DeSheng Zhang

Isolation of an endotoxin–MD-2 complex that produces Toll-like receptor 4-dependent cell activation at picomolar concentrations

Host proinflammatory responses to minute amounts of endotoxins derived from many Gram-negative bacteria require the interaction of lipopolysaccharide-binding protein (LBP), CD14, Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) and MD-2. Optimal sensitivity to endotoxin requires an ordered series of endotoxin–protein and protein–protein interactions. At substoichiometric concentrations, LBP facilitates delivery of endotoxin aggregates to soluble CD14 (sCD14) to form monomeric endotoxin–sCD14 complexes. Subsequent interactions of endotoxin–sCD14 with TLR4 and/or MD-2 have not been specifically defined. This study reports the purification of a stable, monomeric, bioactive endotoxin–MD-2 complex generated by treatment of endotoxin–sCD14 with recombinant MD-2. Efficient generation of this complex occurred at picomolar concentrations of endotoxin and nanogram per milliliter doses of MD-2 and required presentation of endotoxin to MD-2 as a monomeric endotoxin–CD14 complex. TLR4-dependent delivery of endotoxin to human embryonic kidney (HEK) cells and cell activation at picomolar concentrations of endotoxin occurred with the purified endotoxin–MD-2 complex, but not with purified endotoxin aggregates with or without LBP and/or sCD14. The presence of excess MD-2 inhibited delivery of endotoxin–MD-2 to HEK/TLR4 cells and cell activation. These findings demonstrate that TLR4-dependent activation of host cells by picomolar concentrations of endotoxin occurs by sequential interaction and transfer of endotoxin to LBP, CD14, and MD-2 and simultaneous engagement of endotoxin and TLR4 by MD-2.

Biochemical and Functional Characterization of Membrane Blebs Purified from Neisseria meningitidis Serogroup B

Studies with purified aggregates of endotoxin have revealed the importance of lipopolysaccharide-binding protein (LBP)-dependent extraction and transfer of individual endotoxin molecules to CD14 in Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4)-dependent cell activation. Endotoxin is normally embedded in the outer membrane of intact Gram-negative bacteria and shed membrane vesicles (“blebs”). However, the ability of LBP and CD14 to efficiently promote TLR4-dependent cell activation by membrane-associated endotoxin has not been studied extensively. In this study, we used an acetate auxotroph of Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B to facilitate metabolic labeling of bacterial endotoxin and compared interactions of purified endotoxin aggregates and of membrane-associated endotoxin with LBP, CD14, and endotoxin-responsive cells. The endotoxin, phospholipid, and protein composition of the recovered blebs indicate that the blebs derive from the bacterial outer membrane. Proteomic analysis revealed an unusual enrichment in highly cationic (pI > 9) proteins. Both purified endotoxin aggregates and blebs activate monocytes and endothelial cells in a LBP-, CD14-, and TLR4/MD-2-dependent fashion, but the blebs were 3-10-fold less potent when normalized for the amount of endotoxin added. Differences in potency correlated with differences in efficiency of LBP-dependent delivery to and extraction of endotoxin by CD14. Both membrane phospholipids and endotoxin are extracted by LBP/soluble CD14 (sCD14) treatment, but only endotoxin·sCD14 reacts with MD-2 and activates cells. These findings indicate that the proinflammatory potency of endotoxin may be regulated not only by the intrinsic structural properties of endotoxin but also by its association with neighboring molecules in the outer membrane.

Molecular Basis of Reduced Potency of Underacylated Endotoxins

Potent TLR4-dependent cell activation by Gram-negative bacterial endotoxins depends on sequential endotoxin-protein and protein-protein interactions with LPS-binding protein, CD14, myeloid differentiation protein 2 (MD-2), and TLR4. Previous studies have suggested that reduced agonist potency of underacylated endotoxins (i.e., tetra- or penta- vs hexa-acylated) is determined by post-CD14 interactions. To better define the molecular basis of the differences in agonist potency of endotoxins differing in fatty acid acylation, we compared endotoxins (lipooligosaccharides (LOS)) from hexa-acylated wild-type (wt), penta-acylated mutant msbB meningococcal strains as well as tetra-acylated LOS generated by treatment of wt LOS with the deacylating enzyme, acyloxyacylhydrolase. To facilitate assay of endotoxin:protein and endotoxin:cell interactions, the endotoxins were purified after metabolic labeling with [3H]- or [14C]acetate. All LOS species tested formed monomeric complexes with MD-2 in an LPS-binding protein- and CD14-dependent manner with similar efficiency. However, msbB LOS:MD-2 and acyloxyacylhydrolase-treated LOS:MD-2 were at least 10-fold less potent in inducing TLR4-dependent cell activation than wt LOS:MD-2 and partially antagonized the action of wt LOS:MD-2. These findings suggest that underacylated endotoxins produce decreased TLR4-dependent cell activation by altering the interaction of the endotoxin:MD-2 complex with TLR4 in a way that reduces receptor activation. Differences in potency among these endotoxin species is determined not by different aggregate properties, but by different properties of monomeric endotoxin:MD-2 complexes.

