Blake D. Hamilton

COMPARISON OF LAPAROSCOPIC VERSUS OPEN NEPHRECTOMY IN THE PEDIATRIC POPULATION

PURPOSE Laparoscopic renal surgery has become an accepted approach for benign disease in adults. We compare our experience with laparoscopic and open nephrectomy in a pediatric population. MATERIALS AND METHODS A total of 10 pediatric patients underwent laparoscopic nephrectomy or nephroureterectomy and an additional 10 consecutive children underwent similar open procedures. All patients had benign disease and were treated at a single institution. Medical records were reviewed retrospectively for relevant clinical data. RESULTS Planned surgery was completed in all cases. There were no conversions to open surgery in the laparoscopic group. Mean operative time was 175.6 versus 120.2 minutes (p = 0.01) and mean hospital stay was 22.5 versus 41.3 hours (p = 0.03) in the laparoscopic and open nephrectomy groups, respectively. Blood loss was not statistically different. Analgesic use was qualitatively less in the laparoscopic nephrectomy group. CONCLUSIONS Laparoscopic nephrectomy and nephroureterectomy may be performed safely in children. While operative time was somewhat longer in our initial laparoscopic series, postoperative hospital stay was significantly shorter than for open surgery. Further experience with this technique is warranted.

COMPLICATIONS OF LAPAROSCOPIC PROCEDURES AFTER CONCENTRATED TRAINING IN UROLOGICAL LAPAROSCOPY

PURPOSE To increase the safety and efficiency of laparoscopic surgery clinical training programs have been developed to increase the skill and efficiency of urological trainees. We evaluated the impact of dedicated laparoscopy training on the rate and type of complications after trainees entered clinical practice. MATERIALS AND METHODS Data were obtained from 13 centers where laparoscopy was performed by a single surgeon with at least 12 months of training in urological laparoscopy before clinical practice. Data included training experience, laparoscopic procedures performed after commencing clinical practice and associated complications. Procedures were classified as easy, moderate and difficult. RESULTS During training each surgeon participated in a mean of 71 cases. In clinical practice a total of 738 laparoscopic cases were performed with the group reporting an overall complication rate of 11.9%. The rate was unchanged when the initial 20, 30 and 40 cases per surgeon were compared with all subsequent cases (12%, 11.9% and 12% versus 11.8 to 12%, respectively). The re-intervention rate was 1.1%. The complication rate increased with case difficulty. Overall and early complication rates attributable to laparoscopic technique in the initial 20, 30 and 40 cases were identical. The most common complications were neuropathy in 13 patients, urine leakage/urinoma in 9, transfusion in 7 and ileus in 5. CONCLUSIONS The complication rate of surgeons who completed at least 12 months of laparoscopy training did not differ according to initial versus subsequent surgical experience. Intensive training seems to decrease the impact of the learning curve for laparoscopy.

Survey of neuromuscular injuries to the patient and surgeon during urologic laparoscopic surgery

OBJECTIVES Laparoscopy may be complicated by neuromuscular injuries, both to the patient and to the surgeon. We used a survey to estimate the incidence of these injuries during urologic laparoscopic surgery, to assess risk factors for these injuries, and to determine preventive measures. METHODS A survey of neuromuscular injuries associated with laparoscopy submitted to 18 institutions in the United States was completed by 18 attending urologists from 15 institutions. RESULTS From among a total of 1651 procedures, there were 46 neuromuscular injuries in 45 patients (2.7%), including abdominal wall neuralgia (14), extremity sensory deficit (12), extremity motor deficit (8), clinical rhabdomyolysis (6), shoulder contusion (4), and back spasm (2). Neuromuscular injuries were twice as common with upper retroperitoneal as with pelvic laparoscopy (3. 1% versus 1.5%). Among patients with neuromuscular injuries, those with rhabdomyolysis were heavier (means 91 versus 80 kg) and underwent longer procedures (means 379 versus 300 minutes), and those with motor deficits were older (means 51 versus 42 years of age). Of the surgeons, 28% and 17% reported frequent neck and shoulder pain, respectively. CONCLUSIONS Although not common, neuromuscular injuries during laparoscopy do contribute to morbidity. Abdominal wall neuralgias, injuries to peripheral nerves, and joint or back injuries likely occur no more frequently than during open surgery, but risk of rhabdomyolysis may be increased. Positioning in a partial rather than full flank position may reduce the incidence of some injuries. Measures to reduce neuromuscular strain on the surgeon during laparoscopy should be considered.

Comparison of Laparoscopic Versus Open Partial Nephrectomy in a Pediatric Series

PURPOSE Recent advances in laparoscopic surgery as well as increasing experience with these techniques have led to the selection of laparoscopic surgery for many urological procedures. A lesser number of pediatric laparoscopic surgical studies have been reported. Few pediatric comparative laparoscopic versus open surgical procedure studies have been published. We compared 2 groups of similar pediatric patients who underwent partial nephrectomy via the laparoscopic or open technique. MATERIALS AND METHODS A total of 22 consecutive partial nephrectomies were performed in pediatric patients 3 months to 15 years old. Of these procedures 11 chosen according to surgeon preference were performed laparoscopically and 11 were done by the open technique. Clinical data were obtained by chart review and compared retrospectively in the 2 groups. Demographic data, operative time and blood loss, the perioperative complication rate, hospital stay and costs, postoperative analgesic use and followup findings were compared. RESULTS Mean operative time in the laparoscopic and open groups was 200.4 and 113.5 minutes, respectively (p <0.0005). Blood loss was less than 50 cc in all patients. In the laparoscopic and open groups mean hospital stay was 25.5 and 32.6 hours (p = 0.068), and mean cost was

APPARENT UNILATERAL URETEROPELVIC JUNCTION OBSTRUCTION IN THE NEWBORN: EXPECTATIONS FOR RESOLUTION

6,125 and

AMMONIUM ACID URATE CALCULI: A REEVALUATION OF RISK FACTORS

4,244 (p = 0.016), respectively. Patients in the laparoscopic group required fewer doses of analgesics than those who underwent open surgery (mean 10.9 versus 21, p = 0.041). CONCLUSIONS Our findings show that increased operative time and costs are disadvantages of pediatric laparoscopic nephrectomy compared with open techniques. Conversely decreased hospital stay, lower analgesic requirements and cosmesis support the use of laparoscopy for pediatric partial nephrectomy. These differences must be considered when deciding which technique is best for overall patient care.

