Darren V. S. Green

Thousands of chemical starting points for antimalarial lead identification

Malaria is a devastating infection caused by protozoa of the genus Plasmodium. Drug resistance is widespread, no new chemical class of antimalarials has been introduced into clinical practice since 1996 and there is a recent rise of parasite strains with reduced sensitivity to the newest drugs. We screened nearly 2 million compounds in GlaxoSmithKline’s chemical library for inhibitors of P. falciparum, of which 13,533 were confirmed to inhibit parasite growth by at least 80% at 2 µM concentration. More than 8,000 also showed potent activity against the multidrug resistant strain Dd2. Most (82%) compounds originate from internal company projects and are new to the malaria community. Analyses using historic assay data suggest several novel mechanisms of antimalarial action, such as inhibition of protein kinases and host–pathogen interaction related targets. Chemical structures and associated data are hereby made public to encourage additional drug lead identification efforts and further research into this disease.

Impact of high-throughput screening in biomedical research

High-throughput screening (HTS) has been postulated in several quarters to be a contributory factor to the decline in productivity in the pharmaceutical industry. Moreover, it has been blamed for stifling the creativity that drug discovery demands. In this article, we aim to dispel these myths and present the case for the use of HTS as part of a proven scientific tool kit, the wider use of which is essential for the discovery of new chemotypes.

Selecting Combinatorial Libraries to Optimize Diversity and Physical Properties

The program SELECT is presented for the design of combinatorial libraries. SELECT is based on a genetic algorithm with a multi-objective fitness function. Any number of objectives can be included, provided that they can be readily calculated. Typically, the objectives would be to maximize structural diversity while ensuring that the compounds in the library have “drug-like” properties. In the examples given, structural diversity is measured using Daylight fingerprints as descriptors and either the normalized sum of pairwise dissimilarities, calculated with the cosine coefficient, or the average nearest neighbor distance, calculated with the Tanimoto coefficient, as the measure of diversity. The objectives are specified at run time. Combinatorial libraries are selected by analyzing product space, which gives significant advantages over methods that are based on analyzing reactant space. SELECT can also be used to choose an optimal configuration for a multicomponent library. The performance of SELECT is dem...

Diversity screening versus focussed screening in drug discovery.

Which strategy is best for hit identification? Making the right choices in the capital-intensive world of modern drug discovery can make the difference between success and expensive failure. Keeping an open mind to all the options is essential. Two well-established strategies are diversity-based and focussed screening. This review will provide contrasting viewpoints highlighting the strengths and deficiencies of each approach, as well as some insights into why both strategies are likely to have a place in the research armoury of a successful drug company.

Designing focused libraries using MoSELECT

When designing a combinatorial library it is usually desirable to optimise multiple properties of the library simultaneously and often the properties are in competition with one another. For example, a library that is designed to be focused around a given target molecule should ideally have minimum cost and also contain molecules that are bioavailable. In this paper, we describe the program MoSELECT for multiobjective library design that is based on a multiobjective genetic algorithm (MOGA). MoSELECT searches the product-space of a virtual combinatorial library to generate a family of equivalent solutions where each solution represents a combinatorial subset of the virtual library optimised over multiple objectives. The family of solutions allows the relationships between the objectives to be explored and thus enables the library designer to make an informed choice on an appropriate compromise solution. Experiments are reported where MoSELECT has been applied to the design of various focused libraries.

Virtual Screening of Virtual Libraries

Virtual screening of virtual libraries (VSVL) is a rapidly changing area of research. Great efforts are being made to produce better algorithms, selection methods and infrastructure. Yet, the number of successful examples in the literature is not impressive, although the quality of work certainly is high. Why is this? One reason is that these methods tend to be applied at the lead generation stage and therefore there is a large lead-time before successful examples appear in the literature. However, any computational chemist would confirm that these methods are successful and there exists a glut of start-up companies specialising in virtual screening. Moreover, the scientific community would not be focussing so much attention on this area if it were not yielding results. Even so, the paucity of literature data is certainly a hindrance to the development of better methods. The VSVL process is unique within the discovery process, in that it is the only method that can screen the > 10(30) genuinely novel molecules out there. Already, some VSVL methods are evaluating 10(13) compounds, a capacity that high throughput screening can only dream of. There is a huge potential advantage for the company that develops efficient and effective methods, for lead generation, lead hopping and optimization of both potency and ADME properties. To do this, it requires more than the software, it requires confidence to exploit the methodology, to commit synthesis on the basis of it, and to build this approach into the medicinal chemistry strategy. It is a fact that these tools remain quite daunting for the majority of scientists working at the bench. The routine use of these methods is not simply a matter of education and training. Integration of these methods into accessible and robust end user software, without dilution of the science, must be a priority. We have reached a coincidence, where several technologies have the required level of maturity predictive computational chemistry methods, algorithms that manage the combinatorial explosion, high throughput crystallography and ADME measurements and the massive increase in computational horsepower from distributed computing. The author is confident that the synergy of these technologies will bring great benefit to the industry, with more efficient production of higher quality clinical candidates. The future is bright. The future is virtual!

