Arsène Burny

Active anti-interferon-α immunization : A European-Israeli, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial in 242 HIV-1-infected patients (the EURIS study)

This randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, phase II/III study was designed to evaluate safety, immunogenicity, and efficacy of an active anti-interferon-alpha (anti-IFN-alpha) vaccine in asymptomatic HIV-1-infected patients. The active immunization was aimed at inducing anti-IFN-alpha antibodies to counteract IFN-alpha overproduction. In all, 242 patients, recruited between December 1995 and July 1996 in eight centers in Europe and Israel, with CD4+ counts from 100 to 634 cells/mm3 who were receiving or not receiving antiretroviral therapy (including protease inhibitors) were randomized to receive either anti-IFN-alpha vaccine or placebo. The anti-IFN-alpha immunization regimen consisted of three priming injections delivered intramuscularly at 1-month intervals in a water-in-oil emulsion of inactivated recombinant IFN-alpha-2b (i-IFN-alpha) followed by intramuscular booster injections of i-IFN-alpha adsorbed onto calcium phosphate every 3 months. Immunogenicity to vaccine was defined as an increase of anti-IFN-alpha antibody level of more than twofold the preimmunization value. Clinical progression, changes in antiretroviral treatment, and decrease of CD4+ counts to <200 cells/mm3 were considered endpoints for efficacy evaluation. Contrary to our previous experience, in which six to seven oil priming injections induced a >90% response rate, the three oil-adjuvanted injections in this trial were suboptimal because only 40 of 122 vaccinees (33%) had raised anti-IFN-alpha antibody following immunization. In vaccinees, both antibody responders (AbRV) and nonresponders (AbNRV), the tolerance to the vaccine was good and was without evidence of significant safety concerns. During the course of the trial, 62% of vaccine responders, 64% of nonresponders, and 63% of placebo patients elected to add protease inhibitor-containing regimens as new treatment guidelines were established, resulting in a marked decrease in clinical and laboratory progression such that the expected endpoints of the study could not be achieved and further follow-up was halted. Despite the unexpectedly low immunogenicity and fewer than expected endpoints, anti-IFN-alpha vaccine recipients, in comparison with placebo recipients, showed a lower rate of disease progression, nonelective treatment changes, and/or CD4+ count decrease to <200 cells/mm3, but the difference was not statistically significant. Nevertheless, the subgroup of patients immunized to IFN-alpha who experienced a rise in anti-IFN-alpha antibodies had a significantly lower rate of occurrence of HIV-1-related events and of any combination of the endpoints compared with those of either placebo patients or vaccinees who failed to develop anti-IFN-alpha antibodies, the latter two groups behaving similarly. Further studies of this approach are warranted because these data suggest a beneficial effect of this adjuvant approach.

Tat toxoid as a component of a preventive vaccine in seronegative subjects

Because administration of Tat protein, the HIV-1 toxin that induces immunosuppression and apoptosis, may be deleterious to the host immune system, a chemically inactivated but nonetheless immunogenic Tat preparation, Tat toxoid, was used to immunize seronegative individuals against Tat. In an open, controlled, phase I clinical trial, Tat toxoid turned out to be safe, well tolerated, and able to trigger a specific immune reaction. In particular, a threefold to more than 10-fold increase of circulating antibodies directed against the native Tat was observed after immunization in all of 5 immunized study subjects, together with a positive reaction to delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) skin test with Tat toxoid in vivo and increased lymphoproliferative response to native Tat in vitro. Persistent (> or =1 year) high levels of circulating anti-Tat antibodies could prevent the Tat-induced immune suppression and, following HIV-1 exposure, allow the anti-HIV-1 cellular immune response, with its early release of protective beta-chemokines, to occur leading to an increase of host resistance, that is, protection.

Absence of clinical, virological, and immunological signs of progression in HIV-1-infected patients receiving active anti-interferon-α immunization : A 30-month follow-up report

