Crystal L. MacLellan

Delayed Onset of Prolonged Hypothermia Improves Outcome After Intracerebral Hemorrhage in Rats

Prolonged hypothermia reduces ischemic brain injury, but its efficacy after intracerebral hemorrhagic (ICH) stroke is unresolved. Rats were implanted with core temperature telemetry probes and subsequently subjected to an ICH, which was produced by infusing bacterial collagenase into the striatum. Animals were kept normothermic (NORMO), or were made mildly hypothermic (33–35°C) for over 2 days starting 1 hour (HYP-1), 6 hours (HYP-6), or 12 hours (HYP-12) after collagenase infusion. Others were cooled for 7 hours beginning 1 hour after infusion (BRIEF). Skilled reaching, walking, and spontaneous forelimb use were assessed. Normothermic ICH rats sustained, on average, a 36.9-mm3 loss of tissue at 1 month. Only the HYP-12 group had a significantly smaller lesion (25.5 mm3). Some functional improvements were found with this and other hypothermia treatments. Cerebral edema was observed in NORMO rats, and was not lessened significantly by hypothermia (HYP-12). Blood pressure measurements, as determined by telemetry, in BRIEF rats showed that hypothermia increased blood pressure. This BRIEF treatment also resulted in significantly more bleeding at 12 hours after ICH (79.2 μL) versus NORMO-treated rats (58.4 μL) as determined by a spectrophotometric hemoglobin assay. Accordingly, these findings suggest that early hypothermia may fail to lessen lesion size owing to complications, such as elevated blood pressure, whereas much-delayed hypothermia is beneficial after ICH. Future experiments should assess whether counteracting the side effects of early hypothermia enhances protection.

Gauging recovery after hemorrhagic stroke in rats: implications for cytoprotection studies

Successful clinical translation of prospective cytoprotectants will likely occur only with treatments that improve functional recovery in preclinical (rodent) studies. Despite this assumption, many rely solely on histopathologic end points or the use of one or two simple behavioral tests. Presently, we used a battery of tests to gauge recovery after a unilateral intracerebral hemorrhagic stroke (ICH) targeting the striatum. In total, 60 rats (N = 15 per group) were stereotaxically infused with 0 (SHAM), 0.06 (MILD lesion), 0.12 (MODERATE lesion), or 0.18 U (SEVERE lesion) of bacterial collagenase. This created a range of injury akin to moderate (from SEVERE to MODERATE or MODERATE to MILD lesion size ∼30% reduction) and substantial cytoprotection (SEVERE to MILD lesion size—51% reduction). Post-ICH functional testing occurred over 30 days. Tests included the horizontal ladder and elevated beam tests, swimming, limb-use asymmetry (cylinder) test, a Neurologic Deficit Scale, an adhesive tape removal test of sensory neglect, and the staircase and single pellet tests of skilled reaching. Most tests detected significant impairments (versus SHAM), but only a few (e.g., staircase) frequently distinguished among ICH groups and none consistently differentiated among all ICH groups. However, by using a battery of tests we could behaviorally distinguish groups. Thus, preclinical testing would benefit from using a battery of behavioral tests as anything less may miss treatment effects. Such testing must be based on factors including the type of lesion, the postoperative delay and the time required to complete testing.

The Influence of Hypothermia on Outcome After Intracerebral Hemorrhage in Rats

Background and Purpose— Late hypothermia (HYPO) reduces injury after collagenase-induced intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH), whereas early HYPO does not because it exacerbates the protracted bleeding that occurs in this model. We hypothesized that early HYPO would not increase bleeding after whole blood infusion and thus expected early HYPO to improve outcome through reducing secondary consequences of ICH (eg, inflammation). Methods— Autologous blood (100 &mgr;L) was infused into the striatum. Rats were maintained at normothermia or subjected to mild (33°C to 35°C) HYPO for 2 days starting 1 (HYPO-1) or 4 hours (HYPO-4) after ICH. Hematoma volume was measured at 12 hours to determine whether HYPO-1 aggravated bleeding. We measured blood–brain barrier (BBB) disruption and edema 2 days after ICH in all groups. At 4 days, we counted degenerating neurons, neutrophils, and iron-positive cells (eg, macrophages) in the lesioned hemisphere. Recovery was assessed using several behavioral tests (ie, staircase reaching task, ladder walking task, limb use cylinder test) over 7 or 30 days, at which time we quantified lesion volume. Results— HYPO did not increase bleeding. Both HYPO treatments reduced BBB disruption and infiltration of inflammatory cells. HYPO-1 treatment modestly reduced edema and provided limited to no functional benefit in the behavioral tests. HYPO did not affect lesion volume. Conclusions— HYPO reduced edema, BBB disruption, and inflammation. Although encouraging, HYPO treatment must be improved so that histological and functional benefit are obtained before clinical investigation. Otherwise clinical failure is anticipated.

