Cendrine Mony

Fine-scale spatial patterns in grassland communities depend on species clonal dispersal ability and interactions with neighbours

Summary Non-random spatial patterns are a common feature of plant communities. However, the mechanisms leading to their formation remain unknown. The clonal dispersal ability of a species, that is, the average length of spacers between ramets, is commonly acknowledged to influence spatial patterns in clonal plants, although this relationship remains to be demonstrated. Moreover, the clonal dispersal ability of neighbouring species may influence environmental conditions and trigger modifications in clonal characteristics of a focal species. Thus, not only the clonal dispersal ability of a species, but also that of its competitors may influence the fine-scale spatial pattern of a species. In this article, we compared spatial patterns (in terms of colonization and occupation of space) of species with low (L), intermediate (I) or high (H) clonal dispersal abilities. Twelve species were classified within three groups of clonal dispersal (L, I or H) based on their average spacer lengths, and seven types of experimental assemblages consisting of species from one, two or three dispersal groups were studied. Two questions were addressed: (i) does the species clonal dispersal ability influence their spatial patterns and (ii) are species fine-scale spatial patterns affected by the clonal dispersal of neighbours? Species spatial patterns were recorded for each assemblage and were then analyzed using point pattern analysis. Despite strong species-specific effects, L-species displayed the highest level of local aggregation, which is indicative of limited space colonization, and the lowest level of local co-occurrence with other species, which is indicative of a high level of space occupation. The opposite pattern was observed in H-species, while that of I-species was intermediate. The species spatial patterns were modified by the clonal dispersal ability of competitors. Synthesis. This study emphasizes the importance not only of clonal dispersal but also of biotic interactions and, more precisely, of plant neighbour characteristics, in the spatial patterning of grassland plant communities.

Abiotic stressors and stress responses: What commonalities appear between species across biological organization levels?

Organisms are regularly subjected to abiotic stressors related to increasing anthropogenic activities, including chemicals and climatic changes that induce major stresses. Based on various key taxa involved in ecosystem functioning (photosynthetic microorganisms, plants, invertebrates), we review how organisms respond and adapt to chemical- and temperature-induced stresses from molecular to population level. Using field-realistic studies, our integrative analysis aims to compare i) how molecular and physiological mechanisms related to protection, repair and energy allocation can impact life history traits of stressed organisms, and ii) to what extent trait responses influence individual and population responses. Common response mechanisms are evident at molecular and cellular scales but become rather difficult to define at higher levels due to evolutionary distance and environmental complexity. We provide new insights into the understanding of the impact of molecular and cellular responses on individual and population dynamics and assess the potential related effects on communities and ecosystem functioning.

How past and present influence the foraging of clonal plants

Clonal plants spreading horizontally and forming a network structure of ramets exhibit complex growth patterns to maximize resource uptake from the environment. They respond to spatial heterogeneity by changing their internode length or branching frequency. Ramets definitively root in the soil but stay interconnected for a varying period of time thus allowing an exchange of spatial and temporal information. We quantified the foraging response of clonal plants depending on the local soil quality sampled by the rooting ramet (i.e. the present information) and the resource variability sampled by the older ramets (i.e. the past information). We demonstrated that two related species, Potentilla reptans and P. anserina, responded similarly to the local quality of their environment by decreasing their internode length in response to nutrient-rich soil. Only P. reptans responded to resource variability by decreasing its internode length. In both species, the experience acquired by older ramets influenced the plastic response of new rooted ramets: the internode length between ramets depended not only on the soil quality locally sampled but also on the soil quality previously sampled by older ramets. We quantified the effect of the information perceived at different time and space on the foraging behavior of clonal plants by showing a non-linear response of the ramet rooting in the soil of a given quality. These data suggest that the decision to grow a stolon or to root a ramet at a given distance from the older ramet results from the integration of the past and present information about the richness and the variability of the environment.

Responses of clonal architecture to experimental defoliation: a comparative study between ten grassland species

