Jay M. Maniar

Measurement and clinical monitoring of human lymphocyte clonality by massively parallel VDJ pyrosequencing

Massively parallel sequencing of rearranged immune receptor genes permits detection and tracking of specific immune cell populations in normal and pathological contexts. Like a reporter who serially unearths fragments of a story until a plausible picture of the latest scandal emerges, scientists have over time gathered pieces of the vast amount of information inherent in the highly recombined genes of the human immune system—probing their complexity, seeking a disease diagnosis, or hunting for evidence of remission. Back in 1987, Susumu Tonegawa won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for discovering the genetics behind the diversity of human antibodies—a process called V-D-J recombination. Now, more than 20 years later, scientists at Stanford University and 454 Life Sciences have used powerful next-generation DNA sequencing technology to comprehensively characterize the products of V-D-J recombination in both cancer patients and healthy volunteers. Indeed, this ability to exhaustively profile the human immune response will help to untangle some of biomedicine’s most knotty problems—cancer, autoimmune disease, and vaccine development. B and T lymphocytes, cells of the adaptive immune system, build the blueprints for myriad antigen-recognizing proteins—immunoglobulins (Ig) and T cell receptors—by recombination within variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) gene segments to rearrange the intervening highly variable DNA sequences that can specify numerous antigen recognition domains. All of this reassortment creates a repertoire of receptors that recognizes scads of molecules from foreign invaders (antigens), a process that spurs the immune system to respond to the threat. When an immune cell sporting a particular antigen receptor finds and binds its matching antigen, the cell divides repeatedly, giving rise to many genetically identical lymphocytes that target a particular antigen for elimination. In contrast to this vibrant diversity of healthy immune systems, those of people with B lymphocyte– or T lymphocyte–based cancers (lymphomas or leukemias) generate cells that express a single dominant (clonal) receptor. In the new work, Boyd et al. performed massively parallel DNA sequencing of rearranged IgH gene loci in blood and tissue samples from cancer patients and healthy people to examine the diversity of their B cells, the immune cells that make antibodies. To this end, they amplified the rearranged IgH B cell DNA with a series of primers and the polymerase chain reaction to generate bar-coded, amplified DNA mixtures. These samples were then sequenced and the information was analyzed to determine which DNA segments had been joined to generate the blueprints for the IgH immune molecules. The experimental design used by Boyd et al. employs a high-throughput deep sequencing machine and can accommodate up to 150 samples at a time, providing an intricate snapshot of the immune repertoire. From healthy individuals, the authors were able to estimate the normal complexity of the B cell repertoire. With samples from the cancer patients, they obtained disease-specific signatures of clonal B cell proliferation events. For example, in a lymph node sample from one patient, deep sequencing detected two distinct V-D-J rearrangements. This finding indicates that there were two separate clonal B cell populations in this specimen and, therefore, two different B cell lymphomas. Such signatures could be obtained at the time of disease diagnosis and then monitored on an ongoing basis and thereby used to assess the effects of anticancer therapies that target these clonal populations or for early detection of disease relapse. Characterization of immune cell populations by deep sequencing also may illuminate fundamental aspects of infectious and autoimmune diseases as well as the body’s response to vaccination, gene and cell therapies, and other surgical procedures. The complex repertoire of immune receptors generated by B and T cells enables recognition of diverse threats to the host organism. Here, we show that massively parallel DNA sequencing of rearranged immune receptor loci can provide direct detection and tracking of immune diversity and expanded clonal lymphocyte populations in physiological and pathological contexts. DNA was isolated from blood and tissue samples, a series of redundant primers was used to amplify diverse DNA rearrangements, and the resulting mixtures of bar-coded amplicons were sequenced with long-read ultradeep sequencing. Individual DNA molecules were then characterized on the basis of DNA segments that had been joined to make a functional (or nonfunctional) immune effector. Current experimental designs can accommodate up to 150 samples in a single sequence run, with the depth of sequencing sufficient to identify stable and dynamic aspects of the immune repertoire in both normal and diseased circumstances. These data provide a high-resolution picture of immune spectra in normal individuals and in patients with hematological malignancies, illuminating, in the latter case, both the initial behavior of clonal tumor populations and the later suppression or reemergence of such populations after treatment.

