B. Tracy Nixon

Phase transitions in the assembly of multivalent signalling proteins

Cells are organized on length scales ranging from ångström to micrometres. However, the mechanisms by which ångström-scale molecular properties are translated to micrometre-scale macroscopic properties are not well understood. Here we show that interactions between diverse synthetic, multivalent macromolecules (including multi-domain proteins and RNA) produce sharp liquid–liquid-demixing phase separations, generating micrometre-sized liquid droplets in aqueous solution. This macroscopic transition corresponds to a molecular transition between small complexes and large, dynamic supramolecular polymers. The concentrations needed for phase transition are directly related to the valency of the interacting species. In the case of the actin-regulatory protein called neural Wiskott–Aldrich syndrome protein (N-WASP) interacting with its established biological partners NCK and phosphorylated nephrin, the phase transition corresponds to a sharp increase in activity towards an actin nucleation factor, the Arp2/3 complex. The transition is governed by the degree of phosphorylation of nephrin, explaining how this property of the system can be controlled to regulatory effect by kinases. The widespread occurrence of multivalent systems suggests that phase transitions may be used to spatially organize and biochemically regulate information throughout biology.

Opening and Closing of the Bacterial RNA Polymerase Clamp

Clamping Down Crystal structures of RNA polymerase show that a “clamp” region which surrounds the DNA binding site can adopt conformations ranging from a closed to an open state. Chakraborty et al. (p. 591) used single-molecule fluorescence energy transfer experiments to detect the clamps conformational changes in solution during the transcription cycle. The results support a model in which a clamp opening allows DNA to be loaded into the active-center cleft and unwound. Direct interactions with DNA likely trigger clamp closure upon formation of a catalytically competent transcription initiation complex. Single-molecule fluorescence measurements define the clamp conformation during transcription initiation and elongation. Using single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer, we have defined bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP) clamp conformation at each step in transcription initiation and elongation. We find that the clamp predominantly is open in free RNAP and early intermediates in transcription initiation but closes upon formation of a catalytically competent transcription initiation complex and remains closed during initial transcription and transcription elongation. We show that four RNAP inhibitors interfere with clamp opening. We propose that clamp opening allows DNA to be loaded into and unwound in the RNAP active-center cleft, that DNA loading and unwinding trigger clamp closure, and that clamp closure accounts for the high stability of initiation complexes and the high stability and processivity of elongation complexes.

Rhizobium meliloti DctD, a σ54‐dependent transcriptional activator, may be negatively controlled by a subdomain in the C‐terminal end of its two‐component receiver module

Rhizobium meliloti DctD is believed to have three functional domains: an N‐terminal, two‐component receiver domain; and like other σ54‐dependent activators, C‐terminal and central domains for DNA binding and transcription activation. We have characterized a progressive series of M‐terminal deletions of R meliloti DctD. The N‐terminal domain was not needed for binding the dctA upstream activation sequence. Only 25% of the C‐terminal end of the receiver domain was needed to significantly inhibit the central domain, and proteins lacking up to 60% of the N‐terminal end of the receiver domain were‘inducible’in R. meliloti cells. We hypothesize that the W‐terminal two‐thirds of the DctD receiver domain augments and controls an adjacent subdomain for inhibiting the central domain.

Two-component signaling in the AAA + ATPase DctD: binding Mg2+ and BeF3− selects between alternate dimeric states of the receiver domain

