Jacqueline F. Spencer

Syrian Hamster as a Permissive Immunocompetent Animal Model for the Study of Oncolytic Adenovirus Vectors

Oncolytic adenoviruses represent an innovative approach to cancer therapy. These vectors are typically evaluated in immunodeficient mice with human xenograft tumors. However, in addition to being immunodeficient, this model is limited because normal and cancerous mouse tissues are poorly permissive for human adenovirus replication. This prompted us to search for a model that more accurately reflects the use of oncolytic adenoviruses in cancer patients. To this end, we developed a novel Syrian hamster model that is both immunocompetent and replication-permissive. We found that human adenovirus replicates well in Syrian hamster cell lines and confirmed replication in the lungs. Oncolytic adenovirus injection showed efficacy in three different hamster tumor models. Furthermore, i.t. oncolytic adenovirus injection resulted in suppression of primary and metastatic lesions, i.t. replication and necrosis, vector entrance into the bloodstream, replication in the liver and lungs, and anti-adenovirus antibody induction. Our findings show that the Syrian hamster is a promising immunocompetent model that is permissive to human adenovirus replication in tumors as well as normal tissues. Therefore, the Syrian hamster model may become a valuable tool for the field of oncolytic adenovirus vectors in which vector safety and efficacy can be evaluated.

Hexadecyloxypropyl-cidofovir, CMX001, prevents adenovirus-induced mortality in a permissive, immunosuppressed animal model

Adenoviruses (Ads) cause a wide array of end-organ and disseminated diseases in severely immunosuppressed patients. For example, ≈20% of pediatric allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplant recipients develop disseminated Ad infection, and the disease proves fatal in as many as 50–80% of these patients. Ad infections are a serious problem for solid-organ transplant recipients and AIDS patients as well. Unfortunately, there are no antiviral drugs approved specifically to treat these infections. A suitable animal model that is permissive for Ad replication would help in the discovery process. Here we identify an animal model to study Ad pathogenesis and the efficacy of antiviral compounds. We show that human serotype 5 Ad (Ad5) causes severe systemic disease in immunosuppressed Syrian hamsters that is similar to that seen in immunocompromised patients. We also demonstrate that hexadecyloxypropyl-cidofovir (CMX001) rescues the hamsters from a lethal challenge with Ad5. The antiviral drug provided protection both prophylactically and when given up to 2 days after i.v. exposure to Ad5. CMX001 acts by reducing Ad replication in key target organs. Thus, the immunosuppressed Syrian hamster is a powerful model to evaluate anti-Ad drugs, and its use can facilitate the entry of drugs such as CMX001 into clinical trials.

Immunosuppression Enhances Oncolytic Adenovirus Replication and Antitumor Efficacy in the Syrian Hamster Model

We recently described an immunocompetent Syrian hamster model for oncolytic adenoviruses (Ads) that permits virus replication in tumor cells as well as some normal tissues. This model allows exploration of interactions between the virus, tumor, normal organs, and host immune system that could not be examined in the immunodeficient or nonpermissive animal models previously used in the oncolytic Ad field. Here we asked whether the immune response to oncolytic Ad enhances or limits antitumor efficacy. We first determined that cyclophosphamide (CP) is a potent immunosuppressive agent in the Syrian hamster and that CP alone had no effect on tumor growth. Importantly, we found that the antitumor efficacy of oncolytic Ads was significantly enhanced in immunosuppressed animals. In animals that received virus therapy plus immunosuppression, significant differences were observed in tumor histology, and in many cases little viable tumor remained. Notably, we also determined that immunosuppression allowed intratumoral virus levels to remain elevated for prolonged periods. Although favorable tumor responses can be achieved in immunocompetent animals, the rate of virus clearance from the tumor may lead to varied antitumor efficacy. Immunosuppression, therefore, allows sustained Ad replication and oncolysis, which leads to substantially improved suppression of tumor growth.

Targeting Interferon-α Increases Antitumor Efficacy and Reduces Hepatotoxicity of E1A-mutated Spread-enhanced Oncolytic Adenovirus

Novel approaches are needed to improve the antitumor potency and to increase the cancer specificity of oncolytic adenoviruses (Ad). We hypothesized that the combination of interferon-alpha (IFN-α) expression with a specific mutation in the e1a gene of Ad could target vector replication to genetic defects in the IFN-α pathway resulting in both improved antitumor efficacy and reduced toxicity. The conditionally replicative Ad vector KD3-IFN carries the dl1101/1107 mutation in the e1a gene that eliminates binding of E1A proteins to p300/CBP and pRb. KD3-IFN expresses human IFN-α in concurrence with vector replication and overexpresses the adenovirus death protein (ADP; E3-11.6K). The antitumor activity of KD3-IFN was significantly higher than that of a control vector in established human hepatocellular carcinoma tumors in immunodeficient mice and in hamster kidney cancer tumors in immunocompetent Syrian hamsters. The dl1101/1107 mutation rendered Ad replication sensitive to the antiviral effect of IFN-α in normal as opposed to cancer cells. These results translated to reduced vector toxicity upon systemic administration to C57BL/6 mice. The combination of Ad oncolysis, ADP overexpression, and IFN-α-mediated immunotherapy represents a three-pronged approach for increasing the anticancer efficacy of replicative Ads. Exploiting the dl1101/1107 mutation provides a mechanism for additional selectivity of IFN-α-expressing replication-competent Ads.