QSAR workbench: automating QSAR modeling to drive compound design

We describe the QSAR Workbench, a system for the building and analysis of QSAR models. The system is built around the Pipeline Pilot workflow tool and provides access to a variety of model building algorithms for both continuous and categorical data. Traditionally models are built on a one by one basis and fully exploring the model space of algorithms and descriptor subsets is a time consuming basis. The QSAR Workbench provides a framework to allow for multiple models to be built over a number of modeling algorithms, descriptor combinations and data splits (training and test sets). Methods to analyze and compare models are provided, enabling the user to select the most appropriate model. The Workbench provides a consistent set of routines for data preparation and chemistry normalization that are also applied for predictions. The Workbench provides a large degree of automation with the ability to publish preconfigured model building workflows for a variety of problem domains, whilst providing experienced users full access to the underlying parameterization if required. Methods are provided to allow for publication of selected models as web services, thus providing integration with the chemistry desktop. We describe the design and implementation of the QSAR Workbench and demonstrate its utility through application to two public domain datasets.

Automated Lead Optimization of MMP-12 Inhibitors Using a Genetic Algorithm.

Traditional lead optimization projects involve long synthesis and testing cycles, favoring extensive structure-activity relationship (SAR) analysis and molecular design steps, in an attempt to limit the number of cycles that a project must run to optimize a development candidate. Microfluidic-based chemistry and biology platforms, with cycle times of minutes rather than weeks, lend themselves to unattended autonomous operation. The bottleneck in the lead optimization process is therefore shifted from synthesis or test to SAR analysis and design. As such, the way is open to an algorithm-directed process, without the need for detailed user data analysis. Here, we present results of two synthesis and screening experiments, undertaken using traditional methodology, to validate a genetic algorithm optimization process for future application to a microfluidic system. The algorithm has several novel features that are important for the intended application. For example, it is robust to missing data and can suggest compounds for retest to ensure reliability of optimization. The algorithm is first validated on a retrospective analysis of an in-house library embedded in a larger virtual array of presumed inactive compounds. In a second, prospective experiment with MMP-12 as the target protein, 140 compounds are submitted for synthesis over 10 cycles of optimization. Comparison is made to the results from the full combinatorial library that was synthesized manually and tested independently. The results show that compounds selected by the algorithm are heavily biased toward the more active regions of the library, while the algorithm is robust to both missing data (compounds where synthesis failed) and inactive compounds. This publication places the full combinatorial library and biological data into the public domain with the intention of advancing research into algorithm-directed lead optimization methods.

Virtual screening of chemical libraries for drug discovery

Background: Virtual screening has become an established tool for lead generation. In recent years, the computational science behind these tools has evolved to become ever more sophisticated and diverse, whilst the quantity of published successes has continued to increase. Objective: By understanding the origins of virtual screening, the theoretical limitations behind it, and the published examples of success, to understand the current and potential value of these techniques to drug discovery. Method: By reviewing the underlying science and current practice of virtual screening, this article demonstrates the ability of the methods to generate lead molecules. Conclusion: Based on current literature and comparison with ‘wet’ screening techniques such as high-throughput screening and fragment screening, the author suggests areas that need to be addressed if the science of virtual screening is to fulfil its potential.

Rapid and Reliable Binding Affinity Prediction of Bromodomain Inhibitors: A Computational Study

Binding free energies of bromodomain inhibitors are calculated with recently formulated approaches, namely ESMACS (enhanced sampling of molecular dynamics with approximation of continuum solvent) and TIES (thermodynamic integration with enhanced sampling). A set of compounds is provided by GlaxoSmithKline, which represents a range of chemical functionality and binding affinities. The predicted binding free energies exhibit a good Spearman correlation of 0.78 with the experimental data from the 3-trajectory ESMACS, and an excellent correlation of 0.92 from the TIES approach where applicable. Given access to suitable high end computing resources and a high degree of automation, we can compute individual binding affinities in a few hours with precisions no greater than 0.2 kcal/mol for TIES, and no larger than 0.34 and 1.71 kcal/mol for the 1- and 3-trajectory ESMACS approaches.