Deric D. Schoof

Immunomodulatory effects of systemic low-dose recombinant interleukin-2 and lymphokine-activated killer cells in humans.

SummaryThe adoptive immunotherapy of human cancer using lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells in combination with high-dose systemic recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2) has been associated with global changes in several hematological and immunological parameters while imposing profound toxicity on patients. We have evaluated an alternative LAK cell therapy utilizing low-dose systemic rIL-2 in 27 consecutive patients with metastatic cancer. We report that the administration of systemic low-dose rIL-2 is also characterized by significant changes in immunological and hematological parameters, which are qualitatively similar to those induced by high-dose rIL-2. Low-dose systemic rIL-2, given by i.v. bolus, is cleared to baseline levels within 240 min of administration. The induction of lymphocytosis and eosinophilia, which has characterized other protocols, is also a feature of this protocol. In addition, low-dose systemic rIL-2/LAK cell immunotherapy results in increased peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) expression of T-cell activation markers such as OKIa, OKT10 and IL-2 receptor. PBMC sampled approximately 100 h after the final infusion of LAK cells demonstrated a statistically significant increase in their ability to kill natural killer (NK)-sensitive and NK-resistent cell lines such as K562 and Daudi compared to baseline values (P <.05). These data suggest that rIL-2-based immunotherapy using low-dose rIL-2 is capable of inducing quantitative hematological and immunological changes while (in combination with LAK cells) retaining the ability to mediate tumor regressionin vivo.

Survival characteristics of metastatic renal cell carcinoma patients treated with lymphokine-activated killer cells plus interleukin-2

The immunologic manipulation of patients with metastatic renal cell carcinoma using lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells in conjunction with systemic interleukin-2 (IL-2) has been examined under conditions in which the life-threatening toxicities associated with IL-2 treatment have been virtually eliminated. We have examined tumor regression in vivo as well as the survival characteristics of 12 patients with metastatic renal cell carcinoma following immunotherapy. Five of 12 (42%) patients experienced tumor regression exceeding 50 percent following treatment. To determine if immunotherapy had influenced the length of survival, all patients were followed until the time of death. Previous studies have characterized the length of survival of metastatic renal cell cancer patients according to a combination of risk factors unique for each patient. In this model, patients were categorized into risk groups based on the number of risk factors. Survival was found to be dependent on risk factors such as performance status, time from initial diagnosis, number of metastatic sites, recent weight loss, and prior cytotoxic chemotherapy. On completion of the LAK cell immunotherapy protocol, patients were categorized as nonresponders or responders. In addition, they were assigned to risk groups based on their unique profile of risk factors at the time of entry into the protocol. Using this model, we found the median survival of nonresponders (23 months) to be no different from responders (24 months), p > 0.05. This was directly attributable to differences in risk factors which characterized members in these two response groups. However, the observed median survival of nonresponders following therapy was 1.9-fold longer than their projected survival based on the risk factors. Furthermore, the observed median survival of responders was 3.4-fold longer than projected from their risk factors. These results suggest that regardless of response status to therapy, cellular immunotherapy may play a role in mediating a significant palliative effect on the metabolic characteristics of these patients leading to extended survival.

The biological effects of immunosuppression on cellular immunotherapy

Cytoreductive chemotherapy and immunosuppression have been postulated as possible adjuncts to cancer immunotherapy in studies using murine tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL). Treatment of animals with cyclophosphamide (Cy) therapy alone caused two distinct biological activities that altered the relationship between host and tumour. These two in vivo activities were distinguished by altering the timing and dose of Cy administration relative to tumour implantation. Cy administered 3 days following tumour injection caused a significant decline in the number of pulmonary micrometastases and greater survival compared to untreated controls in proportion to the dose of Cy administered. Further reduction in pulmonary disease was observed when Cy-treated mice were given TIL therapy. The possible role(s) of Cy-induced immunosuppression was studied by injecting Cy 24 h prior to tumour injection. This treatment failed to cause the cytoreductive effect observed when Cy was administered 3 days after tumour since Cy-administration prior to tumour resulted in a significantly higher number of pulmonary metastases and diminished survival compared to untreated controls. Despite the increased number of pulmonary metastases and decreased survival in mice treated with Cy before administration of tumour, therapy with TIL significantly diminished pulmonary disease compared to animals treated with Cy alone. Immunosuppression (without concomitant cytoreductive therapy) prior to TIL treatment significantly prolonged survival. Additional studies with TIL therapy indicate that the survival of animals immunosuppressed prior to tumour injection was significantly longer than controls which received immunotherapy alone. These results suggest that the combustion of immunosuppression plus cellular immunotherapy, which leads to significant survival advantage in these murine tumour models, may possibly augment the clinical response in human TIL trials.

Secondary cytokine production by lymphoid cells used in cellular immunotherapy

Interleukin-2 (IL-2) has been used extensively in cellular immunotherapy trials as a systemic activator of the immune system as well as an ex vivo stimulant for lymphoid cell function. Despite the measurement of several in vitro and in vivo immunologic parameters related to cellular immunotherapy, determinants of successful cellular immunotherapy remain unknown. To further delineate the consequences of exposing peripheral blood lymphocytes to high concentrations of IL-2, we assessed the supernatants of IL-2-activated peripheral blood lymphocytes for production of tumour necrosis factor (TNF) and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma). Exposure of normal monocyte-depleted peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) to IL-2 caused a dose-dependent increase in secretion of TNF and IFN-gamma which increased linearly after 48 h in culture. Analysis of positively selected, highly purified PBMC subpopulations exposed to IL-2 revealed that TNF-alpha and TNF-beta were produced by both CD3+ and CD16+ subpopulations but not by CD22+ cells. These studies were extended to supernatants obtained from PBMC cultures used in the adoptive cellular immunotherapy of patients with advanced cancer. Patients treated with lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell immunotherapy were classified as responders (N = 14) or non-responders (N = 17) to therapy. We found no significant difference in the production of TNF between responders and nonresponders (22 +/- 9 U ml-1 vs. 20 +/- 6 U ml-1), P > 0.05. However, LAK cell supernatants harvested from non-responders contained a significantly higher level of IFN-gamma (232 +/- 94 U ml-1) compared with responders (42 +/- 14), P < 0.05. Furthermore, the linear association between IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha production was different between these two response groups (rs = -0.19 for non-responders and rs = 0.48 for responders). These results suggest that secondary cytokine production by adoptively transferred lymphocytesmay play an important role in the host response to cellular immunotherapy.