John L. Norelli

Expression of Endochitinase from Trichoderma harzianum in Transgenic Apple Increases Resistance to Apple Scab and Reduces Vigor.

ABSTRACT The goal of this research was to improve scab resistance of apple by transformation with genes encoding chitinolytic enzymes from the bio-control organism Trichoderma harzianum. The endochitinase gene, as cDNA and genomic clones, was transferred into apple cv. Marshall McIntosh by Agrobacterium-transformation. A total of 15 lines were identified as transgenic by NPTII enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and polymerase chain reaction and confirmed by Southern analysis. Substantial differences in endochitinase activity were detected among different lines by enzymatic assay and western analysis. Eight lines propagated as grafted and own-rooted plants were inoculated with Venturia inaequalis. Six of these transgenic lines expressing endochitinase were more resistant than nontransformed cv. Marshall McIntosh. Disease severity compared with cv. Marshall McIntosh was reduced by 0 to 99.7% (number of lesions), 0 to 90% (percentage of leaf area infected), and 1 to 56% (conidia recovered) in the transgenic lines tested. Endochitinase also had negative effects on the growth of both inoculated and uninoculated plants. There was a significant negative correlation between the level of endochitinase production and both the amount of disease and plant growth.

Fire Blight Management in the Twenty-first Century: Using New Technologies that Enhance Host Resistance in Apple

Fire blight has been known as a destructive disease of apple and pear for over 200 years (3). The disease is caused by the bacterium Erwinia amylovora, which is capable of infecting blossoms, fruits, vegetative shoots, woody tissues, and rootstock crowns (Fig. 1). There are several distinct phases of the disease including blossom blight, shoot blight, and rootstock blight. The diversity of host tissues susceptible to infection, combined with the limited number of management tools available to control the disease, has made it difficult to stop or slow the progress of fire blight epidemics. Effective management of fire blight requires an integrated approach of several practices that are aimed at (i) reducing the amount of inoculum that is available to initiate new infections, (ii) imposing barriers to successful establishment of the pathogen on the host, and (iii) reducing host susceptibility to infection (1,55). Most fire blight management strategies developed during the twentieth century focused on the reduction of inoculum in the orchard and the use of antimicrobial treatments to prevent infection. Although increasing host resistance has been recognized as an important component of fire blight management, its application has been limited by a lack of resistant cultivars suited to commercial needs and by a lack of management practices that could effectively increase resistance. Recent advances have made it feasible to change this paradigm in the twenty-first century. First, apple rootstock breeding programs have developed size-controlling (often dwarfing) rootstocks that are resistant to fire blight and are currently becoming available for commercial use (43). Second, genetic engineering of commercial apple cultivars for increased fire blight resistance has been demonstrated, and transgenic apple plants are now undergoing field trials (2). Third, chemical treatments that enhance host resistance have been demonstrated to be useful in the control of fire blight (9,33,61). Although these technologies are at the early stages of development and are either not available or not proven in the marketplace, incorporating the use of host resistance into fire blight management strategies has become a realistic goal in the twenty-first century. This article describes recent progress in the development of new fire blight control technologies that enhance host resistance by chemical or genetic means.

Synergistic activity of endochitinase and exochitinase from Trichoderma atroviride (T. harzianum) against the pathogenic fungus (Venturia inaequalis) in transgenic apple plants

Genes from the biocontrol fungus Trichoderma atroviride encoding the antifungal proteins endochitinase or exochitinase (N-acetyl-β-D-hexosaminidase) were inserted into ‘Marshall McIntosh’ apple singly and in combination. The genes were driven by a modified CaMV35S promoter. The resulting plants were screened for resistance to Venturia inaequalis, the causal agent of apple scab, and for effects of enzyme expression on growth. Disease resistance was correlated with the level of expression of either enzyme when expressed alone but exochitinase was less effective than endochitinase. The level of expression of endochitinase was negatively correlated with plant growth while exochitinase had no consistent effect on this character. Plants expressing both enzymes simultaneously were more resistant than plants expressing either single enzyme at the same level; analyses indicated that the two enzymes acted synergistically to reduce disease. Selected lines, especially one expressing low levels of endochitinase activity and moderate levels of exochitinase activity, were highly resistant in growth chamber trials and had negligible reduction in vigor relative to control plants. We believe that this is the first report of resistance in plants induced by expression of an N-acetylhexosaminidase and is the first report of in planta synergy between an exochitinase and an endochitinase.