A crystal structure is described for the Mg2+‐BeF3‐‐bound receiver domain of Sinorhizobium meliloti DctD bearing amino acid substitution E121K. Differences between the apo‐ and ligandbound active sites are similar to those reported for other receiver domains. However, the off and on states of the DctD receiver domain are characterized by dramatically different dimeric structures, which supports the following hypothesis of signal transduction. In the off state, the receiver domain and coiled‐coil linker form a dimer that inhibits oligomerization of the AAA+ ATPase domain. In this conformation, the receiver domain cannot be phosphorylated or bind Mg2+ and BeF3‐. Instead, these modifications stabilize an alternative dimeric conformation that repositions the subunits by approximately 20 Å, thus replacing the α4‐β5‐α5 interface with an α4‐β5 interface. Reoriented receiver domains permit the ATPase domain to oligomerize and stimulate open complex formation by the ς54 form of RNA polymerase. NtrC, which shares 38% sequence identity with DctD, works differently. Its activated receiver domain must facilitate oligomerization of its ATPase domain. Significant differences exist in the signaling surfaces of the DctD and NtrC receiver domains that may help explain how triggering the common two‐component switch can variously regulate assembly of a AAA+ ATPase domain.

Engagement of Arginine Finger to ATP Triggers Large Conformational Changes in NtrC1 AAA+ ATPase For Remodeling Bacterial RNA Polymerase

The NtrC-like AAA+ ATPases control virulence and other important bacterial activities through delivering mechanical work to σ54-RNA polymerase to activate transcription from σ54-dependent genes. We report the first crystal structure for such an ATPase, NtrC1 of Aquifex aeolicus, in which the catalytic arginine engages the γ-phosphate of ATP. Comparing the new structure with those previously known for apo and ADP-bound states supports a rigid-body displacement model that is consistent with large-scale conformational changes observed by low-resolution methods. First, the arginine finger induces rigid-body roll, extending surface loops above the plane of the ATPase ring to bind σ54. Second, ATP hydrolysis permits Pi release and retraction of the arginine with a reversed roll, remodeling σ54-RNAP. This model provides a fresh perspective on how ATPase subunits interact within the ring-ensemble to promote transcription, directing attention to structural changes on the arginine-finger side of an ATP-bound interface.

A Structural Study of CESA1 Catalytic Domain of Arabidopsis Cellulose Synthesis Complex: Evidence for CESA Trimers

Assembly into stable trimers provides strong evidence for 18 protein subunits to assemble in a cellulose synthesis complex that synthesizes an 18-chain cellulose microfibril. A cellulose synthesis complex with a “rosette” shape is responsible for synthesis of cellulose chains and their assembly into microfibrils within the cell walls of land plants and their charophyte algal progenitors. The number of cellulose synthase proteins in this large multisubunit transmembrane protein complex and the number of cellulose chains in a microfibril have been debated for many years. This work reports a low resolution structure of the catalytic domain of CESA1 from Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana; AtCESA1CatD) determined by small-angle scattering techniques and provides the first experimental evidence for the self-assembly of CESA into a stable trimer in solution. The catalytic domain was overexpressed in Escherichia coli, and using a two-step procedure, it was possible to isolate monomeric and trimeric forms of AtCESA1CatD. The conformation of monomeric and trimeric AtCESA1CatD proteins were studied using small-angle neutron scattering and small-angle x-ray scattering. A series of AtCESA1CatD trimer computational models were compared with the small-angle x-ray scattering trimer profile to explore the possible arrangement of the monomers in the trimers. Several candidate trimers were identified with monomers oriented such that the newly synthesized cellulose chains project toward the cell membrane. In these models, the class-specific region is found at the periphery of the complex, and the plant-conserved region forms the base of the trimer. This study strongly supports the “hexamer of trimers” model for the rosette cellulose synthesis complex that synthesizes an 18-chain cellulose microfibril as its fundamental product.

Comparative Structural and Computational Analysis Supports Eighteen Cellulose Synthases in the Plant Cellulose Synthesis Complex.

