John M. Martell

Wear is a function of use, not time

Polyethylene wear (linear penetration) in 37 hip replacements was assessed from digital images using a validated two-dimensional, edge detection-based computer algorithm. Patient activity was assessed with a pedometer, a step activity monitor and a simple visual analog scale. Joint use was related to wear at the 90% confidence level. Without three recognized outliers, wear was highly correlated to use. The visual analog scale activity rating was significantly related to wear for the 24 hip replacements with standard polyethylene. Univariate regression analysis indicated that male gender, height, weight (which were both highly correlated to male gender) and hip center of rotation were significantly correlated to wear. Multivariate regression analysis indicated that male gender, femoral off-set, and Hylamer® were significantly correlated to wear. Based on the wear and activity data from the 24 hip replacements with standard polyethylene, the average volumetric wear rate per million cycles with a 70 kg patient weight was 30 mm3. This unique in vivo result can be considered a target wear rate for standard polyethylene in hip simulator studies.

Determination of Polyethylene Wear in Total Hip Replacements with Use of Digital Radiographs

We describe a computer-assisted vector wear technique for the determination of polyethylene wear on digital radiographs. Twenty-five hips that had had a total hip arthroplasty were used to evaluate the repeatability and performance of three radiographic techniques to measure wear of the acetabular polyethylene liner: the manual technique with use of calipers described by Livermore et al., the same technique with use of a digitizing tablet, and our new technique of computer-assisted vector wear analysis. We found our new technique to be at least ten times more repeatable than the technique with use of either calipers or a digitizing tablet. Fourteen of the polyethylene liners were retrieved at autopsy, and the actual measurements of wear of those liners were compared with the measurements that had been obtained with the three radiographic techniques of wear analysis. Computer-assisted vector wear analysis outperformed the manual techniques of Livermore et al. When compared with the data obtained from the specimens retrieved at autopsy, the measurement of wear determined with the computer-assisted technique differed by an average of 0.08 millimeter, whereas the measurements obtained with use of calipers and use of a digitizing tablet differed by 0.26 and 0.25 millimeter, respectively. The performance of computer-assisted vector wear analysis in the clinical setting was evaluated with use of controls with known amounts of wear. These were mounted in pelvic phantoms, and radiographs were made with use of a setup that simulated the clinical setting. Analysis of nine controls with 2.0 millimeters of wear yielded an average measurement of wear (and a standard deviation) of 1.99 ± 0.21 millimeters. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Computer-assisted vector wear analysis demonstrated superior repeatability and accuracy compared with current techniques of manual analysis. Improved repeatability and accuracy in the determination of polyethylene wear should facilitate the investigation of factors related to the prosthesis and to the patient that affect the rates of wear.

Primary total hip reconstruction with a titanium fiber-coated prosthesis inserted without cement

A prospective study was done of the intermediate-term clinical and radiographic results of 121 total hip arthroplasties in which a Harris-Galante porous titanium-fiber-coated prosthesis was inserted without cement in 110 patients. The average age at the time of the operation was forty-nine years (range, twenty to seventy years). The average duration of follow-up was sixty-seven months (range, fifty-five to seventy-nine months). The average preoperative Harris hip score was 55 points, and the average postoperative score was 93 points. One acetabular component was revised due to recurrent dislocation. Eleven femoral implants were unstable, and of these, four were revised. Cortical erosion was present around the distal part of the femoral stem in nine patients (8 per cent) who had stable implants, and one of these femoral implants was revised because the erosion was extensive. Survivorship analysis at five years revealed a 97 per cent chance of survival (95 per cent confidence limit, 0.937 to 1.0) of the Harris-Galante femoral-stem implant inserted without cement.

Clinical performance of a highly cross-linked polyethylene at two years in total hip arthroplasty: a randomized prospective trial

We report the 2-year results for a prospective randomized trial comparing highly cross-linked with standard polyethylene in total hip replacements. In our study, 46 hips were available for radiographic analysis at 2- and 3-year follow-up. Femoral bearings were 28-mm cobalt chrome with the polyethylene insert randomly selected at the time of implantation to be highly cross-linked polyethylene (Crossfire; Stryker Howmedica Osteonics, Allendale, NJ) or standard polyethylene (N(2)/Vac, Stryker Howmedica Osteonics). Polyethylene wear rates were measured based on anterior-posterior (AP) and lateral pelvis radiographs at 6 weeks and at yearly intervals using a validated computer-assisted edge-detection method. Wear rates between the 2 groups were compared using the nonparametric Mann-Whitney test at the 95% level. A significant reduction in 2- and 3-dimensional linear wear rates (42% and 50%) was found in the highly cross-linked group (P =.001 and P =.005).

Validation of two and three-dimensional radiographic techniques for measuring polyethylene wear after total hip arthroplasty.