Effect of Preexisting Immunity on Oncolytic Adenovirus Vector INGN 007 Antitumor Efficacy in Immunocompetent and Immunosuppressed Syrian Hamsters

ABSTRACT Immune responses against adenovirus (Ad) vectors pose a possible concern for the outcome of treatment efficacy. To address the role of preexisting immunity in oncolytic Ad vector antitumor efficacy following intratumoral injection of vector as well as tumor-to-tissue spread of the vector, we employed the Syrian hamster model. These animals are immunocompetent, and their tumors and tissues are permissive for replication of Ad type 5 (Ad5). We used the adenovirus death protein-overexpressing Ad5-based vector INGN 007. Subcutaneous tumors were established in groups of hamsters that were or were not immunized with Ad5. Half of the hamsters in these groups were immunosuppressed with cyclophosphamide. For all groups, tumors injected with INGN 007 grew significantly more slowly than those injected with buffer. Under immunocompetent conditions, there was no significant effect of preexisting immunity on vector antitumor efficacy. Soon after the tumors in naïve animals were injected with vector, the hamsters developed neutralizing antibody (NAb) and the difference in NAb titers between the naïve and immunized groups diminished. Under immunosuppressed conditions, preexisting NAb did significantly reduce vector efficacy. Thus, NAb do reduce vector efficacy to some extent, but immunosuppression is required to observe the effect. Regarding vector toxicity, there was spillover of vector from the tumor to the liver and lungs in naïve immunocompetent hamsters, and this was nearly eliminated in the immunized hamsters. Thus, preexisting immunity to Ad5 does not affect INGN 007 antitumor efficacy following intratumoral injection, but immunity prevents vector spillover from the tumor to the liver and lungs.

INGN 007, an oncolytic adenovirus vector, replicates in Syrian hamsters but not mice: comparison of biodistribution studies

Preclinical biodistribution studies with INGN 007, an oncolytic adenovirus (Ad) vector, supporting an early stage clinical trial were conducted in Syrian hamsters, which are permissive for Ad replication, and mice, which are a standard model for assessing toxicity and biodistribution of replication-defective (RD) Ad vectors. Vector dissemination and pharmacokinetics following intravenous administration were examined by real-time PCR in nine tissues and blood at five time points spanning 1 year. Select organs were also examined for the presence of infectious vector/virus. INGN 007 (VRX-007), wild-type Ad5 and AdCMVpA (an RD vector) were compared in the hamster model, whereas only INGN 007 was examined in mice. DNA of all vectors was widely disseminated early after injection, but decayed rapidly in most organs. In the hamster model, DNA of INGN 007 and Ad5 was more abundant than that of the RD vector AdCMVpA at early times after injection, but similar levels were seen later. An increased level of INGN 007 and Ad5 DNA but not AdCMVpA DNA in certain organs early after injection, and the presence of infectious INGN 007 and Ad5 in lung and liver samples at early times after injection, strongly suggests that replication of INGN 007 and Ad5 occurred in several Syrian hamster organs. There was no evidence of INGN 007 replication in mice. In addition to providing important information about INGN 007, the results underscore the utility of the Syrian hamster as a permissive immunocompetent model for Ad5 pathogenesis and oncolytic Ad vectors.

An acute toxicology study with INGN 007, an oncolytic adenovirus vector, in mice and permissive Syrian hamsters; comparisons with wild-type Ad5 and a replication-defective adenovirus vector

Oncolytic (replication-competent) adenoviruses as anticancer agents provide new, promising tools to fight cancer. In support of a Phase I clinical trial, here we report safety data with INGN 007 (VRX-007), an oncolytic adenovirus with increased anti-tumor efficacy due to overexpression of the adenovirus-encoded ADP protein. Wild-type adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) and a replication-defective version of Ad5 were also studied as controls. A parallel study investigating the biodistribution of these viruses is described elsewhere in this issue. The toxicology experiments were conducted in two species, the Syrian hamster, which is permissive for INGN 007 and Ad5 replication and the poorly permissive mouse. The studies demonstrated that the safety profile of INGN 007 is similar to Ad5. Both viruses caused transient liver damage upon intravenous injection that resolved by 28 days post-infection. The No-Observable-Adverse-Effect-Level (NOAEL) for INGN 007 in hamsters was 3 × 1010 viral particles per kg. In hamsters, the replication-defective vector caused less toxicity, indicating that replication of Ad vectors in the host is an important factor in pathogenesis. With mice, INGN 007 and Ad5 caused toxicity comparable to the replication-defective adenovirus vector. Partially based on these results, the FDA granted permission to enter into a Phase I clinical trial with INGN 007.

