Helle Malerod

On-line solid phase extraction-liquid chromatography, with emphasis on modern bioanalysis and miniaturized systems.

On-line solid phase extraction (SPE)-liquid chromatography (LC) allows for automated, sensitive, precise and selective bioanalysis. It is a common feature in miniaturized- or nano LC systems, which are well suited for applications requiring high sensitivity and/or treatment of limited samples (laser micro-dissection samples, rare cancer stem cells, etc.). Traditionally, particles with reversed phase (RP) functional groups are used for the columns in SPE-LC systems. There is however an expanding diversity in SPE-LC combinations applied to meet todays bioanalytical challenges. Current online SPE-LC combinations employ, e.g. porous graphitic carbon (PGC) and hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) materials for metabolomics and glycomics, restricted access media (RAM) columns coupled with nano LC for peptidomics, immunoaffinity trap columns for targeted proteomics and metal oxide affinity phases for phosphopeptide analysis. However, issues can arise when combining different phases in on-line SPE-LC, e.g. due to solvent incompatibilities between enrichment/separation principles and sample solvent requirements. Consequences can be low recovery and poor resolution, or need for additional instrumentation. On-line SPE-LC with very narrow columns (10-20 μm inner diameters) can be appropriate to obtain maximum sensitivity and information. In such highly miniaturized systems, non-particulate columns are arguably more suited (e.g. monolithic or porous layer open tubular (PLOT) columns) as e.g. hardware contributions resulting in extra column volumes are reduced. Basic SPE-LC systems can be configured/modified to perform quite complex analytical operations, and certain columns, configurations and hardware can improve robustness.

Recent advances in on-line multidimensional liquid chromatography

Multidimensional liquid chromatography (MD LC) has, due to enhanced peak capacity compared to one-dimensional LC, become an important analytical tool for separating components in complex samples, e.g. in proteomics. MD LC can be performed both on-line and off-line. Because of the advantages like possible automation and minimal sample loss, on-line MD LC has appeared to be very attractive also for high throughput analysis. This review includes only on-line coupled MD LC. Different aspects related to the compatibility of separation principles and column dimensions are highlighted and recent applications using on-line mainly two-dimensional (2D) LC have been included.

Improving the resolution of neuropeptides in rat brain with on-line HILIC-RP compared to on-line SCX-RP.

Our two already established on-line 2-D LC systems, a strong cation exchange-RP chromatography (SCX-RP) system and a hydrophilic interaction LC (HILIC)-RP 2-D LC system, were compared to explore which system is best suited for our further studies of differences in cerebral neuropeptide expression as a function of hypoxia-caused stress. The same mass spectrometer and database search parameters were applied in both systems. In total, 19 first dimension fractions were collected with the novel on-line HILIC-RP system, including a Hypercarb SPE column that was applied to trap the compounds not retained on a Kromasil C18 enrichment column. In contrast, six fractions were collected in the SCX-RP method, due to practical limitations of this traditional on-line 2-D LC system. With the on-line HILIC-RP system three times more peaks were detected. It was observed that most of the compounds eluted in the first two fractions in the SCX-RP method, while in the 2-D HILIC-RP method there seemed to be no correlation between peaks detected and fraction number. Thus, from this systematic study it seems that on-line HILIC-RP chromatography is the method of choice for comparative peptidomics of cerebral neuropeptides in future studies.

Hydrophilic interaction chromatography of nucleoside triphosphates with temperature as a separation parameter

Eight deoxynucleoside triphosphates (dNTPs) and nucleoside triphosphates (NTPs): ATP, CTP, GTP, UTP, dATP, dCTP, dGTP and dTTP, were separated with two 15 cm ZIC-pHILIC columns coupled in series, using LC-UV instrumentation. The polymer-based ZIC-pHILIC column gave significantly better separations and peak shape than a silica-based ZIC-HILIC column. Better separations were obtained with isocratic elution as compared to gradient elution. The temperature markedly affected the selectivity and could be used to fine tune separation. The analysis time was also affected by temperature, as lower temperatures surprisingly reduced the retention of the nucleotides. dNTP/NTP standards could be separated in 35 min with a flow rate of 200 μL/min. In Escherichia coli cell culture samples dNTP/NTPs could be selectively separated in 7 0min using a flow rate of 100 μL/min.

