Claudine Theuring

Sites of synthesis, translocation and accumulation of pyrrolizidine alkaloid N-oxides in Senecio vulgaris L.

Abstract14C-Labelled alkaloid precursors (arginine, putrescine, spermidine) fed to Senecio vulgaris plants via the root system were rapidly taken up and efficiently incorporated into the pyrrolizidine alkaloid senecionine N-oxide (sen-Nox) with total incorporations of 3–6%. Considerable amounts of labelled sen-Nox were translocated into the shoot and were directed mainly into the inflorescences, the major sites of pyrrolizidine-alkaloid accumulation. Detached shoots of S. vulgaris were unable to synthesize pyrrolizidine alkaloids, indicating that the roots are the site of their biosynthesis. Further evidence was obtained from studies with in-vitro systems established from S. vulgaris: root cultures were found to synthesize pyrrolizidine alkaloids but not cell-suspension cultures, tumor cultures or shoot-like teratomas obtained by transformation with Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Studies on transport of [14C]sen-Nox, which was fed either to detached shoots or to the root system of intact plants, indicate that the alkaloid N-oxide does not simply follow the transpiration stream but is specifically channelled to the target tissues such as epidermal stem tissue and flower heads. Exogenously applied [14C]senecionine is rapidly N-oxidized. If the phloem path along the stem is blocked by a “steam girdle” translocation of labelled sen-Nox is blocked as well. Root-derived sen-Nox accumulated below the girdle and only trace amounts were found in the tissues above. It is most likely that the root-to-shoot transport of sen-Nox occurs mainly if not exclusively via the phloem. In accordance with previous studies the polar, salt-like N-oxides, which are often considered to be artifacts, were found to be the real products of pyrrolizidine-alkaloid biosynthesis as well as the physiological forms for long-distance transport, tissue-specific distribution and cellular accumulation.

Disentangling Food Quality from Resistance against Parasitoids: Diet Choice by a Generalist Caterpillar

The relative importance of food quality and enemy‐reduced space is a central but unresolved issue in the evolutionary ecology of host use by phytophagous insects. Indeed, a practical obstacle to experimentally disentangling the functional roles of these factors is the host specificity of insect herbivores, particularly toxic plant specialists. In this study, we employ a toxic plant generalist to uniquely disentangle these alternative explanations. We experimentally demonstrate that the value of enemy‐reduced space supersedes that of food quality in determining the diet and host preference of the polyphagous woolly bear caterpillar Grammia geneura (Lepidoptera: Arctiidae). Caterpillars sacrificed superior growth efficiency in choosing a mixed diet that included toxic host plants and provided resistance against parasitoids. The resistance of individual caterpillars was associated with the relative amount of defensive plants eaten as well as with the sequestration of pyrrolizidine alkaloids from one such plant (Senecio longilobus).

Acquired and Partially De Novo Synthesized Pyrrolizidine Alkaloids in Two Polyphagous Arctiids and the Alkaloid Profiles of Their Larval Food-Plants

The profiles of pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) in the two highly polyphagous arctiids Estigmene acrea and Grammia geneura and their potential PA sources in southeastern Arizona were compiled. One of four species of Boraginaceae, Plagiobothrys arizonicus, contained PAs; this is the first PA record for this plant species. The principle PA sources are Senecio longilobus (Asteraceae) and Crotalaria pumila (Fabaceae). The known PA pattern of S. longilobus was extended; the species was found to contain six closely related PAs of the senecionine type. Three novel PAs of the monocrotaline type, named pumilines A–C, were isolated and characterized from C. pumila, a species not studied before. The pumilines are the major PAs in the seeds, while in the vegetative organs they are accompanied by the simple necine derivatives supinidine and as the dominant compound subulacine (1β,2β-epoxytrachelanthamidine). In both plant species, the PAs are stored as N-oxides, except C. pumila seeds, which accumulate the free bases. Great variation in PA composition was observed between local populations of C. pumila. The PA profiles were established for larvae and adults of E. acrea that as larvae had fed on an artificial diet supplemented with crotalaria-powder and of G. geneura fed with S. longilobus. In both experiments, the larvae had a free choice between the respective PA source and diet or food plants free of PAs. The profiles compiled for the two species reflect the alkaloid profiles of their PA sources with one exception, subulacine could never be detected in E. acrea. Besides acquired PAs, insect PAs synthesized from acquired necine bases and necic acids of insect origin were detected in the two arctiid species. These insect PAs that do not occur in the larval food sources accounted for some 40–70% (E. acrea) and 17–37% (G. geneura) of total PAs extracted from the insects. A number of novel insect PAs were identified. Plant-acquired and insect PAs were found to accumulate as N-oxides. The results are discussed in relation to specific biochemical, electrophysiological, and behavioral mechanisms involved in PA sequestration by arctiids.

