Erwin K. Chung

Gene copy-number variation and associated polymorphisms of complement component C4 in human systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE): low copy number is a risk factor for and high copy number is a protective factor against SLE susceptibility in European Americans.

Interindividual gene copy-number variation (CNV) of complement component C4 and its associated polymorphisms in gene size (long and short) and protein isotypes (C4A and C4B) probably lead to different susceptibilities to autoimmune disease. We investigated the C4 gene CNV in 1,241 European Americans, including patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), their first-degree relatives, and unrelated healthy subjects, by definitive genotyping and phenotyping techniques. The gene copy number (GCN) varied from 2 to 6 for total C4, from 0 to 5 for C4A, and from 0 to 4 for C4B. Four copies of total C4, two copies of C4A, and two copies of C4B were the most common GCN counts, but each constituted only between one-half and three-quarters of the study populations. Long C4 genes were strongly correlated with C4A (R=0.695; P<.0001). Short C4 genes were correlated with C4B (R=0.437; P<.0001). In comparison with healthy subjects, patients with SLE clearly had the GCN of total C4 and C4A shifting to the lower side. The risk of SLE disease susceptibility significantly increased among subjects with only two copies of total C4 (patients 9.3%; unrelated controls 1.5%; odds ratio [OR] = 6.514; P=.00002) but decreased in those with > or =5 copies of C4 (patients 5.79%; controls 12%; OR=0.466; P=.016). Both zero copies (OR=5.267; P=.001) and one copy (OR=1.613; P=.022) of C4A were risk factors for SLE, whereas > or =3 copies of C4A appeared to be protective (OR=0.574; P=.012). Family-based association tests suggested that a specific haplotype with a single short C4B in tight linkage disequilibrium with the -308A allele of TNFA was more likely to be transmitted to patients with SLE. This work demonstrates how gene CNV and its related polymorphisms are associated with the susceptibility to a human complex disease.

The Intricate Role of Complement Component C4 in Human Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

It was observed about 50 years ago that low serum complement activity or low protein concentrations of complement C4 concurred with disease activities of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Complete deficiencies of complement components C4A and C4B, albeit rare in human populations, are among the strongest genetic risk factors for SLE or lupus-like disease, across HLA haplotypes and racial backgrounds. However, whether heterozygous or partial deficiency of C4A (C4AQ0) or C4B (C4BQ0) is a predisposing factor for SLE has been a highly controversial topic. In this review we critically analyzed past epidemiologic studies on deficiency of C4A or C4B in human SLE. Cumulative results from more than 35 different studies revealed that heterozygous and homozygous deficiencies of C4A were present in 40-60% of SLE patients from almost all ethnic groups or races investigated, which included northern and central Europeans, Anglo-Saxons, Caucasians in the US, African Americans, Asian Chinese, Koreans and Japanese. In addition, French SLE and control populations had relatively low frequencies of C4AQ0, but the difference between the patient and control groups was statistically significant. The relative risk of C4AQ0 in SLE varied between 2.3 and 5.3 among different ethnic groups. In Caucasian and African SLE patients, the two major causes for C4AQ0 are (1) the presence of a mono-S RCCX (RP-C4-CYP21-TNX) module with a single, short C4B gene in the major histocompatibility complex; and (2) a 2-bp insertion into the sequence for codon 1213 at exon 29 of the mutant C4A gene. Both mono-S structures and 2-bp insertion in exon 29 are absent or extremely rare in the C4AQ0 of Oriental SLE patients. The highly significant association of C4AQ0 with SLE across multiple HLA haplotypes and ethnic groups, and the presence of different mechanisms leading to a C4A protein deficiency among SLE patients suggested that deficiency or low expression level of C4A protein is a primary risk factor for SLE disease susceptibility per se. On the other hand, Spanish, Mexican, Australian Aborigine SLE patients had increased frequencies of C4B deficiency instead of C4A deficiency. Such observations underscore the importance of both C4A and C4B proteins in the fine control of autoimmunity. Different racial and genetic backgrounds could change the thresholds for the requirement of C4A or C4B protein levels in immune tolerance and immune regulation. Most past epidemiological studies of C4 in human SLE did not consider the polygenic and gene size variations of C4A and C4B. In addition, many studies were overly dependent on phenotypic observations or methods that did not distinguish differential C4A and C4B protein expression caused by unequal gene number or different gene size from the absence of a functional C4A or C4B gene. For further longitudinal studies on clinical manifestations of SLE, it would be informative to stratify the patients with accurately defined C4A and C4B genotypes. Likewise, elucidation of epistatic genetic factors interacting with C4AQ0 would provide important insights into the intricate roles of C4 in SLE disease susceptibility and pathogenesis.

