Ekaterina M. Nestorovich

Designed to penetrate: Time-resolved interaction of single antibiotic molecules with bacterial pores

Membrane permeability barriers are among the factors contributing to the intrinsic resistance of bacteria to antibiotics. We have been able to resolve single ampicillin molecules moving through a channel of the general bacterial porin, OmpF (outer membrane protein F), believed to be the principal pathway for the β-lactam antibiotics. With ion channel reconstitution and high-resolution conductance recording, we find that ampicillin and several other efficient penicillins and cephalosporins strongly interact with the residues of the constriction zone of the OmpF channel. Therefore, we hypothesize that, in analogy to substrate-specific channels that evolved to bind certain metabolite molecules, antibiotics have “evolved” to be channel-specific. Molecular modeling suggests that the charge distribution of the ampicillin molecule complements the charge distribution at the narrowest part of the bacterial porin. Interaction of these charges creates a region of attraction inside the channel that facilitates drug translocation through the constriction zone and results in higher permeability rates.

Residue Ionization and Ion Transport through OmpF Channels

Single trimeric channels of the general bacterial porin, OmpF, were reconstituted into planar lipid membranes and their conductance, selectivity, and open-channel noise were studied over a wide range of proton concentrations. From pH 1 to pH 12, channel transport properties displayed three characteristic regimes. First, in acidic solutions, channel conductance is a strong function of pH; it increases by approximately threefold as the proton concentration decreases from pH 1 to pH 5. This rise in conductance is accompanied by a sharp increase in cation transport number and by pronounced open-channel low-frequency current noise with a peak at approximately pH 2.5. Random stepwise transients with amplitudes at approximately 1/5 of the monomer conductance are major contributors to this noise. Second, over the middle range (pH 5/pH 9), channel conductance and selectivity stay virtually constant; open channel noise is at its minimum. Third, over the basic range (pH 9/pH 12), channel conductance and cation selectivity start to grow again with an onset of a higher frequency open-channel noise. We attribute these effects to the reversible protonation of channel residues whose pH-dependent charge influences transport by direct interactions with ions passing through the channel.

Pseudomonas aeruginosa Porin OprF Exists in Two Different Conformations

The major nonspecific porin of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, OprF, produces a large channel yet allows only a slow diffusion of various solutes. Here we provide an explanation of this apparent paradox. We first show, by introduction of tobacco etch virus protease cleavage site in the middle of OprF protein, that most of OprF population folds as a two-domain protein with an N-terminal β-barrel domain and a C-terminal periplasmic domain rich in α-helices. However, sedimentation of unilamellar proteoliposomes through an iso-osmotic gradient showed that only about 5% of the OprF population produced open channels. Gel filtration showed that the open channel conformers tended to occur in oligomeric associations. Because the open channel conformer is likely to fold as a single domain protein with a large β-barrel, we reasoned that residues near the C terminus may be exposed on cell surface in this conformer. Introduction of a cysteine residue at position 312 produced a functional mutant protein. By using bulky biotinylation reagents on intact cells, we showed that this cysteine residue was not exposed on cell surface in most of the OprF population. However, the minority OprF population that was biotinylated in such experiments was enriched for the conformer with pore-forming activity and had a 10-fold higher pore-forming specific activity than the bulk OprF population. Finally trypsin treatment, which preferentially cleaves the C-terminal domain of the two-domain conformer, did not affect the pore-forming activity of OprF nor did it digest the minority conformer whose residue 312 is exposed on cell surface.

Syringomycin E Channel: A Lipidic Pore Stabilized by Lipopeptide?

Highly reproducible ion channels of the lipopeptide antibiotic syringomycin E demonstrate unprecedented involvement of the host bilayer lipids. We find that in addition to a pronounced influence of lipid species on the open-channel ionic conductance, the membrane lipids play a crucial role in channel gating. The effective gating charge, which characterizes sensitivity of the conformational equilibrium of the syringomycin E channels to the transmembrane voltage, is modified by the lipid charge and lipid dipolar moment. We show that the type of host lipid determines not only the absolute value but also the sign of the gating charge. With negatively charged bilayers, the gating charge sign inverts with increased salt concentration or decreased pH. We also demonstrate that the replacement of lamellar lipid by nonlamellar with the negative spontaneous curvature inhibits channel formation. These observations suggest that the asymmetric channel directly incorporates lipids. The charges and dipoles resulting from the structural inclusion of lipids are important determinants of the overall energetics that underlies channel gating. We conclude that the syringomycin E channel may serve as a biophysical model to link studies of ion channels with those of lipidic pores in membrane fusion.

