J. Timothy Sage

Oriented Single-Crystal Nuclear Resonance Vibrational Spectroscopy of [Fe(TPP)(MI)(NO)]: Quantitative Assessment of the trans Effect of NO

This paper presents oriented single-crystal Nuclear Resonance Vibrational Spectroscopy (NRVS) data for the six-coordinate (6C) ferrous heme-nitrosyl model complex [(57)Fe(TPP)(MI)(NO)] (1; TPP(2-) = tetraphenylporphyrin dianion; MI = 1-methylimidazole). The availability of these data enables for the first time the detailed simulation of the complete NRVS data, including the porphyrin-based vibrations, of a 6C ferrous heme-nitrosyl, using our quantum chemistry centered normal coordinate analysis (QCC-NCA). Importantly, the Fe-NO stretch is split by interaction with a porphyrin-based vibration into two features, observed at 437 and 472 cm(-1). The 437 cm(-1) feature is strongly out-of-plane (oop) polarized and shows a (15)N(18)O isotope shift of 8 cm(-1) and is therefore assigned to nu(Fe-NO). The admixture of Fe-N-O bending character is small. Main contributions to the Fe-N-O bend are observed in the 520-580 cm(-1) region, distributed over a number of in-plane (ip) polarized porphyrin-based vibrations. The main component, assigned to delta(ip)(Fe-N-O), is identified with the feature at 563 cm(-1). The Fe-N-O bend also shows strong mixing with the Fe-NO stretching internal coordinate, as evidenced by the oop NRVS intensity in the 520-580 cm(-1) region. Very accurate normal mode descriptions of nu(Fe-NO) and delta(ip)(Fe-N-O) have been obtained in this study. These results contradict previous interpretations of the vibrational spectra of 6C ferrous heme-nitrosyls where the higher energy feature at approximately 550 cm(-1) had usually been associated with nu(Fe-NO). Furthermore, these results provide key insight into NO binding to ferrous heme active sites in globins and other heme proteins, in particular with respect to (a) the effect of hydrogen bonding to the coordinated NO and (b) changes in heme dynamics upon NO coordination. [Fe(TPP)(MI)(NO)] constitutes an excellent model system for ferrous NO adducts of myoglobin (Mb) mutants where the distal histidine (His64) has been removed. Comparison to the reported vibrational data for wild-type (wt) Mb-NO then shows that the effect of H bonding to the coordinated NO is weak and mostly leads to a polarization of the pi/pi* orbitals of bound NO. In addition, the observation that delta(ip)(Fe-N-O) does not correlate well with nu(N-O) can be traced back to the very mixed nature of this mode. The Fe-N(imidazole) stretching frequency is observed at 149 cm(-1) in [Fe(TPP)(MI)(NO)], and spectral changes upon NO binding to five-coordinate ferrous heme active sites are discussed. The obtained high-quality force constants for the Fe-NO and N-O bonds of 2.57 and 11.55 mdyn/A can further be compared to those of corresponding 5C species, which allows for a quantitative analysis of the sigma trans interaction between the proximal imidazole (His) ligand and NO. This is key for the activation of the NO sensor soluble guanylate cyclase. Finally, DFT methods are calibrated against the experimentally determined vibrational properties of the Fe-N-O subunit in 1. DFT is in fact incapable of reproducing the vibrational energies and normal mode descriptions of the Fe-N-O unit well, and thus, DFT-based predictions of changes in vibrational properties upon heme modification or other perturbations of these 6C complexes have to be treated with caution.

Balance between Ultrafast Parallel Reactions in the Green Fluorescent Protein Has a Structural Origin

The fluorescence photocycle of the green fluorescent protein is functionally dependent on the specific structural protein environment. A direct relationship between equilibrium protein side-chain conformation of glutamate 222 and reactivity is established, particularly the rate of ultrafast proton transfer reactions in the fluorescence photocycle. We show that parallel transformations in the photocycle have a structural origin, and we report on the vibrational properties of responsive amino acids on an ultrafast timescale. Blue excitation of GFP drives two parallel, excited-state deuteron transfer reactions with 10 ps and 75 ps time constants to the buried carboxylic acid side chain of glutamate 222 via a hydrogen-bonding network. Assignment of 1456 cm(-1) and 1441 cm(-1) modes to nu(sym) and assignment of 1564 cm(-1) and 1570 cm(-1) features to nu(asym) of E222 in the 10 ps and 75 ps components, respectively, was possible from the analysis of the transient absorption data of an E222D mutant and was consistent with photoselection measurements. In contrast to the wild-type, measurements of E222D can be described with only one difference spectrum, with the nu(sym) mode at 1435 cm(-1) and the nu(asym) mode at 1567 cm(-1), also correlating a large Deltanu(asym-sym) with slow excited-state proton transfer kinetics. Density Functional Theory calculations and published model compound and theoretical studies relate differences in Deltanu(asym-sym) to the strength and number of hydrogen-bonding interactions that are detected via equilibrium geometry and COO- stretching frequency differences of the carboxylate. The correlation of photocycle kinetics with side-chain conformation of the acceptor suggests that proton transfer from S205 to E222 controls the rate of the overall excited-state proton transfer process, which is consistent with recent theoretical predictions. Photoselection measurements show agreement for localized C=O vibrations of chromophore, Q69, and E222 with Density Functional Theory and ab initio calculations placed in the x-ray geometry and provide their vibrational response in the intermediates in the photocycle.

