Benjamin J. McFarland

Symmetry Recognizing Asymmetry: Analysis of the Interactions between the C-Type Lectin-like Immunoreceptor NKG2D and MHC Class I-like Ligands

Engagement of diverse protein ligands (MIC-A/B, ULBP, Rae-1, or H60) by NKG2D immunoreceptors mediates elimination of tumorigenic or virally infected cells by natural killer and T cells. Three previous NKG2D-ligand complex structures show the homodimeric receptor interacting with the monomeric ligands in similar 2:1 complexes, with an equivalent surface on each NKG2D monomer binding intimately to a total of six distinct ligand surfaces. Here, the crystal structure of free human NKG2D and in silico and in vitro alanine-scanning mutagenesis analyses of the complex interfaces indicate that NKG2D recognition degeneracy is not explained by a classical induced-fit mechanism. Rather, the divergent ligands appear to utilize different strategies to interact with structurally conserved elements of the consensus NKG2D binding site.

Energetic asymmetry among hydrogen bonds in MHC class II⋅peptide complexes

Comparison of crystallized MHC class II⋅peptide complexes has revealed that, in addition to pocket interactions involving the peptide side chains, peptide binding to MHC class II molecules is characterized by a series of hydrogen bonds between genetically conserved amino acid residues in the class II molecule and the main chain of the peptide. Many class II⋅peptide structures have two sets of symmetrical hydrogen bonds at the opposite ends of the class II antigen-binding groove (β-His-81, β-Asn-82 vs. α-His-68, α-Asn-69). In this study, we alter these peripheral hydrogen bonds and measure the apparent contribution of each to the kinetic stability of peptide⋅class II complexes. Single conservative amino substitutions were made in the I-Ad protein to eliminate participation as a hydrogen bonding residue, and the kinetic stability of a diverse set of peptides bound to the substituted I-Ad proteins was measured. Although each hydrogen bond does contribute to peptide binding, our results point to the striking conclusion that those hydrogen bonds localized to the amino terminus of the peptide contribute profoundly and disproportionately to the stability of peptide interactions with I-Ad. We suggest that the peripheral hydrogen bonds at the amino terminus of the bound peptide that are conserved in all class II⋅peptide crystal structures solved thus far form a cooperative network that critically regulates peptide dissociation from the class II molecule.

Individual hydrogen bonds play a critical role in MHC class II: peptide interactions: implications for the dynamic aspects of class II trafficking and DM-mediated peptide exchange.

Summary: Determination of the crystal structure of class II:peptide complexes has shown that in addition to pocket interactions involving the side chains of the peptide, peptide binding to MHC class II molecules is characterized by a series of hydrogen bonds which are contributed by genetically conserved amino acid residues in the class II molecule to the main chain of the peptide. Our experiments have revealed an unexpectedly large contribution of hydrogen bonds at the periphery of the MHC peptide binding pocket to MHC class II function. Kinetic studies have shown that peptide dissociation rates are profoundly accelerated by loss of a single hydrogen bonding residue. The magnitude of the effects seen with the loss in potential for a single hydrogen bond support a co‐operative model in which individual bonds between class II and peptide are dependent on the integrity of neighboring interactions. Collectively our studies have revealed that MHC class II structure, peptide binding and intracellular trafficking events are critically dependent on the integrity of the hydrogen bonding network between class II molecules and its bound peptide.

Mutations Designed to Destabilize the Receptor-Bound Conformation Increase MICA-NKG2D Association Rate and Affinity

MICA is a major histocompatibility complex-like protein that undergoes a structural transition from disorder to order upon binding its immunoreceptor, NKG2D. We redesigned the disordered region of MICA with RosettaDesign to increase NKG2D binding. Mutations that stabilize this region were expected to increase association kinetics without changing dissociation kinetics, increase affinity of interaction, and reduce entropy loss upon binding. MICA mutants were stable in solution, and they were amenable to surface plasmon resonance evaluation of NKG2D binding kinetics and thermodynamics. Several MICA mutants bound NKG2D with enhanced affinity, kinetic changes were primarily observed during association, and thermodynamic changes in entropy were as expected. However, none of the 15 combinations of mutations predicted to stabilize the receptor-bound MICA conformation enhanced NKG2D affinity, whereas all 10 mutants predicted to be destabilized bound NKG2D with increased on-rates. Five of these had affinities enhanced by 0.9–1.8 kcal/mol over wild type by one to three non-contacting substitutions. Therefore, in this case, mutations designed to mildly destabilize a protein enhanced association and affinity.

