Douglas A. Hale

Establishment of stable multilineage hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific tolerance without irradiation.

BACKGROUNDnInduction of tolerance to organ transplants will increase graft survival and decrease patient mortality and morbidity. Radiation-induced cytoreduction/ablation followed by donor hematopoietic cell reconstitution has been the most consistently successful approach to experimental tolerance induction. However, reluctance of clinicians to expose recipients to radiation has hampered its clinical application.nnnMETHODSnIn the studies described, administration of polyclonal antilymphocyte serum (ALS), donor-specific bone marrow (DSBM) (150x10(6) cells), and sirolimus (24 mg/kg) in a completely mismatched murine model (B10.A donor, C57B/10 recipient) produced 100% indefinite (>250 days) skin graft survival. The level and character of donor-specific chimerism was evaluated with flow cytometry.nnnRESULTSnSpecific tolerance was confirmed by continued acceptance of primary and secondary donor-specific skin allografts and rejection of third-party grafts. The level and duration of chimerism induced was directly related to the dose of DSBM administered. Mice given 150x10(6) DSBM cells showed levels of 8-10% donor peripheral blood mononuclear cell chimerism by 30 days, and these levels persisted indefinitely (>250 days) in association with permanent tolerance of donor grafts. Eighty percent of donor chimeric cells were B lymphocytes (MHC class I and II positive, Fc receptor positive, CD45/B220 positive but negative for CD4, CD8 and Thy 1.2) and 20% were sorted in the macrophage monocyte population.nnnCONCLUSIONSnThese studies demonstrate for the first time that cytoreduction/ablation with ALS combined with sirolimus and reconstitution with donor bone marrow induces tolerance and chimerism in a completely mismatched murine combination. The use of ALS and sirolimus, currently employed therapies in clinical transplantation, and the lack of requirement for radiation make this tolerance protocol attractive for clinical application.

Use of CTLA4-Ig in combination with conventional immunosuppressive agents to prolong allograft survival

BACKGROUNDnThe objective of our study was to determine the effectiveness of CTLA4-Ig, a novel immunosuppressive agent, in augmenting allograft survival when combined with either cyclosporine, sirolimus, donor-specific bone marrow alone (BM), or bone marrow in conjunction with antilymphocyte serum (ALS).nnnMETHODSnFull-thickness skin allografts were used in C3H to B6AF1 (class I mismatch) and AKR to C57BL/6 (complete mismatch) models. Groups of mice (n=6-14) were treated with various combinations of the following treatment protocols: murine CTLA4-Ig, L-6 control Ig, sirolimus, cyclosporine, ALS, or ALS/BM.nnnRESULTSnIn the class I mismatch model, L-6 control Ig had no effect whereas use of CTLA4-Ig alone resulted in a doubling of the median graft survival compared with controls. The addition of either sirolimus or cyclosporine to CTLA4-Ig increased graft survival over that achieved with CTLA4-Ig alone. CTLA4-Ig demonstrated no efficacy when used in combination with BM, ALS, or ALS/BM. CTLA4-Ig was clearly less effective in the complete mismatch model.nnnCONCLUSIONnThese data suggest that CTLA4-Ig may be effective clinically in combination with cyclosporine or sirolimus but offers no additional effectiveness in combination with antilymphocyte serum with or without donor-specific bone marrow.

Determination of an improved sirolimus (rapamycin)-based regimen for induction of allograft tolerance in mice treated with antilymphocyte serum and donor-specific bone marrow.

