Dale R. Sumner

Dynamic knee loads during gait predict proximal tibial bone distribution.

This study tested the validity of the prediction of dynamic knee loads based on gait measurements. The relationship between the predicted loads at the knee and the distribution of bone between the medial and lateral sides of the tibia was examined. The motion and external forces and moments at the knee were measured during gait and a statically determinate muscle model was used to predict the corresponding forces on the medial and lateral tibial plateaus. In particular, the relationship between the knee adduction moment during gait and the ratio or distribution of medial to lateral tibial bone mineral content was studied. Bone mineral content was measured with dual energy X-ray absorptiometry in four regions, two proximal regions 20 mm in height, one medial and one lateral and two distal regions 20 mm in height, one medial and one lateral. The best single predictor of the medial lateral ratio of proximal bone mineral content (bone distribution) was the adduction moment (R2=0.31, p=0.003). Adding weight (negative coefficient. p=0.0004) and the ratio of the average predicted peak force on the medial plateau to the predicted peak force on the lateral plateau (positive coefficient, p=0.0033) to the regression model significantly increased the ability to predict the proximal medial lateral bone distribution (R2=0.72, p=0.0001). Distally neither the subject characteristics nor the gait moments and predicted forces were significant predictors of the bone distribution. The lack of a correlation distally may be reflective of the forces being more evenly distributed further from the tibial plateau. While it has long been suggested that the adduction moment is the primary determinate of the distribution of load between the medial and lateral plateaus, this is the first evidence of its relationship to the underlying bone distribution.

Enhancement of bone ingrowth by transforming growth factor-beta.

Enhancement of bone ingrowth with transforming growth factor-beta was evaluated in a canine model. Ten dogs had bilateral implantation of a titanium-fiber-metal-coated rod in the proximal part of the humerus. A three-millimeter gap between the outer surface of the porous coating and the surrounding cancellous bone was created to impair bone ingrowth. All of the implants were plasma-flame-sprayed with hydroxyapatite and tricalcium phosphate. In each animal, one implant was also treated with recombinant transforming growth factor-beta 1 while the other implant, which was not so treated, served as a paired control. Two doses of transforming growth factor-beta 1 were used: 335 micrograms in five animals and 120 micrograms in the other five. At four weeks, the amount of bone ingrowth in the implants that had been treated with 120 micrograms of transforming growth factor-beta 1 was threefold higher than that in the paired controls (p = 0.009), but with the numbers available there was no significant increase in bone ingrowth with the higher dose. The amount of new-bone formation in the three-millimeter gaps adjacent to the treated implants was twice that in the gaps of the paired controls, regardless of the dose. The differences between the treated and control implants with regard to the architecture of the new bone in the gap indicate that the mechanism of action of transforming growth factor-beta 1 may include both proliferation of osteoprogenitor cells and production of matrix by committed osteoblasts. Compared with the findings in a previous study in which this canine model was used, the data from the present investigation indicate that enhancement of bone ingrowth in implants that have been treated with a combination of a hydroxyapatite-tricalcium phosphate coating and transforming growth factor-beta 1 may exceed that obtainable with grafting of the gap with autogenous cancellous bone.

Normalization of joint moments during gait: a comparison of two techniques

Joint moments are commonly used to characterize gait. Factors like height and weight influence these moments. This study determined which of two commonly used normalization methods, body mass or body weight times height, most reduced the effects of height and weight on peak hip, knee, and ankle external moments during walking. The effectiveness of each normalization method in reducing gender differences was then tested. Gait data from 158 normal subjects were analyzed using unnormalized values, body mass normalized values, and body weight times height normalized values. Without normalization, height or weight accounted for 7-82% of the variance in all 10 peak components of the moments. With normalization, height and weight accounted for at most 6% of the variance with the exception of the hip adduction moment normalized by body weight times height and the ankle dorsiflexion moment normalized by body mass. For the hip adduction moment normalized by body weight times height, height still accounted for 13% of the variance (p<0.001) and for the ankle dorsiflexion moment normalized by body mass, 22% of the variance (p<0.001). After normalization, significant differences between males and females remained for only two out of 10 moments with the body weight times height method compared to six out of 10 moments with the body mass method. When compared to the unnormalized data, both normalization methods were highly effective in reducing height and weight differences. Even for the two cases where one normalization method was less effective than the other (hip adduction-body weight times height; ankle dorsiflexion-body mass) the normalization process reduced the variance ascribed to height or weight by 48% and 63%, respectively, as compared to the unnormalized data.

