Daniel M. Vernon

Arabidopsis emb175 and other ppr knockout mutants reveal essential roles for pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins in plant embryogenesis

Pentatricopeptide repeat proteins (PPRPs) constitute one of the largest superfamilies in plants, with more than 440 identified in the Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh genome. While some PPRPs are known to take part in organelle gene expression, little is known about the broader biological contexts of PPRP gene function. Here, using developmental- and reverse-genetic approaches, we demonstrate that a number of PPRPs are essential early in plant development. We have characterized the Arabidopsis embryo-defective175 mutant and identified the EMB175 gene. Emb175 consistently displays aberrant cell organization and undergoes morphological arrest before the globular-heart transition. The emb175 mutation disrupts an intronless open reading frame encoding a predicted chloroplast-localized PPR protein— the first to be rigorously associated with an early embryo-lethal phenotype. To determine if other PPRP genes act in embryogenesis, we searched Arabidopsis insertion mutant collections for pprp knockout alleles, and identified 29 mutants representing 11 loci potentially associated with embryo-defective phenotypes. We assessed gene structures, T-DNA insertion position, and allelism for these loci and were able to firmly establish essential functions for six PPRP genes in addition to EMB175. Interestingly, Nomarski DIC microscopy revealed diverse embryonic defects in these lines, ranging from early lethality to dramatic late-stage morphological defects such as enlarged shoot apices and stunted cotyledons. Together, emb175 and these pprp knockout mutants establish essential roles for PPRPs in embryogenesis, thus broadening the known organismal context for PPRP gene function. The diversity of emb–pprp knockout phenotypes indicates that mutation of different PPRPs can, directly or indirectly, have distinct impacts on embryo morphogenesis.

Mesembryanthemum crystallinum, a higher plant model for the study of environmentally induced changes in gene expression

Plants have evolved several strategies to deal with water stress brought about by changes in soil water potential or solute concentration (Hanson & Hitz, 1982; Morgan, 1984). One solution to long-term periods of water stress is avoidance. This often involves rapid completion of ontogeny or prolonged periods of dormancy. Many halophytes adapt to changes in soil salinity by accumulating inorganic ions in the vacuole. The osmotic potential of the cytoplasm is balanced by the synthesis and accumulation of biologically compatible solutes such as proline, betaine, polyamines, sugars or sugar alcohols (Hanson & Hitz, 1982; Flores et al., 1985). A few species actively secrete or sequester salt via salt glands or salt hairs (Hill & Hill, 1976). Some facultative halophytes such as Mesembryanthemum crystallinum switch to crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM),

Development of the Suspensor: Differentiation, Communication, and Programmed Cell Death During Plant Embryogenesis

The suspensor functions early in embryogenesis to provide physical support, nutrition, and growth regulators to the developing embryo proper. In most plants, the suspensor is derived from the basal cell produced following asymmetric division of the zygote. Cellular differences between the suspensor and embryo proper may result from morphogenetic gradients established prior to division of the zygote. The suspensor develops rapidly with respect to the embryo proper and becomes the first differentiated embryonic structure produced during seed development. The suspensor later undergoes programmed cell death and is not present in mature seeds. Several abnormal suspensor mutants of Arabidopsis have been identified in which the suspensor fails to undergo programmed cell death and instead proliferates to form a structure with features characteristic of the embryo proper. Analysis of these mutants suggests that communication with the embryo proper is required early in embryogenesis for maintenance of suspensor cell identity and later in suspensor development for initiation of programmed cell death. The pattern of embryogenic transformation observed in these mutants indicates that suspensor cells have the potential to recapitulate the entire spectrum of developmental programs normally restricted to the embryo proper. During normal development, interactions with the embryo proper appear to inhibit embryogenic programs, allowing suspensor cell identity to be maintained. Based on these observations, we propose that negative regulation of developmental potential plays a major role in suspensor cell differentiation and that the suspensor may serve as a valuable system for addressing mechanisms of cell differentiation and cellular communication during plant development.

A salinity-induced gene from the halophyte M. crystallinum encodes a glycolytic enzyme, cofactor-independent phosphoglyceromutase

In the facultative halophyte Mesembryanthemum crystallinum (ice plant), salinity stress triggers significant changes in gene expression, including increased expression of mRNAs encoding enzymes involved with osmotic adaptation to water stress and the crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) photosynthetic pathway. To investigate adaptive stress responses in the ice plant at the molecular level, we generated a subtracted cDNA library from stressed plants and identified mRNAs that increase in expression upon salt stress. One full-length cDNA clone was found to encode cofactor-independent phosphoglyceromutase (PGM), an enzyme involved in glycolysis and gluconeogenesis. Pgm1 expression increased in leaves of plants exposed to either saline or drought conditions, whereas levels of the mRNA remained unchanged in roots of hydroponically grown plants. Pgm1 mRNA was also induced in response to treatment with either abscisic acid or cytokinin. Transcription run-on experiments confirmed that Pgm1 mRNA accumulation in leaves was due primarily to increased transcription rates. Immunoblot analysis indicated that Pgm1 mRNA accumulation was accompanied by a modest but reproducible increase in the level of PGM protein. The isolation of a salinity-induced gene encoding a basic enzyme of glycolysis and gluconeogenesis indicates that adaptation to salt stress in the ice plant involves adjustments in fundamental pathways of carbon metabolism and that these adjustments are controlled at the level of gene expression. We propose that the leaf-specific expression of Pgm1 contributes to the maintenance of efficient carbon flux through glycolysis/gluconeogenesis in conjunction with the stress-induced shift to CAM photosynthesis.

