Charles C. J. Wo

Unreliability of blood pressure and heart rate to evaluate cardiac output in emergency resuscitation and critical illness

ObjectiveTo evaluate the reliability of the vital signs to evaluate circulatory stability as reflected by cardiac index. DesignDescriptive analysis based on data gathered prospectively, using a predetermined protocol. SettingUniversity-run county hospital, with a large trauma service. PatientsSixty-one high-risk trauma patients with accidental injury who were studied immediately after admission to the Emergency Department, and subsequently, 163 critically ill postoperative ICU patients. InterventionsStandard fluid therapy, usually crystalloids, but occasionally packed red cell transfusions and colloids, as indicated by clinical criteria. Measurements and ResultsArterial BP was measured by pressure transducer and arterial catheter; heart rate (HR) was measured by electrocardiograph signal, and cardiac output was measured by thermodilution. In sudden severe hypovolemic hypotension, the mean arterial pressure (MAP) nadir (lowest) roughly correlated (r2 = .25) with flow, but there was poor correlation (r2 s .0001) when all pressure and flow values were evaluated. The pressure and flow values were obtained throughout the course of the hypotensive episodes during the initial resuscitation in ICU patients and during terminal illnesses. ConclusionsObservations at the time of acute severe hypotensive crises that show rough correlation of MAP and cardiac index should not be extrapolated throughout the entire hypotensive period or to other less extreme clinical situations. The stress response to hypovolemia, with endogenous catecholamines and neural mechanisms, tends to maintain arterial pressure in the face of decreasing flow for a variable period of time. However, when these mechanisms are overwhelmed by prolonged hypovolemia, the pressure decreases precipitously, but not synchronously, with flow. We conclude that blood flow cannot reliably be inferred from arterial pressure and heart rate measurements until extreme hypotension occurs. (Crit Care Med 1993; 21:218–223)

Endpoints of resuscitation of critically injured patients: normal or supranormal? A prospective randomized trial.

ObjectiveTo evaluate the effect of early optimization in the survival of severely injured patients. Summary Background DataIt is unclear whether supranormal (“optimal”) hemodynamic values should serve as endpoints of resuscitation or simply as markers of the physiologic reserve of critically injured patients. The failure of optimization to produce improved survival in some randomized controlled trials may be associated with delays in starting the attempt to reach optimal goals. There are limited controlled data on trauma patients. MethodsSeventy-five consecutive severely injured patients with shock resulting from bleeding and without major intracranial or spinal cord trauma were randomized to resuscitation, starting immediately after admission, to either normal values of systolic blood pressure, urine output, base deficit, hemoglobin, and cardiac index (control group, 35 patients) or optimal values (cardiac index >4.5 L/min/m2, ratio of transcutaneous oxygen tension to fractional inspired oxygen >200, oxygen delivery index >600 mL/min/m2, and oxygen consumption index >170 mL/min/m2; optimal group, 40 patients). Initial cardiac output monitoring was done noninvasively by bioimpedance and, subsequently, invasively by thermodilution. Crystalloids, colloids, blood, inotropes, and vasopressors were used by predetermined algorithms. ResultsOptimal values were reached intentionally by 70% of the optimal patients and spontaneously by 40% of the control patients. There was no difference in rates of death (15% optimal vs. 11% control), organ failure, sepsis, or the length of intensive care unit or hospital stay between the two groups. Patients from both groups who achieved optimal values had better outcomes than patients who did not. The death rate was 0% among patients who achieved optimal values compared with 30% among patients who did not. Age younger than 40 years was the only independent predictive factor of the ability to reach optimal values. ConclusionsSeverely injured patients who can achieve optimal hemodynamic values are more likely to survive than those who cannot, regardless of the resuscitation technique. In this study, attempts at early optimization did not improve the outcome of the examined subgroup of severely injured patients.

Transcutaneous oxygen and CO2 as early warning of tissue hypoxia and hemodynamic shock in critically ill emergency patients.

