Antonio Verdoliva

Novel ligands for the affinity-chromatographic purification of antibodies

Affinity chromatography represents one of the most powerful fractionation techniques for the large-scale purification of biotechnological products. Despite its potential, the use of this methodology is limited by the availability of specific ligands for each target. Combinatorial chemistry and molecular modeling, often combined, have become interesting and innovative methods for generating novel ligands, tailored to specific biotechnological needs. One of the greatest area of application has been the discovery of novel ligands for the purification of antibodies, which represent an emerging but very important class of innovative therapeutic agents for the treatment of a vast array of diseases. Naturally available affinity ligands, such as Protein A or G for IgG purification or lectins for IgA and IgM purification, which are obtained from microorganisms or genetically modified bacteria through complex and expensive procedures, are not well suited for large-scale purification and require moreover time-consuming analytical controls to check for the presence of contaminants which may affect the safety of the purified antibody for clinical purposes. Recent results suggest that the application of combinatorial technologies and molecular modeling for the discovery of synthetic ligands may open new avenues for the development of more efficient, less expensive and--more importantly--safer procedures for antibody purification at the industrial level.

Immunoglobulin specificity of TG19318: a novel synthetic ligand for antibody affinity purification†

A synthetic ligand [TG19318], able to mimic protein A in the recognition of the immunoglobulin Fc portion, has been previously identified in our laboratory through the synthesis and screening of multimeric combinatorial peptide libraries. In this study we have fully characterized its applicability in affinity chromatography for the downstream processing of antibodies, examining the specificity and selectivity for polyclonal and monoclonal immunoglobulins derived from different sources. Ligand specificity was broader than protein A, since IgG deriving from human, cow, horse, pig, mouse, rat, rabbit, goat and sheep sera, IgY obtained from egg yolk, and IgM, IgA and IgE were efficiently purified on TG19318 affinity columns. Adsorbed antibodies were conveniently eluted by a buffer change to 0.1 M acetic acid or 0.1 M sodium bicarbonate pH 9, with full retention of immunological properties. Monoclonal antibodies deriving from cell culture supernatants or ascitic fluids were also conveniently purified on TG19318 affinity columns, even from very diluted samples. The affinity constant for the TG19318–IgG interaction was 0.3u2005µM, as determined by optical biosensor measurements. Under optimized conditions, antibody purity after affinity purification was close to 95%, as determined by densitometric scanning of SDS–PAGE gels of purified fractions, and maximal column capacity reached 25u2005mg Ig/ml support. In vivo toxicity studies in mice indicated a ligand oral toxicity greater than 2000u2005mg kg−1 while intravenous toxicity was close to 150u2005mg kg−1. Validation of antibody affinity purification processes for therapeutic use, a very complex, laborious and costly procedure, is going to be simplified by the use of TG19318, which could reduce considerably the presence of biological contaminants in the purified preparation, a very recurrent problem when using recombinant or extractive biomolecules as affinity ligands. Copyright

Protein A mimetic peptide ligand for affinity purification of antibodies.

A peptide mimicking protein A for its ability to recognize the Fc immunoglobulin portion has been identified through screening of a synthetic multimeric peptide library. Screening of the multimeric library, composed of randomized synthetic tripeptide tetramers, has been carried out using a very simple assay, measuring the library ability to interfere with the interaction between protein A and biotinylated immunoglobulins, monitored on solid phase using an enzyme‐linked immunosorbent assay format. The tetrameric tripeptide identified after three screening cycles was produced in larger amounts and then immobilized in high yield on preactivated solid support for the preparation of affinity columns, which proved useful for a very convenient one‐step purification of antibodies directly from crude sera. Antibody purity after affinity purification was close to 95 per cent, as determined by densitometric scanning of sodium dodecyl sulphate–polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis gels of purified fractions, and up to 2 mg of antibody could be purified from 1 ml of peptide‐derivatized affinity support. The ligand was stable to treatment with a vast array of sanitation agents, such as ethanol and 0.1 M sodium hydroxide, and to repeated use, thus making the ligand applicability extremely attractive for the purification of monoclonal antibodies for therapeutic use. Column binding selectivity was similar to that of protein A‐affinity columns, since immunoglobulin G from several sources (rabbit, goat, sheep, mouse) was conveniently purified, with no detection of leaked ligand fragments in the purified preparations.

