Antony J. Harding

Neuronal loss in functional zones of the cerebellum of chronic alcoholics with and without Wernicke's encephalopathy

This study examines the effect of chronic alcohol consumption on the human cerebellum using operational criteria for case selection [Caine D. et al. (1997) J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiat. 62, 51-60] and unbiased stereological techniques. We describe, for the first time, structural changes in different functional zones of the cerebellum of chronic alcoholics and correlate these changes with specific clinical symptoms. No consistent changes in the number of neurons or the structural volume for any cerebellar region were observed in the chronic alcoholics without the clinical signs of Wernickes encephalopathy. In all cerebellar measures, these chronic alcoholics did not differ significantly from the non-alcoholic controls, suggesting that chronic alcohol consumption per se does not necessarily damage human cerebellar tissue. However, several cerebellar changes were noted in the thiamine-deficient alcoholics studied. There was a significant decrease in Purkinje cell density (reduced on average by 43%) and molecular layer volume (reduced by 32%) in the cerebellar vermis in all thiamine-deficient chronic alcoholics. A decrease in cell density and atrophy of the molecular layer, where the dendritic trees of the Purkinje cells are found, without significant cell loss suggests loss of cellular dendritic structure and volume. These thiamine-deficient alcoholics also had a significant decrease (36% loss) in the estimated Purkinje cell number of the flocculi, disrupting vestibulocerebellar pathways. These results indicate that cerebellar Purkinje cells are selectively vulnerable to thiamine deficiency. There is evidence that this damage contributes significantly to the clinical signs of Wernickes encephalopathy. There was a 36% loss of Purkinje cells in the lateral lobe in alcoholics with mental state signs and 42% atrophy of vermal white matter in ataxic alcoholics. The finding of a 57% loss of Purkinje cells and a 43% atrophy of the molecular layer of the vermis in alcoholics with cerebellar dysfunction supports previous findings highlighting the importance of spinocerebellar pathways to these symptoms.

Chronic alcohol consumption does not cause hippocampal neuron loss in humans

High alcohol consumption for long periods of time causes significant hippocampal neurodegeneration in rodents. A single study using neuronal density measures has reported similar findings in humans. The present study aims to substantiate these findings in human alcoholics using unbiased stereological techniques. Both amnesic (n = 5) and nonamnesic (n = 7) chronic alcoholics were selected and compared with nonalcoholic controls (n = 8) and patients with marked memory loss and hippocampal neurodegeneration caused by Alzheimers disease (n = 4). Hippocampal volume was significantly reduced in the alcoholics and in patients with Alzheimers disease. However, in alcoholics the volume reduction occurred exclusively in the white matter, whereas both the gray and white matter were reduced in the patients with Alzheimers disease. Neuron loss occurred exclusively from the CA1 and subiculum subregions of the hippocampus in Alzheimers disease. No neuron loss occurred from any subregion of the hippocampus in alcoholics. There were no correlations with age and any of the volume or neuron number measures. Hippocampal volume correlated with brain volume and with the regional gray and white matter volumes within the hippocampus. In addition, hippocampal gray matter volume correlated with the number of CA1 pyramidal neurons. These results do not support the theory that chronic alcohol consumption is neurotoxic to hippocampal pyramidal neurons in humans. Further, the present results suggest that changes observed in rodent models of alcoholism do not parallel those observed in humans, questioning the validity of such models. Hippocampus 7:78–87, 1997.

Neuron loss from the hippocampus of Alzheimer's disease exceeds extracellular neurofibrillary tangle formation.

Abstract. Neurofibrillary tangle (NFT) formation in the CA1 region of the hippocampus is one of the early events in the pathogenesis of Alzheimers disease (AD). As the disease progresses more NFTs form and there is substantial neuron loss. In this study we investigated whether NFT formation accounts for all the CA1 pyramidal neuron loss seen in AD. Using unbiased stereological techniques, we estimated the total number of neurons and the number of intra- and extra-cellular NFTs in the hippocampus of 10 patients with AD and 10 age-matched controls. Marked neuronal loss (~60%) was identified in AD, although NFTs accounted for only a small proportion of this loss (2.2–17.2%, mean 8.1%). Analysis of NFT accumulation with duration of dementia showed a linear relationship, supporting the belief that NFTs progressively accumulate with time.

Disruption of frontocerebellar circuitry and function in alcoholism.

