Jonathan D. Moore

Pin1 inhibitors: Pitfalls, progress and cellular pharmacology.

Compelling data supports the hypothesis that Pin1 inhibitors will be useful for the therapy of cancer: Pin1 deficient mice resist the induction of breast cancers normally evoked by expression of MMTV-driven Ras or Erb2 alleles. While Pin1 poses challenges for drug discovery, several groups have identified potent antagonists by structure based drug design, significant progress has been made designing peptidic inhibitors and a number of natural products have been found that blockade Pin1, notably epigallocatchechin gallate (EGCG), a major flavonoid in green tea. Here we critically discuss the modes of action and likely specificity of these compounds, concluding that a suitable chemical biology tool for probing the function of Pin1 has yet to be found. We conclude by outlining some open questions regarding the target validation of Pin1 and the prospects for identification of improved inhibitors in the future.

Discovery of Cell-Active Phenyl-Imidazole Pin1 Inhibitors by Structure-Guided Fragment Evolution.

Pin1 is an emerging oncology target strongly implicated in Ras and ErbB2-mediated tumourigenesis. Pin1 isomerizes bonds linking phospho-serine/threonine moieties to proline enabling it to play a key role in proline-directed kinase signalling. Here we report a novel series of Pin1 inhibitors based on a phenyl imidazole acid core that contains sub-μM inhibitors. Compounds have been identified that block prostate cancer cell growth under conditions where Pin1 is essential.

Structure-guided design of α-amino acid-derived Pin1 inhibitors

The peptidyl prolyl cis/trans isomerase Pin1 is a promising molecular target for anti-cancer therapeutics. Here we report the structure-guided evolution of an indole 2-carboxylic acid fragment hit into a series of alpha-benzimidazolyl-substituted amino acids. Examples inhibited Pin1 activity with IC(50) <100nM, but were inactive on cells. Replacement of the benzimidazole ring with a naphthyl group resulted in a 10-50-fold loss in ligand potency, but these examples downregulated biomarkers of Pin1 activity and blocked proliferation of PC3 cells.

Fragment Screening by Weak Affinity Chromatography: Comparison with Established Techniques for Screening against HSP90

The increasing use of fragment-based lead discovery (FBLD) in industry as well as in academia creates a high demand for sensitive and reliable methods to detect the binding of fragments to act as starting points in drug discovery programs. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), surface plasmon resonance (SPR), and X-ray crystallography are well-established methods for fragment finding, and thermal shift and fluorescence polarization (FP) assays are used to a lesser extent. Weak affinity chromatography (WAC) was recently introduced as a new technology for fragment screening. The study presented here compares screening of 111 fragments against the ATPase domain of HSP90 by all of these methods, with isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) used to confirm the most potent hits. The study demonstrates that WAC is comparable to the established methods of ligand-based NMR and SPR as a hit-id method, with hit correlations of 88% and 83%, respectively. The stability of HSP90 WAC columns was also evaluated and found to give 90% reproducibility even after 207 days of storage. A good correlation was obtained between the various technologies, validating WAC as an effective technology for fragment screening.

Synthetic Lethal Targeting of ARID1A-Mutant Ovarian Clear Cell Tumors with Dasatinib

New targeted approaches to ovarian clear cell carcinomas (OCCC) are needed, given the limited treatment options in this disease and the poor response to standard chemotherapy. Using a series of high-throughput cell-based drug screens in OCCC tumor cell models, we have identified a synthetic lethal (SL) interaction between the kinase inhibitor dasatinib and a key driver in OCCC, ARID1A mutation. Imposing ARID1A deficiency upon a variety of human or mouse cells induced dasatinib sensitivity, both in vitro and in vivo, suggesting that this is a robust synthetic lethal interaction. The sensitivity of ARID1A-deficient cells to dasatinib was associated with G1–S cell-cycle arrest and was dependent upon both p21 and Rb. Using focused siRNA screens and kinase profiling, we showed that ARID1A-mutant OCCC tumor cells are addicted to the dasatinib target YES1. This suggests that dasatinib merits investigation for the treatment of patients with ARID1A-mutant OCCC. Mol Cancer Ther; 15(7); 1472–84. ©2016 AACR.