Specific High Affinity Interactions of Monomeric Endotoxin·Protein Complexes with Toll-like Receptor 4 Ectodomain

Potent Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) activation by endotoxin has been intensely studied, but the molecular requirements for endotoxin interaction with TLR4 are still incompletely defined. Ligand-receptor interactions involving endotoxin and TLR4 were characterized using monomeric endotoxin·protein complexes of high specific radioactivity. The binding of endotoxin·MD-2 to the TLR4 ectodomain (TLR4ECD) and transfer of endotoxin from CD14 to MD-2/TLR4ECD were demonstrated using HEK293T-conditioned medium containing TLR4ECD ± MD-2. These interactions are specific, of high affinity (KD < 300 pm), and consistent with the molecular requirements for potent cell activation by endotoxin. Both reactions result in the formation of a Mr ∼ 190,000 complex composed of endotoxin, MD-2, and TLR4ECD. CD14 facilitates transfer of endotoxin to MD-2 (TLR4) but is not a stable component of the endotoxin·MD-2/TLR4 complex. The ability to assay specific high affinity interactions of monomeric endotoxin·protein complexes with TLR4ECD should allow better definition of the structural requirements for endotoxin-induced TLR4 activation.

A Novel Role for the Bactericidal/Permeability Increasing Protein in Interactions of Gram-Negative Bacterial Outer Membrane Blebs with Dendritic Cells

The bactericidal/permeability-increasing protein (BPI) is thought to play an important role in killing and clearance of Gram-negative bacteria and the neutralization of endotoxin. A possible role for BPI in clearance of cell-free endotoxin has also been suggested based on studies with purified endotoxin aggregates and blood monocytes. Because the interaction of BPI with cell-free endotoxin, during infection, occurs mainly in tissue and most likely in the form of shed bacterial outer membrane vesicles (“blebs”), we examined the effect of BPI on interactions of metabolically labeled ([14C]-acetate) blebs purified from Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B with either human monocyte-derived macrophages or monocyte-derived dendritic cells (MDDC). BPI produced a dose-dependent increase (up to 3-fold) in delivery of 14C-labeled blebs to MDDC, but not to monocyte-derived macrophages in the presence or absence of serum. Both, fluorescently labeled blebs and BPI were internalized by MDDC under these conditions. The closely related LPS-binding protein, in contrast to BPI, did not increase association of the blebs with MDDC. BPI-enhanced delivery of the blebs to MDDC did not increase cell activation but permitted CD14-dependent signaling by the blebs as measured by changes in MDDC morphology, surface expression of CD80, CD83, CD86, and MHC class II and secretion of IL-8, RANTES, and IP-10. These findings suggest a novel role of BPI in the interaction of bacterial outer membrane vesicles with dendritic cells that may help link innate immune recognition of endotoxin to Ag delivery and presentation.

Endotoxin-binding Proteins Modulate the Susceptibility of Bacterial Endotoxin to Deacylation by Acyloxyacyl Hydrolase

Acyloxyacyl hydrolase (AOAH) is an eukaryotic lipase that partially deacylates and detoxifies Gram-negative bacterial lipopolysaccharides and lipooligosaccharides (LPSs or LOSs, endotoxin) within intact cells and inflammatory fluids. In cell lysates or as purified enzyme, in contrast, detergent is required for AOAH to act on LPS or LOS (Erwin, A. L., and Munford, R. S. (1990) J. Biol. Chem. 265, 16444–16449 and Katz, S. S., Weinrauch, Y., Munford, R. S., Elsbach, P., and Weiss, J. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 36579–36584). We speculated that the sequential interactions of endotoxin (E) with endotoxin-binding proteins (lipopolysaccharide-binding protein (LBP), CD14, and MD-2) might produce changes in endotoxin presentation that would allow AOAH greater access to its substrate, lipid A. To test this hypothesis, we measured the activity of purified AOAH against isolated, metabolically labeled meningococcal LOS and Escherichia coli LPS that were presented either as aggregates (LOSagg or LPSagg) ± LBP or as monomeric protein (sCD14 or MD-2)-endotoxin complexes. Up to 100-fold differences in the efficiency of endotoxin deacylation by AOAH were observed, with the following rank order of susceptibility to AOAH: E:sCD14 ≥endotoxin aggregates (Eagg):LBP (molar ratio of E/LBP 100:1) ≫Eagg, Eagg:LBP (E/LBP ∼1, mol/mol), or E:MD-2. AOAH treatment of LOS-sCD14 produced partially deacylated LOS still complexed with sCD14. The underacylated LOS complexed to sCD14 transferred to MD-2 and thus formed a complex capable of preventing TLR4 activation. These findings strongly suggest that LBP- and CD14-dependent extraction and transfer of endotoxin monomers are accompanied by increased exposure of fatty acyl chains within lipid A and that the acyl chains are then sequestered when LOS binds MD-2. The susceptibility of the monomeric endotoxin-CD14 complex to AOAH may help constrain endotoxin-induced TLR4 activation when endotoxin and membrane CD14 are present in excess of MD-2/TLR-4.

