absence of DNAI2 from ciliary axonemes in respiratory cells of patients with mutations in genes encoding the ODA chains DNAH5 and DNAI1, respectively. Thus, DNAI2 and DNAH5 mutations affect assembly of proximal and distal ODA complexes, whereas DNAI1 mutations mainly disrupt assembly of proximal ODA complexes.

Interaction of Pseudomonas aeruginosa with human respiratory mucosa in vitro

Pseudomonas aeruginosa commonly infects the airways of patients with cystic fibrosis and bronchiectasis. It produces several toxins that slow ciliary beat, stimulate mucus production and damage epithelium. It adheres to epithelial cells, damaged mucosa (in animal models), and mucus. However, little is known of the interaction of P. aeruginosa with intact human respiratory mucosa. We have studied the interactions of a nonmucoid clinical isolate of P. aeruginosa with adenoid tissue in a novel organ culture model with an air-mucosal interphase P. aeruginosa (5.9 +/- 0.9 x 10(6) colony-forming units (cfu)) was pipetted onto the organ culture surface, and incubated for 15 min, 1, 2, 4, 8, 12, 16, and 24 h, at 37 degrees C in 5% CO2 in a humidified atmosphere. Assessment has been made by transmission and scanning electron microscopy. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) showed that uninfected organ cultures had normal ultrastructure. TEM of infected organ cultures at 8 h showed significant epithelial damage: 43.9 +/- 10% of cells extruding from the epithelial surface, 17.7 +/- 3% of cells with loss of cilia, 32.9 +/- 10.2% of cells with mitochondrial damage, and 11.6 +/- 3% of cells with cytoplasmic blebbing. P. aeruginosa only infrequently adhered to normal epithelium, but adhered to areas of epithelial damage and to basement membrane. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) of organ cultures up to 2 h found P. aeruginosa only infrequently associated with mucus. SEM at 4 h revealed P. aeruginosa predominantly associated with mucus and extruded damaged epithelial cells, but also occasionally associated with cilia, and very occasionally with unciliated cells.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Functional analysis of cilia and ciliated epithelial ultrastructure in healthy children and young adults

Background: There are very few data on normal ciliary beat frequency, beat pattern, and ultrastructure in healthy children and adults. A study was undertaken to define ciliary structure, beat frequency and beat pattern in a healthy paediatric and young adult population. Methods: Ciliated epithelial samples were obtained from 76 children and adult volunteers aged 6 months to 43 years by brushing the inferior nasal turbinate. Beating cilia were recorded using a digital high speed video camera which allowed analysis of ciliary beat pattern and beat frequency. Tissue was fixed for transmission electron microscopy. Results: The mean ciliary beat frequency for the paediatric population (12.8 Hz (95% CI 12.3 to 13.3)) was higher than for the adult group (11.5 Hz (95% CI 10.3 to 12.7 Hz), p<0.01, t test); 10% (range 6–24%) of ciliated edges were found to have areas of dyskinetically beating cilia. All samples had evidence of mild epithelial damage. This reflected changes found in all measurements used for assessment of epithelial damage. Ciliary ultrastructural defects were found in less than 5% of cilia. Conclusion: Normal age related reference ranges have been established for ciliary structure and beat frequency. In a healthy population localised epithelial damage may be present causing areas of ciliary dyskinesia.

Streptococcus pneumoniae Deficient in Pneumolysin or Autolysin Has Reduced Virulence in Meningitis

BACKGROUND The role played by pneumolysin and autolysin in pneumococcal meningitis is poorly understood. METHODS A rat model was used to investigate the disease, in which surgical implantation of a cisternal catheter allowed bacterial instillation and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) sampling. RESULTS CSF infection of rats with wild-type pneumococci caused meningitis within 26 h, whereas isogenic mutants that do not express pneumolysin (DeltaPly) or autolysin (LytA(-)) caused very mild or no disease. Wild-type infections resulted in pneumococci in the CSF and cortical homogenates, but a minority of the rats infected with DeltaPly or LytA(-) had bacteria in these locations at 26 h. Leukocyte numbers in the CSF were similar after infection with all pneumococci; however, neutrophils and monocytes predominated after wild-type infection, whereas lymphocytes and atypical lymphocytes predominated after infection with the mutants. Wild-type pneumococci caused disruption to the ependyma, but this was not observed in rats infected with DeltaPly or LytA(-). Cells surrounding the ventricles in wild type-infected animals expressed caspase 3, and astrocytes had hypertrophy; both findings were absent in rats infected with the mutants. CONCLUSIONS This study provides strong in vivo evidence that pneumolysin and autolysin play crucial roles in the pathogenesis of pneumococcal meningitis.

