Benedetto Busnardo

Nonparallel patterns of calcitonin and carcinoembryonic antigen levels in the follow-up of medullary thyroid carcinoma.

Serum levels of calcitonin (CT) and carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) were evaluated in a group of 41 patients with histologically proven medullary thyroid carcinoma (MCT) before and sequentially after treatment for a period up to 7 years. Before thyroidectomy, CT levels were high in all patients, and significantly more elevated when metastases were present. On the other hand, CEA levels were high in most but not all the patients, and they also were found more frequently to be elevated in patients with metastases. After treatment, most of the patients without metastases showed persistently normal basal and pentagastrin stimulated CT and CEA levels. In some patients either without or with local metastases, postoperative CT levels, although considerably reduced, remained persistently above normal limits, whereas CEA levels became completely normal. This pattern may be due to the persistence of minute occult foci of the tumor, not sufficient to produce measurable amounts of CEA, which is not synthesized by all tumor cells. Most of the patients with metastases at diagnosis, showed still elevated CT and CEA levels after treatment. In the nonprogressive cases both markers decreased after adjunctive treatment or remained unchanged. In patients with progressive disease, an increase of CEA levels in the absence of a parallel increase of CT levels, which even decreased, was often observed. In one patient with progressive disease high CEA levels were seen for the first time when liver metastases had occurred. These data seem to suggest that, even though CEA production is not recognizable in all patients with MCT, in the CEA positive cases CEA levels may follow a nonparallel pattern and may have a distinct diagnostic meaning with respect to CT levels. In some cases, particularly in advanced disease, CEA may be a more useful marker of poor prognosis.

Combined chemotherapy with bleomycin, adriamycin, and platinum in advanced thyroid cancer

Twenty-two advanced consecutive thyroid cancer patients with varying histologies were treated with the so called BAP regime which consisted of bleomycin (B) 30 mg a day for three days, adriamycin (A) 60 mg/m2 iv in day 5, and cisplatinum (P) 60 mg/m2 iv in day 5. Patients with progressive, symptomatic recurrent or disseminated disease unresponsive to hormonal and/or isotopic treatment were eligible. Nine patients had an objective response: two long-lasting complete and seven partial responses were observed out of 21 evaluable patients. Stable disease was observed in four additional patients. The median duration of response was 12 months (range, 6–29). The total series experienced a median survival of 11 months (range, 1 to 57), with 2 patients actually disease free. Several histologic types of thyroid carcinoma responded, but the best responses were observed in medullary and anaplastic giant-cell carcinomas. Toxicity was reversible in all but one patient. Of the patients failing on BAP chemotherapy three responded to a four drug second line combination containing vincristine, fluorouracil, BCNU and methotrexate. BAP regime can achieve reasonable palliation, and probably increases survival, in poor-prognosis thyroid cancers.

Molecular characteristics in papillary thyroid cancers (PTCs) with no 131I uptake

Objective  Papillary thyroid cancers (PTCs) with no iodine uptake have an aggressive behaviour and a poor prognosis. The aim of our study was to characterize, at molecular level, a subset of PTC with no 131 iodine (131I) uptake.

High prevalence of occult papillary thyroid carcinoma in a surgical series for benign thyroid disease.

In a surgical series of 277 consecutive patients operated on the thyroid for benign diseases, a high prevalence rate (10.5%) of occult papillary carcinoma was found by means of an accurate histologic examination. Indications for surgery were euthyroid multinodular goiter in 25 patients, autonomously hyperfunctioning adenoma in 2 and Graves’ disease in 2 patients. Neoplastic foci were unilaterally found in 25 cases but multifocally in 6 and bilaterally in 4 cases: the diameters ranged from 2-10 mm. After operation (14 subtotal and 15 total thyroidectomies), all patients received TSH-suppressive doses of T4. At a mean follow-up of 5.6 years, neither local recurrences nor lymph node or distant metastases had occurred; no patient died of the tumor. In keeping with other surgical and autopsy series, the prevalence of occult thyroid carcinoma in a normal population is calculated to be about 5-10%, whereas it is known that the prevalence of clinically evident thyroid cancer is only 0.05%. This means that only 1-2% of occult carcinomas may evolve in an overt tumor during life. In view of such an epidemiologic difference and the favorable course of our patients, although the mean follow-up is rather short, we suggest that lobectomy plus T4 treatment may be considered an adequate therapeutic approach in patients with occult papillary thyroid carcinoma.