Search for Cyclodextrin-Based Inhibitors of Anthrax Toxins: Synthesis, Structural Features, and Relative Activities

ABSTRACT Recently, using structure-inspired drug design, we demonstrated that aminoalkyl derivatives of β-cyclodextrin inhibited anthrax lethal toxin action by blocking the transmembrane pore formed by the protective antigen (PA) subunit of the toxin. In the present study, we evaluate a series of new β-cyclodextrin derivatives with the goal of identifying potent inhibitors of anthrax toxins. Newly synthesized hepta-6-thioaminoalkyl and hepta-6-thioguanidinoalkyl derivatives of β-cyclodextrin with alkyl spacers of various lengths were tested for the ability to inhibit cytotoxicity of lethal toxin in cells as well as to block ion conductance through PA channels reconstituted in planar bilayer lipid membranes. Most of the tested derivatives were protective against anthrax lethal toxin action at low or submicromolar concentrations. They also blocked ion conductance through PA channels at concentrations as low as 0.1 nM. The activities of the derivatives in both cell protection and channel blocking were found to depend on the length and chemical nature of the substituent groups. One of the compounds was also shown to block the edema toxin activity. It is hoped that these results will help to identify a new class of drugs for anthrax treatment, i.e., drugs that block the pathway for toxin translocation into the cytosol, the PA channel.

Pseudomonas aeruginosa Porin OprF PROPERTIES OF THE CHANNEL

Using ion channel reconstitution in planar lipid bilayers, we examined the channel-forming activity of subfractions of Pseudomonas aeruginosa OprF, which was shown to exist in two different conformations: a minority single domain conformer and a majority two-domain conformer (Sugawara, E., Nestorovich, E. M., Bezrukov, S. M., and Nikaido, H. (2006) J. Biol. Chem. 281, 16220–16229). With the fraction depleted for the single domain conformer, we were unable to detect formation of any channels with well defined conductance levels. With the unfractionated OprF, we saw only rare channel formation. However, with the single domain-enriched fraction of OprF, we observed regular insertion of channels with highly reproducible conductances. Single OprF channels demonstrate rich kinetic behavior exhibiting spontaneous transitions between several subconformations that differ in ionic conductance and radius measured in polymer exclusion experiments. Although we showed that the effective radius of the most conductive conformation exceeds that of the general outer membrane porin of Escherichia coli, OmpF, we also found that a single OprF channel mainly exists in weakly conductive subconformations and switches to the fully open state for a short time only. Therefore, the low permeability of OprF reported earlier may be due to two factors: mainly to the paucity of the single domain conformer in the OprF population and secondly to the predominance of weakly conductive subconformations within the single domain conformer.

Blockage of Anthrax PA63 Pore by a Multicharged High-Affinity Toxin Inhibitor

Single channels of Bacillus anthracis protective antigen, PA(63), were reconstituted into planar lipid membranes and their inhibition by cationic aminopropylthio-beta-cyclodextrin, AmPrbetaCD, was studied. The design of the highly efficient inhibitor, the sevenfold symmetrical cyclodextrin molecule chemically modified to add seven positive charges, was guided by the symmetry and predominantly negative charge of the PA(63) pore. The protective action of this compound has been demonstrated earlier at both single-molecule and whole-organism levels. In this study, using noise analysis, statistics of time-resolved single-channel closure events, and multichannel measurements, we find that AmPrbetaCD action is bimodal. The inhibitor, when added to the cis side of the membrane, blocks the channel reversibly. At high salt concentrations, the AmPrbetaCD blockage of the channel is well described as a two-state Markov process, in which both the on- and off-rates are functions of the salt concentration, whereas the applied voltage affects only the off-rate. At salt concentrations smaller than 1.5 M, the second mode of AmPrbetaCD action on the channel is discovered: addition of the inhibitor enhances voltage gating, making the closed states of the channel more favorable. The effect depends on the lipid composition of the membrane.