Individual Variation in the Germline Ig Gene Repertoire Inferred from Variable Region Gene Rearrangements

Individual variation in the Ig germline gene repertoire leads to individual differences in the combinatorial diversity of the Ab repertoire, but the study of such variation has been problematic. The application of high-throughput DNA sequencing to the study of rearranged Ig genes now makes this possible. The sequencing of thousands of VDJ rearrangements from an individual, either from genomic DNA or expressed mRNA, should allow their germline IGHV, IGHD, and IGHJ repertoires to be inferred. In addition, where previously mere glimpses of diversity could be gained from sequencing studies, new large data sets should allow the rearrangement frequency of different genes and alleles to be seen with clarity. We analyzed the DNA of 108,210 human IgH chain rearrangements from 12 individuals and determined their individual IGH genotypes. The number of reportedly functional IGHV genes and allelic variants ranged from 45 to 60, principally because of variable levels of gene heterozygosity, and included 14 previously unreported IGHV polymorphisms. New polymorphisms of the IGHD3-16 and IGHJ6 genes were also seen. At heterozygous loci, remarkably different rearrangement frequencies were seen for the various IGHV alleles, and these frequencies were consistent between individuals. The specific alleles that make up an individuals Ig genotype may therefore be critical in shaping the combinatorial repertoire. The extent of genotypic variation between individuals is highlighted by an individual with aplastic anemia who appears to lack six contiguous IGHD genes on both chromosomes. These deletions significantly alter the potential expressed IGH repertoire, and possibly immune function, in this individual.

Amplification of siRNA in Caenorhabditis elegans generates a transgenerational sequence-targeted histone H3 lysine 9 methylation footprint

Exogenous double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) has been shown to exert homology-dependent effects at the level of both target mRNA stability and chromatin structure. Using C. elegans undergoing RNAi as an animal model, we have investigated the generality, scope and longevity of dsRNA-targeted chromatin effects and their dependence on components of the RNAi machinery. Using high-resolution genome-wide chromatin profiling, we found that a diverse set of genes can be induced to acquire locus-specific enrichment of histone H3 lysine 9 trimethylation (H3K9me3), with modification footprints extending several kilobases from the site of dsRNA homology and with locus specificity sufficient to distinguish the targeted locus from the other 20,000 genes in the C. elegans genome. Genetic analysis of the response indicated that factors responsible for secondary siRNA production during RNAi were required for effective targeting of chromatin. Temporal analysis revealed that H3K9me3, once triggered by dsRNA, can be maintained in the absence of dsRNA for at least two generations before being lost. These results implicate dsRNA-triggered chromatin modification in C. elegans as a programmable and locus-specific response defining a metastable state that can persist through generational boundaries.

Minicircle DNA Vectors Achieve Sustained Expression Reflected by Active Chromatin and Transcriptional Level

Current efforts in nonviral gene therapy are plagued by a pervasive difficulty in sustaining therapeutic levels of delivered transgenes. Minicircles (plasmid derivatives with the same expression cassette but lacking a bacterial backbone) show sustained expression and hold promise for therapeutic use where persistent transgene expression is required. To characterize the widely-observed silencing process affecting expression of foreign DNA in mammals, we used a system in which mouse liver presented with either plasmid or minicircle consistently silences plasmid but not minicircle expression. We found that preferential silencing of plasmid DNA occurs at a nuclear stage that precedes transport of mRNA to the cytoplasm, evident from a consistent >25-fold minicircle/plasmid transcript difference observed in both nuclear and total RNA. Among possible mechanisms of nuclear silencing, our data favor chromatin-linked transcriptional blockage rather than targeted degradation, aberrant processing, or compromised mRNA transport. In particular, we observe dramatic enrichment of H3K27 trimethylation on plasmid sequences. Also, it appears that Pol II can engage the modified plasmid chromatin, potentially in a manner that is not productive in the synthesis of high levels of new transcript. We outline a scenario in which sustained differences at the chromatin level cooperate to determine the activity of foreign DNA.