A six-lobed membrane spanning cellulose synthesis complex (CSC) containing multiple cellulose synthase (CESA) glycosyltransferases mediates cellulose microfibril formation. The number of CESAs in the CSC has been debated for decades in light of changing estimates of the diameter of the smallest microfibril formed from the β-1,4 glucan chains synthesized by one CSC. We obtained more direct evidence through generating improved transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images and image averages of the rosette-type CSC, revealing the frequent triangularity and average cross-sectional area in the plasma membrane of its individual lobes. Trimeric oligomers of two alternative CESA computational models corresponded well with individual lobe geometry. A six-fold assembly of the trimeric computational oligomer had the lowest potential energy per monomer and was consistent with rosette CSC morphology. Negative stain TEM and image averaging showed the triangularity of a recombinant CESA cytosolic domain, consistent with previous modeling of its trimeric nature from small angle scattering (SAXS) data. Six trimeric SAXS models nearly filled the space below an average FF-TEM image of the rosette CSC. In summary, the multifaceted data support a rosette CSC with 18 CESAs that mediates the synthesis of a fundamental microfibril composed of 18 glucan chains.

A dimeric two-component receiver domain inhibits the sigma54-dependent ATPase in DctD.

We report the crystal structure of a fragment of Sinorhizobium meliloti DctD, a bacterial enhancer binding protein, at 1.7 Å. The fragment contains the proteins two‐component receiver module and adjacent linker, which in the native protein joins the receiver domain to a σ54‐dependent ATPase domain. The structure reveals a novel dimerization surface, which sequence analysis indicates is common to 4.5% of the known two‐component receiver domains. Genetic, biochemical, and structural data for amino acid substitution variants indicate that the dimer is necessary to inhibit the basal activity of the ATPase domain. The dimerization element is thus needed to maintain the “off” state, and changes within it may signal activation. Analytical ultracentrifugation data for the phosphorylated fragment of DctD appear to rule out the simple model that signaling is mediated via monomerization of the receiver domain.

Functional roles of the pre‐sensor I insertion sequence in an AAA+ bacterial enhancer binding protein

Molecular machines belonging to the AAA+ superfamily of ATPases use NTP hydrolysis to remodel their versatile substrates. The presence of an insertion sequence defines the major phylogenetic pre‐sensor I insertion (pre‐SIi) AAA+ superclade. In the bacterial σ54‐dependent enhancer binding protein phage shock protein F (PspF) the pre‐SIi loop adopts different conformations depending on the nucleotide‐bound state. Single amino acid substitutions within the dynamic pre‐SIi loop of PspF drastically change the ATP hydrolysis parameters, indicating a structural link to the distant hydrolysis site. We used a site‐specific protein–DNA proximity assay to measure the contribution of the pre‐SIi loop in σ54‐dependent transcription and demonstrate that the pre‐SIi loop is a major structural feature mediating nucleotide state‐dependent differential engagement with Eσ54. We suggest that much, if not all, of the action of the pre‐SIi loop is mediated through the L1 loop and relies on a conserved molecular switch, identified in a crystal structure of one pre‐SIi variant and in accordance with the high covariance between some pre‐SIi residues and distinct residues outside the pre‐SIi sequence.

Regulation and action of the bacterial enhancer-binding protein AAA+ domains.

Bacterial EBPs (enhancer-binding proteins) play crucial roles in regulating cellular responses to environmental changes, in part by providing efficient control over sigma(54)-dependent gene transcription. The AAA+ (ATPase associated with various cellular activites) domain of the EBPs, when assembled into a ring, uses energy from ATP binding, hydrolysis and product release to remodel the sigma(54)-RNAP (RNA polymerase) holoenzyme so that it can transition from closed to open form at promoter DNA. The assembly, and hence activity, of these ATPases are regulated by many different signal transduction mechanisms. Recent advances in solution scattering techniques, when combined with high-resolution structures and biochemical data, have enabled us to obtain mechanistic insights into the regulation and action of a subset of these sigma(54) activators: those whose assembly into ring form is controlled by two-component signal transduction. We review (i) experimental considerations of applying the SAXS (small-angle X-ray scattering)/WAXS (wide-angle X-ray scattering) technique, (ii) distinct regulation mechanisms of the AAA+ domains of three EBPs by similar two-component signal transduction receiver domains, and (iii) major conformational changes and correlated sigma(54)-binding activity of an isolated EBP AAA+ domain in the ATP hydrolysis cycle.