Structural Characterization of PTX3 Disulfide Bond Network and Its Multimeric Status in Cumulus Matrix Organization

PTX3 is an acute phase glycoprotein that plays key roles in resistance to certain pathogens and in female fertility. PTX3 exerts its functions by interacting with a number of structurally unrelated molecules, a capacity that is likely to rely on its complex multimeric structure stabilized by interchain disulfide bonds. In this study, PAGE analyses performed under both native and denaturing conditions indicated that human recombinant PTX3 is mainly composed of covalently linked octamers. The network of disulfide bonds supporting this octameric assembly was resolved by mass spectrometry and Cys to Ser site-directed mutagenesis. Here we report that cysteine residues at positions 47, 49, and 103 in the N-terminal domain form three symmetric interchain disulfide bonds stabilizing four protein subunits in a tetrameric arrangement. Additional interchain disulfide bonds formed by the C-terminal domain cysteines Cys317 and Cys318 are responsible for linking the PTX3 tetramers into octamers. We also identified three intrachain disulfide bonds within the C-terminal domain that we used as structural constraints to build a new three-dimensional model for this domain. Previously it has been shown that PTX3 is a key component of the cumulus oophorus extracellular matrix, which forms around the oocyte prior to ovulation, because cumuli from PTX3-/- mice show defective matrix organization. Recombinant PTX3 is able to restore the normal phenotype ex vivo in cumuli from PTX3-/- mice. Here we demonstrate that PTX3 Cys to Ser mutants, mainly assembled into tetramers, exhibited wild type rescue activity, whereas a mutant, predominantly composed of dimers, had impaired functionality. These findings indicate that protein oligomerization is essential for PTX3 activity within the cumulus matrix and implicate PTX3 tetramers as the functional molecular units required for cumulus matrix organization and stabilization.

Affinity purification of immunoglobulins from chicken egg yolk using a new synthetic ligand

Due to the peculiar composition of the egg yolk and the lack of specific affinity ligands, Y immunoglobulins are normally purified using complex and time consuming procedures involving a combination of precipitation and chromatographic steps first to extract and capture and then to polish IgY. In this study, we have examined the applicability for IgY affinity purification of TG19318, a synthetic ligand for immunoglobulin, obtained from the screening of combinatorial libraries, and already characterized for its capability to purify immunoglobulins of class G, M, E and A. Soluble proteins were separated from the lipidic fraction of egg yolk by the water dilution method and loaded on to TG19318 affinity columns prepared by immobilizing the ligand on the commercially available support Emphaze. In a single chromatographic step TG19318 affinity columns led to an efficient capture of IgY directly from crude samples, and with a purity degree higher than 90%, as determined by densitometric scanning of SDS-PAGE analysis of bound fractions, and with full recovery of antibody activity, as determined by ELISA assay. Higher recovery and purity of IgY was obtained by using loading buffers at pH close to 6.5. Column capacity, determined by applying 4x excess IgY to 1 ml bed volume column, and eluting the retained immunoglobulins, was close to 65 mg of IgY per ml of resin. Chemical and chromatographic stability of TG19318/Emphaze was tested before and after various treatments. The derivatized matrix was found to be very stable, in terms of ligand leakage and maintenance of IgY binding capacity, under conditions of normal column usage, cleaning and storage.

The Angiogenic Inhibitor Long Pentraxin PTX3 Forms an Asymmetric Octamer with Two Binding Sites for FGF2

The inflammation-associated long pentraxin PTX3 plays key roles in innate immunity, female fertility, and vascular biology (e.g. it inhibits FGF2 (fibroblast growth factor 2)-mediated angiogenesis). PTX3 is composed of multiple protomers, each composed of distinct N- and C-terminal domains; however, it is not known how these are organized or contribute to its functional properties. Here, biophysical analyses reveal that PTX3 is composed of eight identical protomers, associated through disulfide bonds, forming an elongated and asymmetric, molecule with two differently sized domains interconnected by a stalk. The N-terminal region of the protomer provides the main structural determinant underlying this quaternary organization, supporting formation of a disulfide-linked tetramer and a dimer of dimers (a non-covalent tetramer), giving rise to the asymmetry of the molecule. Furthermore, the PTX3 octamer is shown to contain two FGF2 binding sites, where it is the tetramers that act as the functional units in ligand recognition. Thus, these studies provide a unifying model of the PTX3 oligomer, explaining both its quaternary organization and how this is required for its antiangiogenic function.

Affinity purification of immunoglobulin M using a novel synthetic ligand.

While monoclonal antibodies of the G class can be conveniently purified by affinity chromatography using immobilized protein A or G, even on a large scale, scaling up IgM purification still presents several problems, since specific and cost-effective ligands for IgM are not available. A synthetic peptide (TG19318), deduced from the screening of a combinatorial peptide library, was characterized previously by our group for its binding properties for immunoglobulins of the G class and its applicability as a synthetic ligand for polyclonal and monoclonal IgG purification, from sera or cell culture supernatants. In this study, we have examined the ligand recognition properties for IgM, immobilizing the synthetic peptide on different affinity supports and examining its ability to purify IgMs from serum, ascitic fluid and cell culture supernatants. TG19318 affinity columns proved useful for a very convenient one-step purification of monoclonal IgMs directly from crude sources, loading the samples on the columns equilibrated with saline buffers at pH values ranging from 5 to 7, and eluting adsorbed IgM by a buffer change to 0.1 M acetic acid or 0.05-0.1 M sodium bicarbonate, pH 9.0. Antibody purity after affinity purification was very high, close to 85-95%, as determined by densitometric scanning of sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels of purified fractions, and by gel permeation analysis. Antibody activity was fully recovered after purification, as determined by immunoassays. Column capacity was related to the type of support used for ligand immobilization, and ranged from 2 to 8 mg of IgM/ml of support.