Natural course of subclinical hypothyroidism in Down’s syndrome: Prospective study results and therapeutic considerations

Pathogenesis, natural course and therapeutic management of subclinical hypothyroidism (SH) in Down’s syndrome (DS) remain object of debate in literature. In the present study thyroid function, antithyroid antibody (ATA) prevalence and serum lipid concentrations were investigated in a group of 344 Down patients (DP) and data were compared with those obtained from a control group of 257 age and sex matched healthy subjects. Thyroid function and ATA prevalence were also studied in 120 parents of DP. SH prevalence was clearly higher in DP (32.5% of cases) than in controls (1.1%) and parents (0%). Similarly, ATA prevalence was higher in DP (18% of cases) than in controls (5.8%) and parents (6.6%). In spite of this, no correlation was found in DP between SH and ATA prevalences, since ATA were detected in 18.7% of SH-DP and in 15.8% of euthyroid DP. Thus, circulating ATA were not detected in the majority of SH-DP. No significant differences regarding T4, FT4, T3 and serum lipid levels among SH and euthyroid DP and controls were found. Moreover, TSH levels were only slightly increased, generally less than 10 μU/ml, in most cases of SH-DP. Follow-up was longer than 24 months (range 2–7 years, mean 3.1) in a group of 201 DP: two different patterns of SH course were observed, mainly depending on the presence or the absence of circulating ATA. In particular, 35.7% of ATA-positive SH-DP developed a clinically evident thyroid disease (overt hypothyroidism or hyperthyroidism), while no similar case was recorded among ATA-negative SH-DP. On the contrary, a significant number of these patients (33.9% of cases) showed a spontaneous normalization of TSH levels. The present data suggest that: a) DS per se seems to be a clinical risk condition in developing thyroid autoimmune diseases, b) SH represents a very common conditions in DP and in most cases it appears to be independent of the presence of circulating ATA, c) SH alone, that is in the absence of detectable ATA, does not seem to be predisposing condition to develop a clinically evident thyroid disease, as a spontaneous normalization of TSH levels is often observed. From the therapeutic point of view, it seems unlikely that L-thyroxine substitutive therapy could lead to some improvement in SH-DP in the absence of detectable ATA. A wait and see policy with frequent thyroid function screening could be considered adequate, thus avoiding chronic hormonal therapy at least in DP in whom TSH levels tend to spontaneously normalize. On the contrary, L-thyroxine should not be delayed in ATA-positive SH-DP due to the frequent evolution towards an overt thyroid disease.

Distant metastases in differentiated thyroid cancer: Long-term results of radioiodine treatment and statistical analysis of prognostic factors in 214 patients

Long-term results and statistical analysis of prognostic factors in a series of 214 patients with distant metastases from differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) are reported here. These 214 were part of a total series of 1457 patients with DTC referred to our center from 1967 to 1987. All patients underwent surgery and 131-I therapy and were treated with TSH suppressive doses of thyroid hormones. After a mean follow-up of 7.3 years including clinical, scintigraphic, radiological and laboratory investigations, 24.4 % of patients were alive without disease, 36.5 % alive with disease, 1.8 % dead without disease and 37.3 % dead with disease. One of the main factors influencing the survival in our series was 131-I uptake (RIU) by metastatic tissue. No case of complete remission of disease was observed among patients with nonfunctioning metastases. Another important factor was the site of metastases, patients with bone metastases having the worst prognosis. The patients age at diagnosis represented another important factor for survival; patients over 40 years, particularly those over 60 years had a bad prognosis. A clear interrelation was found among the factors advanced age, nonfunctioning metastases and bone metastases. Patients with these last clinical features were considered to be at high risk and generally had a fatal outcome. Another significant prognostic factor revealed by univariate analysis was the histologic type. Patients with follicular tumor showed a poorer prognosis in comparison to papillary tumor. When multivariate analysis was applied, the factors age at diagnosis, site of metastases and RIU proved to have a significant influence on survival, but not the histologic type. Lastly, the relative rate of males was higher in the group of patients with metastases in comparison to the whole series of DTC patients. Despite this, the factor sex did not influence survival.