A critical threshold of rehabilitation involving brain-derived neurotrophic factor is required for poststroke recovery.

Background. Enriched rehabilitation (ER; environmental enrichment plus skilled reaching) improves recovery after middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAo) in rats. Fundamental issues such as whether ER is effective in other models, optimal rehabilitation intensity, and underlying recovery mechanisms have not been fully assessed. Objective. The authors tested whether the efficacy of ER varies with ischemia model and assessed the importance of rehabilitation intensity and brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) in recovery. Methods. Rats in experiment 1 received 8 weeks of ER or remained in standard housing. Functional outcome was assessed with the staircase and cylinder tasks. Surprisingly, ER provided no functional benefit in any model. In this experiment, ER was delivered during the light phase, whereas other studies delivered ER in the dark phase of the light cycle. It was hypothesized that in the light, rats engaged in less rehabilitation or alternatively that BDNF was lower. Experiment 2 tested these hypotheses. Following MCAo, rats received ER in either the light or dark phase of the light cycle. Functional outcome was assessed and BDNF levels were measured in the motor cortex and hippocampus. Results. Recovery was accompanied by increased BDNF. This occurred only in rats that received ER in the dark and these animals reached more than those in the light condition. Conclusions. Data suggest that there is a critical threshold of rehabilitation, below which recovery will not occur, and that BDNF mediates functional recovery. The use of intensive rehabilitation therapies for stroke patients is strongly supported.

Rodent Models of Intracerebral Hemorrhage

The collagenase and whole blood intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) models are widely used to identify mechanisms of injury and to evaluate treatments. Despite preclinical successes, to date, no treatment tested in phase III clinical trials has benefited ICH patients. These failures call into question the predictive value of current ICH models. By highlighting differences between these common rodent models of ICH, we sought to help investigators choose the more appropriate model for their study and to encourage the use of both whenever possible. For instance, we previously reported substantial differences in the bleeding profile, progression of cell death, and functional outcome between these models. These and other differences influence the efficacy and mechanisms of action of various treatment modalities. Thus, in this review, we also summarize neuroprotective and rehabilitation findings in each model. We conclude that differences between ICH models along with our current inability to identify the more clinically predictive model necessitate that preclinical assessments should normally be done in both. Such an approach, coupled with better assessment practices, will likely improve chances of future clinical success.

Skilled reaching impairments follow intrastriatal hemorrhagic stroke in rats

The infusion of autologous blood into the brain of rats is a widely used model of intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH). Careful assessment of functional recovery is an essential part of preclinical testing (e.g., putative cytoprotectants). However, few tests detect long-term deficits in this model. In this study, we used the staircase and single pellet tests to characterize skilled reaching ability after striatal ICH. Rats were trained to reach for food pellets in these tasks before ICH, which was created by infusing 100muL of autologous blood into the striatum. We assessed reaching success in both tasks for 5 days starting 7 and 28 days after ICH. We counted the number of reaching attempts made with each forelimb in the staircase task and performed kinematic analysis of reaching in the single pellet task. The contralateral (to lesion) forelimb reaching success was significantly impaired in the staircase task 1 week after ICH, but this recovered to pre-surgical levels thereafter. Reaching deficits in the single pellet task were more severe and persistent. Detailed analysis of reaches on day 11 revealed several abnormalities in the following movement components: pronation, grasping, supinating the paw and releasing the pellet. At 1 month, only digit opening and supination were impaired. Accordingly, the single pellet task is better at detecting long-term skilled reaching impairments in the whole blood model of ICH. Thus, the single pellet task seems suited to cytoprotection and rehabilitation studies.

A critical appraisal of experimental intracerebral hemorrhage research

The likelihood of translating therapeutic interventions for stroke rests on the quality of preclinical science. Given the limited success of putative treatments for ischemic stroke and the reasons put forth to explain it, we sought to determine whether such problems hamper progress for intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH). Approximately 10% to 20% of strokes result from an ICH, which results in considerable disability and high mortality. Several animal models reproduce ICH and its underlying pathophysiology, and these models have been widely used to evaluate treatments. As yet, however, none has successfully translated. In this review, we focus on rodent models of ICH, highlighting differences among them (e.g., pathophysiology), issues with experimental design and analysis, and choice of end points. A Pub Med search for experimental ICH (years: 2007 to 31 July 2011) found 121 papers. Of these, 84% tested neuroprotectants, 11% tested stem cell therapies, and 5% tested rehabilitation therapies. We reviewed these to examine study quality (e.g., use of blinding procedures) and choice of end points (e.g., behavioral testing). Not surprisingly, the problems that have plagued the ischemia field are also prevalent in ICH literature. Based on these data, several recommendations are put forth to facilitate progress in identifying effective treatments for ICH.