Probing Vibrational Anisotropy with Nuclear Resonance Vibrational Spectroscopy

One of the important issues of nitrosyl (nitric oxide, NO) iron porphyrinate derivatives (hemes) is to develop a detailed understanding of the molecular basis for selectivity (recognition) between the diatomic ligands NO, CO and O2. The sensing of these gaseous molecules is predominantly by heme-based proteins,[1] and heme- and heme protein-diatomic interactions continues to be an active area of research.[2] In Nature, NO is discriminated from O2 quite efficiently by a number of systems;[3]–[5]most prominent are those of soluble guanalyl cyclase and the NO sensing protein of Clostridium botulinum. Conformational changes in the protein imparted upon ligand binding is a plausible explanation for such differentiation.[6, 7] Very low frequency doming modes, sometimes referred to as reactive modes,[8] may facilitate binding and release of diatomic molecules.[9],[10] Infrared and resonance Raman spectroscopy have provided insight into the interplay of structure and function of heme active sites[11] However, these techniques have some inherent limitations, especially in the low frequency regime where mode assignment is hampered by weak signal, spectral congestion and low sensitivity to isotopic substitution.[8] Also, the directionality of iron within particular vibrations, a potential mechanistic indicator, cannot easily be determined. Our recent studies of the nitrosyl (NO) derivatives of iron porphyrinates have emphasized interesting aspects of nitrosyl dynamics of both the five- and six-coordinate NO species,[8],[12]–[16] including Nuclear Resonance Vibrational Spectroscopy (NRVS, sometimes termed Nuclear Inelastic Scattering, NIS) studies.[8],[15]–[19]

Iron normal mode dynamics in (nitrosyl)iron(II)tetraphenylporphyrin from X-ray nuclear resonance data.

The complete iron atom vibrational spectrum has been obtained by refinement of normal mode calculations to nuclear inelastic x-ray absorption data from (nitrosyl)iron(II)tetraphenylporphyrin, FeTPP(NO), a useful model for heme dynamics in myoglobin and other heme proteins. Nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy (NRVS) provides a direct measurement of the frequency and iron amplitude for all normal modes involving significant displacement of (57)Fe. The NRVS measurements on isotopically enriched single crystals permit determination of heme in-plane and out-of-plane modes. Excellent agreement between the calculated and experimental values of frequency and iron amplitude for each mode is achieved by a force-field refinement. Significantly, we find that the presence of the phenyl groups and the NO ligand leads to substantial mixing of the porphyrin core modes. This first picture of the entire iron vibrational density of states for a porphyrin compound provides an improved model for the role of iron atom dynamics in the biological functioning of heme proteins.

Resonance Raman studies of oriented chromophores: Metmyoglobin single crystals

We report Soret enhanced resonance Raman studies of single crystals of metmyoglobin. Differing scattering intensities of the 345 cm−1 mode in solution and crystalline forms of the protein indicate a structural perturbation of the heme upon crystallization, possibly involving a propionate substituent of the heme. The immobilization of the heme in the crystal also allows observation of low‐quantum‐yield photoreduction of the heme that appears to be driven by Soret band absorption. We present experimental investigations of the orientational dependence of the intensity and polarization of several strong heme Raman modes along with calculations that explore the effects of vibrational mode symmetry and of differential coupling to x‐, y‐, and z‐polarized electronic transitions. Orientation studies provide evidence that the vinyl C=C stretching band at 1622 cm−1 is a superposition of two independent modes that couple selectively to the x‐ and y‐polarized Soret transitions. We also demonstrate how modes of nominal...

Spectroscopic and Computational Study of a Nonheme Iron Nitrosyl Center in a Biosynthetic Model of Nitric Oxide Reductase

A major barrier to understanding the mechanism of nitric oxide reductases (NORs) is the lack of a selective probe of NO binding to the nonheme FeB center. By replacing the heme in a biosynthetic model of NORs, which structurally and functionally mimics NORs, with isostructural ZnPP, the electronic structure and functional properties of the FeB nitrosyl complex was probed. This approach allowed observation of the first S=3/2 nonheme {FeNO}(7) complex in a protein-based model system of NOR. Detailed spectroscopic and computational studies show that the electronic state of the {FeNO}(7) complex is best described as a high spin ferrous iron (S=2) antiferromagnetically coupled to an NO radical (S=1/2) [Fe(2+)-NO(.)]. The radical nature of the FeB -bound NO would facilitate N-N bond formation by radical coupling with the heme-bound NO. This finding, therefore, supports the proposed trans mechanism of NO reduction by NORs.

