Jonathan M. Grasman

Biomimetic scaffolds for regeneration of volumetric muscle loss in skeletal muscle injuries

UNLABELLED Skeletal muscle injuries typically result from traumatic incidents such as combat injuries where soft-tissue extremity injuries are present in one of four cases. Further, about 4.5 million reconstructive surgical procedures are performed annually as a result of car accidents, cancer ablation, or cosmetic procedures. These combat- and trauma-induced skeletal muscle injuries are characterized by volumetric muscle loss (VML), which significantly reduces the functionality of the injured muscle. While skeletal muscle has an innate repair mechanism, it is unable to compensate for VML injuries because large amounts of tissue including connective tissue and basement membrane are removed or destroyed. This results in a significant need to develop off-the-shelf biomimetic scaffolds to direct skeletal muscle regeneration. Here, the structure and organization of native skeletal muscle tissue is described in order to reveal clear design parameters that are necessary for scaffolds to mimic in order to successfully regenerate muscular tissue. We review the literature with respect to the materials and methodologies used to develop scaffolds for skeletal muscle tissue regeneration as well as the limitations of these materials. We further discuss the variety of cell sources and different injury models to provide some context for the multiple approaches used to evaluate these scaffold materials. Recent findings are highlighted to address the state of the field and directions are outlined for future strategies, both in scaffold design and in the use of different injury models to evaluate these materials, for regenerating functional skeletal muscle. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE Volumetric muscle loss (VML) injuries result from traumatic incidents such as those presented from combat missions, where soft-tissue extremity injuries are represented in one of four cases. These injuries remove or destroy large amounts of skeletal muscle including the basement membrane and connective tissue, removing the structural, mechanical, and biochemical cues that usually direct its repair. This results in a significant need to develop off-the-shelf biomimetic scaffolds to direct skeletal muscle regeneration. In this review, we examine current strategies for the development of scaffold materials designed for skeletal muscle regeneration, highlighting advances and limitations associated with these methodologies. Finally, we identify future approaches to enhance skeletal muscle regeneration.

Rapid release of growth factors regenerates force output in volumetric muscle loss injuries.

A significant challenge in the design and development of biomaterial scaffolds is to incorporate mechanical and biochemical cues to direct organized tissue growth. In this study, we investigated the effect of hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) loaded, crosslinked fibrin (EDCn-HGF) microthread scaffolds on skeletal muscle regeneration in a mouse model of volumetric muscle loss (VML). The rapid, sustained release of HGF significantly enhanced the force production of muscle tissue 60 days after injury, recovering more than 200% of the force output relative to measurements recorded immediately after injury. HGF delivery increased the number of differentiating myoblasts 14 days after injury, and supported an enhanced angiogenic response. The architectural morphology of microthread scaffolds supported the ingrowth of nascent myofibers into the wound site, in contrast to fibrin gel implants which did not support functional regeneration. Together, these data suggest that EDCn-HGF microthreads recapitulate several of the regenerative cues lost in VML injuries, promote remodeling of functional muscle tissue, and enhance the functional regeneration of skeletal muscle. Further, by strategically incorporating specific biochemical factors and precisely tuning the structural and mechanical properties of fibrin microthreads, we have developed a powerful platform technology that may enhance regeneration in other axially aligned tissues.

Crosslinking strategies facilitate tunable structural properties of fibrin microthreads.

A significant challenge in the design of biomimetic scaffolds is combining morphologic, mechanical, and biochemical cues into a single construct to promote tissue regeneration. In this study, we analyzed the effects of different crosslinking conditions on fibrin biopolymer microthreads to create morphologic scaffolds with tunable mechanical properties that are designed for directional cell guidance. Fibrin microthreads were crosslinked using carbodiimides in either acidic or neutral buffer, and the mechanical, structural, and biochemical responses of the microthreads were investigated. Crosslinking in the presence of acidic buffer (EDCa) created microthreads that had significantly higher tensile strengths and moduli than all other microthreads, and failed at lower strains than all other microthreads. Microthreads crosslinked in neutral buffer (EDCn) were also significantly stronger and stiffer than uncrosslinked threads and were comparable to contracting muscle in stiffness. Swelling ratios of crosslinked microthreads were significantly different from each other and uncrosslinked controls, suggesting a difference in the internal organization and compaction of the microthreads. Using an in vitro degradation assay, we observed that EDCn microthreads degraded within 24h, six times slower than uncrosslinked control threads, but EDCa microthreads did not show any significant indication of degradation within the 7-day assay period. Microthreads with higher stiffnesses supported significantly increased attachment of C2C12 cells, as well as increases in cell proliferation without a decrease in cell viability. Taken together, these data demonstrate the ability to create microthreads with tunable mechanical and structural properties that differentially direct cellular functions. Ultimately, we anticipate that we can strategically exploit these properties to promote site-specific tissue regeneration.