Selective sequestration and metabolism of plant derived pyrrolizidine alkaloids by chrysomelid leaf beetles

Pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) are assumed to function as plant defence compounds against herbivory. A number of adapted insects are known to sequester plant derived PAs for their own benefit. Here we summarize the chemical interactions between leaf beetles of the genus Oreina (Coleoptera, Chrysomelidae) and their host plants Adenostyles spp., Senecio nemorensis, and S. fuchsii (Asteraceae, tribe Senecioneae). Seneciphylline N-oxide and senecionine N-oxide, the main PAs of Adenostyles, are sequestered in the bodies and exocrine defensive glands of the leaf beetles. The comparison with the PA patterns of the Senecio host plant indicates a selective PA uptake. The uptake into the body (hemolymph) is less specific, whereas the translocation into the defensive glands is highly specific. Only the N-oxides of macrocyclic retronecine esters of the senecionine type are found in significant amounts in the defensive secretions. Many other PAs such as monoesters and open-chain diesters as well as PAs of other structural types (e.g. monocrotaline N-oxide and senkirkine) are not transferred into the defensive glands. Leaf beetles sequester PAs exclusively as N-oxides. A novel PA not found in the food plants was detected in the defensive secretions of Oreina elongata; it was identified as 13,19-expoxisenecionine N-oxide (oreine), the epoxidation product of seneciphylline N-oxide. Besides this transformation, leaf beetles are able to catalyse further transformations such as the O-dealkylation of heliotrine N-oxide to rinderine N-oxide and the O-deacetylation of acetylseneciphylline N-oxide to seneciphylline N-oxide. The plant-beetle interactions are discussed in the functional context of PAs as powerful plant defensive chemicals.

Pyrrolizidine alkaloids in pollen and pollen products.

Recently, 1,2-dehydropyrrolizidine alkaloid (PA) ester alkaloids, found predominantly as their N-oxides (PANOs, pyrrolizidine N-oxides), have been reported in both honey and in pollen obtained directly from PA plants and pollen loads collected by bees, raising the possibility of health risks for consumers of these products. We confirm these findings in regard to floral pollen, using pollen collected directly from flowers of the known PA plants Senecio jacobaea, S. vernalis, Echium vulgare and pollinia of Phalaenopsis hybrids, and we extend analyses of 1,2-unsaturated PAs and 1,2-unsaturated PANOs to include bee-pollen products currently being sold in supermarkets and on the Internet as food supplements. PA content of floral pollen ranged from 0.5 to 5 mg/g. The highest values were observed in pollen obtained from Senecio species. Up to 95% of the PAs are found as PANOs. Detailed studies with S. vernalis revealed unique PA patterns in pollen and flowers. While seneciphylline was the most prominent PA in S. vernalis pollen, the flowers were dominated by senecionine. To analyze trace amounts of 1,2-unsaturated PAs in pollen products, our previously elaborated method consisting of strong cation exchange-SPE, two reduction steps followed by silylation and subsequent capillary high-resolution GC-MS using SIM mode was applied. In total, 55 commercially available pollen products were analyzed. Seventeen (31%) samples contained 1,2-unsaturated PAs in the range from 1.08 to 16.35 microg/g, calculated as retronecine equivalents. The 1,2-unsaturated PA content of pollen products is expressed in terms of a single sum parameter and no background information such as foraged plants, pollen analysis, etc. was needed to analyze the samples. The detection limit of overall procedure and the reliable quantitation limit were 0.003 and 0.01 microg/g, respectively.