Resilience of the Iron Environment in Heme Proteins

Conformational flexibility is essential to the functional behavior of proteins. We use an effective force constant introduced by Zaccai, the resilience, to quantify this flexibility. Site-selective experimental and computational methods allow us to determine the resilience of heme protein active sites. The vibrational density of states of the heme Fe determined using nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy provides a direct experimental measure of the resilience of the Fe environment, which we compare quantitatively with values derived from the temperature dependence of atomic mean-squared displacements in molecular dynamics simulations. Vibrational normal modes in the THz frequency range dominate the resilience. Both experimental and computational methods find a higher resilience for cytochrome c than for myoglobin, which we attribute to the increased number of covalent links to the peptide in the former protein. For myoglobin, the resilience of the iron environment is larger than the average resilience previously determined for hydrogen sites using neutron scattering. Experimental results suggest a slightly reduced resilience for cytochrome c upon oxidation, although the change is smaller than reported in previous Mössbauer investigations on a bacterial cytochrome c, and is not reproduced by the simulations. Oxidation state also has no significant influence on the compressibility calculated for cyt c, although a slightly larger compressibility is predicted for myoglobin.

Protein elasticity probed with two synchrotron-based techniques

Compressibility characterizes three interconnecting properties of a protein: dynamics, structure, and function. The compressibility values for the electron-carrying protein cytochrome c and for other proteins, as well, available in the literature vary considerably. Here, we apply two synchrotron-based techniques--nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy and inelastic x-ray scattering--to measure the adiabatic compressibility of this protein. This is the first report of the compressibility of any material measured with this method. Unlike the methods previously used, this novel approach probes the protein globally, at ambient pressure, does not require the separation of protein and solvent contributions to the total compressibility, and uses samples that contain the heme iron, as in the native state. We show, by comparing our results with molecular dynamics predictions, that the compressibility is almost independent of temperature. We discuss potential applications of this method to other materials beyond proteins.

Spectroscopic identification of reactive porphyrin motions

Nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy (NRVS) reveals the vibrational dynamics of a Mössbauer probe nucleus. Here, (57)Fe NRVS measurements yield the complete spectrum of Fe vibrations in halide complexes of iron porphyrins. Iron porphine serves as a useful symmetric model for the more complex spectrum of asymmetric heme molecules that contribute to numerous essential biological processes. Quantitative comparison with the vibrational density of states (VDOS) predicted for the Fe atom by density functional theory calculations unambiguously identifies the correct sextet ground state in each case. These experimentally authenticated calculations then provide detailed normal mode descriptions for each observed vibration. All Fe-ligand vibrations are clearly identified despite the high symmetry of the Fe environment. Low frequency molecular distortions and acoustic lattice modes also contribute to the experimental signal. Correlation matrices compare vibrations between different molecules and yield a detailed picture of how heme vibrations evolve in response to (a) halide binding and (b) asymmetric placement of porphyrin side chains. The side chains strongly influence the energetics of heme doming motions that control Fe reactivity, which are easily observed in the experimental signal.

Charge transfer in green fluorescent protein.

Charge transfer reactions that contribute to the photoreactions of the wild type green fluorescent protein (GFP) do not occur in the isolated p-hydroxybenzylidene-imidazolidinone chromophore, demonstrating the role of the protein environment. The high quantum efficiency of the fluorescence photocycle that includes excited state proton transfer and the suppression of non-radiative pathways by the protein environment have been correlated with structural dynamics in the chromophore environment. A low quantum efficiency competing phototransformation reaction of GFP is accompanied by both proton and electron transfer, and closely mimics the charge redistribution that is occurring in the fluorescence photocycle. The protein response to this destabilising event has been demonstrated by cryo-trapping of early products in the reaction pathway and is found to be strong even at 100 K, including displacements of chromophore, protein, solvent and a photogenerated CO2 molecule derived from the decarboxylated Glu 222 side chain. We discuss the ramifications of the observation of strong conformational perturbations below the protein dynamical transition at approximately 200 K, in view of low temperature work on other light sensitive proteins such as myoglobin and bacteriorhodopsin. The proton and electron transfer in the phototransformation pathway mimics the proton and charge transfer which occurs during the fluorescence cycle, which leads to common structural responses in both photoreactions as shown by ultrafast spectroscopy. We review and discuss literature on light-induced and thermal charge transfer events, focusing on recent findings addressing conformational dynamics and implications for thermodynamic properties.