Substrates of the Arabidopsis thaliana Protein Isoaspartyl Methyltransferase 1 Identified Using Phage Display and Biopanning

The role of protein isoaspartyl methyltransferase (PIMT) in repairing a wide assortment of damaged proteins in a host of organisms has been inferred from the affinity of the enzyme for isoaspartyl residues in a plethora of amino acid contexts. The identification of PIMT target proteins in plant seeds, where the enzyme is highly active and proteome long-lived, has been hindered by large amounts of isoaspartate-containing storage proteins. Mature seed phage display libraries circumvented this problem. Inclusion of the PIMT co-substrate, S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet), during panning permitted PIMT to retain aged phage in greater numbers than controls lacking co-substrate or when PIMT protein binding was poisoned with S-adenosyl homocysteine. After four rounds, phage titer plateaued in AdoMet-containing pans, whereas titer declined in both controls. This strategy identified 17 in-frame PIMT target proteins, including a cupin-family protein similar to those identified previously using on-blot methylation. All recovered phage had at least one susceptible Asp or Asn residue. Five targets were recovered independently. Two in-frame targets were produced in Escherichia coli as recombinant proteins and shown by on-blot methylation to acquire isoAsp, becoming a PIMT target. Both gained isoAsp rapidly in solution upon thermal insult. Mutant analysis of plants deficient in any of three in-frame PIMT targets resulted in demonstrable phenotypes. An over-representation of clones encoding proteins involved in protein production suggests that the translational apparatus comprises a subgroup for which PIMT-mediated repair is vital for orthodox seed longevity. Impaired PIMT activity would hinder protein function in these targets, possibly resulting in poor seed performance.

An expanded role for the TWN1 gene in embryogenesis: defects in cotyledon pattern and morphology in the twn1 mutant of Arabidopsis (Brassicaceae).

The suspensor is a specialized basal structure that differentiates early in plant embryogenesis to support development of the embryo proper. Suspensor differentiation in Arabidopsis is maintained in part by the TWIN1 (TWN1) gene, which suppresses embryogenic development in suspensor cells: twn1 mutants produce supernumerary embryos via suspensor transformation. To better understand mechanisms of suspensor development and further investigate the function of TWN1, we have characterized late-embryo and post-embryonic development in the twn1 mutant, using seedling culture, microscopy, and genetics. We report here that the twn1 mutation disrupts cotyledon number, arrangement, and morphology and occasionally causes partial conversion of cotyledons into leaves. These defects are not a consequence of suspensor transformation. Thus, in addition to its basal role in suspensor differentiation, TWN1 influences apical pattern and morphology in the embryo proper. To determine whether other genes can similarly affect both suspensor and cotyledon development, we looked for twinning in Arabidopsis mutants previously identified by their abnormal cotyledon phenotypes. One such mutant, amp1, produced a low frequency of twin embryos by suspensor transformation. Our results suggest that mechanisms that maintain suspensor identity also function later in development to influence organ formation at the embryonic shoot apex. We propose that TWN1 functions in cell communication pathways that convey local positional information in both the apical and basal regions of the Arabidopsis embryo.

PIRL1 and PIRL9, encoding members of a novel plant-specific family of leucine-rich repeat proteins, are essential for differentiation of microspores into pollen

Plant intracellular Ras-group-related leucine-rich repeat proteins (PIRLs) are a plant-specific class of leucine-rich repeat (LRR) proteins related to animal and fungal LRRs that take part in developmental signaling and gene regulation. As part of a systematic functional study of the Arabidopsis thaliana PIRL gene family, T-DNA knockout mutants defective in the closely related PIRL1 and PIRL9 genes were identified and characterized. Pirl1 and pirl9 single mutants displayed normal transmission and did not exhibit an obvious developmental phenotype. To investigate the possibility of functional redundancy, crosses to generate double mutants were carried out; however, pirl1;pirl9 plants were not recovered. Reciprocal crosses between wild type and pirl1/PIRL1;pirl9 plants, which produce 50% pirl1;pirl9 gametophytes, indicated male-specific transmission failure of the double-mutant allele combination. Scanning electron microscopy and viability staining showed that approximately half of the pollen produced by pirl1/PIRL1;pirl9 plants was inviable and severely malformed. Tetrad analyses with qrt1 indicated that pollen defects segregated with the double-mutant allele combination, thus demonstrating that PIRL1 and PIRL9 function after meiosis. Pollen development was characterized with bright field, fluorescence, and transmission electron microscopy. Pirl1;pirl9 mutants stopped growing as microspores, failed to initiate vacuolar fission, aborted, and underwent cytoplasmic degeneration. Development consistently arrested at the late microspore stage, just prior to pollen mitosis I. Thus, PIRL1 and PIRL9 have redundant roles essential at a key transition point early in pollen development. Together, these results define a functional context for these two members of this distinct class of plant LRR genes.