Critical assessment of accelerating trypsination methods

In LC-MS based proteomics, several accelerating trypsination methods have been introduced in order to speed up the protein digestion, which is often considered a bottleneck. Traditionally and most commonly, due to sample heterogeneity, overnight digestion at 37 °C is performed in order to digest both easily and more resistant proteins. High efficiency protein identification is important in proteomics, hours with LC-MS/MS analysis is needless if the majority of the proteins are not digested. Based on preliminary experiments utilizing some of the suggested accelerating methods, the question of whether accelerating digestion methods really provide the same protein identification efficiency as the overnight digestion was asked. In the present study we have evaluated four different accelerating trypsination methods (infrared (IR) and microwave assisted, solvent aided and immobilized trypsination). The methods were compared with conventional digestion at 37 °C in the same time range using a four protein mixture. Sequence coverage and peak area of intact proteins were used for the comparison. The accelerating methods were able to digest the proteins, but none of the methods appeared to be more efficient than the conventional digestion method at 37 °C. The conventional method at 37 °C is easy to perform using commercially available instrumentation and appears to be the digestion method to use. The digestion time in targeted proteomics can be optimized for each protein, while in comprehensive proteomics the digestion time should be extended due to sample heterogeneity and influence of other proteins present. Recommendations regarding optimizing and evaluating the tryptic digestion for both targeted and comprehensive proteomics are given, and a digestion method suitable as the first method for newcomers in comprehensive proteomics is suggested.

A Critical Review of Trypsin Digestion for LC-MS Based Proteomics

Proteomics is defined as the large-scale study of proteins in particular for their structures and functions (Anderson and Anderson 1998), and investigations of proteins have become very important since they are the main components of the physiological metabolic pathways in eukaryotic cells. Proteomics increasingly plays an important role in areas like protein interaction studies, biomarker discovery, cancer prevention, drug treatment and disease screening medical diagnostics (Capelo et al. 2009). Proteomics can be performed either in a comprehensive or “shotgun” mode, where proteins are identified in complex mixtures, or as “targeted proteomics” where “selective reaction monitoring” (SRM) is used to choose in advance the proteins to observe, and then measuring them accurately, by optimizing the sample preparation as well as the LC-MS method in accordance to the specific proteins (Mitchell 2010). Whether “MS-based shotgun proteomics” has accomplished anything at all regarding clinically useful results was recently addressed by Peter Mitchell in a feature article (Mitchell 2010), and he states that the field needs to make a further step or even change direction. Referring to discussions with among others John Yates and Matthias Mann, Mitchell addresses the failure in the search for biomarkers as indicators of disease, the difficulties of protein arrays, the uncertainty of quantification in “shotgun proteomics” (due to among others the efficiency of ionization in the mass spectrometers), database shortcomings, the problems of detecting post translational modifications (PTMs), and finally the huge disappointment in the area of drug discovery. The field points in the direction of targeted proteomics, but targeted proteomics will not be the solution to all our questions and comprehensive proteomics will still be needed. In order to get as much information, with as high quality as possible, from a biological sample, both the sample preparation and the final LC-MS analyses need to be optimized. The most important step in the sample preparation for proteomics is the conversion of proteins to peptides and in most cases trypsin is used as enzyme. Trypsin is a protease that specifically cleaves the proteins creating peptides both in the preferred mass range for MS sequencing and with a basic residue at the carboxyl terminus of the peptide, producing information-rich, easily interpretable peptide fragmentation mass spectra. Some other proteases can be used as well, such as Lys-C, which is active in more harsh conditions with 8 M urea, and give larger fragments than trypsin. Asp-N and Glu-C are also highly sequence-

High efficiency, high temperature separations on silica based monolithic columns.

