Basil Rapoport

The thyrotropin receptor autoantigen in Graves disease is the culprit as well as the victim

Graves disease, a common organ-specific autoimmune disease affecting humans, differs from all other autoimmune diseases in being associated with target organ hyperfunction rather than organ damage. Clinical thyrotoxicosis is directly caused by autoantibodies that activate the thyrotropin receptor (TSHR). The etiology of Graves disease is multifactorial, with nongenetic factors playing an important role. Of the latter, there is the intriguing possibility that the molecular structure of the target antigen contributes to the development of thyroid-stimulatory autoantibodies (TSAbs). Among the glycoprotein hormone receptors, only the TSHR undergoes intramolecular cleavage into disulfide-linked subunits with consequent shedding of some of the extracellular, autoantibody-binding A subunits. Functional autoantibodies do not arise to the noncleaving glycoprotein hormone receptors. Recently, TSAbs were found to preferentially recognize shed, rather than attached, A subunits. Here we use a new adenovirus-mediated animal model of Graves disease to show that goiter and hyperthyroidism occur to a much greater extent when the adenovirus expresses the free A subunit as opposed to a genetically modified TSHR that cleaves minimally into subunits. These data show that shed A subunits induce or amplify the immune response leading to hyperthyroidism and provide new insight into the etiology of Graves disease.

Thyroid-stimulating autoantibodies in Graves disease preferentially recognize the free A subunit, not the thyrotropin holoreceptor.

Graves disease is directly caused by thyroid-stimulating autoantibodies (TSAbs) that activate the thyrotropin receptor (TSHR). We observed upon flow cytometry using intact cells that a mouse mAb (3BD10) recognized the TSHR ectodomain with a glycosidylphosphatidylinositol (ECD-GPI) anchor approximately tenfold better than the same ectodomain on the wild-type TSHR, despite the far higher level of expression of the latter. The 3BD10 epitope contains the N-terminal cysteine cluster critical for TSAb action. Consequently, we hypothesized and confirmed that TSAb (but not thyrotropin-blocking autoantibodies [TBAbs]) also poorly recognize the wild-type TSHR relative to the ECD-GPI. Despite poor recognition by TSAb of the holoreceptor, soluble TSHR A subunits (known to be shed from surface TSHR) fully neutralized autoantibody-binding activity. These data indicate that the epitope(s) for TSAbs, but not for TBAbs, are partially sterically hindered on the holoreceptor by the plasma membrane, the serpentine region of the TSHR, or by TSHR dimerization. However, the TSAb epitope on the soluble A subunit is freely accessible. This observation, as well as other evidence, supports the concept that A subunit shedding either initiates or amplifies the autoimmune response to the TSHR, thereby causing Graves disease in genetically susceptible individuals.

Schistosoma mansoni and α-Galactosylceramide: Prophylactic Effect of Th1 Immune Suppression in a Mouse Model of Graves’ Hyperthyroidism

Graves’ hyperthyroidism, an organ-specific autoimmune disease mediated by stimulatory thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) autoantibodies, has been considered a Th2-dominant disease. However, recent data with mouse Graves’ models are conflicting. For example, we recently demonstrated that injection of BALB/c mice with adenovirus coding the TSHR induced Graves’ hyperthyroidism characterized by mixed Th1 and Th2 immune responses against the TSHR, and that transient coexpression of the Th2 cytokine IL-4 by adenovirus skewed Ag-specific immune response toward Th2 and suppressed disease induction. To gain further insight into the relationship between immune polarization and Graves’ disease, we evaluated the effect of Th2 immune polarization by helminth Schistosoma mansoni infection and α-galactosylceramide (α-GalCer), both known to bias the systemic immune response to Th2, on Graves’ disease. S. mansoni infection first induced mixed Th1 and Th2 immune responses to soluble worm Ags, followed by a Th2 response to soluble egg Ags. Prior infection with S. mansoni suppressed the Th1-type anti-TSHR immune response, as demonstrated by impaired Ag-specific IFN-γ secretion of splenocytes and decreased titers of IgG2a subclass anti-TSHR Abs, and also prevented disease development. Similarly, α-GalCer suppressed Ag-specific splenocyte secretion of IFN-γ and prevented disease induction. However, once the anti-TSHR immune response was fully induced, S. mansoni or α-GalCer was ineffective in curing disease. These data support the Th1 theory in Graves’ disease and indicate that suppression of the Th1-type immune response at the time of Ag priming may be crucial for inhibiting the pathogenic anti-TSHR immune response.

