Jole Messa

Cryptic deletions are a common finding in “balanced” reciprocal and complex chromosome rearrangements: a study of 59 patients

Using array comparative genome hybridisation (CGH) 41 de novo reciprocal translocations and 18 de novo complex chromosome rearrangements (CCRs) were screened. All cases had been interpreted as “balanced” by conventional cytogenetics. In all, 27 cases of reciprocal translocations were detected in patients with an abnormal phenotype, and after array CGH analysis, 11 were found to be unbalanced. Thus 40% (11 of 27) of patients with a “chromosomal phenotype” and an apparently balanced translocation were in fact unbalanced, and 18% (5 of 27) of the reciprocal translocations were instead complex rearrangements with >3 breakpoints. Fourteen fetuses with de novo, apparently balanced translocations, all but two with normal ultrasound findings, were also analysed and all were found to be normal using array CGH. Thirteen CCRs were detected in patients with abnormal phenotypes, two in women who had experienced repeated spontaneous abortions and three in fetuses. Sixteen patients were found to have unbalanced mutations, with up to 4 deletions. These results suggest that genome-wide array CGH may be advisable in all carriers of “balanced” CCRs. The parental origin of the deletions was investigated in 5 reciprocal translocations and 11 CCRs; all were found to be paternal. Using customised platforms in seven cases of CCRs, the deletion breakpoints were narrowed down to regions of a few hundred base pairs in length. No susceptibility motifs were associated with the imbalances. These results show that the phenotypic abnormalities of apparently balanced de novo CCRs are mainly due to cryptic deletions and that spermatogenesis is more prone to generate multiple chaotic chromosome imbalances and reciprocal translocations than oogenesis.

Duplications in addition to terminal deletions are present in a proportion of ring chromosomes. Clues to the mechanisms of formation

Background and methods: Ring chromosomes are often associated with abnormal phenotypes because of loss of genomic material at one or both ends. In some cases no deletion has been detected and the abnormal phenotype has been attributed to mitotic ring instability. We investigated 33 different ring chromosomes in patients with phenotypic abnormalities by array based comparative genomic hybridisation (CGH) and fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH). Results: In seven cases we found not only the expected terminal deletion but also a contiguous duplication. FISH analysis in some of these cases demonstrated that the duplication was inverted. Thus these ring chromosomes derived through a classical inv dup del rearrangement consisting of a deletion and an inverted duplication. Discussion: Inv dup del rearrangements have been reported for several chromosomes, but hardly ever in ring chromosomes. Our findings highlight a new mechanism for the formation of some ring chromosomes and show that inv dup del rearrangements may be stabilised not only through telomere healing and telomere capture but also through circularisation. This type of mechanism must be kept in mind when evaluating possible genotype–phenotype correlations in ring chromosomes since in these cases: (1) the deletion may be larger or smaller than first estimated based on the size of the ring, with a different impact on the phenotype; and (2) the associated duplication will in general cause further phenotypic anomalies and might confuse the genotype–phenotype correlation. Moreover, these findings explain some phenotypic peculiarities which previously were attributed to a wide phenotypic variation or hidden mosaicism related to the instability of the ring.

Loss-of-function mutation of the AF9/MLLT3 gene in a girl with neuromotor development delay, cerebellar ataxia, and epilepsy

The human AF9/MLLT3 gene is a common fusion partner for the MLL gene in translocations t(9;11)(p22;q23) associated with acute myeloid leukemia and acute lymphocytic leukemia. The exact function of the gene is still unknown, although a mouse knock-out model points to a role as a controller of embryo patterning. We report the case of a constitutional translocation t(4;9)(q35;p22) disrupting the AF9/MLLT3 gene in a girl with neuromotor development delay, cerebellar ataxia and epilepsy. Array-CGH analysis at 1 Mbase resolution did not reveal any additional deletions/duplications. We hypothesize a loss-of-function mutation of the AF9/MLLT3 gene, and a possible role for the FAT gene on chromosome 4, in the genesis of the proband’s severe neurological phenotype.

Ring syndrome: still true?

We thank Zollino et al for giving us the opportunity to discuss the ring syndrome and its related short stature. According to Cote et al 1 and Kosztolanyi,2 ring syndrome is essentially characterised by severe growth failure that can even be the sole major physical abnormality. The common growth deficiency observed across many patients with diverse ring chromosomes suggested that this phenomenon is due to mitotic instability and tissue specific mosaicism.2 A reduction in growth is one of the most common findings in patients with autosomal imbalances with a characteristic intrauterine and growth retardation.3 This can be due both to the imbalance of dosage sensitive genes involved in stature or to a general morbidity state superimposed on the malformation syndrome. Growth hormone deficiency resulting in extremely short stature has also been reported in several chromosome imbalances such as trip(22)(pter->q11),4 del(18p),5 del(15q)(q11–q13),6 7 and it seems to be related to hypothalamic dysfunction or anatomical abnormalities of …

Loss‐of‐Function FANCL Mutations Associate with Severe Fanconi Anemia Overlapping the VACTERL Association

The diagnosis of VACTERL syndrome can be elusive, especially in the prenatal life, due to the presence of malformations that overlap those present in other genetic conditions, including the Fanconi anemia (FA). We report on three VACTERL cases within two families, where the two who arrived to be born died shortly after birth due to severe organs’ malformations. The suspicion of VACTERL association was based on prenatal ultrasound assessment and postnatal features. Subsequent chromosome breakage analysis suggested the diagnosis of FA. Finally, by next‐generation sequencing based on the analysis of the exome in one family and of a panel of Fanconi genes in the second one, we identified novel FANCL truncating mutations in both families. We used ectopic expression of wild‐type FANCL to functionally correct the cellular FA phenotype for both mutations. Our study emphasizes that the diagnosis of FA should be considered when VACTERL association is suspected. Furthermore, we show that loss‐of‐function mutations in FANCL result in a severe clinical phenotype characterized by early postnatal death.