Diversity in Intrinsic Strengths of the Human Complement System: Serum C4 Protein Concentrations Correlate with C4 Gene Size and Polygenic Variations, Hemolytic Activities, and Body Mass Index

Among the genes and proteins of the human immune system, complement component C4 is extraordinary in its frequent germline variation in the size and number of genes. Definitive genotypic and phenotypic analyses were performed on a central European population to determine the C4 polygenic and gene size variations and their relationships with serum C4A and C4B protein concentrations and hemolytic activities. In a study population of 128 healthy subjects, the number of C4 genes present in a diploid genome varied between two to five, and 77.4% of the C4 genes belonged to the long form that contains the endogenous retrovirus HERV-K(C4). Intriguingly, higher C4 serum protein levels and higher C4 hemolytic activities were often detected in subjects with short C4 genes than those with long genes only, suggesting a negative epistatic effect of HERV-K(C4) on the expression of C4 proteins. Also, the body mass index appeared to affect the C4 serum levels, particularly in the individuals with medium or high C4 gene dosages, a phenomenon that was dissimilar in several aspects from the established correlation between body mass index and serum C3. As expected, there were strong, positive correlations between total C4 gene dosage and serum C4 protein concentrations, and between serum C4 protein concentrations and C4 hemolytic activities. There were also good correlations between the number of long genes with serum levels of C4A, and the number of short genes with serum levels of C4B. Thus, the polygenic and gene size variations of C4A and C4B contribute to the quantitative traits of C4 with a wide range of serum protein levels and hemolytic activities, and consequently the power of the innate defense system.

Genetic Sophistication of Human Complement Components C4A and C4B and RP-C4-CYP21-TNX (RCCX) Modules in the Major Histocompatibility Complex

Human populations are endowed with a sophisticated genetic diversity of complement C4 and its flanking genes RP, CYP21, and TNX in the RCCX modules of the major histocompatibility complex class III region. We applied definitive techniques to elucidate (a) the complement C4 polymorphisms in gene sizes, gene numbers, and protein isotypes and (b) their gene orders. Several intriguing features are unraveled, including (1) a trimodular RCCX haplotype with three long C4 genes expressing C4A protein only, (2) two trimodular haplotypes with two long (L) and one short (S) C4 genes organized in LSL configurations, (3) a quadrimodular haplotype with four C4 genes organized in a SLSL configuration, and (4) another quadrimodular structure, with four long C4 genes (LLLL), that has the human leukocyte antigen haplotype that is identical to ancestral haplotype 7.2 in the Japanese population. Long-range PCR and PshAI-RFLP analyses conclusively revealed that the short genes from the LSL and SLSL haplotypes are C4A. In four informative families, an astonishingly complex pattern of genetic diversity for RCCX haplotypes with one, two, three and four C4 genes is demonstrated; each C4 gene may be long or short, encoding a C4A or C4B protein. Such diversity may be related to different intrinsic strengths among humans to defend against infections and susceptibilities to autoimmune diseases.

Complete Complement Components C4A and C4B Deficiencies in Human Kidney Diseases and Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

Although a heterozygous deficiency of either complement component C4A or C4B is common, and each has a frequency of ∼20% in a Caucasian population, complete deficiencies of both C4A and C4B proteins are extremely rare. In this paper the clinical courses for seven complete C4 deficiency patients are described in detail, and the molecular defects for complete C4 deficiencies are elucidated. Three patients with homozygous HLA A24 Cw7 B38 DR13 had systemic lupus erythematosus, mesangial glomerulonephritis, and severe skin lesions or membranous nephropathy. Immunofixation, genomic restriction fragment length polymorphisms, and pulsed field gel electrophoresis experiments revealed the presence of monomodular RP-C4-CYP21-TNX (RCCX) modules, each containing a solitary, long C4A mutant gene. Sequencing of the mutant C4A genes revealed a 2-bp, GT deletion in exon 13 that leads to protein truncation. The other four patients with homozygous HLA A30 B18 DR7 had SLE, severe kidney disorders including mesangial or membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis, and/or Henoch Schoenlein purpura. Molecular genetic analyses revealed an unusual RCCX structure with two short C4B mutant genes, each followed by an intact gene for steroid 21-hydroxylase. Nine identical, intronic mutations were found in each mutant C4B. In particular, the 8127 g→a mutation present at the donor site of intron 28 may cause an RNA splice defect. Analyses of 12 complete C4 deficiency patients revealed two hot spots of deleterious mutations: one is located at exon 13, the others within a 2.6-kb genomic region spanning exons 20–29. Screening of these mutations may facilitate epidemiologic studies of C4 in infectious, autoimmune, and kidney diseases.