Prevention of Autoantibody-Mediated Graves’-Like Hyperthyroidism in Mice with IL-4, a Th2 Cytokine

Graves’ hyperthyroidism has long been considered to be a Th2-type autoimmune disease because it is directly mediated by autoantibodies against the thyrotropin receptor (TSHR). However, several lines of evidence have recently challenged this concept. The present study evaluated the Th1/Th2 paradigm in Graves’ disease using a recently established murine model involving injection of adenovirus expressing the TSHR (AdCMVTSHR). Coinjection with adenovirus expressing IL-4 (AdRGDCMVIL-4) decreased the ratio of Th1/Th2-type anti-TSHR Ab subclasses (IgG2a/IgG1) and suppressed the production of IFN-γ by splenocytes in response to TSHR Ag. Importantly, immune deviation toward Th2 was accompanied by significant inhibition of thyroid-stimulating Ab production and reduction in hyperthyroidism. However, in a therapeutic setting, injection of AdRGDCMVIL-4 alone or in combination with AdCMVTSHR into hyperthyroid mice had no beneficial effect. In contrast, coinjection of adenoviruses expressing IL-12 and the TSHR promoted the differentiation of Th1-type anti-TSHR immune responses as demonstrated by augmented Ag-specific IFN-γ secretion from splenocytes without changing disease incidence. Coinjection of adenoviral vectors expressing IL-4 or IL-12 had no effect on the titers of anti-TSHR Abs determined by ELISA or thyroid-stimulating hormone-binding inhibiting Ig assays, suggesting that Ab quality, not quantity, is responsible for disease induction. Our observations demonstrate the critical role of Th1 immune responses in a murine model of Graves’ hyperthyroidism. These data may raise a cautionary note for therapeutic strategies aimed at reversing Th2-mediated autoimmune responses in Graves’ disease in humans.

Generation of Recombinant, Enzymatically Active Human Thyroid Peroxidase and its Recognition by Antibodies in the Sera of Patients with Hashimoto's Thyroiditis

A full-length cDNA clone for human thyroid peroxidase (TPO) inserted into the mammalian cell expression vector pECE was stably transfected into Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Clones were assayed for human TPO mRNA, TPO protein, and TPO enzymatic activity. One subclone, expressing the highest TPO enzymatic activity, was used in further studies. FACS analysis of these cells preincubated in Hashimotos serum revealed approximately 100-fold greater fluorescence compared with controls, indicating that recombinant TPO is expressed on the cell surface. Particulate antigen was extracted from these cells and studied by Western blot analysis using a panel of Hashimotos sera of known antimicrosomal antibody (anti-MSA) titer. Under nonreducing conditions a broad, immunoreactive band of approximately 200 kD was observed, as well as a doublet of approximately 110 kD. All of the 36 Hashimotos sera tested reacted with these bands, most in proportion to their anti-MSA titer. Six normal sera tested against this antigen(s) were nonreactive, as were the Hashimotos sera tested against nontransfected CHO cells. Western blots under reducing conditions revealed a considerably diminished signal, with some of the sera of lower anti-MSA titer becoming negative, the loss of the 200-kD broad band, and the apparent conversion of the 110-kD doublet into a single band. Preincubation of cells in tunicamycin revealed no decrease in TPO immunoreactivity. In conclusion, we expressed enzymatically active human TPO in nonthyroidal eukaryotic cells. Our data prove that functionally active TPO is a major component of the thyroid microsomal antigen.

The Thyrotropin Receptor Hinge Region Is Not Simply a Scaffold for the Leucine-Rich Domain but Contributes to Ligand Binding and Signal Transduction

The glycoprotein hormone receptor hinge region connects the leucine-rich and transmembrane domains. The prevalent concept is that the hinge does not play a significant role in ligand binding and signal transduction. Portions of the hinge are redundant and can be deleted by mutagenesis or are absent in certain species. A minimal hinge will be more amenable to future investigation of its structure and function. We, therefore, combined and progressively extended previous deletions (Delta) in the TSH receptor (TSHR) hinge region (residues 277-418). TSHRDelta287-366, Delta287-371, Delta287-376, and Delta287-384 progressively lost their response to TSH stimulation of cAMP generation in intact cells, consistent with a progressive loss of TSH binding. The longest deletion (TSHRDelta287-384), reducing the hinge region from 141 to 43 amino acids, totally lost both functions. Surprisingly, however, with deletions extending from residues 371-384, constitutive (ligand-independent) activity increased severalfold, reversing the suppressive (inverse agonist) effect of the TSHR extracellular domain. TSHR-activating point mutations I486F and I568T in the first and second extracellular loops (especially the former) had reduced activity on a background of TSHRDelta287-371. In summary, our data support the concept that the TSHR hinge contributes significantly to ligand binding affinity and signal transduction. Residues within the hinge, particularly between positions 371-384, appear involved in ectodomain inverse agonist activity. In addition, the hinge is necessary for functionality of activating mutations in the first and second extracellular loops. Rather than being an inert linker between the leucine-rich and transmembrane domains, the TSHR hinge is a signaling-specificity domain.