Relative Roles of Pneumolysin and Hydrogen Peroxide from Streptococcus pneumoniae in Inhibition of Ependymal Ciliary Beat Frequency

ABSTRACT Ciliated ependymal cells line the ventricular system of the brain and the cerebral aqueducts. This study characterizes the relative roles of pneumolysin and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) in pneumococcal meningitis, using the in vitro ependymal ciliary beat frequency (CBF) as an indicator of toxicity. We have developed an ex vivo model to examine the ependymal surface of the brain slices cut from the fourth ventricle. The ependymal cells had cilia beating at a frequency of between 38 and 44Hz. D39 (wild-type) and PLN-A (pneumolysin-negative) pneumococci at 108 CFU/ml both caused ciliary slowing. Catalase protected against PLN-A-induced ciliary slowing but afforded little protection from D39. Lysed PLN-A did not reduce CBF, whereas lysed D39 caused rapid ciliary stasis. There was no effect of catalase, penicillin, or catalase plus penicillin on the CBF. H2O2 at a concentration as low as 100 μM caused ciliary stasis, and this effect was abolished by coincubation with catalase. An additive inhibition of CBF was demonstrated using a combination of both toxins. A significant inhibition of CBF at between 30 and 120 min was demonstrated with both toxins compared with either H2O2 (10 μM) or pneumolysin (1 HU/ml) alone. D39 released equivalent levels of H2O2 to those released by PLN-A, and these concentrations were sufficient to cause ciliary stasis. The brain slices did not produce H2O2, and in the presence of 108 CFU of D39 or PLN-A per ml there was no detectable bacterially induced increase of H2O2release from the brain slice. Coincubation with catalase converted the H2O2 produced by the pneumococci to H2O. Penicillin-induced lysis of bacteria dramatically reduced H2O2 production. The hemolytic activity released from D39 was sufficient to cause rapid ciliary stasis, and there was no detectable release of hemolytic activity from the pneumolysin-negative PLN-A. These data demonstrate that D39 bacteria released pneumolysin, which caused rapid ciliary stasis. D39 also released H2O2, which contributed to the toxicity, but this was masked by the more severe effects of pneumolysin. H2O2 released from intact PLN-A was sufficient to cause rapid ciliary stasis, and catalase protected against H2O2-induced cell toxicity, indicating a role for H2O2 in the response. There is also a slight additive effect of pneumolysin and H2O2 on ependymal toxicity; however, the precise mechanism of action and the role of these toxins in pathogenesis remain unclear.

MCIDAS mutations result in a mucociliary clearance disorder with reduced generation of multiple motile cilia

Reduced generation of multiple motile cilia (RGMC) is a rare mucociliary clearance disorder. Affected persons suffer from recurrent infections of upper and lower airways because of highly reduced numbers of multiple motile respiratory cilia. Here we report recessive loss-of-function and missense mutations in MCIDAS-encoding Multicilin, which was shown to promote the early steps of multiciliated cell differentiation in Xenopus. MCIDAS mutant respiratory epithelial cells carry only one or two cilia per cell, which lack ciliary motility-related proteins (DNAH5; CCDC39) as seen in primary ciliary dyskinesia. Consistent with this finding, FOXJ1-regulating axonemal motor protein expression is absent in respiratory cells of MCIDAS mutant individuals. CCNO, when mutated known to cause RGMC, is also absent in MCIDAS mutant respiratory cells, consistent with its downstream activity. Thus, our findings identify Multicilin as a key regulator of CCNO/FOXJ1 for human multiciliated cell differentiation, and highlight the 5q11 region containing CCNO and MCIDAS as a locus underlying RGMC.