Ectopic expression of a novel peach (Prunus persica) CBF transcription factor in apple (Malus × domestica) results in short-day induced dormancy and increased cold hardiness

Low, non-freezing temperatures and/or short daylength (SD) regulates cold acclimation and dormancy in fruit trees. Regarding cold acclimation, C-repeat binding factor (CBF/DREB) transcriptional activator genes have the well-documented ability to induce the expression of a suite of genes associated with increased cold tolerance. We isolated a full-length cDNA of a peach CBF gene, designated PpCBF1 (GenBank Accession HM992943), and constitutively expressed it using an enhanced 35S promoter in apple. Unexpectedly, constitutive overexpression of the PpCBF1 in apple resulted in strong sensitivity to short daylength. Growth cessation and leaf senescence were induced in transgenic lines exposed to SD and optimal growth temperatures of 25°C over a 4-week period. Following 1–4xa0weeks of SD and 25°C trees were returned to LD and 25°C in the greenhouse. Control (untransformed) plants continued to grow while transgenic lines receiving two or more weeks of SD remained dormant and began to drop leaves. Constitutive overexpression of the PpCBF1 in apple resulted in a 4–6°C increase in freezing tolerance in both the non-acclimated and acclimated states, respectively, compared with untransformed M.26 trees. This is the first instance that constitutive overexpression of a CBF gene has resulted in SD-induction of dormancy and to our knowledge the first time apple has been shown to strongly respond to short daylength as a result of the insertion of a transgene.

Transgenic ‘Malling 26’ apple expressing the attacin E gene has increased resistance to Erwinia amylovora

Apple (Malus domestica) transgenic T1 was obtained by Agrobacterium tumefaciens- mediated transformation of Mailing 26 rootstock using the plasmid binary vector pLDB 15. pLDB 15 contains within its T-DNA a gene encoding the lytic protein attacin E. The integration of the attacin E gene into the apple genome was confirmed by Southern analysis. Northern analysis indicated the presence of an attacin E mRNA in plants inoculated with Erwinia amylovora. After inoculation of in vitro grown plants of T1, Mailing 26, and Mailing 7 (resistant control) with E. amylovora, the log10 of the inoculum concentration lethal to 50% of the plants was 5.4, 4.4, and 5.6, respectively. In greenhouse trials for resistance to fire blight, T1 was significantly more resistant than‘Mailing 26’.

Effect of untranslated leader sequence of AMV RNA 4 and signal peptide of pathogenesis-related protein 1b on attacin gene expression, and resistance to fire blight in transgenic apple

A cDNA clone of the gene encoding attacin was used to construct three plasmid binary vectors in which attE was controlled by the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter with duplicated upstream B domain (35S) (p35SAtt), 35S with the untranslated leader sequence of alfalfa mosaic virus RNA 4 (AMV) (p35SAMVAtt), and 35S with AMV and the signal peptide of pathogenesis-related protein 1b from tobacco (SP) (p35SAMVSPAtt), respectively. These plasmids and pLDB15 containing attE under the control of the potato proteinase inhibitor II (Pin2) promoter were used in Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of the apple scion cultivar `Galaxy and the apple rootstock M.26 to enhance resistance to Erwinia amylovora, the bacterium that causes fire blight. The mean attacin content of transgenic lines containing attacin with AMV was three times higher than lines without AMV. Northern blots suggested that AMV functioned in apple as it does in other plant species by enhancing translation of attE mRNA. Transgenic `Galaxy lines with attacin fused to SP had lower attacin content than lines without SP. In vitro assays indicated that attacin was partially degraded in the intercellular fluid of apple leaves. However, transgenic `Galaxy lines transformed with attacin fused to SP had significantly less disease than those without SP suggesting that intercellularly secreted attacin is more effective in reducing E. amylovora infection than intracellularly localized attacin. A negative correlation was observed between attacin content and disease resistance in Pin2Att transgenic `Galaxy lines following inoculation with E. amylovora, suggesting that attacin enhances resistance to fire blight.

Expressed sequence tag analysis of the response of apple (Malus x domestica 'Royal Gala') to low temperature and water deficit

Leaf, bark, xylem and root tissues were used to make nine cDNA libraries from non-stressed (control) Royal Gala apple trees, and from Royal Gala trees exposed to either low temperature (5 degrees C for 24 h) or water deficit (45% of saturated pot mass for 2 weeks). Over 22 600 clones from the nine libraries were subjected to 5 single-pass sequencing, clustered and annotated using blastx. The number of clusters in the libraries ranged from 170 to 1430. Regarding annotation of the sequences, blastx analysis indicated that within the libraries 65-72% of the clones had a high similarity to known function genes, 6-15% had no functional assignment and 15-26% were completely novel. The expressed sequence tags were combined into three classes (control, low-temperature and water deficit) and the annotated genes in each class were placed into 1 of 10 different functional categories. The percentage of genes falling into each category was then calculated. This analysis indicated a distinct downregulation of genes involved in general metabolism and photosynthesis, while a significant increase in defense/stress-related genes, protein metabolism and energy was observed. In particular, there was a three-fold increase in the number of stress genes observed in the water deficit libraries indicating a major shift in gene expression in response to a chronic stress. The number of stress genes in response to low temperature, although elevated, was much less than the water deficit libraries perhaps reflecting the shorter (24 h) exposure to stress. Genes with greater than five clones in any specific library were identified and, based on the number of clones obtained, the fold increase or decrease in expression in the libraries was calculated and verified by semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction. Genes, of particular note, that code for the following proteins were overexpressed in the low-temperature libraries: dehydrin and metallothionein-like proteins, ubiquitin proteins, a dormancy-associated protein, a plasma membrane intrinsic protein and an RNA-binding protein. Genes that were upregulated in the water deficit libraries fell mainly into the functional categories of stress (heat shock proteins, dehydrins) and photosynthesis. With few exceptions, the overall differences in downregulated genes were nominal compared with differences in upregulated genes. The results of this apple study are similar to other global studies of plant response to stress but offer a more detailed analysis of specific tissue response (bark vs xylem vs leaf vs root) and a comparison between an acute stress (24-h exposure to low temperature) and a chronic stress (2 weeks of water deficit).

