John V. Planz

Mutation rates at Y chromosome short tandem repeats in Texas populations

Father-son pairs from three populations (African American, Caucasian, and Hispanic) of Texas were typed for the 17 Y STR markers DYS19, DYS385, DYS389I, DYS389II, DYS390, DYS391, DYS392, DYS393, DYS437, DYS438, DYS439, DYS456, DYS458, DYS635, DYS448, and Y GATA H4 using the AmpFlSTR YfilerTM kit. With 49,578 allele transfers, 102 mutations were detected. One three-step and four two-step mutations were found, and all others (95.1%) were one-step mutations. The number of gains (48) and losses (54) of repeats were nearly similar. The average mutation rate in the total population is 2.1 x 10(-3) per locus (95% CI (1.7-2.5)x10(-3)). African Americans showed a higher mutation rate (3.0 x 10(-3); 95% CI (2.4-4.0)x10(-3)) than the Caucasians (1.7 x 10(-3); 95% CI (1.1-2.5)x10(-3)) and Hispanics (1.5 x 10(-3); 95% CI (1.0-2.2)x10(-3)), but grouped by repeat-lengths, such differences were not significant. Mutation is correlated with relative length of alleles, i.e., longer alleles are more likely to mutate compared with the shorter ones at the same locus. Mutation rates are also correlated with the absolute number of repeats, namely, alleles with higher number of repeats are more likely to mutate than the shorter ones (p-value=0.030). Finally, occurrences of none, one, and two mutations over the father-son transmission of alleles were consistent with the assumption of independence of mutation rates across loci.

Haplotype block: a new type of forensic DNA markers

Forensic DNA analysis is currently performed using highly discriminating short tandem repeat (STR) markers. SNPs are being investigated as adjunct tools for human identity testing because of their abundance in the human genome, utility for genotyping degraded DNA samples, and amenability to automation. While SNPs can provide an alternative approach, on a per locus basis they have a lower power of discrimination (PD) than STRs. With the discovery of block structures in the human genome, a novel set of SNP markers are available for further exploration of forensic utility. Several neighboring, tightly linked SNPs are inherited together and form a haplotype block, which as a haploblock has a higher discrimination power than the individual SNPs within the block. Candidate haplotype blocks were selected from three major populations (Caucasian, East Asian, and African) using the following parameters: maximum match probability reduction = 0.85, linkage disequilibrium (LD) r2 ≥ 0.7, maximum Fst = 0.06, minimum number of SNPs = 3, minimum heterozygosity = 0.2, and minimum number of haplotypes = 3. From the HapMap Phase II data, 253 haploblocks were identified on the 22 autosomal chromosomes. After removing haploblocks deviating from the Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) or in LD with other haploblocks, 24 haploblocks remained as candidates for forensic consideration. The cumulative PD of these blocks can reach 10−12 in the populations studied. The data support within and between haplotype independence even when they are syntenic. We propose guidelines for evidence interpretation that address the application of haplotype blocks for transfer evidence, mixture, and kinship analyses.

Null allele sequence structure at the DYS448 locus and implications for profile interpretation.

Null alleles can occur with any PCR-based STR typing system. They generally are due to deletions within the target region or primer binding sites or by primer binding site mutations that destabilize hybridization of at least one of the primers flanking the target region. Although not common, null types were detected at the DYS448 locus in seven out of 1,005 unrelated males in the Hispanic population. Of these DYS448 null types, four individuals displayed an apparent duplication at the DYS437 locus. The additional allele observed at the DYS437 locus is in actuality a smaller-sized DYS448 amplicon, which is the result of a deletion of the invariant N42 base pair domain and downstream repeats within the DYS448 locus. Thus, some DYS448 null types are not truly null. A true DYS448 null allele carried numerous primer binding site variants and a large deletion including the N42 base pair domain and surrounding or downstream repeat regions. The presence of null alleles is not a real concern for interpretation of Y STR loci evidence; current methods for interpreting Y STR profiles easily accommodate such phenomena.