Incomplete assessment of experimental cytoprotectants in rodent ischemia studies.

BACKGROUND Inadequate preclinical testing (e.g., rodent studies) has been partly blamed for the failure of many cytoprotectants to effectively treat stroke in humans. For example, some drugs went to clinical trial without rigorous functional and histological assessment over long survival times. In this study, we characterized recent experimental practices in rodent cytoprotection experiments to determine whether the limitations of early studies have been rectified. METHODS We identified 138 rodent cytoprotection studies published in several leading journals (Journal of Neuroscience, Stroke, Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism and Experimental Neurology) for 2000-2002 and compared these to those published in 1990. From each study we determined the ischemia model, age and sex of the animal, the histological and functional endpoints used, and the methodology used to assess intra- and postischemic temperature. RESULTS Ninety-eight percent of recent studies used young adult rodents and most used males. Most studies (60%) did not assess functional outcome and survival times were often < or = 48 hr (66%) for focal ischemia and < or = 7 days (80%) for global ischemia. Over 60% of the experiments relied solely upon rectal temperature during ischemia and only 32.6% of ischemia studies measured temperature after surgery. The 1990 data were similar. CONCLUSIONS Many investigators ignore the need to assess long-term functional and histological outcome and do not accurately represent clinical conditions of ischemia (e.g., use of aged animals). In addition, intra- and postischemic temperature measurement and control is frequently neglected or inadequately performed. Further clinical failures are likely.

Combined use of a cytoprotectant and rehabilitation therapy after severe intracerebral hemorrhage in rats

After moderate intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH), both hypothermia (HYPO) and constraint-induced movement therapy (CIMT) improve recovery and reduce the volume of brain injury. We tested the hypothesis that more severe ICH requires both cytoprotection and rehabilitation to significantly improve recovery. Rats were subjected to a unilateral striatal ICH via collagenase infusion. Rats remained normothermic or were subjected to mild HYPO ( approximately 2 days) starting 12 h later. Fourteen days after ICH, half of the rats received CIMT (7 days of restraint of the less affected limb plus daily exercises); the remainder were untreated. Walking, limb use and skilled reaching were assessed up to 60 days, at which time animals were euthanized and the volume of tissue lost was determined. The HYPO treatment alone did not improve outcome, whereas CIMT alone provided significant benefit on the limb use asymmetry test. In the staircase test, the greatest benefit was achieved with the combination of HYPO and CIMT treatments. The volume of tissue lost after ICH was similar among groups arguing against cytoprotection as a mechanism of functional recovery. Finally, these findings suggest that, at least under the present circumstances (e.g., severe striatal ICH), CIMT provides superior benefit to HYPO and that combination therapy will sometimes further improve recovery.

Failure of delayed and prolonged hypothermia to favorably affect hemorrhagic stroke in rats

Prolonged hypothermia reduces global and focal cerebral ischemic injury in rodents even when delayed for hours. However, it is not known whether hypothermia can reduce injury following intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH). Accordingly, we studied striatal injury and concomitant motor deficits after 2 days of hypothermia, induced 1 h after creation of an ICH by infusion of bacterial collagenase. Rats were first trained to retrieve food pellets in the Montoya staircase task. They were then implanted with core temperature telemetry probes and later subjected to normothermic ICH or sham operation (vehicle injection). Half self-regulated temperature after surgery; others were cooled to 33 degrees C (24 h) and then 35 degrees C (24 h). Hypothermia did not affect behavioral scores of sham animals (89.8% of baseline in staircase test) or histology. Untreated (normothermic) ICH rats lost 23.1 mm(3) of tissue at a 1-month survival, which significantly impaired food pellet retrieval (66.0% retrieval) with the contralateral limb (tested on days 21-25). Contrary to our hypothesis, hypothermia failed to lessen either the reaching impairment (62.8%) or the lesion (22.2 mm(3)). While other hemorrhagic insults or complications may be improved with hypothermia, our data suggest that it will not salvage tissue that is quickly lost after ICH. We also assessed walking across a horizontal ladder and spontaneous paw usage in a cylinder test at 1-4 weeks after ICH, but neither test was sufficiently sensitive to this mild insult. This indicates that skilled reaching is more severely disrupted than spontaneous paw usage or walking after a striatal hemorrhage.