Background Although cardiac and pulmonary function can be measured precisely, evaluation of tissue perfusion remains elusive because it usually is inferred from subjective symptoms and imprecise signs of shock. The latter are indirect criteria used to assess the overall circulatory status as well as tissue perfusion but are not direct quantitative measures of perfusion. However, noninvasive transcutaneous oxygen (PtcO2) and carbon dioxide (PtcCO2) tensions, which directly measure skin oxygenation and CO2 retention, may be used to objectively evaluate skin oxygenation and perfusion in emergency patients beginning with resuscitation immediately after hospital admission. Objective This study was a preliminary evaluation of tissue oxygenation and perfusion by objective PtcO2 and PtcCO2 patterns in severely injured surviving and nonsurviving patients; specifically, the aim was to describe time patterns that may be used as early warning signs of circulatory dysfunction and death. Design Prospective descriptive study of a consecutive series of severely injured emergency patients. Setting University-affiliated Level I trauma center and intensive care unit. Patients and Methods Forty-eight consecutive severely injured patients were prospectively monitored by PtcO2 and PtcCO2 sensors immediately after emergency admission. Results Compared with survivors, patients who died had significantly lower PtcO2 and higher PtcCO2 values beginning with the early stage of resuscitation. All patients who maintained PtcO2 >150 torr (19.99 kPa) throughout monitoring survived. Periods of PtcO2 <50 torr (6.66 kPa) for >60 mins or PtcCO2 >60 torr (8.00 kPa) for >30 mins were associated with 90% mortality and 100% morbidity. Conclusion PtcO2 and PtcCO2 monitoring continuously evaluate tissue perfusion and serve as early warning in critically injured patients during resuscitation immediately after hospital admission.

Intraoperative evaluation of tissue perfusion in high-risk patients by invasive and noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring.

OBJECTIVE Although invasive monitoring has not been effective in late stages after organ failure has occurred, early postoperative monitoring revealed differences in survivor and nonsurvivor patterns and provided goals for improving outcome. We searched for the earliest divergence of survivor and nonsurvivor circulatory changes as an approach to earlier preventive therapy. The aim was to describe the intraoperative time course of circulatory dysfunction in survivors and nonsurvivors among high-risk elective surgery patients using both the thermodilution pulmonary artery catheter (PAC) and multicomponent noninvasive monitoring. DESIGN Prospective intraoperative description of circulatory dysfunction. SETTING University-run county hospital. PATIENTS Two hundred nine consecutively monitored high-risk elective surgery patients. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS We evaluated the data of high-risk elective surgery patients using both PAC and multicomponent noninvasive monitoring. The latter consisted of the following: a) an improved bioimpedance method for estimating cardiac output; b) the standard pulse oximetry to screen for pulmonary problems; c) transcutaneous oxygen and carbon dioxide tension sensors to evaluate tissue perfusion; and d) routine noninvasive blood pressure and heart rate. The current noninvasive impedance cardiac output estimations closely approximated those of the thermodilution method; r2 = .74, p < .001; the precision and bias was -0.124 +/- 0.75 L/min/m2. Outcome measures included intraoperative description of circulatory patterns of high-risk surgical patients who survived compared with nonsurvivors. Hypotension, low cardiac index, arterial hemoglobin desaturation, low transcutaneous oxygen, high transcutaneous carbon dioxide tensions, low oxygen delivery, and low oxygen consumption developed intraoperatively gradually over time; the abnormalities were more pronounced in the nonsurvivors than in the survivors. CONCLUSIONS The survivors had slightly higher mean arterial pressure, cardiac index, and mixed venous oxygen saturation, as well as significantly higher oxygen delivery, oxygen consumption, transcutaneous oxygen tension, and transcutaneous oxygen tension/FIO2 ratios, than did the nonsurvivors. The data suggest that blood flow, oxygen delivery, and tissue oxygenation of the nonsurvivors became inadequate toward the end of the operation. Noninvasive monitoring provides similar information to that of the PAC; both approaches revealed low-flow and poor tissue perfusion that were worse in the nonsurvivors. The continuous on-line real-time displays of hemodynamic trends facilitate early recognition of acute circulatory dysfunction.