Size-exclusion chromatography can identify faster-associating protein complexes and evaluate design strategies

BackgroundWe previously developed a set of rationally designed mutant MICA protein ligands for the NKG2D immunoreceptor in which MICA was mutated at residues that do not contact NKG2D. Some of these MICA mutants, predicted by RosettaDesign to be destabilized, bound NKG2D with affinities enhanced by more than an order of magnitude when evaluated by surface plasmon resonance (SPR).FindingsSmall-zone size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) detected persistent high-affinity MICA mutant-NKG2D complexes in solution as early-eluting peaks. The SEC binding assay used standard protein purification instrumentation to evaluate complex stability, qualitatively paralleled the SPR results, and successfully discriminated among complexes that differed only in on-rates. We used the SEC binding assay, along with SPR, to assess the results of a follow-up design strategy targeting the non-interfacial redesigned region. Both SEC and SPR agreed that these mutations did not enhance affinity as much as previous mutants. When the SEC binding assay was run in 1 M urea, only the highest affinity complex was detected.ConclusionThis SEC binding assay provides a correlation with SPR results for protein complex affinities, detecting changes in complex on-rates, and tunable to lower sensitivity with 1 M urea. The SEC binding assay is complementary to other protein design evaluation methods, can be adapted to the undergraduate research laboratory, and may provide additional structural information about changes in hydrodynamic radii from elution times. Our assay allowed us to conclude that further alteration of MICA at non-contacting residues is unlikely to further enhance NKG2D affinity.

Combining different design strategies for rational affinity maturation of the MICA‐NKG2D interface

We redesigned residues on the surface of MICA, a protein that binds the homodimeric immunoreceptor NKG2D, to increase binding affinity with a series of rational, incremental changes. A fixed‐backbone RosettaDesign protocol scored a set of initial mutations, which we tested by surface plasmon resonance for thermodynamics and kinetics of NKG2D binding, both singly and in combination. We combined the best four mutations at the surface with three affinity‐enhancing mutations below the binding interface found with a previous design strategy. After curating design scores with three cross‐validated tests, we found a linear relationship between free energy of binding and design score, and to a lesser extent, enthalpy and design score. Multiple mutants bound with substantial subadditivity, but in at least one case full additivity was observed when combining distant mutations. Altogether, combining the best mutations from the two strategies into a septuple mutant enhanced affinity by 50‐fold, to 50 nM, demonstrating a simple, effective protocol for affinity enhancement.

Alternative Splice Transcripts for MHC Class I–like MICA Encode Novel NKG2D Ligands with Agonist or Antagonist Functions

MHC class I chain–related proteins A and B (MICA and MICB) and UL16-binding proteins are ligands of the activating NKG2D receptor involved in cancer and immune surveillance of infection. Structurally, MICA/B proteins contain an α3 domain, whereas UL16-binding proteins do not. We identified novel alternative splice transcripts for MICA encoding five novel MICA isoforms: MICA-A, -B1, -B2, -C, and -D. Alternative splicing associates with MICA*015 and *017 and results from a point deletion (G) in the 5′ splice donor site of MICA intron 4 leading to exon 3 and exon 4 skipping and/or deletions. These changes delete the α3 domain in all isoforms, and the α2 domain in the majority of isoforms (A, B1, C, and D). Endothelial and hematopoietic cells contained endogenous alternative splice transcripts and isoforms. MICA-B1, -B2, and -D bound NKG2D by surface plasmon resonance and were expressed at the cell surface. Functionally, MICA-B2 contains two extracellular domains (α1 and α2) and is a novel potent agonist ligand for NKG2D. We found that MICA-D is a new truncated form of MICA with weak affinity for NKG2D despite lacking α2 and α3 domains. MICA-D may functionally impair NKG2D activation by competing with full-length MICA or MICA-B2 for NKG2D engagement. Our study established NKG2D binding for recombinant MICA-B1 but found no function for this isoform. New truncated MICA isoforms exhibit a range of functions that may drive unexpected immune mechanisms and provide new tools for immunotherapy.