Twenty-seven HIV-1-infected patients, 16 at early stage of disease and without concomitant antiretroviral therapy and 11 at more advanced stage of disease receiving antiretroviral therapy, have been followed since their enrollment, November 1992 and July 1993, respectively, in phase I/II studies to evaluate safety and immunogenicity of an anti-interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) vaccine, aimed at modulating the impaired cytokine network in AIDS patients by counteracting IFN-alpha overproduction. We compared clinical, virological, and immunological markers of disease progression, including circulating IFN-alpha levels in a 24- to 30-month follow-up period with those of 62 patients fulfilling the same enrollment criteria and comparable for sex, risk factor, and age, regularly followed at our center. Anti-IFN-alpha immunization consisted of four-six intramuscular injections 1 month apart of a water-in-oil emulsion of 500 micrograms formalin-inactivated recombinant IFN-alpha-2b (iIFN-alpha) followed by intramuscular injections of 250 micrograms iIFN-alpha adsorbed onto calcium phosphate every 3 months. Neither clinical deterioration nor a CD4+ cell count decrease from pretreatment values was observed in IFN-alpha-immunized patients in the follow-up period, whereas clinical and immunological disease progressions were observed among open-comparison patients. Furthermore, statistical analysis showed a strong association between occurrence of clinical manifestations and high circulating IFN-alpha titers, while nonprogression of IFN-alpha-immunized patients was associated with decreased levels of circulating IFN-alpha.

IFN-α and CD46 stimulation are associated with active lupus and skew natural T regulatory cell differentiation to type 1 regulatory T (Tr1) cells

Immune suppressive activities exerted by regulatory T-cell subsets have several specific functions, including self-tolerance and regulation of adaptive immune reactions, and their dysfunction can lead to autoimmune diseases and contribute to AIDS and cancer. Two functionally distinct regulatory T-cell subsets are currently identified in peripheral tissues: thymus-developed natural T regulatory cells (nTregs) controlling self-tolerance and antiinflammatory IL-10–secreting type 1 regulatory T cells (Tr1) derived from Ag-stimulated T cells, which regulate inflammation-dependent adaptive immunity and minimize immunopathology. We establish herein that cell contact-mediated nTreg regulatory function is inhibited by inflammation, especially in the presence of the complement C3b receptor (CD46). Instead, as with other T-cell subsets, the latter inflammatory conditions of stimulation skew nTreg differentiation to Tr1 cells secreting IL-10, an effect potentiated by IFN-α. The clinical relevance of these findings was verified in a study of 152 lupus patients, in which we showed that lupus nTreg dysfunction is not due to intrinsic defects but is rather induced by C3b stimulation of CD46 and IFN-α and that these immune components of inflammation are directly associated with active lupus. These results provide a rationale for using anti–IFN-α Ab immunotherapy in lupus patients.

Anti-IFNα immunization raises the IFNα-neutralizing capacity of serum — an adjuvant to antiretroviral tritherapy

Summary HAART (highly active antiretroviral therapy) suppresses but does not eradicate HIV-1 infection. However, since the antiretroviral agents used in HAART may also be toxic in the long-term, immunotherapies which correct HIV-1 immunosuppression or the cytokine dysregulation associated with it may be beneficial. In this respect, a double blind multicentric placebo-controlled phase II/III anti-IFNα vaccine trial has been carried out on 242 HIV-1 patients, the majority of whom were undergoing HAART treatment. In vaccinated patients (vaccinees) who responded to immunization by increased levels of IFNα Abs (whether under HAART or not) when compared to placebo or non-responder vaccinees, a strong correlation was found between an increased IFNα neutralizing capacity and the reduction ot clinical manifestations.

Biological effect of active anti-IFNα immunization in HIV-infected patients

Circulating interferon (IFN) was investigated in HIV-1 seropositive patients by measuring the IFN alpha antiviral effect in the serum. While serum of healthy seronegative individuals exhibits an antiviral effect, not due to IFNs, considered as background, serum of seropositive patients showed an additional antiviral effect due to the abnormal presence of IFN alpha. Increased titers of IFN alpha were found in the course of the HIV infection and seemed to correlate with the evolution of AIDS disease. Furthermore, patients immunized against IFN alpha had both stabilized CD4 cell count and decreased IFN alpha in their serum. HIV-1-infected patients also exhibited higher titers of natural anti-IFN antibodies than seronegative controls and the level of specific antibodies (Abs) markedly increased in immunized patients. Finally, serum from immunized patients, when compared to seronegative controls, exhibits an interferon neutralizing capacity.

Lectin production by human T-lymphocytes.

Cultured human peripheral blood monocytes (PBMC) and the cell line H9 release a lectin. This lectin is not the previously described sarcolectin, since it does not specifically recognize the sugars lactose and sialic acid. The lectinic T-cell factor reduces the release by APCs of IFN alpha--a key cytokine known to inhibit the proliferation of activated T-lymphocytes.