Sequestration, metabolism and partial synthesis of tertiary pyrrolizidine alkaloids by the neotropical leaf-beetle Platyphora boucardi

Platyphora boucardi leaf-beetles sequester tertiary pyrrolizidine alkaloids of the lycopsamine type acquired from their host-plant Prestonia portobellensis (Apocynaceae) and synthesize their own alkaloids from exogenous retronecine and aliphatic 2-hydroxy acids. Tracer studies with [14C]rinderine and its N-oxide revealed that P. boucardi sequesters both alkaloidal forms with the same efficiency, but accumulates exclusively tertiary alkaloids. There is no substantial alkaloid accumulation in the body outside the defensive glands. Feeding studies with [2H][14C]rinderine confirmed that P. boucardi specifically epimerizes rinderine to its stereoisomers intermedine and lycopsamine. Feeding studies with [2H][14C]retronecine proved the ability of P. boucardi to synthesize O7- and O9-(2-hydroxyisovaleryl)-retronecine and O7-lactyl-O9-(2-hydroxyisovaleryl)-retronecine. Both, alkaloids of the lycopsamine type and self-synthesized retronecine esters accumulate in the defensive secretions at concentrations up to 38 mM and 33 mM, respectively. The different biochemical strategies to maintain pro-toxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids and to prevent self-poisoning, developed by specialized insects, are compared. There are two major findings: (1) the chemical defense mediated by plant acquired pyrrolizidine alkaloids in the taxonomically related palaearctic Oreina and neotropical Platyphora leaf beetles have been evolved independently, since the biochemical mechanisms of storing and maintaining the alkaloids is completely different in the two genera; (2) unexpected parallels exist between taxonomically unrelated Coleoptera and Lepidoptera in their ability to synthesize the same retronecine esters and to catalyze the same site-specific epimerizations of the lycopsamine stereoisomers.

Pyrrolizidine alkaloids and pentacyclic triterpene saponins in the defensive secretions of Platyphora leaf beetles

Summary. Field collected exocrine defensive secretions of nine neotropical Platyphora species were analyzed for the presence of plant acquired pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) and pentacyclic triterpene saponins. All species secrete saponins. In addition, five species feeding on Tournefortia (Boraginaceae), Koanophyllon (Asteraceae, tribe Eupatorieae) and Prestonia (Apocynaceae) were shown to sequester PAs of the lycopsamine type, which are characteristic for species of the three plant families. The PA sequestering species commonly store intermedine, lycopsamine and their O3′-acetyl or propionyl esters as well as O7- and O9-hydroxyisovaleryl esters of retronecine. The latter as well as the O3′-acyl esters were not found in the beetles’ host plants, suggesting the ability of the beetles to esterify plant derived retronecine and intermedine or its stereoisomers. Despite the conformity of the beetles’ PA patterns, considerable inconsistencies exist regarding the PA patterns of the respective host plants. One host plant was devoid of PAs, while another contained only simple necines. Since the previous history of the field collected beetles was unknown this discrepancy remains obscure. In contrast to the Palearctic chrysomeline leaf beetles, e.g. some Oreina species which ingest and store PAs as their non-toxic N-oxides, Platyphora leaf beetles absorb and store PAs as the toxic free base (tertiary PA), but apparently avoid to accumulate PAs in the haemolymph. This suggests that Chrysolina and Platyphora leaf beetles developed different lines of adaptations in their parallel evolution of PA mediated chemical defense.