Background: Three-dimensional radiographic techniques have been developed to estimate in vivo polyethylene wear of total hip replacements. We are not aware of any published study examining the accuracy of these in vivo methods. Our objective was to validate two radiographic techniques by comparing their results with those obtained directly from retrieved specimens. Methods: A coordinate measuring machine was used to probe the interior bearing surface of seventeen acetabular liners that had been retrieved at revision surgery. Solid models were created to determine volumetric polyethylene loss and linear depth and direction of wear. Two in vivo radiographic techniques (PolyWare and the Martell Hip Analysis Suite) were used to calculate two-dimensional linear, three-dimensional linear, and volumetric wear. The radiographic analysis was done independently, and the results were compared with the known values of polyethylene wear derived with use of the coordinate measuring machine. Results: Correlation coefficients comparing the values for two-dimensional and three-dimensional linear wear and volumetric wear derived with the PolyWare radiographic technique with the values derived with the coordinate measuring machine were r 2 = 0.78, r 2 = 0.75, and r 2 = 0.91, respectively (all p < 0.001), and the correlation coefficients comparing the values derived with the Martell Hip Analysis Suite radiographic technique with those derived with the coordinate measuring machine were r 2 = 0.80, r 2 = 0.84, and r 2 = 0.91, respectively (p < 0.001). The average absolute difference between the radiographic estimates and the results derived with the coordinate measuring machine was approximately 19% (range, 13% to 24%). Conclusions: There was good agreement between the wear estimates made with both in vivo techniques and the measurements of the retrieved polyethylene liners made with the coordinate measuring machine. Two-dimensional wear analysis (based on anteroposterior radiographs) accounted for most of the polyethylene wear, while one technique of three-dimensional wear analysis (PolyWare) demonstrated some additional wear in the lateral plane. Clinical Relevance: The use of two-dimensional measurements, based solely on an anteroposterior radiograph, may suffice in the clinical setting. In this series, these techniques detected relatively large changes in femoral head penetration.

Comparison of two and three-dimensional computerized polyethylene wear analysis after total hip arthroplasty

Background: The accurate determination of acetabular polyethylene wear in vivo is necessary to assess the clinical performance of the bearing surfaces of total hip replacements. Our objective in this study was to determine the clinical performance of two and three-dimensional computerized wear analysis and to assess the implications of this performance on requirements for patient enrollment in studies designed to detect wear of total hip prostheses.Methods: Two and three-dimensional digital computerized analyses of acetabular polyethylene wear were performed on 153 hips in 140 patients. The acetabular components consisted of a polyethylene insert in a titanium shell, articulating with a 28-mm cobalt-chromium femoral component. The average duration of radiographic follow-up was 8.4 years. The correlation coefficient for two-dimensional versus three-dimensional analysis was calculated, as was the difference between the wear detected by the two techniques. The same observer analyzed each image twice, allowing an assessment of the repeatability of the two-dimensional and three-dimensional analyses. The impact of the clinical performance of each technique on the sample size needed for adequate power in prospective studies was evaluated.Results: There was a high correlation between two-dimensional and three-dimensional wear analysis (r 2 = 0.933). In thirty-one (5.2%) of 595 observations, the wear values derived with the two-dimensional and three-dimensional techniques were not consistent. Logistic regression demonstrated that acetabular anteversion had a significant effect on the likelihood of such inconsistency occurring. The two-dimensional technique detected 90.1% of the total linear wear subsequently detected by the three-dimensional analysis. The average wear value was 1.09 mm as detected by two-dimensional analysis and 1.21 mm as detected by three-dimensional analysis. The two-dimensional technique was four times more repeatable than the three-dimensional technique. Power analysis indicated that up to 1.4 times more patients need to be enrolled if the three-dimensional technique is used for wear analysis.Conclusions: While three-dimensional analysis detected 10% more wear, its repeatability was four times worse than that of the two-dimensional technique and, as a consequence, patient enrollment requirements for wear detection were higher. The poor quality of the lateral radiographs contributed to the decrease in the repeatability of the three-dimensional analysis. Three-dimensional analysis may be useful for highly anteverted cups, but the limited improvement in wear detection achieved with that technique, coupled with its inferior repeatability, limits its clinical value.Level of Evidence: Diagnostic study, Level IV-2 (poor reference standard). See Instructions to Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

The role of patient factors and implant position in squeaking of ceramic-on-ceramic total hip replacements

