John R. Silvius

Membrane Phosphatidylserine Regulates Surface Charge and Protein Localization

Electrostatic interactions with negatively charged membranes contribute to the subcellular targeting of proteins with polybasic clusters or cationic domains. Although the anionic phospholipid phosphatidylserine is comparatively abundant, its contribution to the surface charge of individual cellular membranes is unknown, partly because of the lack of reagents to analyze its distribution in intact cells. We developed a biosensor to study the subcellular distribution of phosphatidylserine and found that it binds the cytosolic leaflets of the plasma membrane, as well as endosomes and lysosomes. The negative charge associated with the presence of phosphatidylserine directed proteins with moderately positive charge to the endocytic pathway. More strongly cationic proteins, normally associated with the plasma membrane, relocalized to endocytic compartments when the plasma membrane surface charge decreased on calcium influx.

Interactions of mammalian cells with lipid dispersions containing novel metabolizable cationic amphiphiles

Several novel cationic amphiphiles, based on a hydrophobic cholesteryl or dioleoylglyceryl moiety, have been prepared whose hydrophobic and cationic portions are linked by ester bonds to facilitate efficient degradation in animal cells. Dispersions combining such cationic species with phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), certain structural analogues of PE or diacylglycerol can mediate efficient transfer of both nonexchangeable lipid probes and the DNA plasmid pSV2cat into cultured mammalian (CV-1 and 3T3) cells. The abilities of different types of cationic lipid dispersions to mediate transfection of mammalian cells with pSV2cat could not be directly correlated with their abilities to coalesce with other membranes, as assessed by their ability to intermix lipids efficiently with large unilamellar phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylserine vesicles in the presence or absence of DNA. The cytotoxicities toward CV-1 cells of dispersions combining PE with most of the degradable cationic amphiphiles studied here compare favorably with those reported previously for similar dispersions containing other types of cationic amphiphiles. Fluorescent analogues of two of the diacylglycerol-based cationic amphiphiles examined in this study are shown to be readily degraded after incorporation into CV-1 cells from PE/cationic lipid dispersions.

Use of Cyclodextrins to Monitor Transbilayer Movement and Differential Lipid Affinities of Cholesterol

In view of the demonstrated cholesterol-binding capabilities of certain cyclodextrins, we have examined whether these agents can also catalyze efficient transfer of cholesterol between lipid vesicles. We here demonstrate that beta- and gamma-cyclodextrins can dramatically accelerate the rate of cholesterol transfer between lipid vesicles under conditions where a negligible fraction of the sterol is bound to cyclodextrin in steady state. beta- and gamma-cyclodextrin enhance the rate of transfer of cholesterol between vesicles by a larger factor than they accelerate the transfer of phospholipid, whereas, for alpha- and methyl-beta-cyclodextrin, the opposite is true. Analysis of the kinetics of cyclodextrin-mediated cholesterol transfer between large unilamellar vesicles composed mainly of 1-stearoyl-2-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine (SOPC) or SOPC/cholesterol indicates that transbilayer flip-flop of cholesterol is very rapid (halftime < 1-2 min at 37 degrees C). Using beta-cyclodextrin to accelerate cholesterol transfer, we have measured the relative affinities of cholesterol for a variety of different lipid species. Our results show strong variations in cholesterol affinity for phospholipids bearing different degrees of chain unsaturation and lesser, albeit significant, effects of phospholipid headgroup structure on cholesterol-binding affinity. Our findings also confirm previous suggestions that cholesterol interacts with markedly higher affinity with sphingolipids than with common membrane phospholipids.

Fluorescence Energy Transfer Reveals Microdomain Formation at Physiological Temperatures in Lipid Mixtures Modeling the Outer Leaflet of the Plasma Membrane

An approach is described using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) to detect inhomogeneity in lipid organization, on distance scales of the order of tens of nanometers or greater, in lipid bilayers. This approach compares the efficiency of energy transfer between two matched fluorescent lipid donors, differing in their affinities for ordered versus disordered regions of the bilayer, and an acceptor lipid that distributes preferentially into disordered regions. Inhomogeneities in bilayer organization, on spatial scales of tens of nanometers or greater, are detected as a marked difference in the efficiencies of quenching of fluorescence of the two donor species by the acceptor. Using a novel pair of 7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl (NBD)-labeled tetraacyl lipids as donor species with a rhodaminyl-labeled acceptor, this strategy faithfully reports homo- versus inhomogeneous mixing in each of several lipid bilayer systems whose organization on the FRET distance scale can be predicted from previous findings. Interestingly, however, the present FRET method reports clear evidence of inhomogeneity in the organization of mixtures combining sphingomyelin or saturated phospholipids with unsaturated phospholipids and physiological proportions of cholesterol, even at physiological temperatures where these systems have been reported to appear homogeneous by fluorescence microscopy. These results indicate that under physiological conditions, lipid mixtures mimicking the lipid composition of the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane can form domains on a spatial scale comparable to that inferred for the dimensions of lipid rafts in biological membranes.