Use of the Syrian hamster as an animal model for oncolytic adenovirus vectors.

Oncolytic adenoviruses (Ads) are promising candidates for cancer therapy. However, current animal models to evaluate these vectors have substantial limitations. Because Ad replication is generally species-specific, oncolytic Ads are usually examined in immunodeficient mice bearing human xenograft tumors. However, this model suffers because the animals are immunodeficient and normal and cancerous mouse tissues are poorly permissive to human Ad replication. We have recently developed a Syrian hamster model that is both immunocompetent and permissive to human Ad replication in normal and cancerous tissues. The Syrian hamster is also permissive for Ad5 replication in the lung, which is the natural site of infection in humans. Human Ads replicate well in vitro in the Syrian hamster cell lines examined and demonstrate significant antitumor efficacy following injection into Syrian hamster tumors in vivo. In this chapter we describe the maintenance of these Syrian hamster cell lines in culture and how to assess oncolytic Ad vector replication in these cells in vitro. We also describe detailed methods for growth of these cell lines as subcutaneous tumors, for intravenous and intratumoral injections in hamsters, and for evaluation of the efficacy, replication, and biodistribution of oncolytic Ad vectors following administration in hamsters. In addition, we describe how to assess replication in normal tissues such as the lungs and give helpful tips on handling, anesthesia, and general care of Syrian hamsters.

Pre-existing Immunity and Passive Immunity to Adenovirus 5 Prevents Toxicity Caused by an Oncolytic Adenovirus Vector in the Syrian Hamster Model

We have used Syrian hamsters to examine the role of pre-existing immunity to adenovirus (Ad) 5 in the toxicity of the oncolytic Ad vector INGN 007. Groups of hamsters were or were not immunized with Ad5. Half the hamsters were immunosuppressed using cyclophosphamide (CP), then injected intravenously (i.v.) with 3x the maximum tolerated dose (MTD) of INGN 007 (in immunocompetent hamsters), and toxicity and vector replication in the liver were quantitated. In nonimmunized immunocompetent hamsters, toxicity was observed early but the hamsters recovered by day 6 after vector injection. In nonimmunized immunosuppressed hamsters, the vector was lethal by 3 days. Pre-existing neutralizing antibody (NAb) prevented liver infection and hepatotoxicity in both immunocompetent and immunosuppressed hamsters. In another study, passive immunization of immunosuppressed hamsters 1 day before a lethal dose (1x MTD) of INGN 007 prevented liver infection and replication, but immunization 1 day after vector administration was barely effective. When immunosuppressed hamsters were passively immunized 1 day after injection of 1/3rd the MTD of INGN 007, then significant protection was observed against liver infection and toxicity. Therefore, serum NAb are sufficient to prevent oncolytic Ad vector liver infection and toxicity. We saw no evidence that pre-existing immunity was associated with increased vector toxicity.

New pancreatic carcinoma model for studying oncolytic adenoviruses in the permissive Syrian hamster

Syrian hamster is a practical animal model for studying the systemic effects of oncolytic vectors derived from adenovirus serotype 5 (Ad5). Ad5 replicates well in Syrian hamster tissues, and Syrian hamster cell lines are available that are known to support Ad5 replication. In this study, we established four new Syrian hamster cell lines from transplantable pancreatic, renal, hepatic and lung tumors. The pancreatic cell line (SHPC6) and the renal cell line were highly permissive for Ad5 replication. The SHPC6 cell line formed disseminated intraperitoneal tumors when cells were injected into the peritoneal cavity. INGN 007, an oncolytic Ad5-based vector, completely reversed the growth of disseminated intraperitoneal SHPC6 tumor nodules following intraperitoneal injection of the vector, leading to 100% survival of the treated animals. SHPC6 cells also formed subcutaneous tumors, whose growth was suppressed by INGN 007 following intratumoral injection. INGN 007 replicated in both the intraperitoneal and subcutaneous SHPC6 tumors. Following intraperitoneal injection, INGN 007 did not replicate in the livers of hamsters with intraperitoneal SHPC6 tumors, and was not hepatotoxic. These studies suggest that the SHPC6 cell line may be useful as a model for disseminated pancreatic cancer, and that INGN 007 may be a safe and effective vector to treat these tumors.