Clonal architecture may enable plants to effectively respond to environmental constraints but its role in plant tolerance to defoliation remains poorly documented. In several non-clonal species, modifications of plant architecture have been reported as a mechanism of plant tolerance to defoliation, yet this has been little studied in clonal plants. In a glasshouse experiment, five rhizomatous and five stoloniferous species of grazed pastures were subjected to three frequencies of defoliation in order to test two hypotheses. (1) We expected plant clonal response to defoliation to be either a more compact architecture (low clonal propagation, but high branching), or a more dispersed one (long-distance propagation and low branching). Such plastic adjustments of clonal architecture were assumed to be involved in tolerance to defoliation i.e. to promote genet performance in terms of biomass and number of ramets. (2) The response of clonal architecture to defoliation was expected to be dependent on the species and to be more plastic in stoloniferous than in rhizomatous species. Most genets of each species were tolerant to defoliation as they survived and developed in every treatment. Architectural modifications in response to defoliation did not match our predictions. Clonal growth was either maintained or reduced under defoliation. Relative growth rate (RGR) decreased in eight species, whereas defoliated genets of seven species produced as many ramets as control genets. Biomass allocation to ramet shoots remained stable for all but one species. In defoliated genets, the number and mean length of connections, and mean inter-ramet distance were equal to or lower than those in control genets. Four groups of species were distinguished according to their architectural response to defoliation and did not depend on the type of connections. We hypothesised that dense clonal architectures with low plasticity may be the most advantageous response in defoliated conditions such as in grazed pastures.

Morphological response to competition for light in the clonal Trifolium repens (Fabaceae)

PREMISE OF THE STUDY Plant communities in temperate zones are dominated by clonal plants that can plastically modify their growth characteristics in response to competition. Given that plants compete with one another, and the implications this has for species coexistence, we conducted a study to assess how clonal species morphologically respond to competition for light depending on its intensity and heterogeneity, which are determined by the competitor species. METHODS We assessed the morphological response to competition for light of the clonal species Trifolium repens L. by measuring its growth performance, and vertical and horizontal growth traits. We used five competitive environments, i.e., one without competitor and four differing by their competitor species creating different conditions of competition intensity and heterogeneity. KEY RESULTS The morphological response of Trifolium repens to competition for light depended on the competitor identity. Competition intensity and heterogeneity, determined by competitor identity, had an interactive effect on most traits. The increase in petiole elongation and specific leaf area due to increased competition intensity was observed only at low to intermediate competition heterogeneity. Competition heterogeneity promoted the elongation of clone connections allowing space exploration. CONCLUSIONS Our results demonstrated that the intensity and heterogeneity of competition, which depended on competitor identity, are of primary importance in determining the plastic response of Trifolium repens. This emphasizes that it is important to consider the fine-scale spatial distribution of individuals when studying their interactions within plant communities.

Clonal Growth Strategies Along Flooding and Grazing Gradients in Atlantic Coastal Meadows

Specific composition and species clonal traits were characterized along combined flooding and grazing gradients to answer two questions. i) To what extent does the interaction of flooding and grazing influence the clonal characteristics of the vegetation? ii) Are the effects of both environmental factors independent or interactive? This study was carried out in a wet meadow along the Atlantic coast (France). Three plant communities (hygrophilous, meso-hygrophilous and mesophilous) were distinguished along a flooding gradient and five levels of grazing pressure were controlled through an experimental design (from no grazing to heavy grazing). We monitored species composition and retrieved, for each species, the type of clonal growth organs (CGOs) and clonal traits from the CLO-PLA3 database. We identified two syndromes of clonal traits: “above-ground splitters” and “below-ground integrators”. Clonal traits played a key role in plant assembly in the studied meadows. The interaction of both environmental factors selected for particular syndromes of clonal traits; however, flooding had a stronger filtering effect than grazing. The hygrophilous community was dominated by above-ground splitters, whereas the meso-hygrophilous vegetation was dominated by below-ground integrators. In the mesophilous community, clonal composition was the most diverse and shared clonal traits with the vegetation of both the hygrophilous and meso-hygrophilous communities. Grazing impact on CGOs and clonal traits differed between plant communities, i.e., the effect of grazing was modulated by the flooding regime. This study confirmed that vegetation responses to grazing might depend on the pool of traits, primarily filtered by environmental factors such as flooding.

Resprouting Response of Aquatic Clonal Plants to Cutting May Explain Their Resistance to Spate Flooding

Resprouting ability may increase a plant’s resistance to recurrent disturbances in aquatic ecosystems. We investigated the effect of mechanical disturbances on survival and regrowth patterns in three clonal aquatic species of similar growth form but with different ecological ranges in terms of flooding (Myriophyllum verticillatum, Myriophyllum spicatum and Potamogeton coloratus). P. coloratus prefers to colonize stable habitats, whereas M. verticillatum occurs in intermediately flooded habitats and M. spicatum is tolerant to a high flooding frequency. Two cutting treatments (single cuts or repeated cuts) were applied under controlled conditions. We hypothesized that M. verticillatum and M. spicatum would be resistant to cutting displaying either a tolerant or an escape strategy whereas P. coloratus would be sensitive to cutting. Our hypothesis was validated, as the three species displayed contrasting responses to disturbance. M. verticillatum displayed efficient clonal propagation following breakage (escape strategy), but its growth rate decreased after recurrent disturbances. P. coloratus displayed a close response but was unable to compensate biomass loss even after one cut. M. spicatum maintained a similar growth rate by developing a densely branched form despite recurrent disturbances but with a low investment in clonal growth (tolerance strategy). Both biomass compensation and clonal propagation influence plant fitness, but their relative advantage differs depending on the flooding frequency experienced by plants in their natural habitats. Clonal propagation may promote recolonization after disturbances in infrequently flooded sites, but seems less efficient than a tolerance strategy for survival in frequently flooded sites.