Polymer Partitioning and Ion Selectivity Suggest Asymmetrical Shape for the Membrane Pore Formed by Epsilon Toxin

Using poly-(ethylene glycol)s of different molecular weights, we probe the channels formed in planar lipid bilayers by epsilon toxin secreted by the anaerobic bacterium Clostridium perfringens. We find that the pore is highly asymmetric. The cutoff size of polymers entering the pore through its opening from the cis side, the side of toxin addition, is approximately 500 Da, whereas the cutoff size for the polymers entering from the trans side is approximately 2300 Da. Comparing these characteristic molecular weights with those reported earlier for OmpF porin and the alpha-Hemolysin channel, we estimate the radii of cis and trans openings as 0.4 nm and 1.0 nm, respectively. The simplest geometry corresponding to these findings is that of a truncated cone. The asymmetry of the pore is also confirmed by measurements of the reversal potential at oppositely directed salt gradients. The moderate anionic selectivity of the channel is salted-out more efficiently when the salt concentration is higher at the trans side of the pore.

Tailored ß-Cyclodextrin Blocks the Translocation Pores of Binary Exotoxins from C. Botulinum and C. Perfringens and Protects Cells from Intoxication

Background Clostridium botulinum C2 toxin and Clostridium perfringens iota toxin are binary exotoxins, which ADP-ribosylate actin in the cytosol of mammalian cells and thereby destroy the cytoskeleton. C2 and iota toxin consists of two individual proteins, an enzymatic active (A-) component and a separate receptor binding and translocation (B-) component. The latter forms a complex with the A-component on the surface of target cells and after receptor-mediated endocytosis, it mediates the translocation of the A-component from acidified endosomal vesicles into the cytosol. To this end, the B-components form heptameric pores in endosomal membranes, which serve as translocation channels for the A-components. Methodology/Principal Findings Here we demonstrate that a 7-fold symmetrical positively charged ß-cyclodextrin derivative, per-6-S-(3-aminomethyl)benzylthio-ß-cyclodextrin, protects cultured cells from intoxication with C2 and iota toxins in a concentration-dependent manner starting at low micromolar concentrations. We discovered that the compound inhibited the pH-dependent membrane translocation of the A-components of both toxins in intact cells. Consistently, the compound strongly blocked transmembrane channels formed by the B-components of C2 and iota toxin in planar lipid bilayers in vitro. With C2 toxin, we consecutively ruled out all other possible inhibitory mechanisms showing that the compound did not interfere with the binding of the toxin to the cells or with the enzyme activity of the A-component. Conclusions/Significance The described ß-cyclodextrin derivative was previously identified as one of the most potent inhibitors of the binary lethal toxin of Bacillus anthracis both in vitro and in vivo, implying that it might represent a broad-spectrum inhibitor of binary pore-forming exotoxins from pathogenic bacteria.

Designing Inhibitors of Anthrax Toxin

Introduction: Present-day rational drug design approaches are based on exploiting unique features of the target biomolecules, small- or macromolecule drug candidates and physical forces that govern their interactions. The 2013 Nobel Prize in chemistry awarded ‘for the development of multiscale models for complex chemical systems’ once again demonstrated the importance of the tailored drug discovery that reduces the role of the trial-and-error approach to a minimum. The intentional dissemination of Bacillus anthracis spores in 2001 via the so-called anthrax letters has led to increased efforts, politically and scientifically, to develop medical countermeasures that will protect people from the threat of anthrax bioterrorism. Areas covered: This article provides an overview of the recent rational drug design approaches for discovering inhibitors of anthrax toxin. The review also directs the readers to the vast literature on the recognized advances and future possibilities in the field. Expert opinion: Existing options to combat anthrax toxin lethality are limited. With the only anthrax toxin inhibiting therapy (protective antigen-targeting with a monoclonal antibody, raxibacumab) approved to treat inhalational anthrax, the situation, in our view, is still insecure. Further, the FDAs animal rule for drug approval, which clears compounds without validated efficacy studies on humans, creates a high level of uncertainty, especially when a well-characterized animal model does not exist. Better identification and validation of anthrax toxin therapeutic targets at the molecular level as well as elucidation of the parameters determining the corresponding therapeutic windows are still necessary for more effective therapeutic options.