J. Larry Campbell

Differential mobility spectrometry-driven shotgun lipidomics.

The analysis of lipids by mass spectrometry (MS) can provide in-depth characterization for many forms of biological samples. However, such workflows can also be hampered by challenges like low chromatographic resolution for lipid separations and the convolution of mass spectra from isomeric and isobaric species. To address these issues, we describe the use of differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) as a rapid and predictable separation technique within a shotgun lipidomics workflow, with a special focus on phospholipids (PLs). These analytes, ionized by electrospray ionization (ESI), are filtered using DMS prior to MS analysis. The observed separation (measured in terms of DMS compensation voltage) is affected by several factors, including the m/z of the lipid ion, the structure of an individual ion, and the presence of chemical modifiers in the DMS cell. Such DMS separations can simplify the analysis of complex extracts in a robust and reproducible manner, independent of utilized MS instrumentation. The predictable separation achieved with DMS can facilitate correct lipid assignments among many isobaric and isomeric species independent of the resolution settings of the MS analysis. This leads to highly comprehensive and quantitative lipidomic outputs through rapid profiling analyses, such as Q1 and MRM scans. The ultimate benefit of the DMS separation in this unique shotgun lipidomics workflow is its ability to separate many isobaric and isomeric lipids that by standard shotgun lipidomics workflows are difficult to assess precisely, for example, ether and diacyl species and phosphatidylcholine (PC) and sphingomyelin (SM) lipids.

Ozone-induced dissociation on a modified tandem linear ion-trap: observations of different reactivity for isomeric lipids

Ozone-induced dissociation (OzID) exploits the gas-phase reaction between mass-selected lipid ions and ozone vapor to determine the position(s) of unsaturation. In this contribution, we describe the modification of a tandem linear ion-trap mass spectrometer specifically for OzID analyses wherein ozone vapor is supplied to the collision cell. This instrumental configuration provides spatial separation between mass-selection, the ozonolysis reaction, and mass-analysis steps in the OzID process and thus delivers significant enhancements in speed and sensitivity (ca. 30-fold). These improvements allow spectra revealing the double-bond position(s) within unsaturated lipids to be acquired within 1 s: significantly enhancing the utility of OzID in high-throughput lipidomic protocols. The stable ozone concentration afforded by this modified instrument also allows direct comparison of relative reactivity of isomeric lipids and reveals reactivity trends related to (1) double-bond position, (2) substitution position on the glycerol backbone, and (3) stereochemistry. For cis- and trans-isomers, differences were also observed in the branching ratio of product ions arising from the gas-phase ozonolysis reaction, suggesting that relative ion abundances could be exploited as markers for double-bond geometry. Additional activation energy applied to mass-selected lipid ions during injection into the collision cell (with ozone present) was found to yield spectra containing both OzID and classical-CID fragment ions. This combination CID-OzID acquisition on an ostensibly simple monounsaturated phosphatidylcholine within a cow brain lipid extract provided evidence for up to four structurally distinct phospholipids differing in both double-bond position and sn-substitution.

Probing electrospray ionization dynamics using differential mobility spectrometry: the curious case of 4-aminobenzoic acid.

Here, we present the separation of two ions that differ only by the site of protonation of the analyte molecule using differential mobility spectrometry (DMS). Protonated 4-aminobenzoic acid molecules (4-ABA) generated by positive-mode electrospray ionization [ESI(+)] can exist with the proton residing on either the amine nitrogen (N-protonated) or the carboxylic acid oxygen (O-protonated), and the protonation site can differ on the basis of the solvent system used. In this study, we demonstrate the identification and separation of N- and O-protonated 4-ABA using DMS, with structural assignments verified by: (1) the presence of distinct peaks in the DMS ionogram, (2) the observed effects resulting from altering the ESI(+) solvent system, (3) the observed (13)C NMR chemical shifts arising from altering the solvent system, (4) the observation of distinct MS/MS fragmentation patterns for the two DMS-separated ions, (5) the unique hydrogen-deuterium exchange behavior for these ions, and (6) the fundamental behavior of these two ions within the DMS cell, linked back to the structural differences between the two protonated forms.

