J. Regan

A prospective randomised trial of 4 Gy or 8 Gy single doses in the treatment of metastatic bone pain

270 patients with painful bone metastases requiring palliative radiotherapy were randomised to receive single fractions of 4 Gy or 8 Gy in a randomised trial. Pain scores and analgesic usage were recorded before treatment and at 2, 4, 8 and 12 weeks. Pain was assessed by patients on a 4 point graded scale using pain charts administered by a central trials office. Response was defined as an improved rating compared to the pretreatment value. Compliance with the pain chart was 72% at 4 weeks. At 4 weeks, the actual response rates were 69% for 8 Gy and 44% for 4 Gy (p less than 0.001), but there was no difference in complete response (no pain) rates at 4 weeks or duration of response between the two arms. It is concluded that 8 Gy gives a higher probability of pain relief than 4 Gy, but that 4 Gy can be an effective alternative in situations of reduced tolerance.

Cellular radiosensitivity and complication risk after curative radiotherapy

PURPOSE To test for an association between in vitro fibroblast radiosensitivity and complication risk in a case-control study of breast cancer patients treated under standard conditions in a clinical trial of radiotherapy dose fractionation. PATIENTS AND METHODS A cohort of patients participating in a randomised clinical trial of radiotherapy dose fractionation was selected on the basis of treatment-induced changes in the breast several years later. Thirty-nine cases with marked normal tissue changes were matched on several variables with 65 controls with no changes attributable to radiotherapy. Dermal fibroblast strains were established from duplicate skin biopsies, and clonogenic cell survival assays performed in triplicate after both high ( approximately 1.6 Gy/min) and low ( approximately 1 cGy/min) dose-rate irradiation. Laboratory studies were blind to patient identity, treatment outcome and radiotherapy schedule. RESULTS Analysis of 1128 clonogenic survival curves confirmed significant inter-patient variation in fibroblast radiosensitivity as measured by clonogenic survival. However, no association between fibroblast radiosensitivity and the development of late radiotherapy normal tissue effects was detected. CONCLUSIONS Inter-individual variation in cellular radiosensitivity may not be the main determinant of complication risk in patients undergoing radiotherapy for breast cancer. Other biological and technical factors may be more important in explaining the marked inter-patient differences in normal tissue damage evident several years after curative radiotherapy.

Effect of local radiotherapy for bone pain on urinary markers of osteoclast activity

Urinary markers of bone resorption, pyridinoline and deoxypyridinoline were measured before and at 4 weeks after radiotherapy for metastatic bone pain. An association was shown between relief of metastatic skeletal pain by radiotherapy and low marker concentrations before and after treatment, lending support to the hypothesis that relief of metastatic bone pain by radiotherapy relates to an effect on bone, rather than tumour physiology.

Heterozygosity for mutations in the ataxia telangiectasia gene is not a major cause of radiotherapy complications in breast cancer patients

Of patients being treated by radiotherapy for cancer, a small proportion develop marked long-term radiation damage. It is believed that this is due, at least in part, to intrinsic individual differences in radiosensitivity, but the underlying mechanism is unknown. Individuals affected by the recessive disease ataxia telangiectasia (AT) exhibit extreme sensitivity to ionizing radiation. Cells from such individuals are also radiosensitive in in vitro assays, and cells from AT heterozygotes are reported to show in vitro radiosensitivity at an intermediate level between homozygotes and control subjects. In order to examine the possibility that a defect in the ATM gene may account for a proportion of radiotherapy complications, 41 breast cancer patients developing marked changes in breast appearance after radiotherapy and 39 control subjects who showed no clinically detectable reaction after radiotherapy were screened for mutations in the ATM gene. One out of 41 cases showing adverse reactions was heterozygous for a mutation (insertion A at NT 898) that is predicted to generate a truncated protein of 251 amino acids. No truncating mutations were detected in the control subjects. On the basis of this result, the estimated percentage (95% confidence interval) of AT heterozygous patients in radiosensitive cases was 2.4% (0.1-12.9%) and in control subjects (0-9.0%). We conclude that ATM gene defects are not the major cause of radiotherapy complications in women with breast cancer.

