Caroline Koshy

Alternating-access mechanism in conformationally asymmetric trimers of the betaine transporter BetP

Betaine and Na+ symport has been extensively studied in the osmotically regulated transporter BetP from Corynebacterium glutamicum, a member of the betaine/choline/carnitine transporter family, which shares the conserved LeuT-like fold of two inverted structural repeats. BetP adjusts its transport activity by sensing the cytoplasmic K+ concentration as a measure for hyperosmotic stress via the osmosensing carboxy-terminal domain. BetP needs to be in a trimeric state for communication between individual protomers through several intratrimeric interaction sites. Recently, crystal structures of inward-facing BetP trimers have contributed to our understanding of activity regulation on a molecular level. Here we report new crystal structures, which reveal two conformationally asymmetric BetP trimers, capturing among them three distinct transport states. We observe a total of four new conformations at once: an outward-open apo and an outward-occluded apo state, and two closed transition states—one in complex with betaine and one substrate-free. On the basis of these new structures, we identified local and global conformational changes in BetP that underlie the molecular transport mechanism, which partially resemble structural changes observed in other sodium-coupled LeuT-like fold transporters, but show differences we attribute to the osmolytic nature of betaine, the exclusive substrate specificity and the regulatory properties of BetP.

Investigation of the sodium-binding sites in the sodium-coupled betaine transporter BetP

Sodium-coupled substrate transport plays a central role in many biological processes. However, despite knowledge of the structures of several sodium-coupled transporters, the location of the sodium-binding site(s) often remains unclear. Several of these structures have the five transmembrane-helix inverted-topology repeat, LeuT-like (FIRL) fold, whose pseudosymmetry has been proposed to facilitate the alternating-access mechanism required for transport. Here, we provide biophysical, biochemical, and computational evidence for the location of the two cation-binding sites in the sodium-coupled betaine symporter BetP. A recent X-ray structure of BetP in a sodium-bound closed state revealed that one of these sites, equivalent to the Na2 site in related transporters, is located between transmembrane helices 1 and 8 of the FIRL-fold; here, we confirm the location of this site by other means. Based on the pseudosymmetry of this fold, we hypothesized that the second site is located between the equivalent helices 6 and 3. Molecular dynamics simulations of the closed-state structure suggest this second sodium site involves two threonine sidechains and a backbone carbonyl from helix 3, a phenylalanine from helix 6, and a water molecule. Mutating the residues proposed to form the two binding sites increased the apparent Km and Kd for sodium, as measured by betaine uptake, tryptophan fluorescence, and 22Na+ binding, and also diminished the transient currents measured in proteoliposomes using solid supported membrane-based electrophysiology. Taken together, these results provide strong evidence for the identity of the residues forming the sodium-binding sites in BetP.

Substrate specificity and ion coupling in the Na+/betaine symporter BetP.

BetP is an Na+‐coupled betaine‐specific transporter of the betaine–choline–carnitine (BCC) transporter family involved in the response to hyperosmotic stress. The crystal structure of BetP revealed an overall fold of two inverted structurally related repeats (LeuT‐fold) that BetP shares with other sequence‐unrelated Na+‐coupled symporters. Numerous structures of LeuT‐fold transporters in distinct conformational states have contributed substantially to our understanding of the alternating access mechanism of transport. Nevertheless, coupling of substrate and co‐transported ion fluxes has not been structurally corroborated to the same extent. We converted BetP by a single‐point mutation—glycine to aspartate—into an H+‐coupled choline‐specific transporter and solved the crystal structure of this mutant in complex with choline. The structure of BetP‐G153D demonstrates a new inward‐facing open conformation for BetP. Choline binding to a location close to the second, low‐affinity sodium‐binding site (Na2) of LeuT‐fold transporters is facilitated by the introduced aspartate. Our data confirm the importance of a cation‐binding site in BetP, playing a key role in a proposed molecular mechanism of Na+ and H+ coupling in BCC transporters.

Structural evidence for functional lipid interactions in the betaine transporter BetP

Bilayer lipids contribute to the stability of membrane transporters and are crucially involved in their proper functioning. However, the molecular knowledge of how surrounding lipids affect membrane transport is surprisingly limited and despite its general importance is rarely considered in the molecular description of a transport mechanism. One reason is that only few atomic resolution structures of channels or transporters reveal a functional interaction with lipids, which are difficult to detect in X‐ray structures per se. Overcoming these difficulties, we report here on a new structure of the osmotic stress‐regulated betaine transporter BetP in complex with anionic lipids. This lipid‐associated BetP structure is important in the molecular understanding of osmoregulation due to the strong dependence of activity regulation in BetP on the presence of negatively charged lipids. We detected eight resolved palmitoyl‐oleoyl phosphatidyl glycerol (PG) lipids mimicking parts of the membrane leaflets and interacting with key residues in transport and regulation. The lipid–protein interactions observed here in structural detail in BetP provide molecular insights into the role of lipids in osmoregulated secondary transport.

