James E. Bruce

High-resolution accurate mass measurements of biomolecules using a new electrospray ionization ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer

A novel electrospray ionization/Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer based on a 7-T superconducting magnet was developed for high-resolution accurate mass measurements of large biomolecules. Ions formed at atmospheric pressure using electrospray ionization (ESI) were transmitted (through six differential pumping stages) to the trapped ion cell maintained below 10−9 torr. The increased pumping speed attainable with cryopumping (> 105 L/s) allowed brief pressure excursions to above 10−4 torr, with greatly enhanced trapping efficiencies and subsequent short pumpdown times, facilitating high-resolution mass measurements. A set of electromechanical shutters were also used to minimize the effect of the directed molecular beam produced by the ES1 source and were open only during ion injection. Coupled with the use of the pulsed-valve gas inlet, the trapped ion cell was generally filled to the space charge limit within 100 ms. The use of 10–25 ms ion injection times allowed mass spectra to be obtained from 4 fmol of bovine insulin (Mr 5734) and ubiquitin (Mr 8565, with resolution sufficient to easily resolve the isotopic envelopes and determine the charge states. The microheterogeneity of the glycoprotein ribonuclease B was examined, giving a measured mass of 14,898.74 Da for the most abundant peak in the isotopic envelope of the normally glycosylated protein (i.e., with five mannose and two N-acetylglucosamine residues (an error of approximately 2 ppm) and an average error of approximately 1 ppm for the higher glycosylated and various H3PO4 adducted forms of the protein. Time-domain signals lasting in excess of 80 s were obtained for smaller proteins, producing, for example, a mass resolution of more than 700,000 for the 4+ charge state (m/z 1434) of insulin.

DISSOCIATION OF TETRAMERIC IONS OF NONCOVALENT STREPTAVIDIN COMPLEXES FORMED BY ELECTROSPRAY IONIZATION

The noncovalent tetrameric association of the protein streptavidin formed by electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry has been observed intact and dissociated in the gas phase. An extended mass-to-charge ratio range quadrupole mass spectrometer was employed to examine the effects of harsher conditions in the ESI atmosphere-vacuum interface region on the streptavidin tetramer. Thermally induced dissociation caused the mass spectra to exhibit a series of complementary monomer and trimer ions that correspond to decomposition of the tetrameric species. Similar results were obtained with tandem mass spectrometric experiments on a Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer by application of sustained off-resonance irradiation (SORI) on a selected tetrameric charge state. The technique of single-frequency quadrupole excitation was used to accomplish selected-ion accumulation of the 14 + charge state of the tetramer during ion injection. Subsequent low energy SORI combined with broadband quadrupole cooling produced the 7 + monomer and 7 + trimer species, as well as the 6 + monomer and 8 + trimer complementary ions. The observed asymmetric breakup of the tetramer is qualitatively explained by using physical models.

Identification of intrinsic order and disorder in the DNA repair protein XPA

The DNA‐repair protein XPA is required to recognize a wide variety of bulky lesions during nucleotide excision repair. Independent NMR solution structures of a human XPA fragment comprising approximately 40% of the full‐length protein, the minimal DNA‐binding domain, revealed that one‐third of this molecule was disordered. To better characterize structural features of full‐length XPA, we performed time‐resolved trypsin proteolysis on active recombinant Xenopus XPA (xXPA). The resulting proteolytic fragments were analyzed by electrospray ionization interface coupled to a Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry and SDS‐PAGE. The molecular weight of the full‐length xXPA determined by mass spectrometry (30922.02 daltons) was consistent with that calculated from the sequence (30922.45 daltons). Moreover, the mass spectrometric data allowed the assignment of multiple xXPA fragments not resolvable by SDS‐PAGE. The neural network program Predictor of Natural Disordered Regions (PONDR) applied to xXPA predicted extended disordered N‐ and C‐terminal regions with an ordered internal core. This prediction agreed with our partial proteolysis results, thereby indicating that disorder in XPA shares sequence features with other well‐characterized intrinsically unstructured proteins. Trypsin cleavages at 30 of the possible 48 sites were detected and no cleavage was observed in an internal region (Q85‐I179) despite 14 possible cut sites. For the full‐length xXPA, there was strong agreement among PONDR, partial proteolysis data, and the NMR structure for the corresponding XPA fragment.