Percutaneous Endoscopic Trigonoplasty: A Minimally Invasive Approach to Correct Vesicoureteral Reflux

PURPOSE We retrospectively reviewed the records of patients with prenatal hydronephrosis to characterize those in whom it was more likely to resolve with conservative management. MATERIALS AND METHODS We studied 51 patients in a 4-year period who presented with nonspecific unilateral hydronephrosis diagnosed by prenatal and confirmed by postnatal sonography. Patients were followed with sequential nuclear renograms with furosemide washout to evaluate function and drainage. In all cases a nonoperative approach was attempted. Pyeloplasty was performed only for poor or decreasing kidney function and/or drainage. RESULTS Four of the 51 patients were lost to followup, 21 of the remaining 47 (45%) eventually underwent surgery, and 26 (55%) had complete normalization of renal function and washout pattern without surgery. There was no statistically significant correlation between hydronephrosis grade on initial postnatal sonography and the likelihood of nonsurgical resolution. However, the shape of the washout curve on nuclear renography was informative for predicting outcome, since 86% of the cases with a nonobstructive drainage pattern normalized without surgery, while 62% with indeterminate and only 18% with obstructive curves resolved with conservative management (p <0.01). Notably in 83% of the cases of normalization without surgery resolution occurred before age 18 months. Also, an initial obstructed washout pattern was more likely to be associated with a poor outcome. Of the 6 patients with less than 40% final differential function 5 had an obstructed washout pattern on the initial nuclear renogram. CONCLUSIONS Patients diagnosed by prenatal ultrasound with apparent unilateral ureteropelvic junction obstruction generally do well with conservative treatment. However, those who present with an obstructed washout pattern are less likely to have resolution without surgery and more likely to have poor final differential function.

TECHNIQUE OF LAPAROSCOPIC ADRENALECTOMY

PURPOSE We reevaluate the demographic and metabolic risk factors for ammonium acid urate stones. MATERIALS AND METHODS Since 1986, 23 women and 21 men ranging in age from 20 to 81 years (mean 48.7) were treated for stones partly composed of ammonium acid urate. Stone composition ranged from 2 to 60% ammonium acid urate (mean 24.1) of the total stone mass. No patient had a pure ammonium acid urate stone, although 11 (25%) had stones with ammonium acid urate as the predominant crystal. RESULTS In the 44 patients 1 or more potential risk factors for ammonium acid urate were identified. Of the patients 11 (25%) had a history of inflammatory bowel disease with 10 (22.7%) having undergone ileostomy diversion, 6 (13.6%) admitted to a history of significant laxative use or abuse, 18 (40.9%) were morbidly obese, 16 (36.4%) had a history of recurrent urinary tract infections and 9 (20.5%) had a history of recurrent uric acid stones. CONCLUSIONS Patients clearly at risk for stones with an ammonium acid urate component include those with a history of inflammatory bowel disease and ileostomy diversion or laxative abuse. Other factors that may potentially enhance ammonium acid urate stone formation include morbid obesity, recurrent uric acid calculi and recurrent urinary tract infection. A careful history followed by further metabolic evaluation is warranted in these patients.

Pediatric Urinary Stone Composition in the United States

PURPOSE A procedure was designed to correct vesicoureteral reflux with minimally invasive technology. MATERIALS AND METHODS A total of 22 children 14 months to 18 years old underwent percutaneous endoscopic trigonoplasty between January and June 1995. Followup ranges from 4 to 11 months. In 32 ureters reflux was grade 2 in 13, grade 3 in 13, grade 4 in 5 and grade 5 in 1. RESULTS All patients had normal sonography of the kidneys after surgery. On followup voiding cystourethrography at 2 or 6 months there was resolution of reflux in 20 of the 32 ureters (62.5%). The probability of resolution was unrelated to patient age, laterality of reflux, initial grade, operative sequence or preoperative bladder instability. The 3 major complications were vesicovaginal fistula, hyponatremia and perivesical fluid collection. CONCLUSIONS Percutaneous endoscopic trigonoplasty is technically feasible but it involves a distinct learning curve. It offers significant advantages related to more rapid recovery with less discomfort. The success rate is modest at present. If it were to be improved with technical modifications, percutaneous endoscopic trigonoplasty may change the basic approach to treating children with vesicoureteral reflux.

Transperitoneal laparoscopic adrenalectomy.

Laparoscopic adrenalectomy by the transperitoneal route has been shown to be a safe and effective approach to select adrenal pathology. Although the specific indications will continue to be refined, it is clear that for adrenal masses of 6 cm or less, laparoscopy provides excellent access with little additional risk to the patient. In addition there appears to be an improved postoperative course when compared with open adrenalectomy. This latter point, however, requires careful prospective studies to confirm this impression objectively. The operative times are longer by the laparoscopic approach, but undoubtedly these times will decrease with increasing experience and improved laparoscopic instrumentation.