J.M. Brown

The effect of treatment in fractionated schedules with the combination of x-irradiation and six cytotoxic drugs on the RIF-1 tumor and normal mouse skin

RIF-1 tumors, implanted syngeneically in the gastrocnemius muscles of the right hind legs of C3H/Km mice, were treated either with X ray alone, drug alone, or drug and X ray combined. The drugs tested were bleomycin, BCNU, cis-diamminedichloro platinum, adriamycin, cyclophosphamide, and actinomycin-D. All drugs were administered either in the maximum tolerated dose or a dose that causes minimal tumor growth delay. Both drugs and X rays were administered either as a single dose or in five daily fractions. In addition to the single modality controls, seven different schedules of combined modalities were tested. Tumors were measured periodically after treatment in order that the day at which each tumor reached 4 times its initial cross-sectional area, i.e., its size at the time of treatment, could be determined. The effect of treatment on tumors was based upon excess growth delay (GD), i.e., T400% (treated)-T400% (untreated control). Treatment effects for the same combined modality schedules were also determined for normal skin, using the early skin reaction as an endpoint. Dose effect factors (DEF) were computed for all combined modality schedules and were based upon calculated radiation dose equivalents. We also calculated supra-additivity ratios, SRI and SRII, therapeutic gain factors and adjusted therapeutic gain factors. The only drugs to produce significant supra-additivity with X rays were cis-Pt and cyclo. Maximum supra-additivity for cis-Pt was afforded by divided doses of the drug (5 X 2.4 mg/kg/day) given immediately before X ray (5 X 1000 rad/day) on 5 consecutive days, although 3 other schedules also produced significant supra-additivity. Maximum supra-additivity for cyclo was seen for a single dose of 100 mg/kg followed 1 day later by a course of 5 daily X ray doses (5 X 1000 rad/day), and at least one other schedule produced almost as great an effect.

STRUCTURE-ACTIVITY RELATIONSHIPS FOR BENZOTRIAZINE DI-N-OXIDES

SR 4233 (3-amino-1,2,4-benzotriazine 1,4-dioxide) is a bioreductive agent that selectively kills and radiosensitizes hypoxic mammalian cells in vitro and murine tumors in vivo. In an attempt to better understand the mechanism of action of the drug, and to determine whether a superior analog may exist, 15 benzotriazine-di-N-oxide analogs of SR 4233 have been evaluated to date for the following properties: hypoxic and aerobic toxicity toward CHO cells in vitro, drug-induced stimulation of oxygen consumption by incubation with respiration-inhibited cells, and acute LD50 evaluated in BALB/c mice. We noted several correlations between these biological properties of the drugs and some of their physicochemical characteristics. Both the hypoxic cytotoxicity and stimulation of oxygen consumption by respiration-inhibited cells were positively correlated with E1/2, the polarographic half-wave reduction potential, and a measure of electron affinity. The air-to-nitrogen differential cytotoxicity reached a maximum (corresponding to SR 4233) and then declined with increasing E1/2. The acute LD50 of each analog in mice decreased with increasing E1/2. One new compound, SR 4482, was found to be more toxic to hypoxic cells in vitro, but less toxic to mice, than SR 4233. It is similar in structure to SR 4233, but lacks any substituent in the 3-position of the triazine ring. This promising drug may represent a member of a new subseries of 1,2,4-benzotriazines with different structure-activity relationships.

Changes in misonidazole binding with hypoxic fraction in mouse tumors

Binding of misonidazole (MISO) or a derivative to hypoxic cells in tumors has been proposed as a method for identifying tumors and measuring their level of hypoxia. We have recently shown that the hypoxic fraction of tumor cells can be altered over a wide range in vivo by acutely changing the hematocrit of the host animal by transfusion. The present study aimed to investigate the changes in binding by 14C MISO that accompanied this procedure. Tumor bearing mice were injected with 14C MISO, irradiated with a single dose of X rays (20 Gy) and their tumor excised and bisected. One half of each tumor was used to determine cell survival in vitro, the other was used for 14C scintillation counting. As previously described, tumor cell survival was dramatically increased in acutely anemic mice and this was accompanied by an increase in 14C MISO binding to the tumors. The relationship between clonogenic cell survival and binding was found to be linear on a log-log plot for each of the tumor lines studied, but the slopes of the lines were different tumor lines and generally steeper than the value of 1.0 expected for a 1:1 correspondence between cells binding radioactivity and radiobiological resistance. We attribute these differences to MISO binding to cells in the tumor which were not clonogenic.

The Effect of Alterations in Haematocrit on Tumour Sensitivity to X-rays

Hypoxic cells in human tumours probably contribute to the failure of radiotherapy in some sites. Changes in the oxygen carrying capacity of the blood, such as in anaemia, have been shown to influence tumour response. The effect of acute and chronic changes in haematocrit on the radiosensitivity of three mouse tumours (EMT6, KHT and RIF-1) were studied. Alterations in haematocrit were achieved by bleeding followed by retransfusion. When radiation was preceded immediately by an acute reduction in haematocrit (anaemia), radiosensitivity was markedly reduced in each tumour. An acute rise in haematocrit (polycythaemia) increased or decreased X-ray sensitivity depending on its severity. The optimum haematocrit for maximum sensitivity was always found to be at a level 5-10 per cent above normal. When the time between induction of anaemia and irradiation was increased, simulating a progressively longer duration of anaemia, marked changes in radiosensitivity of all the tumours were observed. A short duration of anaemia resulted in a resistant tumour with each cell line, but the resistance was gradually lost as the anaemia was prolonged, even though no recovery in haematocrit occurred. The rate of recovery to normal radiosensitivity varied from 24 to 72 hours in the different tumours. Therefore, only haematocrit changes which occurred within 1-3 days of a dose of radiation affect the radiosensitivity of these tumours.

