James J. Ireland

Numbers of Antral Follicles During Follicular Waves in Cattle: Evidence for High Variation Among Animals, Very High Repeatability in Individuals, and an Inverse Association with Serum Follicle-Stimulating Hormone Concentrations

Abstract The extent, causes, and physiological significance of the variation in number of follicles growing during ovarian follicular waves in human beings and cattle are unknown. Therefore, the present study examined the variability and repeatability in numbers of follicles 3 mm or greater in diameter during the follicular waves in bovine estrous cycles, and we determined if the variation in number of follicles during waves was associated with alterations in secretion of FSH, estradiol, inhibin, and insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I). Dairy cattle were subjected to twice-daily ultrasound analysis to count total number of antral follicles 3 mm or greater in diameter throughout 138 different follicular waves. In another study, blood samples were taken at frequent intervals from cows that consistently had low or very high numbers of follicles during waves and were subjected to immunoassays. Results indicate the following: First, despite an approximately sevenfold variation in number of follicles during waves among animals and marked differences in age, stage of lactation, and season of the year, a very highly repeatable (0.95) number of follicles 3 mm or greater in diameter is maintained during the ovulatory and nonovulatory follicular waves of individuals. Second, variation in number of follicles 3 mm or greater in diameter during waves and the inverse association of number of follicles during waves with FSH are not directly explained by alterations in the patterns of secretion of estradiol, inhibin, or IGF-I. Third, ovarian ultrasound analysis can be used reliably by investigators to identify cattle that consistently have low or high numbers of follicles during waves, thus providing a novel experimental model to determine the causes and physiological significance of the high variation in antral follicle number during follicular waves among single-ovulating species, such as cattle or humans.

Antral Follicle Count Reliably Predicts Number of Morphologically Healthy Oocytes and Follicles in Ovaries of Young Adult Cattle

Abstract Methods to predict numbers of healthy oocytes in the ovaries of young adults could have important diagnostic relevance in family planning and animal agriculture. We have observed that peak antral follicle count (AFC) determined by serial ovarian ultrasonography during follicular waves is very highly reproducible within individual young adult cattle, despite 7-fold variation among animals. Herein, we tested the hypothesis that AFC is positively associated with the number of morphologically healthy oocytes and follicles in ovaries and with serum concentrations of anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH), an indirect marker for number of healthy follicles and oocytes in ovaries. In the present study, age-matched young adult cattle (12–18 mo old) were subjected to serial ultrasonography to identify animals with a consistently high (≥25 follicles that were ≥3 mm in diameter) or low (≤15 follicles) AFC during follicular waves. Differences in serum AMH concentrations, ovary weight, and number of morphologically healthy and atretic follicles and oocytes were determined. The phenotypic classifications of cattle based on AFC during follicular waves or AMH concentrations both predict reliably the relative number of morphologically healthy follicles and oocytes in ovaries of age-matched young adult cattle.

Alterations in Intrafollicular Regulatory Factors and Apoptosis During Selection of Follicles in the First Follicular Wave of the Bovine Estrous Cycle

Abstract Changes in follicular fluid (FF) concentrations of estradiol, inhibin forms, and insulin-like growth factor binding proteins (IGFBPs), percentage of apoptotic granulosa cells (%A), and follicular size for individual follicles in a growing cohort were determined throughout the first wave of follicular development during the bovine estrous cycle and related to FSH decline. Four groups of heifers (n = 31) were ovariectomized between Days 1.5 and 4.5 of the estrous cycle at 5 ± 1, 33 ± 2, 53 ± 1, and 84 ± 2 h after the periovulatory peak in FSH concentrations. Follicles ≥2.5 mm were dissected, measured, and FF aspirated. The five largest follicles were ranked based on their diameter (F1 to F5). Diameters of F1 to F5 were positively correlated with interval from FSH peak (r ≥ 0.6, P < 0.05). Five hours after the FSH peak, follicular diameter and FF concentrations of estradiol, inhibins, and IGFBPs were similar for F1 to F5. From 5 to 33 h, amounts of the six precursor inhibin forms (≥48 kDa) increased (P < 0.05) in F1 follicles. The IGFBPs in F1 follicles remained low at all time periods. At 33 h, amounts of IGFBP-4 and -5 were higher (P < 0.05) in F4 and F5 compared with F1 follicles. At 84 h, IGFBP-2, -4, and -5 were increased (P < 0.05) in F3, F4, and F5 compared with F1. At 5, 33, or 53 h, %A was not different between follicles in any size class. At 84 h %A was increased (P < 0.05) in follicles <6 mm in diameter. However, at that time, %A did not differ between the selected DF and the largest subordinate follicle. For individual heifers, the selected DF at 84 h was largest in size, highest in estradiol, and lowest in IGFBP-2 and -4. The F1 follicle had highest estradiol in 23 of 27 heifers irrespective of stage of the wave and lowest IGFBP-4 in 19 of 21 heifers from 33 h. We concluded that the earliest intrafollicular changes that differentiate a dominant-like follicle from the growing cohort are enhanced capacity to produce estradiol and maintenance of low levels of IGFBPs.