Fire Blight: Applied Genomic Insights of the Pathogen and Host

The enterobacterial phytopathogen Erwinia amylovora causes fire blight, an invasive disease that threatens a wide range of commercial and ornamental Rosaceae host plants. The response elicited by E. amylovora in its host during disease development is similar to the hypersensitive reaction that typically leads to resistance in an incompatible host-pathogen interaction, yet no gene-for-gene resistance has been described for this host-pathogen system. Comparative genomic analysis has found an unprecedented degree of genetic uniformity among strains of E. amylovora, suggesting that the pathogen has undergone a recent genetic bottleneck. The genome of apple, an important host of E. amylovora, has been sequenced, creating new opportunities for the study of interactions between host and pathogen during fire blight development and for the identification of resistance genes. This review includes recent advances in the genomics of both host and pathogen.

Overexpression of a peach CBF gene in apple: a model for understanding the integration of growth, dormancy, and cold hardiness in woody plants

The timing of cold acclimation and deacclimation, dormancy, and budbreak play an integral role in the life cycle of woody plants. The molecular events that regulate these parameters have been the subject of much study, however, in most studies these events have been investigated independently of each other. Ectopic expression of a peach CBF (PpCBF1) in apple increases the level of both non-acclimated and acclimated freezing tolerance relative to the non-transformed control, and also inhibits growth, induces early bud set and leaf senescence, and delays bud break in the spring. The current study examined differences in the seasonal expression of genes (CBF, DAM, RGL, and EBB) that have been reported to be associated with freezing tolerance, dormancy, growth, and bud break, respectively, in the PpCBF1 T166 transgenic apple line and the non-transformed M.26 control. Results indicated that expression of several of these key genes, including MdDAM, MdRGL, and MdEBB was altered in transgenic T166 trees relative to non-transformed M.26 trees. In particular, several putative MdDAM genes, associated with the dormancy-cycle in other species of woody plants in the Rosaceae, exhibited different patterns of expression in the T166 vs. M.26 trees. Additionally, for the first time a putative APETALA2/Ethylene-responsive transcription factor, originally described in poplar and shown to regulate the timing of bud break, was shown to be associated with the timing of bud break in apple. Since the overexpression of PpCBF1 in apple results in a dramatic alteration in cold acclimation, dormancy, and growth, this transgenic line (T166) may represent a useful model for studying the integration of these seasonal life-cycle parameters.

Factors affecting the transformation of 'Marshall McIntosh' apple by Agrobacterium tumefaciens

The goal of this research was to develop an efficient transformation system for Marshall McIntosh apple. To determine the optimum combination of agar and Gelrite gelling agents in the media to maximize regeneration and minimize hyperhydicity (vitrification), the following combinations of agar (A)+Gelrite (G) in g l-1 were tested: 7.0 A+0 G; 5.2 A+0.6 G; 3.5 A+2.5 G; 1.7 A+1.8 G; and 0 A+2.5 G. Both 5.2 A+0.6 G and 3.5 A+1.2 G provided greatest regeneration of healthy non-hyperhydric shoots. To determine the optimal concentration of aminoglycoside for the selection and regeneration of transgenic Marshall McIntosh on agar-Gelrite-based media, kanamycin was tested at 0, 10, 25, 50, 75 and 100 mg l-1, and paromomycin was tested at 0, 50, 100, 150, 200 and 250 mg l-1. Kanamycin was more effective than paromomycin in the initial selection of transgenics. For selection of transformants of Marshall McIntosh, the use of kanamycin at 25 mg l-1on 5.2 A+0.6 G solidified medium is suggested. By optimizing the medium and selection conditions, a protocol was developed that resulted in four transgenic lines as confirmed by a GUS assay, NPT II ELISA, PCR, and Southern analysis. In repeated experiments with this protocol, transformation efficiencies of 3.1 and 2.6% were obtained.