Pregnancy after high therapeutic doses of iodine-131 in differentiated thyroid cancer: potential risks and recommendations

Seventy female patients who had been treated with high doses of iodine-131 for differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) and who had a subsequent pregnancy were evaluated. The total 131I dose ranged from 1.85 to 16.55 GBq (mean±SD=4.39±25.20 GBq). Age at first therapy ranged from 15 to 36 years (mean±SD = 24.3±5.0 years) and the interval from 131I therapy topregnancy varied from 2to 10 years (mean±SD = 5.3±2.8 years). The estimated radiation doseto the gonads ranged from 10 to 63 cGy (mean±SD = 24.0±13.5 eGy). All patients were treated with l-thyroxine at doses capable of suppressing thyroid-stimulating hormone. Seventy-three children were followed-up and seven pregnancies are still in progress. One child was affected by Fallots trilogy and three had a low birth weight though with subsequent normal growth; the others were healthy with subsequent normal growth. No newborn with clinical or biochemical thyroid dysfunctions was found. Two spontaneous abortions during the second month of pregnancy were recorded. One of two patients in question subsequently had two healthy children. On the basis of these data, previous administration of high 131I doses does not appear to be a valid reason for dissuading young female DTC patients from considering pregnancy. However, patients should be advised to avoid pregnancy after 131I administration for a period sufficient to ensure complete elimination of the radionuclide and to permit confirmation of complete disease remission, i.e. at least 1 year in our opinion.

Usefulness of the combined antithyroglobulin antibodies and thyroglobulin assay in the follow-up of patients with differentiated thyroid cancer

A total of 1050 patients with differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) have been followed in the Thyroid Center of Padua by means of serum thyroglobulin (Tg) measured with IRMA method and anti-Tg antibodies (TgAb) assays. Circulating TgAbs were detected in 102 (9.7%) patients. In 32 of these 102, TgAbs were evaluated before and after total thyroidectomy and 131l ablation. In these patients no relationship was found between preoperative serum TgAb levels on the one hand and tumor stage at diagnosis or outcome of the disease on the other. During the follow-up, TgAb serum levels decreased or disappeared in 21 cases considered tumor-free, while they remained unchanged or even increased, in comparison with the preoperative ones, in 11 patients, 5 with proven metastases and 6 considered tumor-free. Evaluating the whole group of 102 TgAb-positive patients, we observed that TgAb serum levels, measured after thyroid ablation, were significantly higher in cases with metastases than in those considered tumor-free (653.0 ± 196.9 vs 157.7 ± 116.5 U/ml, m ± SD, p < 0.0001). In the group of patients with metastases and circulating TgAbs, Tg serum levels were elevated in 27% of cases on TSH- suppressive therapy and in 44% off therapy when nodal metastases were present, and in 67% of cases on TSH-suppressive therapy and in 83% off therapy when distant metastases were present. Our data suggest that: i) In a very large series of patients with DTC, circulating TgAbs are detectable in 9.7% of cases; ii) In the follow-up, patients with high TgAb serum levels even in absence of detectable serum Tg values are at risk for metastases; in fact circulating TgAbs might be due to the presence of tumor and circulating TgAbs themselves may prevent the detection of serum Tg; iii) serum IRMA-Tg assay appears to maintain its value as a tumoral marker in more than half the patients with metastases and circulating TgAbs.