Structural insights into functional lipid–protein interactions in secondary transporters☆

BACKGROUND Structural evidences with functional corroborations have revealed distinct features of lipid-protein interactions especially in channels and receptors. Many membrane embedded transporters are also known to require specific lipids for their functions and for some of them cellular and biochemical data suggest tight regulation by the lipid bilayer. However, molecular details on lipid-protein interactions in transporters are sparse since lipids are either depleted from the detergent solubilized transporters in three-dimensional crystals or not readily resolved in crystal structures. Nevertheless the steady increase in the progress of transporter structure determination contributed more examples of structures with resolved lipids. SCOPE OF REVIEW This review gives an overview on transporter structures in complex with lipids reported to date and discusses commonly encountered difficulties in the identification of functionally significant lipid-protein interactions based on those structures and functional in vitro data. Recent structures provided molecular details into regulation mechanism of transporters by specific lipids. The review highlights common findings and conserved patterns for distantly related transporter families to draw a more general picture on the regulatory role of lipid-protein interactions. MAJOR CONCLUSIONS Several common themes of the manner in which lipids directly influence membrane-mediated folding, oligomerization and structure stability can be found. Especially for LeuT-like fold transporters similarities in structurally resolved lipid-protein interactions suggest a common way in which transporter conformations are affected by lipids even in evolutionarily distinct transporters. Lipids appear to play an additional role as joints mechanically reinforcing the inverted repeat topology, which is a major determinant in the alternating access mechanism of secondary transporters. GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE This review brings together and adds to the repertoire of knowledge on lipid-protein interactions of functional significance presented in structures of membrane transporters. Knowledge of specific lipid-binding sites and modes of lipid influence on these proteins not only accomplishes the molecular description of transport cycle further, but also sheds light into localization dependent differences of transporter function. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Structural biochemistry and biophysics of membrane proteins.

Role of Bundle Helices in a Regulatory Crosstalk in the Trimeric Betaine Transporter BetP

The Na(+)-coupled betaine symporter BetP regulates transport activity in response to hyperosmotic stress only in its trimeric state, suggesting a regulatory crosstalk between individual protomers. BetP shares the overall fold of two inverted structurally related five-transmembrane (TM) helix repeats with the sequence-unrelated Na(+)-coupled symporters LeuT, vSGLT, and Mhp1, which are neither trimeric nor regulated in transport activity. Conformational changes characteristic for this transporter fold involve the two first helices of each repeat, which form a four-TM-helix bundle. Here, we identify two ionic networks in BetP located on both sides of the membrane that might be responsible for BetPs unique regulatory behavior by restricting the conformational flexibility of the four-TM-helix bundle. The cytoplasmic ionic interaction network links both first helices of each repeat in one protomer to the osmosensing C-terminal domain of the adjacent protomer. Moreover, the periplasmic ionic interaction network conformationally locks the four-TM-helix bundle between the same neighbor protomers. By a combination of site-directed mutagenesis, cross-linking, and betaine uptake measurements, we demonstrate how conformational changes in individual bundle helices are transduced to the entire bundle by specific inter-helical interactions. We suggest that one purpose of bundle networking is to assist crosstalk between protomers during transport regulation by specifically modulating the transition from outward-facing to inward-facing state.

Assignment of the resting state of the secondary active transporter BetP by integrating spectroscopic measurements and molecular simulations

The glycine betaine symporter BetP regulates the osmotic stress response of Corynebacterium glutamicum, a soil bacterium used extensively in biotechnology. Although BetP is a homotrimer, biochemical studies have shown that each protomer is able to transport its substrate independently. Crystallographic structures of BetP have been determined in several conformations, seemingly capturing outward-open, inward-open and occluded states, both loaded with the substrate and in the apo form. However, it has been challenging to establish a correspondence between each of these structures and specific states in the mechanism of the transporter under more physiological conditions. To this end, we examined the dynamics of spin-labelled BetP using pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR) under different stimuli. We then carried out molecular simulations of structures of the BetP monomer to interpret the PELDOR data, using the enhanced-sampling methodology EBMetaD (1), whereby the dynamics of the protein are minimally biased so as to reproduce the experimental data. Comparison of the magnitude of the biasing work required for different input structures permitted us to assign them to specific states of the transport cycle under each of the experimental conditions. In particular, this analysis showed that BetP adopts inward-facing conformations in the presence of excess sodium, and a mixture of states when betaine is added. These studies better delineate the major conformations adopted by BetP in its transport cycle, and therefore provide important insights into its mechanism. More broadly, we illustrate how integrative simulations can aid interpretation of ambiguous structural and spectroscopic data on membrane proteins. Abbreviations BetP betaine permease TM transmembrane POPG palmitoyl oleyl phosphatidyl-glycerol DDM β-dodecyl-maltoside SEC size-exclusion chromatography EPR electron paramagnetic resonance PELDOR pulsed electron-electron double resonance DEER double electron-electron resonance EBmetaD ensemble-biased metadynamics MD molecular dynamics R5 1-oxyl-2,2,5,5-tetramethylpyrrolidin-3-yl)methyl methanethiosulfonate