Obtaining more accurate Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass measurements without internal standards using multiply charged ions.

Space-charge effects produce frequency shifts in Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometry and correction for these shifts is necessary for obtaining accurate mass measurements. We report a novel method for obtaining accurate mass calibration to correct for space-charge induced mass shifts without the requirement for internal calibrants. The new approach is particularly well suited for electrospray ionization-FTICR mass spectra that contain multiple charge states of the same molecular species. This method, deconvolution of Coulombic affected linearity (DeCAL), is described and presented with several examples demonstrating the increased mass measurement accuracy obtained. DeCAL provides the basis for more routinely obtaining higher mass accuracy measurements in conjunction with chromatographic separations for complex mixture analysis, and obviates the need for internal calibration in many applications.

Isotopic beat patterns in Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry: implications for high resolution mass measurements of large biopolymers

Abstract Fourier trasform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometry time domain signals from multiply charged biopolymer ions exhibit characteristics and predictable beat patterns due to the closely spaced cyclotron frequencies of the various isotopic constituents. Isotope beat frequencies can readily and accurately be predicted from the difference in cyclotron frequencies of neighbouring isotope peaks. The nature of these signals has important implications for high resolution mass analysis, particularly in instances where rapid spectral acquisition is desirable as with on-line analysis of chromatographic/electrophoretic effluents. Due to the pulsed nature of the frequency information in these transients, resolution improvements are effectively realized in a stepwise nature. As will be demonstrated, the application of apodization functions can have deleterious effects on signal-to-note and resolution when beats are present only near the beginning and end of the transient. Additionally, in instances where the length of FTICR data acquisition is critical (such as in conjunction with on-line separations or in the analysis of very high molecular weight species), it is crucial to choose data acquisition parameters based on the predicted behavior of the time domain signal for the efficient and accurate acquisition of mass spectra.

Electrospray ionization-Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry at 11.5 tesla : Instrument design and initial results

Initial results obtained using a new electrospray ionization (ESI) Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometer operated at a magnetic field 11.5 tesla are presented. The new instrument utilized an electrostatic ion guide between the ESI source and FTICR trap that provided up to 5% overall transmission efficiency for light ions and up to 30% efficiency for heavier biomolecules. The higher magnetic field in combination with an enlarged FTICR ion trap made it possible to substantially improve resolving power and operate in a more robust fashion for large biopolymers compared to lower field instruments. Mass resolution up to 106 has been achieved for intermediate size biopolymers such as bovine ubiquitin (8.6 kDa) and bovine cytochrome c (12.4 kDa) without the use of frequency drift correction methods. A mass resolution of 370,000 has been demonstrated for isotopically resolved molecular ions of bovine serum albumin (66.5 kDa). Comparative measurements were made with the same spectrometer using a lower field 3.5-tesla magnet allowing the performance gains to be more readily quantified. Further improvements in pumping capacity of the vacuum system and efficiency of ion transmission from the source are expected to lead to further substantial sensitivity gains.

Capillary electrophoresis fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry with sustained off-resonance irradiation for the characterization of protein and peptide mixtures

A new approach to protein and peptide analysis that involves the coupling of on-line capillary electrophoresis-electrospray ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry with a variation of sustained off-resonance irradiation is described. With this technique, multiple irradiation frequencies are broadcast simultaneously, which yields fragmentation of species at different mass-to-charge ratio values from the same waveform. In conjunction with capillary electrophoresis, this technique can provide sequence information from small amounts of proteins or peptides in complex mixtures. Initial results obtained from a mixture of gramicidin S (1141 u), bee venom melittin (2845 u), and equine apomyoglobin (16,951 u) are presented.