Subtelomeric FISH analysis in 76 patients with syndromic developmental delay/intellectual disability

BackgroundIntellectual disability affects approximately 1 to 3% of the general population. The etiology is still poorly understood and it is estimated that one-half of the cases are due to genetic factors. Cryptic subtelomeric aberrations have been found in roughly 5 to 7% of all cases.MethodsWe performed a subtelomeric FISH analysis on 76 unrelated children with normal standard karyotype ascertained by developmental delay or intellectual disability, associated with congenital malformations, and/or facial dysmorphisms.ResultsTen cryptic chromosomal anomalies have been identified in the whole cohort (13,16%), 8 in the group of patients characterized by developmental delay or intellectual disability associated with congenital malformations and facial dysmorphisms, 2 in patients with developmental delay or intellectual disability and facial dysmorphisms only.ConclusionWe demonstrate that a careful clinical examination is a very useful tool for pre-selection of patients for genomic analysis, clearly enhancing the chromosomal anomaly detection rate. Clinical features of most of these patients are consistent with the corresponding emerging chromosome phenotypes, pointing out these new clinical syndromes associated with specific genomic imbalances.

Direct duplication 12p11.21-p13.31 mediated by segmental duplications : a new recurrent rearrangement?

We describe the characterization of an interstitial duplication of 12p, dup(12)(p11.21p13.31), by array-CGH and FISH in a patient with mental retardation and dysmorphic features. The sequence analysis of the breakpoints revealed the presence of homologous low copy repeats (LCRs) flanking the duplication region, thus suggesting that they have mediated the rearrangement. Pip-maker analysis showed that a third cluster of homologous LCRs lie distally to the two mediating the 12p duplication. We hypothesize that this duplication might be a new recurrent rearrangement and that, thanks to the different orientations of the homologous regions lying within each cluster, the three clusters are responsible for at least some of the several 12p aneuploidies reported in the literature such as direct and inverted duplications, deletions and supernumerary analphoid chromosomes. Moreover, we excluded that polymorphic inversions between these three clusters are present in the normal population.

A prenatal case of duplication with terminal deletion of 5p not identified by conventional cytogenetics

A 4-year long prospective study referring to secondtrimester termination of pregnancy due to fetal malformation revealed chromosomal anomalies in about 16% of the 57 cases with congenital malformation diagnosed by ultrasound examination and confirmed by fetal autopsy (Akgun et al., 2007). It is possible that many of the fetuses thought to have a normal karyotype, have instead cryptic chromosomal deletions or duplications that cannot be detected by conventional cytogenetic techniques. In fact, Mefford et al. (2007) found that 6% of autopsy samples from 155 fetuses (128 with normal karyotype, and 27 without any karyotype information) with well-defined developmental pathologies had cryptic imbalances detected through an array-based comparative genomic hybridization (array-CGH) containing bacterial artificial chromosomes (BACs) targeted to rearrangement hotspots. Here we report a 24-year-old woman who underwent chorionic villus sampling, after a diagnosis of cystic hygroma in the first trimester of pregnancy. Although chromosome analysis on cells from both short and long term cultures preparation at a resolution of about 320–400 bands did not reveal any numerical or structural rearrangement (Figure 1), array-CGH analysis on fetal blood after termination of pregnancy revealed a de novo large rearrangement on the short arm of one chromosome 5 with a deletion of at least 25 Mb of the short arm of the chromosome 5 and a contiguous duplication of 20.3 Mb (Figure 1). Thus, the karyotype of the fetus was 46,XY,del(5)(pter-p14.1),dup(5)(p14.1p11). Microsatellite analysis demonstrated the paternal origin of the rearranged chromosome 5 with maternal alleles present only in the deletion region. The area of paternal allelic peaks in the duplication region was double in respect to the maternal alleles (Table 1). The woman was referred for cytogenetic evaluation between the 12th and the 13th week of pregnancy

Idiopathic central precocious puberty associated with 11 mb de novo distal deletion of the chromosome 9 short arm.

We report a girl with a de novo distal deletion of 9p affected by idiopathic central precocious puberty and intellectual disability. Genome-wide array-CGH revealed a terminal deletion of about 11 Mb, allowing to define her karyotype as 46; XX, del(9)(p23-pter). To our knowledge, this is the second reported case of precocious puberty associated with 9p distal deletion. A third case associates precocious puberty with a more proximal 9p deletion del(9)(p12p13,3). In our case, more than 40 genes were encompassed in the deleted region, among which, DMRT1 which is gonad-specific and has a sexually dimorphic expression pattern and ERMP1 which is required in rats for the organization of somatic cells and oocytes into discrete follicular structures. Although we cannot exclude that precocious puberty in our del(9p) patient is a coincidental finding, the report of the other two patients with 9p deletions and precocious puberty indeed suggests a causative relationship.