NMR studies of hexaacylated endotoxin bound to wild-type and F126A mutant MD-2 and MD-2·TLR4 ectodomain complexes.

Background: Phenylalanine 126 of MD-2 is essential for endotoxin-induced TLR4 activation. Results: NMR of 13C-labeled endotoxin bound to wt or F126A MD-2 ± TLR4 ectodomain reveals effects of Phe126 on interactions of MD-2 ± TLR4 with endotoxin. Conclusion: Phe126 acts as a “hydrophobic switch” promoting agonist-dependent TLR4 dimerization. Significance: This study describes a novel approach to further define the structural requirements for endotoxin-induced TLR4 activation. Host response to invasion by many Gram-negative bacteria depends upon activation of Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) by endotoxin presented as a monomer bound to myeloid differentiation factor 2 (MD-2). Metabolic labeling of hexaacylated endotoxin (LOS) from Neisseria meningitidis with [13C]acetate allowed the use of NMR to examine structural properties of the fatty acyl chains of LOS present in TLR4-agonistic and -antagonistic binary and ternary complexes with, respectively, wild-type or mutant (F126A) MD-2 ± TLR4 ectodomain. Chemical shift perturbation indicates that Phe126 affects the environment and/or position of each of the bound fatty acyl chains both in the binary LOS·MD-2 complex and in the ternary LOS·MD-2·TLR4 ectodomain complex. In both wild-type and mutant LOS·MD-2 complexes, one of the six fatty acyl chains of LOS is more susceptible to paramagnetic attenuation, suggesting protrusion of that fatty acyl chain from the hydrophobic pocket of MD-2, independent of association with TLR4. These findings indicate that re-orientation of the aromatic side chain of Phe126 is induced by binding of hexaacylated E, preceding interaction with TLR4. This re-arrangement of Phe126 may act as a “hydrophobic switch,” driving agonist-dependent contacts needed for TLR4 dimerization and activation.

Metabolic labeling to characterize the overall composition of Francisella lipid A and LPS grown in broth and in human phagocytes

A hallmark of Francisella tularensis, a highly virulent Gram-negative bacterium, is an unusual LPS that possesses both structural heterogeneity and characteristics that may contribute to innate immune evasion. However, none of the methods yet employed has been sufficient to determine the overall LPS composition of Francisella. We now demonstrate that metabolic labeling of francisellae with [14C]acetate, combined with fractionation of [14C]acetate-labeled lipids by ethanol precipitation rather than hot phenol–water extraction, permits a more sensitive and quantitative appraisal of overall compositional heterogeneity in lipid A and LPS. The majority of lipid A of different francisellae strains grown in diverse bacteriologic media and within human phagocytes accumulated as very hydrophobic species, including free lipid A, with <10% of the lipid A molecules substituted with O-Ag polysaccharides. The spectrum of lipid A and LPS species varied in a medium- and strain-dependent fashion, and growth in THP-1 cells yielded lipid A species that were not present in the same bacteria grown in brain heart infusion broth. In summary, metabolic labeling with [14C]acetate greatly facilitates assessment of the effect of genotypic and/or environmental variables on the synthesis and accumulation of lipid A and LPS by Francisella, including during growth within the cytosol of infected host cells.

Purified monomeric ligand.MD-2 complexes reveal molecular and structural requirements for activation and antagonism of TLR4 by Gram-negative bacterial endotoxins

A major focus of work in our laboratory concerns the molecular mechanisms and structural bases of Gram-negative bacterial endotoxin recognition by host (e.g., human) endotoxin-recognition proteins that mediate and/or regulate activation of Toll-like receptor (TLR) 4. Here, we review studies of wild-type and variant monomeric endotoxin.MD-2 complexes first produced and characterized in our laboratories. These purified complexes have provided unique experimental reagents, revealing both quantitative and qualitative determinants of TLR4 activation and antagonism. This review is dedicated to the memory of Dr. Theresa L. Gioannini (1949–2014) who played a central role in many of the studies and discoveries that are reviewed.

Stable isotope metabolic labeling of Neisseria meningitidis lipooligosaccharide

The lipooligosaccharide (LOS) of a Neisseria meningitidis acetate auxotroph was metabolically labeled with either [2-13C]-sodium acetate or [1,2-13C 2]-sodium acetate. In this study, we demonstrated that this label was efficiently incorporated into both the lipid A acyl moieties and the two N-acetylglucosamines present in the oligosaccharide branch of the LOS. The development of this efficient labeling protocol should prove useful in future structural studies analyzing the interactions between LOS and host proteins.