A Whole-Transcriptome Approach to Evaluating Reference Genes for Quantitative Gene Expression Studies: A Case Study in Mimulus

While quantitative PCR (qPCR) is widely recognized as being among the most accurate methods for quantifying gene expression, it is highly dependent on the use of reliable, stably expressed reference genes. With the increased availability of high-throughput methods for measuring gene expression, whole-transcriptome approaches may be increasingly utilized for reference gene selection and validation. In this study, RNA-seq was used to identify a set of novel qPCR reference genes and evaluate a panel of traditional “housekeeping” reference genes in two species of the evolutionary model plant genus Mimulus. More broadly, the methods proposed in this study can be used to harness the power of transcriptomes to identify appropriate reference genes for qPCR in any study organism, including emerging and nonmodel systems. We find that RNA-seq accurately estimates gene expression means in comparison to qPCR, and that expression means are robust to moderate environmental and genetic variation. However, measures of expression variability were only in agreement with qPCR for samples obtained from a shared environment. This result, along with transcriptome-wide comparisons, suggests that environmental changes have greater impacts on expression variability than on expression means. We discuss how this issue can be addressed through experimental design, and suggest that the ever-expanding pool of published transcriptomes represents a rich and low-cost resource for developing better reference genes for qPCR.

Effect of sporophytic PIRL9 genotype on post-meiotic expression of the Arabidopsis pirl1;pirl9 mutant pollen phenotype.

Plant intracellular ras-group-related leucine-rich repeat proteins (PIRLs) are a novel class of plant leucine-rich repeat (LRR) proteins structurally related to animal ras-group LRRs involved in cell signaling and gene regulation. Gene knockout analysis has shown that two members of the Arabidopsis thalianaPIRL gene family, PIRL1 and PIRL9, are redundant and essential for pollen development and viability: pirl1;pirl9 microspores produced by pirl1/PIRL1;pirl9 plants consistently abort just before pollen mitosis I. qrt1 tetrad analysis demonstrated that the genes become essential after meiosis, during anther stage 10. In this study, we characterized the phenotype of pirl1;pirl9 pollen produced by plants heterozygous for pirl9 (pirl1;pirl9/PIRL9). Alexander’s staining, scanning electron microscopy, and fluorescence microscopy indicated that pirl1;pirl9 double mutants produced by pirl9 heterozygotes have a less severe phenotype and more variable morphology than pirl1;pirl9 pollen from pirl1/PIRL1;pirl9 plants. Mutant pollen underwent developmental arrest with variable timing, often progressing beyond pollen mitosis I and arresting at the binucleate stage. Thus, although the pirl1 and pirl9 mutations act post-meiosis, the timing and expressivity of the pirl1;pirl9 pollen phenotype depends on the pirl9 genotype of the parent plant. These results suggest a continued requirement for PIRL1 and PIRL9 beyond the initiation of pollen mitosis. Furthermore, they reveal a modest but novel sporophytic effect in which parent plant genotype influences a mutant phenotype expressed in the haploid generation.

The Arabidopsis Plant Intracellular Ras-group LRR (PIRL) Family and the Value of Reverse Genetic Analysis for Identifying Genes that Function in Gametophyte Development.

Arabidopsis thaliana has proven a powerful system for developmental genetics, but identification of gametophytic genes with developmental mutants can be complicated by factors such as gametophyte-lethality, functional redundancy, or poor penetrance. These issues are exemplified by the Plant Intracellular Ras-group LRR (PIRL) genes, a family of nine genes encoding a class of leucine-rich repeat proteins structurally related to animal and fungal LRR proteins involved in developmental signaling. Previous analysis of T-DNA insertion mutants showed that two of these genes, PIRL1 and PIRL9, have an essential function in pollen formation but are functionally redundant. Here, we present evidence implicating three more PIRLs in gametophyte development. Scanning electron microscopy revealed that disruption of either PIRL2 or PIRL3 results in a low frequency of pollen morphological abnormalities. In addition, molecular analysis of putative pirl6 insertion mutants indicated that knockout alleles of this gene are not represented in current Arabidopsis mutant populations, suggesting gametophyte lethality may hinder mutant recovery. Consistent with this, available microarray and RNA-seq data have documented strongest PIRL6 expression in developing pollen. Taken together, these results now implicate five PIRLs in gametophyte development. Systematic reverse genetic analysis of this novel LRR family has therefore identified gametophytically active genes that otherwise would likely be missed by forward genetic screens.