Novel antitenascin antibody with increased tumour localisation for Pretargeted Antibody-Guided RadioImmunoTherapy (PAGRIT)

The Pretargeted Antibody-Guided RadioImmunoTherapy (PAGRIT) method is based on intravenous, sequential administration of a biotinylated antibody, avidin/streptavidin and 90Y-labelled biotin. The hybridoma clone producing the monoclonal antitenascin antibody BC4, previously used for clinical applications, was found not suitable for further development because of the production of an additional, nonfunctional light chain. In order to solve this problem, the new cST2146 hybridoma clone was generated. The monoclonal antibody ST2146, produced by this hybridoma, having the same specificity as BC4 but lacking the nonfunctional light chain, was characterised. ST2146 was found able to bind human tenascin at an epitope strictly related, if not identical, to the antigenic epitope of BC4. It showed, compared to BC4, higher affinity and immunoreactivity and similar selectivity by immunohistochemistry. Biodistribution studies of biotinylated ST2146 and three other monoclonal antitenascin antibodies showed for ST2146 the highest and more specific tumour localisation in HT29-grafted nude mice. On the overall, ST2146 appears to be a good alternative to BC4 for further clinical development of PAGRIT.

Low and High Tenascin-Expressing Tumors Are Efficiently Targeted by ST2146 Monoclonal Antibody

ST2146biot is a biotinylated anti-tenascin monoclonal antibody (mAb) to be used for Pretargeted Antibody Guided Radioimmunotherapy (PAGRIT) of solid tumors. In vivo biodistribution studies of 125I-labeled ST2146biot were done in nude mice transplanted with human HT-29 colon carcinoma and/or human U-118MG glioblastoma cells characterized for low and high tenascin expression, respectively. In vitro results show that ST2146 retains immunoreactivity upon biotinylation, in contrast to other anti-tenascin mAbs. In vivo biodistribution of ST2146 shows specific tumor accumulation up to 10 days after the i.v. injection, with no relevant differences between biotinylated and nonbiotinylated ST2146. A dose of 4 μg/mouse saturates the low tenascin-expressing human colon carcinoma HT-29, whereas the high tenascin-expressing human glioblastoma U-118MG seems to be saturated at a ST2146biot dose between 320 and 640 μg/mouse. The percentage of injected dose per gram of tumor ranges from 10% to 30%, corresponding to an amount of ST2146biot/g of tumor of ∼400 ng/g and >200 μg/g for HT-29 and U-118MG, respectively. Tumor to normal organs uptake ratios are between 15 and 60, confirming high tumor selectivity of ST2146biot despite its cross-reactivity with the tenascin expressed at low level in the normal mouse organs. The ST2146biot localization data are substantially confirmed even when both low and high tenascin-expressing tumors are implanted in the same animal. To our knowledge, the absolute amount of ST2146biot, specifically localized in xenotransplanted human tumors, is the highest thus far described and supports the clinical use of this mAb in PAGRIT®.

Affinity purification of polyclonal antibodies using immobilized multimeric peptides

The possibility of using multiple antigenic peptides (MAP) not only for the production and characterisation of antibodies but also for their purification by affinity chromatography, has been explored with two different tetrameric MAPs synthesised starting from a tetradentate lysine core. Recognition selectivity and specificity of the multimeric antigens were retained after immobilization on preactivated affinity supports, allowing convenient antibody purification directly from crude sera in a single chromatographic step. Since antibodies raised against MAPs recognise very frequently the N-terminal portion of the peptide antigen, results suggest that only a limited number of peptide chains remains covalently linked to the solid phase, leaving the others uncoupled and free to interact fully with the antibody. Recovery of antibody immunoreactivity from affinity purifications on MAP-columns was much higher than that obtained from columns prepared by immobilizing at the same density the corresponding linear peptide antigen. The purity of thus obtained antibodies is also far superior, as detected by SDS-PAGE analysis. Retention of the multimeric peptide recognition properties for the corresponding antibodies after immobilization on solid supports suggests that production, characterization, and even the affinity purification of anti-peptide antibodies, could be carried out simply and conveniently via the synthesis of a single multimeric antigen, without additional steps.