Sphingolipid Partitioning into Ordered Domains in Cholesterol-Free and Cholesterol-Containing Lipid Bilayers

We have used fluorescence-quenching measurements to characterize the partitioning of a variety of indolyl-labeled phospho- and sphingolipids between gel or liquid-ordered and liquid-disordered lipid domains in several types of lipid bilayers where such domains coexist. In both cholesterol-free and cholesterol-containing lipid mixtures, sphingolipids with diverse polar headgroups (ranging from sphingomyelin and monoglycosylceramides to ganglioside GM1) show a net preference for partitioning into ordered domains, which varies modestly in magnitude with varying headgroup structure. The affinities of different sphingolipids for ordered lipid domains do not vary in a consistent manner with the size or other simple structural properties of the polar headgroup, such that for example ganglioside GM1 partitions between ordered and disordered lipid domains in a manner very similar to sphingomyelin. Ceramide exhibits a dramatically higher affinity for ordered lipid domains in both cholesterol-free and cholesterol-containing bilayers than do other sphingolipids. Our findings suggest that sphingolipids with a variety of headgroup structures will be enriched by substantial factors in liquid-ordered versus liquid-disordered regions of membranes, in a manner that is only modestly dependent on the nature of the polar headgroup. Ceramide is predicted to show a very strong enrichment in such domains, supporting previous suggestions that ceramide-mediated signaling may be compartmentalized to liquid-ordered (raft and raft-related) domains in the plasma membrane.

Fluorescence-Based Evaluation of the Partitioning of Lipids and Lipidated Peptides into Liquid-Ordered Lipid Microdomains: A Model for Molecular Partitioning into “Lipid Rafts”

A fluorescence-quenching assay is described that can directly monitor the relative extents of partitioning of different but structurally homologous fluorescent molecules into liquid-ordered (l(o)) domains in lipid vesicles exhibiting liquid-ordered/liquid-disordered (l(o)/l(d)) phase coexistence. Applying this assay to a series of bimane-labeled diacyl phospholipid probes in cholesterol-containing ternary lipid mixtures exhibiting l(o)/l(d) phase separation, we demonstrate that partitioning into l(o)-phase domains is negligible for diunsaturated species and greatest for long-chain disaturated species. These conclusions agree well with those derived from previous studies of the association of lipids and lipid-anchored molecules with l(o)-phase domains, using methods based on the isolation of a detergent-insoluble fraction from model or biological membranes at low temperatures. However, we also find that monounsaturated and shorter-chain saturated species partition into l(o) phases with significant, albeit modest affinities, and that the level of partitioning of these latter species into l(o)-phase domains is significantly underestimated (relative to that of their long-chain saturated counterparts) by the criterion of low-temperature detergent insolubility. Finally, applying the fluorescence-quenching method to a family of lipid-modified peptides, we demonstrate that the S-palmitoyl/S-isoprenyl dual-lipidation motif found in proteins such as H- and N-ras and yeast Ste18p does not promote significant association with l(o) domains in l(o)/l(d)-phase-separated bilayers.

Fluorescence-quenching and resonance energy transfer studies of lipid microdomains in model and biological membranes (Review)

Measurements of contact-dependent fluorescence quenching and of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) within bilayers provide information concerning the spatial relationships between molecules on distance scales of a few nm or up a few tens of nm, respectively, and are therefore well suited to detect the presence and composition of membrane microdomains. As described in this review, techniques based on fluorescence quenching and FRET have been used to demonstrate the formation of nanoscale liquid-ordered domains in cholesterol-containing model membranes under physiological conditions, and to investigate the structural features of lipids and proteins that influence their partitioning between liquid-ordered and liquid-disordered domains. FRET-based methods have also been used to test for the presence of ‘raft’ microdomains in the plasma membranes of mammalian cells. We discuss the sometimes divergent findings of these studies, possible modifications to the ‘raft hypothesis’ suggested by studies using FRET and other techniques, and the further potential of FRET-based methods to test and to refine current models of the nature and organization of membrane microdomains.