This article represents a symposium of the 2002 joint meeting of RSA and ISBRA held in San Francisco. Presentations were Neuropathology of alcohol-related cerebellar damage in humans, by Antony J. Harding; Neuropathological evidence of cerebellar damage in an animal model of alcoholism, by Roberta Pentney and Cynthia Dlugos; Understanding cortical-cerebellar circuits through neuroimaging study of chronic alcoholics, by Peter R. Martin and Mitchell H. Parks; and Functional reorganization of the brain in alcoholism: neuroimaging evidence, by John E. Desmond, S.H. Annabel Chen, Michelle R. Pryor, Eve De Rosa, Adolf Pfefferbaum, and Edith V. Sullivan.

Patients with vascular dementia due to microvascular pathology have significant hippocampal neuronal loss

Background: Alzheimers disease (AD) is characterised by functional impairment, cerebral atrophy, and degeneration of specific neuronal populations, especially pyramidal neurones of the cerebral cortex and hippocampal formation. Although patients with subcortical vascular dementia have been shown to have similar metabolic and volumetric deficits to those with AD, the underlying pathogenesis of these changes is poorly understood. Objective: To determine whether pyramidal cell loss occurs in small vessel disease (SVD) dementia by quantifying hippocampal volume and CA1 neurone number. Methods: Fifty four prospectively studied patients with dementia were screened, and four patients fulfilling criteria for SVD with no other significant neuropathological abnormality were identified. These were compared with five patients fulfilling criteria for AD and seven controls matched for age and sex. The hippocampal formation was serially sectioned, and the number of CA1 pyramidal neurones estimated using the optical dissector technique. Analysis of variance was used to evaluate group differences. Results: Patients in both the AD and SVD groups showed a substantial loss of pyramidal neurones from the CA1 region. The pattern of hippocampal atrophy and the degree of CA1 neuronal loss were similar in the two dementia groups. Conclusions: These findings support recent in vivo studies showing similar metabolic deficits and atrophy in AD and subcortical vascular dementia. In addition, they provide evidence that the underlying cause of these abnormalities is a similar loss of neurones. Whereas the cause of the neuronal loss in AD is related to the deposition of abnormal proteins, the cause in SVD is unknown. In the absence of other pathologies, damage to cerebral microvasculature should be considered a likely candidate.

Loss of vasopressin-immunoreactive neurons in alcoholics is dose-related and time-dependent

The chronic consumption of alcohol significantly reduces the number of vasopressin-producing neurons in the rat supraoptic nucleus [Maderia et al. (1993) Neourscience 56, 657-672] suggesting this region is particularly vulnerable to alcohol neurotoxicity. As hypothalamic vasopressin producing neurons are necessary for fluid homeostasis, it is important to assess if similar changes occur in humans. We analysed arginine vasopressin-immunoreactive neurons in the magnocellular hypothalamic nuclei of ten chronic alcoholic men (consuming > 80 g of ethanol per day) and four age- and sex-matched controls (consuming < 10g of ethanol per day). Brains were collected at autopsy and fixed in formalin. Serial 50 mu m-thick-sections of the hypothalamus were stained and assessed. The volume of the paraventricular and supraoptic nuclei and number of neurons were estimated using Cavalieris principle and the optical dissector technique. The volume of these nuclei significantly correlated with the number of neurons and the number of vasopressin-immunoreactive neurons, and these measures significantly correlated with the maximum daily intake of alcohol. There was a loss of neurons at consumption levels greater than 100 g of ethanol per day, principally affecting the supraoptic nucleus although neuron loss also occurred in the paraventricular nucleus in cases with long histories of alcohol consumption. These results indicate that chronic alcohol consumption is toxic to hypothalamic vasopressin-producing neurons in a concentration- and time-dependent manner. As these magnocellular neurons are osmo-receptive, neuronal loss may result in fluid imbalances.

Regional brain atrophy in progressive supranuclear palsy and Lewy body disease

There have been no previous three‐dimensional volumetric studies of regional brain atrophy in patients with pathologically confirmed progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP). Postmortem cortical and subcortical volumes were compared with neuropathology in 9 patients with PSP, 15 patients with Parkinsons disease, 10 patients with dementia with Lewy bodies, and 23 controls. Cases with the neuritic pathology of Alzheimers disease were excluded. The topography of brain atrophy differed according to clinicopathological phenotype. Patients with Parkinsons disease had atrophy confined to the amygdala. Atrophy of the frontal lobe was found in both PSP and dementia with Lewy bodies and correlated with increasing neurofibrillary tangle or Lewy body densities, respectively. Patients with PSP could be differentiated by their marked atrophy of the internal globus pallidus. Further analysis of variance revealed that trends for greater frontal lobe atrophy correlated with clinical dementia in PSP, whereas both greater frontal and hippocampal atrophy and higher densities of Lewy bodies and Lewy neurites correlated with clinical dementia in cases with Lewy bodies. The present study provides evidence for selective regional atrophy that correlates with the underlying pathology of PSP and Lewy body disease. Ann Neurol 2000;47:718–728