Determinants of stress shielding : design versus materials versus interface

Experimental studies of cementless porous-coated total hip arthroplasty indicate that a critical design variable for femoral remodeling is stem stiffness. In the long term (two years) in the canine model, other variables, including the presence, type, and placement of the porous coating, did not significantly affect the pattern of bone remodeling when tested with metallic stems. The basic pattern of bone remodeling was characterized by proximal cortical atrophy, and distal cortical and medullary bone hypertrophy. In the short term (six months), the use of low-stiffness stems altered this pattern, leading to reduced proximal bone loss, increased proximal medullary bone hypertrophy, and no distal cortical hypertrophy, suggesting that stem stiffness had a profound effect on stress shielding.

Functional adaptation and ingrowth of bone vary as a function of hip implant stiffness

The purpose of the present study was to test the hypothesis that cortical bone loss, trabecular bone density and the amount of bone ingrowth vary as a function of stem stiffness in a canine cementless hip replacement model. The study was motivated by the problem of cortical bone atrophy in the proximal femur following cementless total hip replacement. Two stem stiffnesses were used and both designs were identical in external geometry and porous coating placement. The high stiffness stem caused approximately 26% cortical bone stress-shielding and the low stiffness stem caused approximately 7.5% stress-shielding, as assessed by beam theory. Each group included nine adult, male canines who received unilateral arthroplasties for a period of six months. The animals with the low stiffness stems tended to lose less proximal cortical bone than the animals with high stiffness stems (4% +/- 9 as opposed to 11% +/- 14), but the difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.251). However, the patterns of bone ingrowth into the implant and change in medullary bone density adjacent to the implant were fundamentally different as a function of stem stiffness (p < 0.01). Most importantly, while the high stiffness group had peaks in these variables at the distal end of the stem, the low stiffness group had peak values proximally. These different patterns of functional adaptation are consistent with the idea that reduced stem stiffness enhances proximal load transfer.

A decreased subchondral trabecular bone tissue elastic modulus is associated with pre-arthritic cartilage damage

In osteoarthritis, one postulate is that changes in the mechanical properties of the subchondral bone layer result in cartilage damage. The goal of this study was to examine changes in subchondral trabecular bone properties at the calcified tissue level in the early stages of cartilage damage. Finite element models were constructed from microCT scans of trabecular bone from the proximal tibia of donors with mild cartilage damage and from normal donors. In the donors with cartilage damage, macroscopic damage was present only in the medial compartment. The effective tissue elastic moduli were determined using a combination of finite element models and mechanical testing. The bone tissue modulus was reduced by 60% in the medial condyle of the cases with cartilage damage compared to the control specimens. Neither the presence of cartilage damage nor the anatomic site (medial vs. lateral) affected the elastic modulus at the apparent level. The volume fraction of trabecular bone was higher in the medial compartment compared to the lateral compartment of tibiae with cartilage damage (but not the controls), suggesting that mechanical properties were preserved in part at the apparent level by an increase in the bone volume fraction. It seems likely that the normal equilibrium between cartilage properties, bone tissue properties and bone volume fraction is disrupted early in the development of osteoarthritis.

A comparative study of porous coatings in a weight-bearing total hip-arthroplasty model.