Ion-Molecule Clustering in Differential Mobility Spectrometry: Lessons Learned from Tetraalkylammonium Cations and their Isomers

AbstractDifferential mobility spectrometry (DMS) can distinguish ions based upon the differences in their high- and low-field ion mobilities as they experience the asymmetric waveform applied to the DMS cell. These mobilities are known to be influenced by the ions’ structure, m/z, and charge distribution (i.e., resonance structures) within the ions themselves, as well as by the gas-phase environment of the DMS cell. While these associations have been developed over time through empirical observations, the exact role of ion structures or their interactions with clustering molecules remains generally unknown. In this study, that relationship is explored by observing the DMS behaviors of a series of tetraalkylammonium ions as a function of their structures and the gas-phase environment of the DMS cell. To support the DMS experiments, the basin-hopping search strategy was employed to identify candidate cluster structures for density functional theory treatment. More than a million cluster structures distributed across 72 different ion-molecule cluster systems were sampled to determine global minimum structures and cluster binding energies. This joint computational and experimental approach suggests that cluster geometry, in particular ion-molecule intermolecular separation, plays a critical role in DMS. Figureᅟ

Ozone-induced dissociation of conjugated lipids reveals significant reaction rate enhancements and characteristic odd-electron product ions

AbstractOzone-induced dissociation (OzID) is an alternative ion activation method that relies on the gas phase ion-molecule reaction between a mass-selected target ion and ozone in an ion trap mass spectrometer. Herein, we evaluated the performance of OzID for both the structural elucidation and selective detection of conjugated carbon-carbon double bond motifs within lipids. The relative reactivity trends for [M + X]+ ions (where X = Li, Na, K) formed via electrospray ionization (ESI) of conjugated versus nonconjugated fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs) were examined using two different OzID-enabled linear ion-trap mass spectrometers. Compared with nonconjugated analogues, FAMEs derived from conjugated linoleic acids were found to react up to 200 times faster and to yield characteristic radical cations. The significantly enhanced reactivity of conjugated isomers means that OzID product ions can be observed without invoking a reaction delay in the experimental sequence (i.e., trapping of ions in the presence of ozone is not required). This possibility has been exploited to undertake neutral-loss scans on a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer targeting characteristic OzID transitions. Such analyses reveal the presence of conjugated double bonds in lipids extracted from selected foodstuffs. Finally, by benchmarking of the absolute ozone concentration inside the ion trap, second order rate constants for the gas phase reactions between unsaturated organic ions and ozone were obtained. These results demonstrate a significant influence of the adducting metal on reaction rate constants in the fashion Li > Na > K.

Near-Complete Structural Characterization of Phosphatidylcholines Using Electron Impact Excitation of Ions from Organics

Although lipids are critical components of many cellular assemblies and biological pathways, accurate descriptions of their molecular structures remain difficult to obtain. Many benchtop characterization methods require arduous and time-consuming procedures, and multiple assays are required whenever a new structural feature is probed. Here, we describe a new mass-spectrometry-based workflow for enhanced structural lipidomics that, in a single experiment, can yield almost complete structural information for a given glycerophospholipid (GPL) species. This includes the lipids sum (Brutto) composition from the accurate mass measured for the intact lipid ion and the characteristic headgroup fragment, the regioisomer composition from fragment ions unique to the sn-1 and sn-2 positions, and the positions of carbon-carbon double bonds in the lipid acyl chains. Here, lipid ions are fragmented using electron impact excitation of ions from organics (EIEIO)--a technique where the singly charged lipid ions are irradiated by an electron beam, producing diagnostic product ions. We have evaluated this methodology on various lipid standards, as well as on a biological extract, to demonstrate this new methods utility.

Targeted Ion Parking for the Quantitation of Biotherapeutic Proteins: Concepts and Preliminary Data

Targeted ion parking (or TIPing) is the first quantitative application of ion/ion reactions for mass spectrometry. In TIPing, intact biotherapeutic proteins are electrosprayed as intact molecules (no digestion) and, as expected, many multiply protonated species are produced (e.g., (M + 7H)7+, (M + 8H)8+, etc.). Several of these multiply charged species are selectively isolated using a quadrupole mass analyzer and then contained in a linear ion trap. The protein ions are then subjected to a proton-transfer reaction with a reagent anion. The ions undergo sequential charge reduction (e.g., to (M + 6H)6+) during a defined reaction period. Applying a low-amplitude waveform to the trap during this reaction time stops the ion/ion reaction at a chosen (and predicted) charge state for the protein. This funnels the analyte ions into a single channel with relatively high efficiency (>-50% of reactant ion signal is converted into product ion signal) that can be used for quantitation. In TIPing, the target protein’s molecular weight and charge state distribution are the only prerequisite knowledge required. This information can be acquired experimentally or can be easily predicted based upon amino acid sequences. Preliminary data for a biotherapeutic protein, a domain antibody, were collected using TIPing coupled online with liquid chromatography (LC-TIPing). The LC-TIPing data demonstrate a linear response for samples from 10–1000 ng/mL extracted from a complex plasma sample, demonstrating the analytical potential for TIPing.