BACKGROUNDnPosttransplant donor-specific bone marrow (BM) infusion in mice treated with antilymphocyte serum (ALS) induces specific unresponsiveness (tolerance) to skin allografts, which can be augmented by the adjuvant administration of chemotherapeutic immunosuppressive agents. The purpose of this study was to determine the optimal dose and timing of administration of sirolimus (rapamycin) to induce maximal skin allograft survival in ALS-treated, BM-infused recipients.nnnMETHODSnDBA/2 donor skin grafts were placed on B6AF1 recipients (class I- and II-disparate). Groups of recipient mice (n=10 each) received combinations of the following treatment protocols: ALS, 0.5 ml on days -1 and 2; BM, 25x10(6) donor-specific cells on day 7; sirolimus, 6, 12, 18, or 24 mg/kg at times indicated; and cyclosporine, 50 mg/kg at times indicated. The immune status of putatively tolerant animals was examined with mixed lymphocyte cultures, cell-mediated lympholysis assays (CML), and limiting dilution analyses.nnnRESULTSnWhen administered in conjunction with ALS/BM, a single dose of sirolimus (6 mg/kg) on days 21, 18, 14, 10, or 7 resulted in median skin graft survival times of 35, 26, 40, 46, and 103 days, respectively, versus a median survival of 27 days in mice given ALS and BM alone. The addition of cyclosporine to sirolimus (6 mg/kg) given on day 7 or days 7 and 10 did not significantly increase graft survival over that achieved with sirolimus alone. A single dose (18 or 24 mg/kg) of sirolimus administered on day 7 to ALS/BM-treated recipients resulted in 100% 200-day skin graft acceptance. Tolerant mice demonstrated nonspecific suppression of the mixed lymphocyte culture assays at 90 and 200 days and a nonspecific reduction of the CML assay at 50 days. By 200 days, the third-party CML response was restored, whereas donor-specific cell-mediated cytotoxicity remained suppressed. There was a donor-specific reduction in the number of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones by limiting dilution assay at 120 days. In vivo specificity of immunosuppression induced with this protocol was demonstrated by indefinite survival of second donor-specific skin grafts placed on putatively tolerant mice at day 90, whereas third-party skin grafts were rejected in 14 days.nnnCONCLUSIONnA single dose of sirolimus (18-24 mg/kg) administered on day 7, within the context of an ALS/BM immunosuppressive regimen, reliably induces permanent skin allograft acceptance in this model. In vitro measures of immunocompetence demonstrated an early nonspecific suppression of the recipients immune status and later recovery of third-party immunoreactivity. In vivo testing indicates an operationally tolerant state that is donor-specific 90 days after treatment.

Superiority of sirolimus (rapamycin) over cyclosporine in augmenting allograft and xenograft survival in mice treated with antilymphocyte serum and donor-specific bone marrow.

BACKGROUNDnSirolimus is a potent immunosuppressive agent with great therapeutic potential. The objective of our study was to evaluate the efficacy of sirolimus versus cyclosporine in augmenting the unresponsiveness induced by an antilymphocyte serum (ALS)/donor-specific bone marrow (BM)-based regimen across three levels of histoincompatibility: class I and II disparate (DBA/2 to B6AF1), complete mismatch (AKR to C57BL/6), and xenograft (ACI rat to B6AF1).nnnMETHODSnFull-thickness skin grafts were taken from donors and placed on recipients in standard fashion. Seven groups of recipient mice (n=10-28) received various combinations of the following treatment protocols: sirolimus, 1.5 mg/kg (3.0 mg/kg for xenografts) every other day from day 0 to day 12; cyclosporine, 50 mg/kg every other day from day 10 through 22; ALS, 0.5 ml on days -1 and 2 for allografts and days -1, 2, and 4 for xenografts; and BM, 25 million donor-specific cells IV on day 7.nnnRESULTSnThe administration of ALS or ALS/BM resulted in modest but significant prolongation of skin graft survival in all combinations tested. Cyclosporine combined with ALS or ALS/BM significantly extended allograft survival compared with ALS or ALS/BM alone (P<0.05) but had no effect on xenograft survival. In contrast, the combination of sirolimus with ALS or ALS/BM resulted in a two- to threefold increase in allograft survival and over a fourfold increase in xenograft survival when compared with the comparable cyclosporine-based regimen. Additionally, lymphocytes isolated from class I and II incompatible mice with skin grafts surviving >100 days demonstrated markedly reduced interleukin 2 and interferon-gamma secretion in response to irradiated donor-specific lymphocytes in culture.nnnCONCLUSIONSnIn the regimens tested, sirolimus was superior to cyclosporine in augmenting donor BM-induced skin graft prolongation in ALS-treated mice across all levels of histoincompatibility.

Use of pharmacologic immunosuppression to augment the specific unresponsiveness (tolerance) to skin allografts induced by donor-specific bone marrow in antilymphocyte serum-treated mice: the unique effect of sirolimus

Tolerance produced with ALS treatment, DSBM, and sirolimus involves multiple mechanisms of a specific and nonspecific nature. In eventual clinical application for tolerance induction, sirolimus (rapamycin) has great potential for augmenting the tolerogenicity of the ALS/BM regimen.