Determining the one, two, three, or four long and short loci of human complement C4 in a major histocompatibility complex haplotype encoding C4A or C4B proteins.

The complex genetics of human complement C4 with unusually frequent variations in the size and number of C4A and C4B, as well as their neighboring genes, in the major histocompatibility complex has been a hurdle for accurate epidemiological studies of diseases associated with C4. A comprehensive series of novel or improved techniques has been developed to determine the total gene number of C4 and the relative dosages of C4A and C4B in a diploid genome. These techniques include (1) definitive genomic restriction-fragment-length polymorphisms (RFLPs) based on the discrete duplication patterns of the RCCX (RP-C4-CYP21-TNX) modules and on the specific nucleotide changes for C4A and C4B isotypes; (2) module-specific PCR to give information on the total number of C4 genes by comparing the relative quantities of RP1- or TNXB-specific fragments with TNXA-RP2 fragments; (3) labeled-primer single-cycle DNA polymerization procedure of amplified C4d genomic DNA for diagnostic RFLP analysis of C4A and C4B; and (4) a highly reproducible long-range-mapping method that employs PmeI-digested genomic DNA for pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, to yield precise information on the number of long and short C4 genes in a haplotype. Applications of these vigorously tested techniques may clarify the roles that human C4A and C4B gene-dosage variations play in infectious and autoimmune diseases.

Phenotypes, genotypes and disease susceptibility associated with gene copy number variations: complement C4 CNVs in European American healthy subjects and those with systemic lupus erythematosus.

A new paradigm in human genetics is high frequencies of inter-individual variations in copy numbers of specific genomic DNA segments. Such common copy number variation (CNV) loci often contain genes engaged in host-environment interaction including those involved in immune effector functions. DNA sequences within a CNV locus often share a high degree of identity but beneficial or deleterious polymorphic variants are present among different individuals. Thus, common gene CNVs can contribute, both qualitatively and quantitatively, to a spectrum of phenotypic variants. In this review we describe the phenotypic and genotypic diversities of complement C4 created by copy number variations of RCCX modules (RP-C4-CYP21-TNX) and size dichotomy of C4 genes. A direct outcome of C4 CNV is the generation of two classes of polymorphic proteins, C4A and C4B, with differential chemical reactivities towards peptide or carbohydrate antigens, and a range of C4 plasma protein concentrations (from 15 to 70 mg/dl) among healthy subjects. Deliberate molecular genetic studies enabled development of definitive techniques to determine exact patterns of RCCX modular variations, copy numbers of long and short C4A and C4B genes by Southern blot analyses or by real-time quantitative PCR. It is found that in healthy European Americans, the total C4 gene copy number per diploid genome ranges from 2 to 6: 60.8% of people with four copies of C4 genes, 27.2% with less than four copies, and 12% with more than four copies. Such a distribution is skewed towards the low copy number side in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), a prototypic autoimmune disease with complex etiology. In SLE, the frequency of individuals with less than four copies of C4 is significantly increased (42.2%), while the frequency of those with more than four copies is decreased (6%). This decrease in total C4 gene copy number in SLE is due to increases in homozygous and heterozygous deficiencies of C4A but not C4B. Therefore, it is concluded that lower copy number of C4 is a risk factor for and higher gene copy number of C4 is a protective factor against SLE disease susceptibility.

Dancing with complement C4 and the RP-C4-CYP21-TNX (RCCX) modules of the major histocompatibility complex.

The number of the complement component C4 genes varies from 2 to 8 in a diploid genome among different human individuals. Three quarters of the C4 genes in Caucasian populations have the endogenous retrovirus, HERV-K(C4), in the ninth intron. The remainder does not. The C4 serum proteins are highly polymorphic and their concentrations vary from 100 to approximately 1000 microg/ml. There are two distinct classes of C4 protein, C4A and C4B, which have diversified to fulfill (a) the opsonization/immunoclearance purposes and (b) the well-known complement function in the killing of microbes by lysis and neutralization, respectively. Many infectious and autoimmune diseases are associated with complete or partial deficiency of C4A and/or C4B. The adverse effects of high C4 gene dosages, however, are just emerging, as the concepts of human C4 genetics are revised and accurate techniques are applied to distinguish partial deficiencies from differential expression caused by unequal C4A and C4B gene dosages and gene sizes. This review attempts to dissect the sophisticated genetics of complement C4A and C4B. The emphases are on the qualitative and quantitative diversities of C4 genotypes and phenotypes. The many allotypic variants and the processed products of human and mouse C4 proteins are described. The modular variation of C4 genes together with the serine/threonine nuclear kinase gene RP, the steroid 21-hydroxylase CYP21, and extracellular matrix protein TNX (RCCX modules) are investigated for the effects on homogenization of C4 protein polymorphisms, and on the unequal genetic crossovers that knocked out the functions of CYP21 and/or TNX. Furthermore, the influence of the endogenous retrovirus HERV-K(C4) on C4 gene expression and the dispersal of HERV-K(C4) family members in the human genome are discussed.