Protection from Feed-Forward Amplification in an Amplified RNAi Mechanism

The effectiveness of RNA interference (RNAi) in many organisms is potentiated through the signal-amplifying activity of a targeted RNA-directed RNA polymerase (RdRP) system that can convert a small population of exogenously-encountered dsRNA fragments into an abundant internal pool of small interfering RNA (siRNA). As for any biological amplification system, we expect an underlying architecture that will limit the ability of a randomly encountered trigger to produce an uncontrolled and self-escalating response. Investigating such limits in Caenorhabditis elegans, we find that feed-forward amplification is limited by biosynthetic and structural distinctions at the RNA level between (1) triggers that can produce amplification and (2) siRNA products of the amplification reaction. By assuring that initial (primary) siRNAs can act as triggers but not templates for activation, and that the resulting (secondary) siRNAs can enforce gene silencing on additional targets without unbridled trigger amplification, the system achieves substantial but fundamentally limited signal amplification.

EGO-1, a C. elegans RdRP, Modulates Gene Expression via Production of mRNA-Templated Short Antisense RNAs

BACKGROUND The development of the germline in Caenorhabditis elegans is a complex process involving the regulation of thousands of genes in a coordinated manner. Several genes required for small RNA biogenesis and function are among those required for the proper organization of the germline. EGO-1 is a putative RNA-directed RNA polymerase (RdRP) that is required for multiple aspects of C. elegans germline development and efficient RNA interference (RNAi) of germline-expressed genes. RdRPs have been proposed to act through a variety of mechanisms, including the posttranscriptional targeting of specific mRNAs, as well as through a direct interaction with chromatin. Despite extensive investigation, the molecular role of EGO-1 has remained enigmatic. RESULTS Here we use high-throughput small RNA and messenger RNA sequencing to investigate EGO-1 function. We found that EGO-1 is required to produce a distinct pool of small RNAs antisense to a number of germline-expressed mRNAs through several developmental stages. These potential mRNA targets fall into distinct classes, including genes required for kinetochore and nuclear pore assembly, histone-modifying activities, and centromeric proteins. We also found several RNAi-related genes to be targets of EGO-1. Finally, we show a strong association between the loss of small RNAs and the rise of mRNA levels in ego-1(-) animals. CONCLUSIONS Our data support the conclusion that EGO-1 produces triphosphorylated small RNAs derived from mRNA templates and that these small RNAs modulate gene expression through the targeting of their cognate mRNAs.

An in vitro-identified high-affinity nucleosome-positioning signal is capable of transiently positioning a nucleosome in vivo

BackgroundThe physiological function of eukaryotic DNA occurs in the context of nucleosomal arrays that can expose or obscure defined segments of the genome. Certain DNA sequences are capable of strongly positioning a nucleosome in vitro, suggesting the possibility that favorable intrinsic signals might reproducibly structure chromatin segments. As high-throughput sequencing analyses of nucleosome coverage in vitro and in vivo have become possible, a vigorous debate has arisen over the degree to which intrinsic DNA:nucleosome affinities orchestrate the in vivo positions of nucleosomes, thereby controlling physical accessibility of specific sequences in DNA.ResultsWe describe here the in vivo consequences of placing a synthetic high-affinity nucleosome-positioning signal, the 601 sequence, into a DNA plasmid vector in mice. Strikingly, the 601 sequence was sufficient to position nucleosomes during an early phase after introduction of the DNA into the mice (when the plasmid vector transgene was active). This positioning capability was transient, with a loss of strong positioning at a later time point when the transgenes had become silent.ConclusionsThese results demonstrate an ability of DNA sequences selected solely for nucleosome affinity to organize chromatin in vivo, and the ability of other mechanisms to overcome these interactions in a dynamic nuclear environment.