Epigenetic Mechanisms and Microbiota as a Toolbox for Plant Phenotypic Adjustment to Environment

The classic understanding of organisms focuses on genes as the main source of species evolution and diversification. The recent concept of genetic accommodation questions this gene centric view by emphasizing the importance of phenotypic plasticity on evolutionary trajectories. Recent discoveries on epigenetics and symbiotic microbiota demonstrated their deep impact on plant survival, adaptation and evolution thus suggesting a novel comprehension of the plant phenotype. In addition, interplays between these two phenomena controlling plant plasticity can be suggested. Because epigenetic and plant-associated (micro-) organisms are both key sources of phenotypic variation allowing environmental adjustments, we argue that they must be considered in terms of evolution. This ‘non-conventional’ set of mediators of phenotypic variation can be seen as a toolbox for plant adaptation to environment over short, medium and long time-scales.

Plant traits respond to the competitive neighbourhood at different spatial and temporal scales

BACKGROUND AND AIMS Clonal plants can plastically modify their traits in response to competition, but little is known regarding the spatio-temporal scale at which a competitive neighbourhood determines the variability in species traits. This study tests the hypothesis that the local neighbourhood can be expected to influence the processes that are involved in competition tolerance and avoidance, and that this effect depends on organ lifespan. METHODS Fragments of the rhizomatous Elytrigia repens (Poaceae) were sampled in 2012 in experimental plant communities that varied in species identity and abundance. These communities had been cultivated since 2009 in mesocosms in a common garden. Fragment performance, shoot and clonal traits were measured, and the effects of past and present local neighbourhoods of five different radius sizes (5-25 cm) were examined. Past and present local neighbourhood compositions were assessed in 2011 and 2012, respectively. KEY RESULTS Most of the measured traits of E. repens responded to the local neighbourhood (5-10 cm radius), with an additional effect of the larger neighbourhood (20-25 cm radius) on ramet height, leaf dry matter content, maximal internode length and specific rhizome mass. Contrary to the expectation of the hypothesis, the temporal influence was not due to the organ lifespan. Indeed, five of the eight traits studied responded to both the past and present neighbourhoods. With the exception of specific rhizome mass, all trait responses were explained by the abundance of specific species. CONCLUSIONS This study demonstrates that the traits of a single clonal individual can respond to different competitive environments in space and time. The results thus contribute to the understanding of competition mechanisms.

Do spatial patterns of clonal fragments and architectural responses to defoliation depend on the structural blue-print? An experimental test with two rhizomatous Cyperaceae

Clonal architecture is involved in performance of clonal fragments, as it determines spatial distribution of ramets. It is expected to rely on the species-specific expression of several architectural traits (structural blue-print). However, in contrasting environments, realized clonal architectures may differ, due to phenotypic plasticity. In this paper, we compared clonal architectures between two rhizomatous ecologically close Cyperaceae (Carex divisa and Eleocharis palustris) in non-defoliated and defoliated conditions. Two questions were addressed. (1) How much do the structural blue-print and resulting colonization and occupation of space differ between both species? (2) Does the structural blue-print constrain plastic responses of clonal architecture to defoliation? Traits related to performance, spatial pattern, architecture and biomass allocation of clonal fragments were monitored through an original non-destructive mapping method. In non-defoliated conditions, both species showed similar biomass but contrasting architectures and patterns of biomass allocation to rhizomes that resulted in different spatial patterns. The rhizome network of C. divisa, which consisted in only two primary rhizomes but several branches, was involved in resource storage rather than in spatial colonization. Conversely, E. palustris produced on average six primary rhizomes that grew in the whole horizontal plane, maximizing both occupation and colonization of space. These differences in structural constraints coupled with allometric relationships, resulted in differential responses to defoliation. In C. divisa, the costs associated to defoliation caused a decrease in branching, limiting the area occupied and number of ramets produced by clonal fragments, but increasing ramet density. Conversely, the weakly branched rhizome network of E. palustris was not affected by defoliation. Both spatial strategies (consolidation vs. colonization) are likely to provide ecological advantages allowing their coexistence in grazed meadows.