Practical considerations for the use of the optical disector in estimating neuronal number

The aim of this study was to establish methodological variability in the estimation of the total number of neurones using the optical disector. Variations in the 3 dimensions of the disector probe were analysed under uniform sampling conditions in 50-microns-thick frozen sections of the human mediodorsal thalamic nucleus. There was no significant difference between the estimated neuronal number using samples of variable height (fractionator vs. non-fractionator sampling). In addition, different methods of volume calculation (individual sample vs. an average) did not significantly change the estimated total neuronal number. Large variations in the estimated total neuronal number occurred when the x and y dimensions of the disector probe were altered. In this study, accurate and reproducible estimates were achieved when the disector probe was large enough to have a probability of sampling at least 2 cells per frame. We conclude that the variables in the x-y plane (the disector frame size as well as the sample interval) significantly contribute to differences in the estimated total neuronal number. Several practical measurements to estimate this probability and enhance experimental design are discussed.

Selection of reference gene expression in a schizophrenia brain cohort

Objective: In order to conduct postmortem human brain research into the neuropatho-logical basis of schizophrenia, it is critical to establish cohorts that are well-characterized and well-matched. The aim of the present study was therefore to determine if specimen characteristics including: diagnosis, age, postmortem interval (PMI), brain acidity (pH), and/or the agonal state of the subject at death related to RNA quality, and to determine the most appropriate reference gene mRNAs. Methods: A matched cohort was selected of 74 subjects (schizophrenia/schizoaffective disorder, n = 37; controls, n = 37). Middle frontal gyrus tissue was pulverized, tissue pH was measured, RNA isolated for cDNA from each case, and RNA integrity number (RIN) measurements were assessed. Using quantitative reverse transcription–polymerase chain reaction, nine housekeeper genes were measured and a geomean calculated per case in each diagnostic group. Results: The RINs were very good (mean = 7.3) and all nine housekeeper control genes were significantly correlated with RIN. Seven of nine housekeeper genes were also correlated with pH; two clinical variables, agonal state and duration of illness, did have an effect on some control mRNAs. No major impact of PMI or freezer time on housekeeper mRNAs was detected. The results show that people with schizophrenia had significantly less PPIA and SDHA mRNA and tended to have less GUSB and B2M mRNA, suggesting that these control genes may not be good candidates for normalization. Conclusions: In the present cohort <10% variability in RINs was detected and the diagnostic groups were well matched overall. The cohort was adequately powered (0.80–0.90) to detect mRNA differences (25%) due to disease. The study suggests that multiple factors should be considered in mRNA expression studies of human brain tissues. When schizophrenia cases are adequately matched to control cases subtle differences in gene expression can be reliably detected.

Practical measures to simplify the Braak tangle staging method for routine pathological screening

Abstract The examination of neurofibrillary tangles is now recommended for the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease as their location and density can distinguish early, intermediate and late disease stages. While the Braak tangle staging protocol can identify these stages, it uses an uncommon silver stain and hippocampal sample. The present study evaluates the Braak protocol using commonly used methods and cases fulfilling either CERAD criteria for Alzheimer’s disease, criteria for dementia with Lewy bodies or without neurological disease. Temporal and occipital cortices from 72 cases were stained using tau immunohistochemistry and the Gallyas and modified Bielschowsky silver stains. The modified Bielschowsky silver stain was equivalent to the Gallyas silver stain for tangle staging. Semiquantitative evaluation of neurofibrillary tangles in the hippocampus and the inferior temporal cortex provided equivalent information to that obtained using the original Braak tangle staging protocol (kappa statistic of 0.97). Comparison of this modification with the CERAD criteria provided moderate agreement (0.51) between diagnostic categories when cases with dementia with Lewy bodies were included, but substantially increased agreement (0.74) when they were excluded. This simplification of the Braak tangle staging protocol is easy to apply, can be readily incorporated into existing CERAD procedures, and helps to distinguish cases with neurofibrillary tangles from those with Lewy bodies.