Targeting conserved water molecules: design of 4-aryl-5-cyanopyrrolo[2,3-d]pyrimidine Hsp90 inhibitors using fragment-based screening and structure-based optimization.

Inhibitors of the Hsp90 molecular chaperone are showing promise as anti-cancer agents. Here we describe a series of 4-aryl-5-cyanopyrrolo[2,3-d]pyrimidine ATP competitive Hsp90 inhibitors that were identified following structure-driven optimization of purine hits revealed by NMR based screening of a proprietary fragment library. Ligand-Hsp90 X-ray structures combined with molecular modeling led to the rational displacement of a conserved water molecule leading to enhanced affinity for Hsp90 as measured by fluorescence polarization, isothermal titration calorimetry and surface plasmon resonance assays. This displacement was achieved with a nitrile group, presenting an example of efficient gain in binding affinity with minimal increase in molecular weight. Some compounds in this chemical series inhibit the proliferation of human cancer cell lines in vitro and cause depletion of oncogenic Hsp90 client proteins and concomitant elevation of the co-chaperone Hsp70. In addition, one compound was demonstrated to be orally bioavailable in the mouse. This work demonstrates the power of structure-based design for the rapid evolution of potent Hsp90 inhibitors and the importance of considering conserved water molecules in drug design.

Transient treatment with CDK inhibitors eliminates proliferative potential even when their abilities to evoke apoptosis and DNA damage are blocked

Transient treatment with small molecule CDK inhibitors is toxic to cancer cells and leads to depletion of anti-apoptotic proteins and Chk1, coupled with DNA damage and induction of apoptosis. Here we have examined, which of these phenomena are necessary for CDK inhibitors to have an anti-proliferative effect. We find that 24 hours treatment with either a primarily CDK2-specific, or a primarily CDK7/9-specific, antagonist eliminates proliferative potential even if apoptosis is blocked and the tendency of CDK inhibition to result in DNA damage is overcome by expression of recombinant Chk1. Loss of proliferative potential is correlated with irreversible suppression of biomarkers of cell cycle progression. CDK inhibitors dramatically reduced levels of the anti-apoptotic proteins, Mcl-1 and XIAP, but siRNA-mediated suppression of Mcl-1 and XIAP did not induce cell death in the osteosarcoma cells used in this study. Finally, we found that many literature CDK inhibitors do not effectively suppress the CDK/cyclin complexes responsible for cell-cycle progression at the minimum doses required to block proliferation: some are only effective after a substantial delay and may act via inhibition of CDK7.

Application of Off-Rate Screening in the Identification of Novel Pan-Isoform Inhibitors of Pyruvate Dehydrogenase Kinase.

Libraries of nonpurified resorcinol amide derivatives were screened by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) to determine the binding dissociation constant (off-rate, kd) for compounds binding to the pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase (PDHK) enzyme. Parallel off-rate measurements against HSP90 and application of structure-based drug design enabled rapid hit to lead progression in a program to identify pan-isoform ATP-competitive inhibitors of PDHK. Lead optimization identified selective sub-100-nM inhibitors of the enzyme which significantly reduced phosphorylation of the E1α subunit in the PC3 cancer cell line in vitro.

Design of Leucine-Rich Repeat Kinase 2 (LRRK2) Inhibitors Using a Crystallographic Surrogate Derived from Checkpoint Kinase 1 (CHK1).