Identification of Potential Intrafollicular Factors Involved in Selection of Dominant Follicles in Heifers

Abstract A surgical procedure to aspirate follicular fluid concurrently from individual follicles from the same heifer was validated and used to determine if intrafollicular amounts of estradiol, progesterone, inhibins, activin-A, follistatins, and insulin-like growth factor binding proteins (IGFBP) differed for the future dominant compared with subordinate follicles during selection of the first wave dominant follicle. Heifers were subjected to surgery and aspiration of follicular fluid from the two or three largest follicles on Day 3 of the estrous cycle (∼1.5 days after emergence). Ultrasound was used to determine the fate of each aspirated follicle after surgery. At aspiration, diameter of the future dominant and largest subordinate follicle was similar in heifers. However, estradiol was higher, whereas IGFBP-4 was lower in the future dominant compared with the largest or next largest subordinate follicles. Also, the future dominant follicle in most cohorts had the highest estradiol and lowest IGFBP-4 compared with future subordinate follicles. We concluded that: IGFBP-4 and estradiol may have key roles in determining the physiological fate of follicles during selection of the first wave dominant follicle in heifers, and that both are reliable markers to predict which follicle in a growing cohort of 5- to 8.5-mm follicles becomes dominant.

Identification of Genes Involved in Apoptosis and Dominant Follicle Development During Follicular Waves in Cattle

Abstract We hypothesize that granulosa and theca cells from growing dominant follicles, with relatively high intrafollicular concentrations of estradiol, have a greater expression of genes involved in inhibiting apoptosis pathways and lower expression of genes involved in apoptosis pathways than growing subordinate follicles with lower estradiol concentrations. Using the well-characterized bovine dominant follicle model, we collected granulosa and theca cells from individual dominant and the largest subordinate follicle 3 days after initiation of a follicular wave in four animals. Based on ultrasound analysis, both follicle types were in the growth phase at the time of ovariectomy. However, dominant follicles were larger (9.8 ± 1.0 versus 7.6 ± 0.6 mm in diameter, P < 0.05) and had greater intrafollicular concentrations of estradiol (132.2 ±3 8.5 versus 24.1 ± 12.1 ng/ml, P < 0.05), compared with the largest subordinate follicles. We used bovine cDNA microarrays, which contained a total of 1400 genes, including a subset of 53 genes known to be involved in apoptosis pathways, to determine which apoptosis and marker genes from each of the four dominant versus subordinate follicles were potentially differentially expressed. Using a low stringency-screening criterion, 22 genes were identified. Quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction confirmed that 16 of these genes were differentially expressed. Our novel results demonstrate that the high intrafollicular concentrations of estradiol in growing dominant follicles were positively associated with enhanced expression of mRNAs in granulosa cells for aromatase, LH receptor, estradiol receptor β, DICE-1, and MCL-1, compared with granulosa cells from subordinate follicles (all survival-associated genes). In contrast, the relatively low intrafollicular concentrations of estradiol in growing subordinate follicles were positively associated with enhanced expression of mRNAs in granulosa cells for β glycan, cyclo-oxygenase-1, tumor necrosis factor α, caspase-activated DNase, and DRAK-2, and in theca cells for β glycan, caspase 13, P58(IPK), Apaf-1, BTG-3, and TS-BCLL, compared with granulosa or theca cells from dominant follicles (genes that are all associated with cell death and/or apoptosis). We suggest that that these genes may be candidate estradiol target genes and that they may be early markers for the final stages of follicle differentiation or initiation of apoptosis and thus selection of dominant follicles during follicular waves.