Mutations in CCDC39 and CCDC40 are the major cause of primary ciliary dyskinesia with axonemal disorganization and absent inner dynein arms.

Primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) is a genetically heterogeneous disorder caused by cilia and sperm dysmotility. About 12% of cases show perturbed 9+2 microtubule cilia structure and inner dynein arm (IDA) loss, historically termed “radial spoke defect.” We sequenced CCDC39 and CCDC40 in 54 “radial spoke defect” families, as these are the two genes identified so far to cause this defect. We discovered biallelic mutations in a remarkable 69% (37/54) of families, including identification of 25 (19 novel) mutant alleles (12 in CCDC39 and 13 in CCDC40). All the mutations were nonsense, splice, and frameshift predicting early protein truncation, which suggests this defect is caused by “null” alleles conferring complete protein loss. Most families (73%; 27/37) had homozygous mutations, including families from outbred populations. A major putative hotspot mutation was identified, CCDC40 c.248delC, as well as several other possible hotspot mutations. Together, these findings highlight the key role of CCDC39 and CCDC40 in PCD with axonemal disorganization and IDA loss, and these genes represent major candidates for genetic testing in families affected by this ciliary phenotype. We show that radial spoke structures are largely intact in these patients and propose this ciliary ultrastructural abnormality be referred to as “IDA and microtubular disorganisation defect,” rather than “radial spoke defect.”

Ciliated air-liquid cultures as an aid to diagnostic testing of primary ciliary dyskinesia.

BACKGROUND The diagnosis of primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) can prove difficult because of secondary damage of ciliated tissue. METHODS Here we audit culturing cells, obtained by nasal brushing, to a ciliated phenotype using an air-liquid interface method to determine if the effects of secondary damage on cilia were reduced following culture. RESULTS Of 231 patients consecutively referred for diagnostic testing, culture was attempted in 187, with 101 (54%) becoming ciliated. Of the 90 brush biopsy samples with a low dyskinesia score (< 40%), 71 grew cilia after culture (79% success). Significant secondary damage (> 40% dyskinesia) was present in 69 (43%) of the initial brush biopsy samples, and of these, 18 (26%) became ciliated after culture. In these samples, ciliary dyskinesia was significantly (P < .001) reduced (64% ± 6.8% before culture, 31% ± 4.5% after culture). Ciliary beat frequency (CBF) after cell culture was similar to CBF before culture. Cell culture helped to exclude PCD in eight patients for whom ciliary dyskinesia was present in > 70% of the initial brush biopsy sample, a level at which a rebiopsy would normally be requested. In six patients in whom no cilia were found in the initial brush biopsy samples, ciliated cell culture was successful and excluded the diagnosis. PCD was diagnosed in 28 patients and ciliated cell culture was successful in 12 (43%) showing identical ciliary beat pattern and electron microscopy findings. CONCLUSIONS Ciliary dyskinesia was reduced following cell culture to a ciliated phenotype compared with the initial brush biopsy sample. The specific PCD phenotype was maintained after culture.

Inner dynein arm defects causing primary ciliary dyskinesia: repeat testing required

Primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) results in chronic nasal symptoms and chest disease leading to bronchiectasis. We noted a number of patients referred for diagnostic testing whose initial results suggested PCD due to an inner dynein arm or radial spoke defect but in whom no abnormality was found on retesting. The present study was an audit of all patients referred for PCD diagnostic testing over a 3-yr period whose initial electron microscopy (EM) and beat pattern analysis suggested an inner dynein arm or radial spoke defect. 21 patients referred for diagnostic testing for PCD suspected of an inner dynein arm defect and six suspected of a radial spoke defect on initial EM and beat pattern analysis had repeat testing performed. On repeat testing, five patients initially suspected of an inner dynein arm defect and one with a radial spoke defect had normal EM and beat pattern, leading to the initial diagnosis being questioned. Patients suspected of PCD due to an inner dynein arm defect or radial spoke defect should have the diagnosis reassessed if it has been based on only one diagnostic sample.