A novel high-performance Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance cell for improved biopolymer characterization

A new trapped ion cell design for use with Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry is described. The design employs 15 cylindrical ring electrodes to generate trapping potential wells and 32 separately assignable rod electrodes for excitation and detection. The rod electrodes are positioned internal to the ring electrodes and provide excitation fields that are thereby linearized along the magnetic field over the entire trapped ion volume. The new design also affords flexibility in the shaping of the trapping field using the 15 ring electrodes. Many different trapping well shapes can be generated by applying different voltages to the individual ring electrodes, ranging from quadratic to linearly ramped along the magnetic field axis, to a shape that is nearly flat over the entire trap volume, but rises very steeply near the ends of the trap. This feature should be useful for trapping larger ion populations and extension of the useful range of ion manipulation and dissociation experiments since the number of stages of ion manipulation or dissociation is limited in practice by the initial trapped ion population size. Predicted trapping well shapes for two different ring electrode configurations are presented, and these and several other possible configurations are discussed, as are the predicted excitation fields based on the use of rod electrodes internal to the trapping ring electrodes. Initial results are presented from an implementation of the design using a 3.5 T superconducting magnet. It was found that ions can be successfully trapped and detected with this cell design and that selected ion accumulation can be performed with the utilization of four rods for quadrupolar excitation. The initial results presented here illustrate the feasibility of this cell design and demonstrate differences in observed performance based upon different trapping well shapes.

Improved isotopic abundance measurements for high resolution fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectra via time-domain data extraction

The simultaneous high resolution and accurate mass measurements possible with Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry coupled with the gentle ionization of electrospray hold attractions for protein, peptide, and oligonucleotide characterization, including multistage-mass spectrometry measurements for assignment of fragment masses and greater confidence in structural measurements. The detection of cyclotron motion over extended periods of time (in some cases for several minutes) allows higher resolution and mass accuracy. Generally, signal duration has been considered to be limited primarily by background pressure, with ion-neutral collisions leading to the reduction and dephasing of cyclotron motion, causing signal loss. However, recent theoretical work has shown that the ion cloud stability that is a prerequisite for high performance measurements is highly dependent on the electric field generated by the ion cloud, thus giving rise to a minimum number of charges or ions required for extended time-domain signals. The effects of ion population on ion cloud stability and signal duration, and the subsequent effects on resolution and measured isotopic abundances are reported. Individual time-domain signals for bovine insulin isotopic peaks were extracted to allow a comparison of the damping rates for each of these ion clouds and the measured time-domain amplitude maxima are shown to provide a better match with the theoretically predicted isotopic abundances for insulin. These results show that different damping rates of ions of very similar mass, but different ion cloud population sizes, can have dramatic effects on the observed isotopic patterns. Additionally, more accurate, high resolution spectra can be produced by correcting for the effects of the different damping rates that are observed for different ion population sizes.

Large Molecule Characterization Based upon Individual Ion Detection with Electrospray Ionization-FTICR Mass Spectrometry

We report a new method for mass spectrometric measurements of high-molecular-weight species based on the summation of sequential Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) spectra of individual multiply charged ions. This approach produces statistically useful mass spectra for large multiply charged molecular species formed by electrospray ionization and circumvents conventional limitations upon achievable resolving power and precision for high-molecular-weight species which arise due to Coulombic constraints. For very large molecules with tens to thousands of charges each, the total number of charges required to define the charge-state distribution, and thus provide accurate mass information, greatly exceeds the useful charge capacity of the FTICR cell. As trapped ion populations approach or exceed this capacity, FTICR performance degrades due to large frequency shifts, peak coalescence phenomena, and rapid loss of ion packet coherence, which effectively precludes high-resolution and precision measurements for molecules above ∼80-kDa size for a 7-T magnetic field strength. The present approach is based on the summation of many spectra having moderate populations of individual ions and relies on sensitivity sufficient for individual ion detection. While the number of trapped ions contributing to each mass spectrum may generally be insufficient to define the isotopic or charge-state distributions (and thus produce accurate information on the molecular weight distribution in a conventional fashion), the present data processing and summation approach suppresses the noise component (as well as smaller signals) that would otherwise be problematic. Importantly, this approach circumvents natural limitations for very high molecular weight species due to Coulombic interactions and thus provides a basis for much greater resolution and mass measurement accuracy than otherwise possible. This paper presents the details of this approach and its demonstration for the 66-kDa protein bovine serum albumin (where the conventional approach is also feasible) and discusses important aspects of the data manipulation.