Molecular Evidence That Growth of Dominant Follicles Involves a Reduction in Follicle-Stimulating Hormone Dependence and an Increase in Luteinizing Hormone Dependence in Cattle

Abstract The bovine dominant follicle (DF) model was used to identify molecular mechanisms potentially involved in initial growth of DF during the low FSH milieu of ovarian follicular waves. Follicular fluid and RNA from granulosa and theca cells were harvested from 10 individual DF obtained between 2 and 5.5 days after emergence of the first follicular wave of the estrous cycle. Follicular fluid was subjected to RIA to determine estradiol (E) and progesterone (P) concentrations and RNA to cDNA microarray analysis and (or) quantitative real-time PCR. Results showed that DF growth was associated with a decrease in intrafollicular E:P ratio and in mRNA for the FSH receptor, estrogen receptor 2 (ER beta), inhibin alpha, activin A receptor type I, and a proliferation (cyclin D2) and two proapoptotic factors (apoptosis regulatory protein Siva, Fas [TNFRSF6]-associated via death domain) in granulosa cells. In contrast, mRNAs for the LH receptor in granulosa cells and for two antiapoptotic factors (TGFB1-induced antiapoptotic factor 1, LAG1 longevity assurance homolog 4 [Saccharomyces cerevisiae]) and one proapoptotic factor (tumor necrosis factor [ligand] superfamily, member 8) were increased in theca cells. We conclude that the bovine DF provides a unique model to identify novel genes potentially involved in survival and apoptosis of follicular cells and, importantly, to determine the FSH-, estradiol-, and LH-target genes regulating its growth and function. Results provide new molecular evidence for the hypothesis that DF experience a reduction in FSH dependence but acquire increased LH dependence as they grow during the low FSH milieu of follicular waves.

Identification of Novel Bovine Cumulus Cell Molecular Markers Predictive of Oocyte Competence: Functional and Diagnostic Implications

Abstract The present study was undertaken to discover molecular markers in bovine cumulus cells predictive of oocyte competence and to elucidate their functional significance. Differences in RNA transcript abundance in cumulus cells harvested from oocytes of adult versus prepubertal animals (a model of poor oocyte quality) were identified by microarray analysis. Four genes of interest encoding for the lysosomal cysteine proteinases cathepsins B, S, K, and Z and displaying greater transcript abundance in cumulus cells surrounding oocytes harvested from prepubertal animals were chosen for further investigation. Greater mRNA abundance for such genes in cumulus cells of prepubertal oocytes was confirmed by real-time RT-PCR. Elevated transcript abundance for cathepsins B, S, and Z also was observed in cumulus cells surrounding adult metaphase II oocytes that developed to the blastocyst stage at a low percentage following parthenogenetic activation versus those that developed at a high percentage. Functional significance of cumulus cell cathepsin expression to oocyte competence was confirmed by treatment of cumulus-oocyte complexes during in vitro oocyte maturation with a cell-permeable cysteine proteinase (cathepsin) inhibitor. Inhibitor treatment decreased apoptotic nuclei in the cumulus layer and enhanced development of parthenogenetically activated and in vitro-fertilized adult oocytes to the blastocyst stage. Stimulatory effects of inhibitor treatment during meiotic maturation on subsequent embryonic development were not observed when oocytes were matured in the absence of cumulus cells. The present results support a functional role for cumulus cell cathepsins in compromised oocyte competence and suggest that cumulus cell cathepsin mRNA abundance may be predictive of oocyte quality.

Low numbers of ovarian follicles ≥3 mm in diameter are associated with low fertility in dairy cows