Great genotypic and phenotypic diversities associated with copy-number variations of complement C4 and RP-C4-CYP21-TNX (RCCX) modules: A comparison of Asian-Indian and European American populations

Inter-individual gene copy-number variations (CNVs) probably afford human populations the flexibility to respond to a variety of environmental challenges, but also lead to differential disease predispositions. We investigated gene CNVs for complement component C4 and steroid 21-hydroxylase from the RP-C4-CYP21-TNX (RCCX) modules located in the major histocompatibility complex among healthy Asian-Indian Americans (AIA) and compared them to European Americans. A combination of definitive techniques that yielded cross-confirmatory results was used. The medium gene copy-numbers for C4 and its isotypes, acidic C4A and basic C4B, were 4, 2 and 2, respectively, but their frequencies were only 53-56%. The distribution patterns for total C4 and C4A are skewed towards the high copy-number side. For example, the frequency of AIA-subjects with three copies of C4A (30.7%) was 3.92-fold of those with a single copy (7.83%). The monomodular-short haplotype with a single C4B gene and the absence of C4A, which is in linkage-disequilibrium with HLA DRB1*0301 in Europeans and a strong risk factor for autoimmune diseases, has a frequency of 0.012 in AIA but 0.106 among healthy European Americans (p=6.6x10(-8)). The copy-number and the size of C4 genes strongly determine the plasma C4 protein concentrations. Parallel variations in copy-numbers of CYP21A (CYP21A1P) and TNXA with total C4 were also observed. Notably, 13.1% of AIA-subjects had three copies of the functional CYP21B, which were likely generated by recombinations between monomodular and bimodular RCCX haplotypes. The high copy-numbers of C4 and the high frequency of RCCX recombinants offer important insights to the prevalence of autoimmune and genetic diseases.

Relationship between complement components C4A and C4B diversities and two TNFA promoter polymorphisms in two healthy Caucasian populations

The RP-C4-CYP21-TNX (RCCX) modules and the tumor necrosis factor (TNF) gene cluster are probably the most polymorphic genomic regions in the human central major histocompatibility complex (MHC). Using definitive methods for genotypic and phenotypic analyses of complement components C4A and C4B, determination of the RCCX length variants, and SSP-PCR/RFLP analyses of TNFA promoter polymorphisms at positions -308 and -238, we studied the complex relationships between the C4 and TNFA polymorphisms in two normal Caucasian populations. The patterns of the RCCX modular structures and the allelic frequency of -308A TNFA (TNF2) were similar between the Budapest (n = 125) and the Ohio (n = 80) Caucasians. However, the frequency of the -238A allele was significantly higher in the Ohio (11.3%) than in the Budapest (1.6%) study population (p < 0.0001). Marked features were found in the RCCX length variants in the TNF2 carriers and noncarriers. Strong associations were found between the C4AQ0 B1 haplotype from the monomodular short (mono-S) RCCX structure and the TNF2 allele, and between the C4A6 B1 haplotype from the bimodular long-short (LS) structure of the RCCX and the TNFA -238A allele. However, 36%-46% of the TNF2 carriers did not associate with a mono-S in both study cohorts, and 57.1% of the TNFA -238A carriers in Ohio did not associate with C4A6, which has a defective complement C5 convertase activity. The carriers of TNF2 allele had significantly lower C4A serum concentration (0.17 +/- 0.08 g/l) than noncarriers (0.23 +/- 0.09 g/l) (p < 0.001). The lowest C4A serum levels were found in TNF2 carriers with mono-S structures (0.14 +/- 0.06 g/l). In essence, our results demonstrated the heterogeneities of the TNFA promoter polymorphisms, and the linkage disequilibrium of TNFA -308A and -238A alleles with complement C4A deficiency and impaired C4A protein function, respectively.