The therapeutic potential of misonidazole enhancement of alkylating agent cytotoxicity.

The effect of prolonged exposure to low misonidazole (MISO) levels on the cytotoxicity of three alkylating agents was studied in mouse tumors. A concentration of 100 micrograms/ml was maintained in the plasma for 7 hr by multiple injections of MISO. Cyclophosphamide (CYC). Melphalan (L-PAM), or CCNU were given after 4 hrs of MISO exposure. In each case, prolonged low level MISO exposure enhanced tumor response as measured by regrowth delay or a cloning assay. The effect of this treatment was also studied in several normal tissues: bone marrow, white blood cell counts, and spermatogonia. In none of these was any enhancement seen after prolonged MISO exposure. These encouraging results show that clinically relevant exposures to MISO can greatly improve tumor response to alkylating agents without increased normal tissue toxicity.

STRUCTURE-ACTIVITY RELATIONSHIPS FOR TUMOUR RADIOSENSITIZATION BY ANALOGUES OF NICOTINAMIDE AND BENZAMIDE

Nicotinamide has been shown in our laboratory and those of other investigators to be an effective radiosensitizer of a variety of mouse tumours, while producing little or no radiosensitization of normal tissues. Its mechanism of action is different from classical electron-affinic compounds and appears to be the result of improved tumour oxygenation. In this study we have synthesized 29 analogues of nicotinamide and benzamide and characterized them for their tumour radiosensitization and acute toxicity in mice. The data show that a wide range of additions to the nicotinamide and benzamide ring produce tumour radiosensitization similar to that produced by equimolar doses of misonidazole, but that substitutions of the amide tend to reduce radiosensitization. Other structure-activity relationships are evident. Although some compounds produce similar tumour radiosensitization to nicotinamide at equimolar doses, and are comparably low in acute toxicity, none appears sufficiently superior to supplant nicotinamide itself as a candidate for clinical trials. Thus these data provide evidence that nicotinamide, because of the extensive experience with its use in man, is likely to be the best drug in the benzamide-nicotinamide series for development as a radiosensitizer of human tumours.

The effect of timing on chemosensitization by clinical levels of SR-2508

The nitroimidazole SR-2508 is currently being tested clinically as a radiosensitizer. Its relatively low toxicity allows it to be used at higher doses than misonidazole so that its potential as a chemosensitizer is also of considerable interest. Multiple injections of SR-2508 were given to SCC VII/St tumor-bearing mice to achieve a clinically realistic plasma concentration of approximately 300 micrograms/ml over 8 hrs. Single doses of melphalan (L-PAM) or cyclophosphamide (CY) were given at different times after the first SR 2508 injection. With L-PAM, a delay of at least 2 hr was necessary before enhancement of L-PAM cytotoxicity was observed. A similar result was obtained when a simulation was carried out with SCC VII/St tumor cells in vitro. Results with CY were less clear, although the most consistent enhancement was observed when a 4 to 8 hr interval elapsed between the beginning of SR 2508 exposure and the CY injection. In general, although precise timing was not essential for enhancement, an interval of at least 4 hr is recommended between the administration of SR 2508 and either alkylating agent. This is particularly important for L-PAM where no enhancement would be expected if the drugs were given simultaneously.

Enhancement of melphalan cytotoxicity in vivo and in vitro by inhibitors of poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase

In these preliminary experiments, we have found enhanced cell killing by the bifunctional alkylating agent L-phenylalanine mustard (L-PAM) in the presence of inhibitors of poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (ADPRP) in vitro. In vivo enhancement of the tumoricidal effects of L-PAM was observed with the ADPRP inhibitor nicotinamide (1000 mg/kg), although enhanced myelosuppression was also demonstrated. Nicotinamide also increased the plasma elimination half-life of L-PAM by a factor of at least 2. This alteration of L-PAm pharmacokinetics makes it difficult to assess the role that ADPRP inhibition plays in the enhancement of L-PAM tumor cell killing in vivo.

Hydralazine does not increase hypoxia in tumors growing in preirradiated tissue

There is a growing interest in the exploitation of hypoxia in solid tumors for therapeutic gain by the use of hypoxic cytotoxins and other agents. Tumor hypoxia can be greatly increased in a number of animal tumor models with the vasoactive drug hydralazine (HDZ), and in some cases this potentiates the effect of drugs that are selectively toxic to hypoxic cells. Our interest was to determine if HDZ would also increase tumor hypoxia in tumors growing in previously irradiated normal tissue- a situation such as might be found in the clinic with regrowing solid tumors after radiotherapy. SCCVII tumors in untreated mice were compared with tumors growing in a previously irradiated tissue with respect to their level of hypoxia in response to HDZ. HDZ increased tumor hypoxia in the tumors from unirradiated mice as measured by 14C-misonidazole binding. However, HDZ had little or no effect on tumor hypoxia in tumors growing in previously irradiated sites. We also showed that the pre-HDZ extent of hypoxia was higher in tumors growing in a previously irradiated tissue. This may in part explain the lack of effect of HDZ in these tumors. The lack of response of the tumors growing in irradiated sites suggests a limitation on the use of HDZ in combination with specific hypoxic cytotoxins or other chemotherapeutic drugs in the treatment of recurrent solid tumors. The data also show that if such tumors have an elevated hypoxic fraction relative to their counterparts growing in untreated sites, these tumors might be intrinsically more resistant to conventional radiotherapy, but, on the other hand, might be sensitive to bioreductive drugs and more likely to be radiosensitized by a hypoxic cell sensitizer.