Isolation of a complementary DNA clone for thyroid microsomal antigen. Homology with the gene for thyroid peroxidase.

The thyroid microsomal antigen (MSA) in autoimmune thyroid disease is a protein of approximately 107 kD. We screened a human thyroid cDNA library constructed in the expression vector lambda gt11 with anti-107-kD monoclonal antibodies. Of five clones obtained, the recombinant beta-galactosidase fusion protein from one clone (PM-5) was confirmed to react with the monoclonal antiserum. The complementary DNA (cDNA) insert from PM-5 (0.8 kb) was used as a probe on Northern blot analysis to estimate the size of the mRNA coding for the MSA. The 2.9-kb messenger RNA (mRNA) species observed was the same size as that coding for human thyroid peroxidase (TPO). The probe did not bind to human liver mRNA, indicating the thyroid-specific nature of the PM-5-related mRNA. The nucleotide sequence of PM-5 (842 bp) was determined and consisted of a single open reading frame. Comparison of the nucleotide sequence of PM-5 with that presently available for pig TPO indicates 84% homology. In conclusion, a cDNA clone representing part of the microsomal antigen has been isolated. Sequence homology with porcine TPO, as well as identity in the size of the mRNA species for both the microsomal antigen and TPO, indicate that the microsomal antigen is, at least in part, TPO.

Autoimmune response to the thyroid in humans: thyroid peroxidase--the common autoantigenic denominator.

Autoimmunity to thyroid peroxidase (TPO), manifest as high affinity IgG class auto-antibodies, is the common denominator of human thyroid autoimmunity, encompassing patients with overt hyper-or hypothyroidism as well as euthyroid individuals with subclinical disease. The identification and cloning of TPO (the “thyroid microsomal antigen”) provided the critical tool for analyzing B and T cell reactivity to this major thyroid autoantigen. In particular, the availability of immunoreactive TPO permitted the isolation of essentially the entire repertoire of human monoclonal antibodies, a feat unparalled in an organ-specific autoimmune disease. These recombinant autoantibodies (expressed as Fab) provide insight into the genes encoding their H and L chains as well as the conformational epitopes on TPO with which serum autoantibodies interact. Analyses of TPO autoantibody epitopic “fingerprints” indicate a lack of epitope spreading as well as a genetic basis for their inheritance. Limited data are available for the responses and cytokine profiles of T cells to endogenously processed TPO. Moreover, the role of thyroid cells in initiating the autoimmune response to TPO, and of B cells in expanding and/or modulating the response of sensitized T cells, has yet to be established. Finally, because autoantibody (and likely T cell) responses to TPO parallel those to TSH receptor and thyroglobulin, manipulation of T and B cell responses to TPO may provide the basis for the development of immunospecific therapy for autoimmune thyroid disease in general.

Naked TSH Receptor DNA Vaccination: A TH1 T Cell Response in Which Interferon-γ Production, Rather than Antibody, Dominates the Immune Response in Mice

Two approaches have been developed to induce TSH receptor antibodies in mice with properties resembling those in Graves’ disease, the Shimojo model of injecting live fibroblasts coexpressing the TSH receptor and major histocompatibility complex antigen Class II, and TSH receptor-DNA vaccination. Thyroid-stimulating antibodies appear to occur less commonly after DNA vaccination, but there has been no direct comparison of these models. We performed a three-way comparison of 1) AKR/N and 2) BALB/c mice vaccinated with TSH receptor-DNA and 3) AKR/N mice injected with fibroblasts expressing the TSH receptor and the major histocompatibility complex antigen class II of AKR/N mice. TSH receptor-DNA vaccinated mice had low or undetectable levels of TSH receptor antibodies determined by ELISA or flow cytometry. Nonspecific binding precluded comparisons with sera from Shimojo mice by these assays. TSH binding inhibition and thyroid-stimulating antibody were undetectable in TSH receptor-DNA vaccinated mice. In Shimoj...

Mechanisms of Autoantibody-Induced Pathology

Autoantibodies are frequently observed in healthy individuals. In a minority of these individuals, they lead to manifestation of autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis or Graves’ disease. Overall, more than 2.5% of the population is affected by autoantibody-driven autoimmune disease. Pathways leading to autoantibody-induced pathology greatly differ among different diseases, and autoantibodies directed against the same antigen, depending on the targeted epitope, can have diverse effects. To foster knowledge in autoantibody-induced pathology and to encourage development of urgently needed novel therapeutic strategies, we here categorized autoantibodies according to their effects. According to our algorithm, autoantibodies can be classified into the following categories: (1) mimic receptor stimulation, (2) blocking of neural transmission, (3) induction of altered signaling, triggering uncontrolled (4) microthrombosis, (5) cell lysis, (6) neutrophil activation, and (7) induction of inflammation. These mechanisms in relation to disease, as well as principles of autoantibody generation and detection, are reviewed herein.