Sequestration and Metabolism of Protoxic Pyrrolizidine Alkaloids by Larvae of the Leaf Beetle Platyphora boucardi and Their Transfer via Pupae into Defensive Secretions of Adults

Several neotropical leaf-beetles of the genus Platyphora ingest and specifically metabolize plant acquired pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) of the lycopsamine type (e.g., rinderine or intermedine) and enrich the processed alkaloids in their exocrine defensive secretions. In contrast to the related palaearctic leaf beetles of the genus Oreina, which absorb and store only the non-toxic alkaloid N-oxides, Platyphora sequesters PAs exclusively as protoxic tertiary amines. In this study, the ability of P. boucardi larvae to accumulate PAs was investigated. Tracer studies with [14C]rinderine and its N-oxide revealed that P. boucardi larvae, like adult beetles, utilize the two alkaloidal forms with the same efficiency, but accumulate the alkaloid as a tertiary amine exclusively. Ingested rinderine is rapidly epimerized to intermedine, which is localized in the hemolymph and all other tissues; it is also detected on the larval surface. Like adults, larvae are able to synthesize their own alkaloid esters (beetle PAs) from orally administered [14C]retronecine and endogenous aliphatic 2-hydroxy acids. These retronecine esters show the same tissue distribution as intermedine. A long-term feeding experiment lasting for almost four months revealed that retronecine esters synthesized from [14C]retronecine in the larvae are transferred from larvae via pupae into the exocrine glands of adult beetles. Pupae contain ca. 45% of the labeled retronecine originally ingested, metabolized, and stored by larvae; ca. 12% of larval radioactivity could be recovered from the defensive secretions of adults sampled successively over two and a half months. Almost all of this radioactivity is found in the insect-made retronecine esters that are highly enriched in the defensive secretions, i.e., more than 200-fold higher concentration compared to pupae.

Are Insect-Synthesized Retronecine Esters (Creatonotines) the Precursors of the Male Courtship Pheromone in the Arctiid Moth Estigmene acrea?

The pyrrolizidine alkaloid (PA) profiles were determined for adults of the polyphagous arctiid Estigmene acrea, which as larvae had fed on artificial diet supplemented with Crotalaria-pumila powder with known concentrations of PAs. The larvae always had a free choice between alkaloid-containing and plain diets. The alkaloid profiles of adults revealed a striking sexual dimorphism. Both sexes contained macrocyclic PAs of the monocrotaline type sequestered from the diet and, in addition, a substantial proportion of supinidine and retronecine esters synthesized by the insects from necine bases derived from the dietary alkaloids and necic acids of insect origin. These insect alkaloids accounted for 35% and 55% of total PAs in males and females, respectively. The difference was that in females the retronecine esters (creatonotines) made up 58 μg (43% of total PAs), while males contained a fivefold lower proportion, 12 μg (13%). Four of the ten male individuals analyzed were found devoid of creatonotines. Based on the experimental data in combination with evidence from the literature, it is suggested that the creatonotines are direct pheromone precursors in E. acrea. It is hypothesized that this may represent a general mechanism of hydroxydanaidal formation from diverse macrocyclic PAs in arctiids.

Phenological fate of plant-acquired pyrrolizidine alkaloids in the polyphagous arctiid Estigmene acrea

Summary. The alkaloid profiles of the life history stages of the highly polyphagous arctiid Estigmene acrea were established. As larvae individuals had free choice between a plain diet (alkaloid-free) and a diet that was supplemented with Crotalaria-pumila powder with a known content and composition of pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs). Idiosyncratic retronecine esters (insect PAs) accounted for approximately half of the PAs recovered from the larvae. These alkaloids were synthesized by the larvae through esterification of dietary supinidine yielding the estigmines, and esterification of retronecine yielding the creatonotines. The retronecine is derived from insect-mediated degradation of the sequestered pumilines (macrocyclic PAs of the monocrotaline type). With one exception, the PA profiles established for larvae were found almost unaltered in all life-stages as well as larval exuviae and pupal cocoons. The exception is the males, which in comparison to pupae and adult females, showed a significantly decreased quantity of the creatonotines and pumilines. These data support the idea that the creatonotines are direct precursors of the PA-derived male courtship pheromone, hydroxydanaidal. Crosses of PA-free males with PA-containing females and vice versa confirmed an efficient trans-mission of PAs from males to females and then from females to eggs. In single cases a male bestowed almost his total PA load to the female, and a female her total load to the eggs. The results are discussed with respect to pheromone formation, PA transmission between life-stages, and the defensive role of PAs against predators and parasitoids