The effectiveness of the routine clinic visit in the follow-up of breast cancer patients: Analysis of a defined patient cohort

The study aimed to identify the proportion of patients with relapse or a contralateral breast tumour who are diagnosed as a consequence of regular follow-up in a specialist breast clinic after breast conserving surgery and radiotherapy for early breast cancer. A retrospective review was undertaken of 490 consecutive patients entered into a randomized clinical trial of radiotherapy fractionation at a single institution. As part of the trial, patients were reviewed in a multidisciplinary breast clinic 3-monthly for the first 3 years, 6-monthly between 3 and 5 years and annually thereafter, with biennial mammography. For this study, information was retrieved from hospital records to ascertain: (a) whether patients were symptomatic at the time of relapse or contralateral breast tumour; and (b) whether they presented at a scheduled appointment or brought their appointment dates forward. The subsequent management of patients with relapse was reviewed to determine whether or not this may have been influenced favourably by a policy of regular follow-up. Twenty-one (44%) of the 48 patients with locoregional relapse were asymptomatic. Of these, 17 were detected by clinical examination (that is, directly as a result of a routine clinic attendance), while four were detected by routine mammography. Ten of the 17 patients diagnosed by clinical examination had successful surgery for locoregional relapse and all have remained disease free. Five of 17 developed distant metastases within 6 months and two others had skin nodules on the breast excised. Only three of the 67 patients with distant relapses were asymptomatic. Two of the 11 patients with contralateral breast tumours were asymptomatic and were diagnosed on routine mammography. The benefits and cost-effectiveness of less rigid approaches to follow-up of breast cancer patients needs to be evaluated in large prospective randomized trials.

Palliation and life quality in lung cancer; how good are clinicians at judging treatment outcome?

A recent trial by the MRC Lung Cancer Working Party used physician assessments to compare two palliative schedules of radiotherapy in lung cancer. A prospective study has been undertaken on a subset of these trial patients to see how physician assessments of symptomatic relief and general condition correlate with patient perception of therapeutic response. In 40 patients followed up monthly from presentation until close to death, good agreement was found between doctors and patients on change in specific physical symptoms and overall physical condition. Doctors were poor judges of life quality at presentation but appeared able to identify relative improvement or deterioration in overall quality of life. In conclusion, physician assessments may constitute valid end-points for radiotherapy trials comparing palliative schedules in lung cancer.

Dynamic MRI of breast hardness following radiation treatment

To evaluate functional microvascular characteristics of breast induration several years after radiation treatment using dynamic contrast‐enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (DCE‐MRI) techniques.

Magnetic resonance imaging of induration in the irradiated breast

BACKGROUND The causes of induration (hardness) in the breast many years after tumour excision and whole breast radiotherapy for early stage breast cancer are not well established. The purpose of this study is to describe morphological magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) appearances and MRI-derived microvascular functional characteristics of the indurated breast several years post-treatment. PATIENTS AND METHODS Fifteen women with moderate or marked induration at the electron boost site after breast preserving surgery and radiotherapy for early breast cancer (median 6 years; range, 2-15 years) underwent MRI, including 6/15 with very marked breast shrinkage and 8/15 with marked induration. Morphological T1- and T2-weighted and STIR images were obtained followed by a dynamic contrast medium enhanced sequence. The breast skin and underlying parenchyma of the irradiated breast were evaluated for thickening, oedema and the presence of enhancement compared to the contralateral breast. Particular note of boost site findings was made. RESULTS No evidence of tumour recurrence was seen. Fat necrosis was seen in 2/15 cases. Skin thickening and skin oedema not evident clinically were seen in 11/15 patients. Increased parenchymal oedema at the electron boost site was seen in 12/15 patients. The parenchymal oedema was not confined to the electron boost site, but was strongest in this location in 9/12 patients. Post-contrast images in 12/14 patients showed persistent parenchymal enhancement in nine (marked in three, who also had severe breast shrinkage and marked induration), a finding consistent with, but not diagnostic of tissue fibrosis. CONCLUSIONS Fat necrosis is not likely to contribute to breast induration several years after radiotherapy in more than a minority of patients. Increased fluid content in the breast parenchyma and skin oedema are likely to be more important contributors to palpable induration. Increased fluid content may be related to persistent capillary leakage even many years post-treatment, an expression of radiation-induced vascular injury. Fibrosis cannot be scored directly on MRI, but persistent parenchymal enhancement in a high proportion of post-contrast images is compatible with this pathology.

The influence of breast size on late radiation effects and association with radiotherapy dose inhomogeneity

A prospective assessment of late changes in breast appearance in 559 patients after tumour excision and radiotherapy for early breast cancer noted a strong association with breast size. Only 3/48 (6%) patients with small breasts developed moderate or severe late changes compared with 94/423 (22%) with medium sized breasts and 34/88 (39%) patients with large breasts (p < 0.001). One possibility is that greater radiation changes are related to greater dose inhomogeneity in women with large breasts. To explore this hypothesis, radiation dose distributions were assessed in a separate group of 37 women in whom three-level transverse computer tomographic images of the breast in the treatment position were available. A significant correlation was found between breast size and dose inhomogeneity which may account for the marked changes in breast appearance reported in women with large breasts.