Mutations in leucine-rich repeat kinase 2 (LRRK2), such as G2019S, are associated with an increased risk of developing Parkinsons disease. Surrogates for the LRRK2 kinase domain based on checkpoint kinase 1 (CHK1) mutants were designed, expressed in insect cells infected with baculovirus, purified, and crystallized. X-ray structures of the surrogates complexed with known LRRK2 inhibitors rationalized compound potency and selectivity. The CHK1 10-point mutant was preferred, following assessment of surrogate binding affinity with LRRK2 inhibitors. Fragment hit-derived arylpyrrolo[2,3-b]pyridine LRRK2 inhibitors underwent structure-guided optimization using this crystallographic surrogate. LRRK2-pSer935 HEK293 IC50 data for 22 were consistent with binding to Ala2016 in LRRK2 (equivalent to Ala147 in CHK1 10-point mutant structure). Compound 22 was shown to be potent, moderately selective, orally available, and brain-penetrant in wild-type mice, and confirmation of target engagement was demonstrated, with LRRK2-pSer935 IC50 values for 22 in mouse brain and kidney being 1.3 and 5 nM, respectively.

Abstract 700: Investigating KRAS synthetic lethal/co-dependency interactions using siRNA and CRISPR

No molecularly targeted therapy has yet been identified for KRAS mutant cancers. As oncogenic mutations reduce RAS enzymatic activity, classic small molecule approaches are ineffective, hence most work has focussed on drugging RAS-effector pathways. Multiple inhibitors of MEK, RAF and PI3K have been identified but toxicity issues and pathway adaptation have stymied their success against KRAS-driven cancers. An alternative approach is to exploit “non-oncogene addiction” by identifying targets with synthetic lethal or co-dependence interactions with KRAS. A number of siRNA and shRNA screens have identified targets that exhibit differential dependencies between KRAS mutant and KRAS wild-type tumours, but there is poor overlap between the different published studies. This discordance may arise from (1) the noise inherent in using cell line panels differing in much more than their KRAS mutant/wild-type status and (2) the use of RNA interference methodologies driving incomplete knockdown and associated with substantial off-target effects. Next generation screens that exploit both isogenic cell lines and cell line panels, and use a combination of knockdown and knock-out (i.e. CRISPR/Cas9-sgRNA) methodologies, may be better suited for identifying novel targets that withstand validation. However, if we are to detect co-dependence as well as synthetic lethal interactions, screens must be performed under conditions where mutant KRAS alleles are essential for growth. A library of siRNAs targeting proposed KRAS synthetic lethal targets was assembled and screened under conditions where proliferation is dependent on KRAS status. DLD1 cells harbour an activating KRASG13D mutation dispensable for proliferation in 2D, but essential for proliferation under 3D (soft agar) conditions. Knockdown of several targets including KRAS itself, PLK1, TBK1, BCL-XL & RAF1 proved more anti-proliferative under 3D conditions. This screen was extended to a panel of KRAS-mutant colon lines, with varying levels of KRAS sensitivity, where we found the requirement for RAF1 highly correlated with the requirement for KRAS. With the advent of CRISPR we are now able to design sgRNA libraries capable of probing the effect of ‘knocking out’ rather than ‘knocking down’ targets, providing a potentially superior alternative to RNA interference. Data from mouse models indicates RAF1 is required for the initiation of lung cancer by oncogenic KRAS. Although we found good correlation between sensitivity to KRAS and RAF1 depletion, we were unable to unambiguously validate RAF1 as a target in human lung cancer cells using RNA interference methodologies. However, using CRISPR-Cas9, we found complete loss of RAF1 expression was anti-proliferative in A549 cells, supporting the concept of targeting RAF1 in a KRAS mutant lung cancers. These results demonstrate that a more penetrant sgRNA based screening approach may identify novel KRAS synthetic lethal or co-dependent interactions. Citation Format: Simon F. Scrace, Elpida Tsonou, Paul Russell, Julie A. Wickenden, Steffen Lawo, Tim M. Scales, Ceri M. Wiggins, Jonathan D. Moore. Investigating KRAS synthetic lethal/co-dependency interactions using siRNA and CRISPR. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 106th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2015 Apr 18-22; Philadelphia, PA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2015;75(15 Suppl):Abstract nr 700. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.AM2015-700