Hirofumi Kuwahara

Validation study of the Short Time Exposure (STE) test to assess the eye irritation potential of chemicals.

Short time exposure (STE) test is a cytotoxicity test in SIRC cells (rabbit corneal cell line) that assesses eye irritation potential following a 5-min chemical exposure. This validation study assessed transferability, intra- and inter-laboratory reproducibility, and predictive capacity of STE test in five laboratories (supported by Japanese Society for Alternatives to Animal Experiments). Sodium lauryl sulfate, calcium thioglycolate, and Tween 80 were evaluated, in triplicate, using 5%, 0.5%, and 0.05% concentrations in physiological saline, to confirm transferability. Good transferability was noted when similar mean relative viabilities and rank classifications were obtained in all five laboratories and were comparable to data from test method developing laboratory. Good intra- and inter-laboratory reproducibility was obtained with four assay controls (three solvents and one positive control), and four assay controls and 25 chemicals, respectively. STE irritation category based on relative viability of a 5% solution of 25 blinded test chemicals showed good correlation with Globally Harmonized System (GHS) categories (NI; I: Cat. 1 and 2). The STE prediction model, using relative viability of the 5% and 0.05% solutions, provided an irritation rank (1, 2, or 3) that had a good correlation (above 80%), or predictive capacity, with GHS irritation ranks in all laboratories. Based on these findings, the STE test is a promising alternative eye irritation test that could be easily standardized.

An interlaboratory study of the short time exposure (STE) test using SIRC cells for predicting eye irritation potential

We have developed the short time exposure (STE) test using a rabbit corneal cell line (SIRC cells) as an alternative eye irritation test. The STE test uses relative viability as the endpoint after cells are exposed to the test material at 5%, 0.5%, and 0.05% concentrations for 5 minutes. In this interlaboratory study, 2 laboratories conducted the test using 70 raw materials in order to evaluate transferability, between-laboratory reproducibility, and predictive capacity of the STE test as an alternative eye irritation test. Transferability was assessed using saline as a negative control and 0.01% sodium lauryl sulfate as a positive control. The relative viabilities obtained for the 2 laboratories were almost the same. Therefore, transferability was considered to be excellent. The 2 laboratories showed similar relative viabilities for all 70 raw materials at each test concentration. The correspondence rates of the eye irritation categories (irritants and nonirritants) were over 97% for each concentration tested, exhibiting high between-laboratory reproducibility. The correspondence rates for predicting eye irritation potential of undiluted raw materials and a diluted solution (10%) were over 85% at each laboratory for the 5% and 0.05% test concentrations in the STE. Lastly, the correspondence rate for the rank classification by the STE test prediction model at each laboratory was over 72%, and the correspondence rate became almost 90% when acids, amines, and alcohols were excluded from the analysis. From the above data, excellent transferability, high between-laboratory reproducibility, and high predictive capacity of the STE test were observed in the interlaboratory study by 2 laboratories.

Second-phase validation study of short time exposure test for assessment of eye irritation potency of chemicals.

A Short Time Exposure (STE) test is a cytotoxicity test that uses SIRC cells (rabbit corneal cell line) to assess eye irritation potency following a 5-min chemical exposure. This second-phase validation study assessed the predictive capacity of the STE test using 40 coded test substances at three laboratories. A Validation Management Team (VMT) then evaluated the predictivity of the STE test for United Nation (UN) Globally Harmonized System (GHS) categories using 63 test substances including the results of the first-phase validation study. The STE test can assess not only the severe or corrosive ocular irritants (corresponding to the UN GHS Category 1) but also non-irritant (corresponding to UN GHS Non Category) from other toxicity classes, especially for limited types of test substances. The predictivity by STE test, however, was insufficient for identification of UN GHS categories (Category 1, Category 2, or Non Category). These results suggest that the STE test can be recommended as an initial step in a top-down approach to identification of severe irritants and test substances that require classification for eye irritation (UN GHS Category 1) as well as an initial step in a bottom-up approach to identification of test substances that do not require classification for eye irritation (UN GHS Non Category) from other toxicity classes, especially for limited types of test substances. On the other hand, the STE test is not considered adequate for the identification of mild or moderate irritants (i.e., UN GHS Categories 2A and 2B) and severe irritants (UN GHS Category 1).