US forensic Y-chromosome short tandem repeats database

A forensic Y-STR database generated in the US was compiled with profiles containing a portion or complete typing of 16 STR markers DYS19, DYS385, DYS389I, DYS389II, DYS390, DYS391, DYS392, DYS393, DYS437, DYS438, DYS439, DYS456, DYS458, DYS635, DYS448, and Y GATA H4. There were 17,447 samples in the version of database in which 77% and 20% were collected in North America and Asia, respectively. The database was separated into six general populations, African American, Asian, Caucasian, Hispanic, Indian, and Native American. Each population was further classified into subgroups according to geographic regions. Some subgroups were tested, found to be homogenous and merged together. Allele and haplotype frequencies, as well as sample sizes were summarized. Of the full haplotypes (i.e., 16 STRs without missing data), 93.7% in total population were distinct, 92.9% were population specific, and 89.3% were only observed once. The majority of shared haplotypes were found among North American populations as a result of admixture lasting the past few hundred years. The power of discrimination (PD), coancestry coefficient (F(st)), and coefficient of gene differentiation (G(st)) at locus and haplotype levels were also calculated. The most polymorphic marker was DYS385; this marker contains a tandem duplication and actually is composed of two loci. Both G(st) and F(st) estimates were very small with haplotypes composed of a high number of STRs haplotypes (e.g., 10-16 markers), although G(st) is slightly more conservative for these extended haplotypes. With Native American removed from the total population data set, the G(st) and F(st) estimates reduce further. PD was 0.9998 for the total population dataset for all 16 Y-STR markers. Three measures of Y-STR profile frequency were calculated: (1) unconditional haplotype frequency, (2) population substructure adjusted frequency, and (3) binomial upper bound of the haplotype frequency. The binomial upper bound is the most conservative estimate for most forensic applications. Estimates of the weight of a Y-STR haplotype can be estimated using population specific or total population databases.

Automated analysis of sequence polymorphism in STR alleles by PCR and direct electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Short tandem repeats (STRs) are the primary genetic markers used for the analysis of biological samples in forensic and human identity testing. The discrimination power of a combination of STRs is sufficient in many human identity testing comparisons unless the evidence is substantially compromised and/or there are insufficient relatives or a potential mutation may have arisen in kinship analyses. An automated STR assay system that is based on electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) has been developed that can increase the discrimination power of some of the CODIS core STR loci and thus provide more information in typical and challenged samples and cases. Data from the ESI-MS STR system is fully backwards compatible with existing STR typing results generated by capillary electrophoresis. In contrast, however, the ESI-MS analytical system also reveals nucleotide polymorphisms residing within the STR alleles. The presence of these polymorphisms expands the number of alleles at a locus. Population studies were performed on the 13 core CODIS STR loci from African Americans, Caucasians and Hispanics capturing both the length of the allele, as well as nucleotide variations contained within repeat motifs or flanking regions. Such additional polymorphisms were identified in 11 of the 13 loci examined whereby several nominal length alleles were subdivided. A substantial increase in heterozygosity was observed, with close to or greater than 5% of samples analyzed being heterozygous with equal-length alleles in at least one of five of the core CODIS loci. This additional polymorphism increases discrimination power significantly, whereby the seven most polymorphic STR loci have a discrimination power equivalent to the 10 most discriminating of the CODIS core loci. An analysis of substructure among the three population groups revealed a higher θ than would be observed compared with using alleles designated by nominal length, i.e., repeats solely. Two loci, D3S1358 and vWA produced θ estimates of 0.0477 and 0.0234, respectively, when the expanded allele complement (i.e., nominal allele and SNPs) was considered compared to 0.0145 and 0.01266, respectively when only nominal repeat number was considered. These differences may indicate underlying population specific allele distributions exist within these populations. A system of nomenclature has been developed that facilitates the databasing, searching and analyses of these combined data forms.

Genetic composition of six miniSTR in a Brazilian Mulatto sample population

The present study characterizes the genetic variability of Mulatto population based on the polymorphism of six miniSTR autosomal loci, known as Non Codis 01 and 02 (NC01 and NC02) and evaluate their applicability in forensic genetics. A sample of 102 unrelated Brazilian mulattoes were genotyped for miniSTR loci D1S1677, D2S441, D4S2364 (miniplex NC02) and 45 individuals for D10S1248, D14S1434, D22S1045 (miniplex NC01). No significant deviations from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium expectations were detected. The combined power of discrimination (PD) and mean power of exclusion (PE) were 0.999996 and 0.98991, respectively. The results also support the effectiveness of the NC01and NC02 miniplexes for human identification.

Molecular Diagnostic Applications in Forensic Science

Publisher Summary This chapter describes the general characteristics of short tandem repeats on Y chromosomes (Y-STRs) in forensic analyses, analytic procedures for typing Y-STR loci, and general interpretation issues. Y-chromosome DNA resides in the nucleus, but its markers differ in some respects from the autosomal loci. Most of the DNA in the Y-chromosome is non-recombinant, with only the most distal portions of the chromosome able to recombine with the X-chromosome. Barring mutation, the Y-linked DNA types are identical for all paternal relatives, including male siblings. This characteristic is helpful in human identity cases, such as those involving the analysis of the remains of a missing person. In such cases, known paternal relatives can provide reference samples for direct comparison to the unknown Y-linked DNA types. A set of markers residing on the Y-chromosome enable the analysis of samples, such as mixtures composed of minute amounts of male DNA amid a large background of female DNA. Issues to be considered when implementing DNA typing methods for Y-STRs are exemplified and core sets of Y-STR loci are defined. Molecular diagnostic applications in forensic science require the methods to be validated and developed for placing statistical weight on an evidence profile that matches a reference sample profile, quality assurance measures to be implemented, and interpretation guidelines instituted.