‘Inc-miRs’: functional intron-interrupted miRNA genes

The discovery of microRNAs (miRNAs) lin-4 and let-7 as temporal regulators in Caenorhabditis elegans led to broader searches for novel miRNAs and their biological roles. Unlike protein-coding genes and some long noncoding RNAs, canonical metazoan miRNAs are not known to contain introns within their genomic precursor sequences. Because the short length of miRNAs complicates a statistically definitive assignment of split genes in RNA sequencing data sets, we took an experimental approach toward testing the compatibility of splicing and functional miRNA biogenesis. To definitively evaluate the possibility that miRNAs could derive from interrupted genes, we constructed intron-interrupted variants of C. elegans lin-4 and assayed for their miRNA-encoding capability and biological activity in the developing organism. Our studies indicate that (1) intron-containing miRNAs (inc-miRs) can be efficiently spliced and processed to produce miRNAs with normal termini, and (2) these miRNAs can be functional in full rescue of developmental phenotypes in null mutants lacking endogenous lin-4. This study provides the first evidence to support the ability of intron-interrupted miRNA precursors to produce functional regulators and identifies an additional modality available for metazoan miRNA production.

クロマチン線虫Caenorhabditis elegansではsiRNAの 増幅により、世代を超えて標的配列に特異的な ヒストンH3の9番目のリシンのメチル化フットプリントが作り出される。

Exogenous double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) has been shown to exert homology-dependent effects at the level of both target mRNA stability and chromatin structure. Using C. elegans undergoing RNAi as an animal model, we have investigated the generality, scope and longevity of dsRNA-targeted chromatin effects and their dependence on components of the RNAi machinery. Using high-resolution genome-wide chromatin profiling, we found that a diverse set of genes can be induced to acquire locus-specific enrichment of histone H3 lysine 9 trimethylation (H3K9me3), with modification footprints extending several kilobases from the site of dsRNA homology and with locus specificity sufficient to distinguish the targeted locus from the other 20,000 genes in the C. elegans genome. Genetic analysis of the response indicated that factors responsible for secondary siRNA production during RNAi were required for effective targeting of chromatin. Temporal analysis revealed that H3K9me3, once triggered by dsRNA, can be maintained in the absence of dsRNA for at least two generations before being lost. These results implicate dsRNA-triggered chromatin modification in C. elegans as a programmable and locus-specific response defining a metastable state that can persist through generational boundaries.

A transgenerational impact of siRNA on chromatin: siRNA amplification in Caenorhabditis elegans generates a homology-targeted footprint of H3K9 methylated nucleosomes

Exogenous double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) has been shown to exert homology-dependent effects at the level of both target mRNA stability and chromatin structure. Using C. elegans undergoing RNAi as an animal model, we have investigated the generality, scope and longevity of dsRNA-targeted chromatin effects and their dependence on components of the RNAi machinery. Using high-resolution genome-wide chromatin profiling, we found that a diverse set of genes can be induced to acquire locus-specific enrichment of histone H3 lysine 9 trimethylation (H3K9me3), with modification footprints extending several kilobases from the site of dsRNA homology and with locus specificity sufficient to distinguish the targeted locus from the other 20,000 genes in the C. elegans genome. Genetic analysis of the response indicated that factors responsible for secondary siRNA production during RNAi were required for effective targeting of chromatin. Temporal analysis revealed that H3K9me3, once triggered by dsRNA, can be maintained in the absence of dsRNA for at least two generations before being lost. These results implicate dsRNA-triggered chromatin modification in C. elegans as a programmable and locus-specific response defining a metastable state that can persist through generational boundaries.