Proving Lipid Rafts Exist: Membrane Domains in the Prokaryote Borrelia burgdorferi Have the Same Properties as Eukaryotic Lipid Rafts

Lipid rafts in eukaryotic cells are sphingolipid and cholesterol-rich, ordered membrane regions that have been postulated to play roles in many membrane functions, including infection. We previously demonstrated the existence of cholesterol-lipid-rich domains in membranes of the prokaryote, B. burgdorferi, the causative agent of Lyme disease [LaRocca et al. (2010) Cell Host & Microbe 8, 331–342]. Here, we show that these prokaryote membrane domains have the hallmarks of eukaryotic lipid rafts, despite lacking sphingolipids. Substitution experiments replacing cholesterol lipids with a set of sterols, ranging from strongly raft-promoting to raft-inhibiting when mixed with eukaryotic sphingolipids, showed that sterols that can support ordered domain formation are both necessary and sufficient for formation of B. burgdorferi membrane domains that can be detected by transmission electron microscopy or in living organisms by Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). Raft-supporting sterols were also necessary and sufficient for formation of high amounts of detergent resistant membranes from B. burgdorferi. Furthermore, having saturated acyl chains was required for a biotinylated lipid to associate with the cholesterol-lipid-rich domains in B. burgdorferi, another characteristic identical to that of eukaryotic lipid rafts. Sterols supporting ordered domain formation were also necessary and sufficient to maintain B. burgdorferi membrane integrity, and thus critical to the life of the organism. These findings provide compelling evidence for the existence of lipid rafts and show that the same principles of lipid raft formation apply to prokaryotes and eukaryotes despite marked differences in their lipid compositions.

Solid- and liquid-phase equilibria in phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylethanolamine mixtures. A calorimetric study

Phase diagrams have been determined for mixing of binary mixtures of phosphatidylethanolamines (PE) with phosphatidylcholines (PC), using high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry and allowing extensive incubation times to equilibrate samples in the solid phase. All of the PE-PC systems examined, which contained saturated or trans-unsaturated PC components, showed limited solid-phase miscibility, chiefly because the PC component can adopt more solid phases than the PE component. For the dielaidoyl PE-PC system, the lamellar-to-hexagonal II transition endotherm seen at 63.5 degrees C for the pure PE is shifted to considerably higher temperatures upon incorporation of even low mole fractions of PC. All of the PE-PC systems examined here reveal a complete miscibility in the liquid phase, including the dipalmitoyl PE-dielaidoyl PC system for which limited liquid-phase miscibility had previously been suggested (Wu, S-H. and McConnell, H.M. (1975) Biochemistry 14, 847-854). However, PE-PC mixing appears to be less nearly ideal than the mixing of either PE or PC with anionic phospholipids. Our results demonstrate that calorimetry can be useful in determining accurate phase diagrams for lipid mixtures of this type, but only if proper attention is given to the existence and the proper equilibration of multiple solid phases in these systems.

Steric and not structure-specific factors dictate the endocytic mechanism of glycosylphosphatidylinositol-anchored proteins

Diverse glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored proteins enter mammalian cells via the clathrin- and dynamin-independent, Arf1-regulated GPI-enriched early endosomal compartment/clathrin-independent carrier endocytic pathway. To characterize the determinants of GPI protein targeting to this pathway, we have used fluorescence microscopic analyses to compare the internalization of artificial lipid-anchored proteins, endogenous membrane proteins, and membrane lipid markers in Chinese hamster ovary cells. Soluble proteins, anchored to cell-inserted saturated or unsaturated phosphatidylethanolamine (PE)-polyethyleneglycols (PEGs), closely resemble the GPI-anchored folate receptor but differ markedly from the transferrin receptor, membrane lipid markers, and even protein-free PE-PEGs, both in their distribution in peripheral endocytic vesicles and in the manner in which their endocytic uptake responds to manipulations of cellular Arf1 or dynamin activity. These findings suggest that the distinctive endocytic targeting of GPI proteins requires neither biospecific recognition of their GPI anchors nor affinity for ordered-lipid microdomains but is determined by a more fundamental property, the steric bulk of the lipid-anchored protein.