The effect of temperature on separation using reversed-phase monolithic columns has been investigated using a nano-LC pumping system for gradient separation of tryptic peptides with MS detection. A goal of this study was to find optimal conditions for high-speed separations. The chromatographic performance of the columns was evaluated by peak capacity and peak capacity per time unit. Column lengths ranging from 20 to 100 cm and intermediate gradient times from 10 to 30 min were investigated to assess the potential of these columns in a final step separation, e.g. after fractionation or specific sample preparation. Flow rates from 250 to 2000 nL/min and temperatures from 20 to 120°C were investigated. Temperature had a significant effect on fast separations, and a flow rate of 2000 nL/min and a temperature of 80°C gave the highest peak capacity per time unit. These settings produced 70% more protein identifications in a biological sample compared to a conventional packed column. Alternatively, an equal amount of protein identifications was obtained with a 40% reduction in run time compared to the conventional packed column.

Large volume injection of aqueous peptide samples on a monolithic silica based zwitterionic-hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography system for characterization of posttranslational modifications

Zwitterionic-hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) has been found very appropriate for separation of polar compounds and peptides with post-translational modifications (PTMs) such as phosphorylation and glycosylation. In this study, a column switching system based on zwitterionic-HILIC silica based monolith columns was used for enrichment and separation of peptides and characterization of N-linked glycosylation by higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD) Orbitrap mass spectrometry (MS). Peptides were found to be retained on a zwitterionic-HILIC precolumn, even in an aqueous buffer due to electrostatic interactions. Thus, a novel approach of using a zwitterionic-HILIC precolumn, for introduction of an aqueous sample such as a tryptic digest, followed by HILIC separation of the peptides is presented. The repeatability and loadability of the zwitterionic-HILIC-zwitterionic-HILIC column switching system were explored using a tryptic digest of transferrin and a mixture of six proteins. The column switching system was furthermore used to enrich and separate a tryptic digested rat liver extract gel fraction, where in total 48 peptides corresponding to 14 proteins were identified. N-linked glycoforms were also identified, both in the standard test proteins (transferrin and six protein mixture digest) and the rat liver extract fraction. In all cases, the identified N-linked glycoforms were identified at the end of the gradient, at high aqueous buffer content in the mobile phase, showing the suitability of the developed method for characterization of glycosylated peptides in aqueous samples.

2‐D hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography‐RP separation in urinary proteomics – Minimizing variability through improved downstream workflow compatibility

Optimization of every step in a bottom-up urinary proteomics approach was studied with respect to maximize the protein recovery and making the downstream steps in the workflow fully compatible without compromising on the amount of information obtained. Sample enrichment and desalting using centrifugal filtration (5 kDa cut-off) yielded protein recoveries up to 97% when 8 M urea was used. Although yielding lower recoveries (88%), addition of Tris-HCl/NaCl was considered a better choice due to good down-stream compatibility. The consecutive depletion of HSA, using an immunoaffinity column was successfully adapted for use in urine. Separation of the trypsin generated peptides in an offline 2-D chromatographic system consisting of a hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography column, followed by a RP chromatography column showed a high peak capacity and good repeatability in addition to a high degree of orthogonality. All operations were modified in order to keep sample handling between every step to a minimum, reducing the variability of each process. In order to test the suitability of the full method in an extensive proteomic experiment, a urine sample from a kidney-transplanted patient was analyzed (n 5 6). The total variability of the method was identified with RSD values ranging from 11 to 30%. Eventually, we identified a total of 1668 peptides and 438 proteins from a single urine sample despite the use of low-resolution MS/MS equipment. The optimized and ‘‘streamlined’’ complex method has shown potential for use in future urinary proteomic studies. Urine