Continuous intraoperative noninvasive cardiac output monitoring using a new thoracic bioimpedance device

OBJECTIVES To compare a new noninvasive bioimpedance device with the standard thermodilution method during the intraoperative period in high-risk patients undergoing oncological surgery. DESIGN Prospectively collected data with retrospective analysis. SETTING The study was undertaken at a university hospital, single institution. PARTICIPANTS Twenty-three selected adults undergoing extensive, ablative oncological surgery. INTERVENTIONS Simultaneous measurements of cardiac output by a new bioimpedance method and the standard thermodilution method during the intraoperative and immediate postoperative periods. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS The correlation coefficient between the two methods was r = 0.89, p < 0.001. Bias and precision analysis between the two techniques showed a mean bias of 0.1 L/min and SD of the bias [precision] of 1.0 L/min [95% level of agreement +2.1 L/min to -1.9 L/min]. After software enhancement, data from the last 11 monitored patients showed improved correlation between the two methods; r = 0.93, mean bias -0.1 L/min, and precision 0.8 L/min. Electrical and motion-induced interference only transiently impaired the performance of the new impedance method. CONCLUSION This new impedance device is a safe, reliable, clinically acceptable alternative to the invasive thermodilution method in the operating room environment.

Invasive and noninvasive haemodynamic monitoring of acutely ill sepsis and septic shock patients in the emergency department.

&NA; The objective of this study was to describe early circulatory events of patients presenting to the emergency department (ED) with severe sepsis or septic shock. Invasive and noninvasive monitoring were used to evaluate sequential patterns of both central haemodynamics and peripheral tissue perfusion/oxygenation and to test the hypothesis that increased cardiac output is an early compensation to increased body metabolism. This is a prospective observational study of 45 patients who entered the ED with severe sepsis or septic shock in an urban academic ED. Invasive clinical monitoring was performed using a radial artery catheter and a thermodilution pulmonary artery catheter. Noninvasive monitoring consisted of an improved thoracic electrical bioimpedance device to estimate cardiac output; pulse oximetry for arterial saturation to reflect changes in pulmonary function, and transcutaneous oxygen (PtcO2) and carbon dioxide tensions (PtcCO2) as a reflection of tissue perfusion. Survivors had higher cardiac index, mean arterial pressure (MAP), and better tissue perfusion as measured by PtcO2. oxygen delivery, and oxygen consumption. Oxygen extraction ratio was higher in the nonsurvivors (p < 0.05) and there were episodes of high PtcCO2 values in the nonsurvivors. No significant differences were found in the heart rate. PAOP (wedge pressure) and SaO2 by pulse oximetry between the two groups. It is concluded that ED monitoring septic patients provides a unique opportunity to document early physiologic interactions, between cardiac. pulmonary, and tissue perfusion functions in surviving and nonsurviving patients with septic shock. The data is consistent with the concept that increased cardiac output is an earlty compensatory response to increased body metabolism Real time haemodvnamic monitoring of pattients in the ED provides early warning of outcome and may be used to guide therapy

Is noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring appropriate for the elderly critically injured patient

BACKGROUND Noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring in critically ill patients using bioimpedance technology has been shown to be a reliable alternative to invasive thermodilution techniques. However, there have been some concerns that the bioimpedance method may be unreliable in elderly patients with an atherosclerotic and rigid thoracic aorta. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the effect of age on the reliability of noninvasive bioimpedance technology in measuring cardiac index. METHODS This is a retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data in critically injured patients admitted to the surgical intensive care unit. All patients had simultaneous measurement using thermodilution cardiac index (TDCI) and bioimpedance cardiac index (BICI). The population was divided into three age groups (<55 years, 55-70 years, and >70 years). The correlation between TDCI and BICI was calculated for each age group. RESULTS There were 1,138 simultaneous measurements of TDCI and BICI in 285 patients. The BICI correlated well with TDCI in all three age groups (r = 0.82 for group <55 years, r = 0.87 for group 55-70 years, and r = 0.80 for group >70 years). CONCLUSION Noninvasive cardiac index monitoring in elderly patients is reliable and correlates well with standard thermodilution techniques.

Noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring for combat casualties

The aims of this study were to develop and to test a noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring system that could be applied to combat casualties to supplement conventional vital signs, to use an advanced information system to predict outcomes, and to evaluate the relative effectiveness of various therapies with instant feedback information during acute emergency conditions. In a university-run inner city public hospital, we evaluated 1,000 consecutively monitored trauma patients in the initial resuscitation period, beginning shortly after admission to the emergency department. In addition to conventional vital signs, we used noninvasive monitoring devices (cardiac index by bioimpedance with blood pressure and heart rate to measure cardiac function, arterial hemoglobin oxygen saturation by pulse oximetry to reflect changes in pulmonary function, and tissue oxygenation by transcutaneous oxygen tension indexed to fractional inspired oxygen concentration and carbon dioxide tension to evaluate tissue perfusion). The cardiac index, mean arterial pressure, pulse oximetry (arterial hemoglobin oxygen saturation), and transcutaneous oxygen tension/fractional inspired oxygen concentration were significantly higher in survivors, whereas the heart rate and carbon dioxide tension were higher in nonsurvivors. The calculated survival probability was a useful outcome predictor that also served as a measure of severity of illness. The rate of misclassification of survival probability was 13.5% in the series as a whole but only 6% for patients without severe head injuries and brain death. Application of noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring to acute emergency trauma patients in the emergency department is feasible, safe, and inexpensive and provides accurate hemodynamic patterns in continuous, on-line, real-time, graphical displays of the status of cardiac, pulmonary, and tissue perfusion functions. Combined with an information system, this approach provided an early outcome predictor and evaluated, with an objective individualized method, the relative efficacy of alternative therapies for specific patients.

Outcome prediction in chest injury by a mathematical search and display program.

OBJECTIVE This study applies a stochastic or probability search and display model to prospectively predict outcome and to evaluate therapeutic effects in a consecutively monitored series of 396 patients with severe thoracic and thoracoabdominal injuries. STUDY DESIGN Prospective observational study of outcome prediction using noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring by previously designed protocols and tested against actual outcome at hospital discharge in a level 1 trauma service of a university-run, inner-city public hospital. METHODS Cardiac index (CI), heart rate (HR), mean arterial pressure (MAP), arterial oxygen saturation measured by pulse oximetry (Sp(O2)), transcutaneous oxygen tension (PtC(O2)), and transcutaneous carbon dioxide tension (Ptc(CO2)) were monitored beginning shortly after admission to the emergency department. The stochastic search and display model with a decision support program based on noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring was applied to 396 severely ill patients with major thoracic and thoracoabdominal trauma. The survival probability (SP) was calculated during initial resuscitation continuously until patients were stabilized, and compared with the actual outcome when the patient was discharged from the hospital usually a week or more later. RESULTS The CI, Sp(O2), Ptc(O2), and MAP were appreciably higher in survivors than in nonsurvivors. HR and Ptc(CO2) were higher in the nonsurvivors. The calculated SP in the first 24-h observation period of survivors of chest wounds averaged 83 +/- 18% (+/- SD) and 62 +/- 19% for nonsurvivors. Misclassifications were 9.6%. The relative effects of alternative therapies were evaluated before and after therapy, using hemodynamic monitoring and SP as criteria. CONCLUSIONS Noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring with an information system provided a feasible approach to early outcome predictions and therapeutic decision support.

ROLE OF AUTONOMIC ACTIVITY IN THE HEMODYNAMIC PATTERN OF SEPTIC SHOCK

Methods: We noninvasively monitored concurrent autonomic and hemodynamic patterns in 208 consecutive severely ill septic and septic shock patients. Simultaneous respiratory rate (RR) variability and heart rate (HR) variability (HRV) spectral patterns were collected. We used two types of ANS monitoring: a) HRV without respiratory analysis, and b) HRV with respiratory analysis. The former calculates the SNS and PSNS, Low Frequency (LF) and High Frequency (HF) parameters, respectively, according to the standard spectral analysis of HRV methodology. The latter adds spectral analysis of RR variability to compute more sensitive SNS and PSNS measures (the Low Frequency areas (LFa) and Respiratory Frequency area (RFa), respectively) according to the MIT technique. Noninvasive hemodynamic monitoring included: a) cardiac index (CI) by bioimpedance, HR, and mean arterial pressure (MAP) to reflect cardiac function, b) pulse oximetry (SapO2) to reflect changes in pulmonary function, and c) transcutaneous oxygen (PtcO2) indexed to the FiO2 as a marker of tissue perfusion.