The purposes of this study were to compare ingrowth of bone into three types of porous coating and to determine the effect of the type of porous coating and the degree of coverage of the stem on the remodeling of bone on the femoral side in cementless hip arthroplasty. A left total hip arthroplasty was performed in forty dogs. Thirty of the dogs had a titanium-alloy femoral prosthesis that had had one of three types of commercially pure titanium porous material applied along the length of the anterior and posterior surfaces of the stem: ten with sintered fiber-metal, ten with sintered beads, and ten with plasma flame-spray coating. The remaining ten dogs had a femoral component that was circumferentially coated with commercially pure titanium that was plasma flame-sprayed along the length of the stem. In each group, five animals were killed at one month and five were killed at six months. Ingrowth of bone into all three types of porous coating was observed, indicating secure fixation of all components. By six months, there was more ingrowth of bone and new medullary bone adjacent to the proximal and distal aspects of the stems compared with the middle level of the stems in all groups. No significant difference in ingrowth of bone was observed in the beaded surface (25.2 per cent) and the fiber-metal surface (16.6 per cent) at one month, but at six months there was significantly less ingrowth into the beaded surface (23.3 per cent) than into the fiber-metal surface (37.3 per cent). In all groups, a proximal-to-distal gradient of loss of cortical bone was observed by six months. The group of dogs that had the stem with the circumferential coating experienced more severe loss of bone than did the three groups that had a stem with a partial coating. The magnitude of loss of bone was dependent on the extent rather than the type of porous coating.

Revision of the acetabular component without cement after total hip arthroplasty. Three to six-year follow-up.

One hundred and thirty-eight consecutive revisions of an acetabular component were performed in 132 patients between 1983 and 1986. The revision prosthesis was a hemispherical component that was coated with porous titanium mesh and was secured to the pelvis with a variable number of screws. There were seventy-five women and fifty-seven men, and the mean age at the time of the revision was fifty-two years (range, twenty to seventy-nine years). Due to defects in the acetabulum, 80 per cent of the hips were treated with bone grafts, usually a mixture of local autogenous graft and freeze-dried allograft. One hundred and twenty-four patients (129 hips) were available for follow-up, at a mean of forty-four months (range, thirty-six to eighty months). Seven hips (5 per cent) were revised again: four because of infection and three because of instability. There were no revisions for loosening without infection, and none of the components migrated in the absence of infection. Radiolucent lines were common and usually corresponded to regions in which allograft had been used. All bone grafts united by twelve months. Non-contained medial grafts underwent a phenomenon of resorption, consolidation, and remodeling to a sclerotic rim by twenty-four months. There were no complications related to placement of the screws. The results in this series were superior to results of revisions of acetabular components with the use of cement, which were associated with rates of failure of almost 10 per cent after a similar duration of follow-up. The technique of maximization of host-bone coverage and of packing of all defects with cancellous autogenous graft or allograft, or both, was successful for all classes of acetabular deficiencies.

A quantitative study of bone and soft tissues in cementless porous-coated acetabular components retrieved at autopsy

The authors examined 11 cementless acetabular components of one design retrieved at autopsy and made observations concerning tissue ingrowth and local tissue reaction, radiographic-histologic correlation, and the distribution of particulate wear debris. The cups were hemispherical in design with a commercially pure titanium fiber-metal porous coating. All of the prostheses were implanted with screws. The implants were in place for an average of 41 months (range, 5 weeks to 75 months). Ten of the cups had bone ingrowth, with the average volume fraction being 12.1 +/- 8.2%. There were no differences in the amount of bone ingrowth when the component was partitioned into nine anatomic regions. However, there was more bone adjacent to screw holes through which screws were inserted compared with empty screw holes. As the number of radiolucent zones increased on the clinical radiographs less bone ingrowth was observed histologically. The amount of metal debris in holes with screws and holes without screws was similar. In the longest term cases, polyethylene debris was noted within empty screw holes, but no granulomatous reactions or osteolytic processes were observed.

Epidemiology Introduction: 1995 Focus Issue Meeting on Fusion

Jeffrey N. Katz, Kevin F. Spratt, Gunnar B. J. Andersson, Scott D. Boden, Robert D. Fraser, Scott R. Garfin, Vijay K. Goel, Edward N. Hanley Jr., Malcolm H. Pope, Volker K. H. Sonntag, Dale R. Sumner and Thomas A. Zdeblick