We investigated factors that were thought to be associated with an increased incidence of squeaking of ceramic-on-ceramic total hip replacements. Between June 1997 and December 2008 the three senior authors implanted 2406 primary total hip replacements with a ceramic-on-ceramic bearing surface. The mean follow-up was 10.6 years. The diagnosis was primary osteoarthritis in each case, and no patient had undergone previous surgery to the hip. We identified 74 squeaking hips (73 patients) giving an incidence of 3.1% at a mean follow-up of 9.5 years (4.1 to 13.3). Taller, heavier and younger patients were significantly more likely to have hips that squeaked. Squeaking hips had a significantly higher range of post-operative internal (p = 0.001) and external rotation (p = 0.003) compared with silent hips. Patients with squeaking hips had significantly higher activity levels (p = 0.009). A squeaking hip was not associated with a significant difference in patient satisfaction (p = 0.24) or Harris hip score (p = 0.34). Four implant position factors enabled good prediction of squeaking. These were high acetabular component inclination, high femoral offset, lateralisation of the hip centre and either high or low acetabular component anteversion. This is the largest study to date to examine patient factors and implant position factors that predispose to squeaking of a ceramic-on-ceramic hip. The results suggest that factors which increase the mechanical forces across the hip joint and factors which increase the risk of neck-to-rim impingement, and therefore edge-loading, are those that predispose to squeaking.

Cementless Acetabular Reconstruction and Structural Bone-Grafting in Dysplastic Hips

BACKGROUND Studies of acetabular reconstruction with use of cement and bulk bone graft have demonstrated increasing rates of cup failure in patients with dysplastic hips seven years after total hip arthroplasty. Comparable data on the long-term results of bulk bone-grafting done in conjunction with cementless implants are limited. The aim of this study was to review the clinical and radiographic results of autologous bulk bone-grafting in conjunction with a cementless cup. METHODS From 1987 to 1992, forty-seven patients (forty women and seven men, with an average age of 50.4 years) who had developmental dysplasia of the hip underwent fifty-six total hip arthroplasties and received a structural graft in combination with a cementless Harris-Galante type-I cup. All patients were followed prospectively. In fifty-five hips, implant migration was measured with single-image radiographic analysis. RESULTS After an average duration (and standard deviation) of 10.2 +/- 2.9 years, three patients (four hips) had died. In the surviving patients, four implants had been revised and two had radiographic evidence of loosening. With use of revision and loosening as end points, the eleven-year survival rates were 91.6% and 88.9%, respectively. Of the fifty implants that had no loosening, fourteen had measurable cup migration, thirty-five had no migration, and one implant could not be measured. All migrations but one were progressive. With loosening used as the end point, the survival rate at eleven years was 100% for the implants with no migration; however, the survival rate for the cups that had migrated was 69.3% (p = 0.0012). CONCLUSIONS The eleven-year survival rate for the spherical press-fit cups in combination with bulk bone-grafting is satisfactory, given the complexity of these reconstructions. However, the difference between the survival of the implants that had migrated and those that had not was significant. We expect that the thirteen implants with progressive acetabular migration at the time of the latest follow-up are at risk for loosening, which will increase the revision rate for this series in the coming years.

Comparison of femoral head penetration using RSA and the Martell method.

Radiostereometry has high precision and accuracy measuring polyethylene wear in total hip arthroplasty but requires a specialized setup. The Martell method is simpler and can be used on larger populations. The hypothesis that the radiostereometry analysis and the Martell analysis would yield comparable wear data from the same group of patients having total hip arthroplasty was tested. A group of twenty-five total hip arthroplasty patients who had both radiostereometry and standard anterior-posterior pelvic and cross-table lateral radiographs of sufficient quality for analysis were identified. The films were taken at postoperative periods of 6 weeks, 1 year, 2 years, and 5 years. Femoral head penetration was measured by both methods at each time point. The median penetration rates measured by each method decreased over time. Penetration results were affected by method of analysis, time, and dimension, with greater penetration for Martell compared with radiostereometry at each time point, greater penetration with increasing time for each method, and larger three-dimensional magnitude compared with two-dimensional analysis. Level of Evidence: Case series Level IV. See Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Total hip replacement with insertion of an acetabular component without cement and a femoral component with cement. Four to seven-year results.

One hundred and fifty-three so-called hybrid total hip replacements were performed in 142 patients from 1985 to 1987 at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Lukes Medical Center. A hemispherical porous-coated acetabular component was inserted without cement and was fixed with screws, and a femoral stem was inserted with the use of so-called third-generation cementing techniques. The average age of the patients at the time of the operation was sixty-seven years (range, thirty-nine to eighty-five years). The average preoperative Harris hip score was 46 points (range, 9 to 73 points). One hundred and eleven patients (120 hips) were available for clinical review; 100 of these patients (109 hips) had a complete set of radiographs available. The average Harris hip score was 86 points (range, 29 to 100 points) at the time of follow-up (average duration, sixty-two months; range, forty-eight to eighty-five months). There was progressive migration of one cup (1 per cent); another cup migrated one centimeter in the first two years after the operation, with no additional migration evident after that time. The remaining acetabular components were stable. Two femoral components (2 per cent) were determined to be definitely loose. The remaining femoral components were stable. This population of patients had a good result after so-called hybrid total hip replacement with insertion of a porous-coated acetabular component without cement and a femoral component with cement for the reconstruction of a painful hip.