On performing simultaneous electron transfer dissociation and collision-induced dissociation on multiply protonated peptides in a linear ion trap

We propose a tandem mass spectrometry method that combines electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) with simultaneous collision-induced dissociation (CID), termed ETD/CID. This technique can provide more complete sequence coverage of peptide ions, especially those at lower charge states. A selected precursor ion is isolated and subjected to ETD. At the same time, a residual precursor ion is subjected to activation via CID. The specific residual precursor ion selected for activation will depend upon the charge state and m/z of the ETD precursor ion. Residual precursor ions, which include unreacted precursor ions and charge-reduced precursor ions (either by electron-transfer or proton transfer), are often abundant remainders in ETD-only reactions. Preliminary results demonstrate that during an ETD/CID experiment, b, y, c, and z-type ions can be produced in a single experiment and displayed in a single mass spectrum. While some peptides, especially doubly protonated ones, do not fragment well by ETD, ETD/CID alleviates this problem by acting in at least one of three ways: (1) the number of ETD fragment ions are enhanced by CID of residual precursor ions, (2) both ETD and CID-derived fragments are produced, or (3) predominantly CID-derived fragments are produced with little or no improvement in ETD-derived fragment ions. Two interesting scenarios are presented that display the flexibility of the ETD/CID method. For example, smaller peptides that show little response to ETD are fragmented preferentially by CID during the ETD/CID experiment. Conversely, larger peptides with higher charge states are fragmented primarily via ETD. Hence, ETD/CID appears to rely upon the fundamental reactivity of the analyte cations to provide the best fragmentation without implementing any additional logic or MS/MS experiments. In addition to the ETD/CID experiments, we describe a novel dual source interface for providing front-end ETD capabilities on a linear ion trap mass spectrometer.

Studying Gas-Phase Interconversion of Tautomers Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry

AbstractIn this study, we report on the use of differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) as a tool for studying tautomeric species, allowing a more in-depth interrogation of these elusive isomers using ion/molecule reactions and tandem mass spectrometry. As an example, we revisit a case study in which gas-phase hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX)—a probe of ion structure in mass spectrometry—actually altered analyte ion structure by tautomerization. For the N- and O-protonated tautomers of 4-aminobenzoic acid, when separated using DMS and subjected to subsequent HDX with trace levels of D2O, the anticipated difference between the exchange rates of the two tautomers is observed. However, when using higher levels of D2O or a more basic reagent, equivalent and almost complete exchange of all labile protons is observed. This second observation is a result of the interconversion of the N-protonated tautomer to the O-protonated form during HDX. We can monitor this transformation experimentally, with support from detailed molecular dynamics and electronic structure calculations. In fact, calculations suggest the onset of bulk solution phase properties for 4-aminobenzoic acid upon solvation with eight CH3OH molecules. These findings also underscore the need for choosing HDX reagents and conditions judiciously when separating interconvertible isomers using DMS. Graphical Abstractᅟ

Combining liquid chromatography with ozone-induced dissociation for the separation and identification of phosphatidylcholine double bond isomers.

AbstractRevealing the inherent molecular diversity of lipid biology requires advanced analytical technologies. Distinguishing phospholipids that differ in the position(s) of carbon-carbon double bonds within their acyl chains presents a particular challenge because of their similar chromatographic and mass spectral behaviours. Here—for the first time—we combine reversed-phase liquid chromatography for separation of isomeric phospholipids with on-line mass spectral analysis by ozone-induced dissociation (OzID) for unambiguous double bond position assignment. The customised tandem linear ion-trap mass spectrometer used in our study is capable of acquiring OzID scans on a chromatographic timescale. Resolving the contributions of isomeric lipids that are indistinguishable based on conventional mass spectral analysis is achieved using the combination of liquid chromatography and OzID. Application of this method to the analysis of simple (egg yolk) and more complex (sheep brain) extracts reveals significant populations of the phosphatidylcholine PC 16:0_18:1(n−7) alongside the expected PC 16:0_18:1(n−9) isomer. Graphical AbstractSeparation and identification double bond positional isomers of phosphatidylcholines using LC-OzID