The total number of ovarian follicles ≥ 3mm in diameter (antral follicle count, AFC) during follicular waves varies among cattle of similar age, but AFC is highly repeatable within individuals. We hypothesized that lower AFC could be associated with reduced fertility in cattle. The AFC was assessed by ultrasonography for 2 d consecutively during the first wave of follicular growth of the estrous cycle, 4.6±1.43 d (mean ± SD) after estrus, in 306 Holstein-Friesian dairy cows approximately 70 d postpartum. Cows were classified into 3 groups based on AFC: low (AFC ≤15), intermediate (AFC=16 to 24), and high (AFC ≥25). During the cycle in which AFC was assessed and in subsequent cycles, cows were artificially inseminated (AI) following detection of estrus, and pregnancy status was assessed using ultrasonography. Cows with high AFC had 3.34 times greater odds of being pregnant at the end of the breeding season compared with cows with low AFC; the odds of a successful pregnancy at first service were 1.75 times greater in the intermediate compared with the low group. The predicted probability of a successful pregnancy by the end of the breeding period (length of breeding season was 86±16.3 d) was 94, 88, and 84% for the high, intermediate, and low AFC groups, respectively. No difference was evident among groups in 21-d submission rate (proportion of all cows detected in estrus and submitted for AI in the first 21 d of the breeding season), but the interval from calving to conception was shorter in the high (109.5±5.1 d) versus low (117.1±4 d) group, and animals with intermediate AFC received fewer services during the breeding season (2.3±0.1) compared with animals with low AFC (2.7±0.1). Lactating cows with ≤15 ovarian follicles have lower reproductive performance compared with cows with higher numbers of follicles, but the existence of a positive association between high numbers of ovarian follicles and fertility is yet to be established.

Variation in the Ovarian Reserve Is Linked to Alterations in Intrafollicular Estradiol Production and Ovarian Biomarkers of Follicular Differentiation and Oocyte Quality in Cattle

Abstract The mechanisms whereby the high variation in numbers of morphologically healthy oocytes and follicles in ovaries (ovarian reserve) may have an impact onovarian function, oocyte quality, and fertility are poorly understood. The objective was to determine whether previously validated biomarkers for follicular differentiation and function, as well as oocyte quality differed between cattle with low versus a high antral follicle count (AFC). Ovaries were removed (n = 5 per group) near the beginning of the nonovulatory follicular wave, before follicles could be identified via ultrasonography as being dominant, from heifers with high versus a low AFC. The F1, F2, and F3 follicles were dissected and diameters determined. Follicular fluid and thecal, granulosal, and cumulus cells and the oocyte were isolated and subjected to biomarker analyses. Although the size and numerous biomarkers of differentiation, such as mRNAs for the gonadotropin receptors, were similar, intrafollicular concentrations of estradiol and the abundance of mRNAs for CYP19A1 in granulosal cells and ESR1, ESR2, and CTSB in cumulus cells were greater, whereas mRNAs for AMH in granulosal cells and TBC1D1 in thecal cells were lower for animals with low versus a high AFC during follicle waves. Hence, variation in the ovarian reserve may have an impact on follicular function and oocyte quality via alterations in intrafollicular estradiol production and expression of key genes involved in follicle-stimulating hormone action (AMH) and estradiol (CYP19A1) production by granulosal cells, function and survival of thecal cells (TBC1D1), responsiveness of cumulus cells to estradiol (ESR1, ESR2), and cumulus cell determinants of oocyte quality (CTSB).

Evidence That High Variation in Ovarian Reserves of Healthy Young Adults Has a Negative Impact on the Corpus Luteum and Endometrium During Estrous Cycles in Cattle

Abstract Low progesterone concentrations and diminished ovarian reserves (total number of healthy oocytes) during reproductive cycles are linked to infertility in single-ovulating species like cattle. However, the extent and mechanisms whereby the inherently high variation in ovarian reserves may negatively affect progesterone production are unknown. Cattle were chosen to address these questions because the size of their ovarian reserves can be predicted based on an antral follicle count (AFC) during follicular waves. The present study determined if progesterone concentrations, differentiation and function of the corpus luteum (CL), and endometrial thickness differed during reproductive cycles of age-matched healthy young adult cattle with low versus high AFC during follicular waves. The results showed that, despite enhanced LH secretion, progesterone concentrations were lower during estrous cycles for animals with low versus high AFC. Animals with low versus high AFC also had a decreased basal, LH-, and 25-hydroxycholesterol-induced capacity of luteal and granulosal cells to produce progesterone, reduced amounts of STAR and mRNAs for STAR and LH receptor in the CL, and no change in endometrial thickness during estrous cycles. Taken together, these results 1) supported the conclusion that high variation in ovarian reserves of young adults is associated with alterations in differentiation and function of the CL and 2) provided insight into the potential factors that may cause suboptimal luteal function (e.g., heightened LH secretion and desensitization of the LH receptor, diminished LH responsiveness, diminished STAR, inherent deficiency in capacity of granulosal cells to undergo luteinization) and infertility (e.g., low progesterone, poor endometrial growth) in individuals with diminished ovarian reserves.