A multimodality therapeutic approach in anaplastic thyroid carcinoma: Study on 39 patients

The aim of this study was to investigate the role of multimodality treatment in patients with anaplastic thyroid carcinoma. From 1992 to 1999, 39 consecutive patients with a histologically or cytologically proven anaplastic thyroid carcinoma were referred to the Thyroid Center of Padua General Hospital. There were 28 females and 11 males with a median age of 69 years (range 39–88 years). About one-third of patients had a history of preceeding nodular goiter. Two patients had areas of differentiated thyroid carcinoma at histological examination. Local disease was present in 26 patients while distant metastases, mainly to the lung, were present in 22 at diagnosis or quickly developed during the observation period in all the others except one. Thirty-two patients were previously untreated: 9 of them were in good general condition, 1 had limited lung metastases, and the tumor mass was considered resectable by the surgeon. These 9 patients were treated with cisplatin once a week and radiotherapy (RT) 36Gy in 18 fractions over three weeks, followed by total thyroidectomy (TT) and by further chemotherapy (CHT) with adriamycin and bleomycin in 4 patients. Seven patients, 3 with lung metastases at diagnosis, had undergone TT, followed by RT in 5, in another hospital and were subsequently referred to our center due to the presence of distant metastases. Therefore, a total of 16 patients (Group 1) was treated with TT, RT and CHT in various order. Nine patients with distant metastases at diagnosis (Group 2) received CHT; one of them had a disappearance of lung metastases and was then treated by TT and further CHT. Group 3 consisted of 14 elderly patients in poor general conditions; 4 of these received local RT, while the remaining did not receive any treatment. Four complete responses were seen in patients from Group 1, and 1 from Group 2. One patient without distant metastases at diagnosis is alive and free of disease 6 months after TT and adjuvant CHT, and 12 months after diagnosis. Three had long-term survival (14, 24, 27 months) with a disease-free interval of 6-8-10 months. The patient from Group 2 who was treated in a second time by TT is alive without disease after 60 months. Median survival rate was 11 months for Group 1, 5.7 months for Group 2 and 4 months for Group 3. In some patients multimodality treatment (TT, RT and CHT) is associated with increased survival. Nine out of 16 patients, who underwent surgery and complementary treatment, had no local progression. In all but one distant metastases developed, mainly in the lung, during or after post-surgical CHT. The best results were obtained in younger patients with less advanced disease. Early diagnosis is mandatory. Only a few patients responded to CHT, confirming that anaplastic thyroid carcinoma is often resistant to anticancer drugs. Our experience with combination modalities suggests that aggressive and appropriate combinations of RT, TT and CHT may provide some benefit in patients with anaplastic thyroid carcinoma. Preoperative CHT and RT may enhance surgical resectability of the primary tumor.

BRAF in primary and recurrent papillary thyroid cancers: the relationship with 131I and 2-[18F]fluoro-2-deoxy-d-glucose uptake ability

OBJECTIVE BRAF V600E is a potential marker of poor prognosis in papillary thyroid cancers (PTC). In a previous report, we showed that recurrent PTC with no radioiodine ((131)I) uptake are frequently associated with BRAF mutations, a low expression of thyroid-related genes and a high expression of glucose type-1 transporter gene. AIM The aim of the present study was to assess BRAF status in a large series of recurrent PTC patients, considering paired primary and recurrent cancers. The BRAF genotype was correlated with the ability to concentrate (131)I and/or 2-[(18)F]fluoro-2-deoxi-d-glucose ((18)F-FDG) in the recurrent cancers, serum markers of recurrence, and patient outcome. DESIGN AND METHODS We studied 50 PTC patients with recurrent cervical disease submitted to a re-intervention, followed up in median for 9 years. BRAF analysis was conducted by direct sequencing and mutant allele-specific PCR amplification. In 18 cases, molecular analysis was also assessed in the primary cancer. Out of 50 patients, 30 underwent (18)F-FDG-positron emission tomography-computed tomography. RESULTS BRAF V600E-positive recurrent patients were found (131)I-negative in 94% of cases (P<0.001); 73% of the cancers carrying BRAF V600E were both (131)I-negative and (18)F-FDG positive. In paired primary and recurrent PTC, BRAF V600E was observed in 79% of the primary cancers and 84% of their recurrences. Three patients with (131)I-negative and BRAF V600E-positive recurrent cancers deceased during follow-up. CONCLUSIONS BRAF mutations are more common in thyroid recurrences with no (131)I uptake than in (131)I-positive cases. They are correlated with the ability to concentrate (18)F-FDG, and they can appear, albeit rarely, as a de novo event in the course of PTC recurrences.