Static axial stretching enhances the mechanical properties and cellular responses of fibrin microthreads

Fibrin microthreads are a platform technology that can be used for a variety of applications, and therefore the mechanical requirements of these microthreads differ for each tissue or device application. To develop biopolymer microthreads with tunable mechanical properties, we analyzed fibrin microthread processing conditions to strengthen the scaffold materials without the use of exogenous crosslinking agents. Fibrin microthreads were extruded, dried, rehydrated and static axially stretched 0-200% of their original lengths; then the mechanical and structural properties of the microthreads were assessed. Stretching significantly increased the tensile strength of microthreads 3-fold, yielding scaffolds with tensile strengths and stiffnesses that equaled or exceeded values reported previously for carbodiimide crosslinked threads without affecting intrinsic material properties such as strain hardening or Poissons ratio. Interestingly, these stretching conditions did not affect the rate of proteolytic degradation of the threads. The swelling ratios of stretched microthreads decreased, and scanning electron micrographs showed increases in grooved topography with increased stretch, suggesting that stretching may increase the fibrillar alignment of fibrin fibrils. The average cell alignment with respect to the longitudinal axis of the microthreads increased 2-fold with increased stretch, further supporting the hypothesis that stretching microthreads increases the alignment of fibrin fibrils on the surfaces of the scaffolds. Together, these data suggest that stretching fibrin microthreads generates stronger materials without affecting their proteolytic stability, making stretched microthreads ideal for implantable scaffolds that require short degradation times and large initial loading properties. Further modifications to stretched microthreads, such as carbodiimide crosslinking, could generate microthreads to direct cell orientation and align tissue deposition, with additional resistance to degradation for use as a long-term scaffold for tissue regeneration.

The Effect of Sterilization Methods on the Structural and Chemical Properties of Fibrin Microthread Scaffolds

A challenge for the design of scaffolds in tissue engineering is to determine a terminal sterilization method that will retain the structural and biochemical properties of the materials. Since commonly used heat and ionizing energy-based sterilization methods have been shown to alter the material properties of protein-based scaffolds, the effects of ethanol and ethylene oxide (EtO) sterilization on the cellular compatibility and the structural, chemical, and mechanical properties of uncrosslinked, UV crosslinked, or 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide (EDC) crosslinked fibrin microthreads in neutral (EDCn) or acidic (EDCa) buffers are evaluated. EtO sterilization significantly reduces the tensile strength of uncrosslinked microthreads. Surface chemistry analyses show that EtO sterilization induces alkylation of EDCa microthreads leading to a significant reduction in myoblast attachment. The material properties of EDCn microthreads do not appear to be affected by the sterilization method. These results significantly enhance the understanding of how sterilization or crosslinking techniques affect the material properties of protein scaffolds.

Human endothelial cells secrete neurotropic factors to direct axonal growth of peripheral nerves

Understanding how nerves spontaneously innervate tissues or regenerate small injuries is critical to enhance material-based interventions to regenerate large scale, traumatic injuries. During embryogenesis, neural and vascular tissues form interconnected, complex networks as a result of signaling between these tissue types. Here, we report that human endothelial cells (HUVECs) secrete brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), which significantly stimulated axonal growth from chicken or rat dorsal root ganglia (DRGs). HUVEC-conditioned medium was sufficient to enhance axonal growth, demonstrating that direct cell-cell contact was not required. When BDNF was neutralized, there was a significant reduction in axonal growth when incubated in HUVEC-conditioned medium and in direct co-culture with HUVECs. These data show that HUVECs secrete neurotrophic factors that significantly enhance axonal growth, and can inform future in vivo studies to direct or pattern the angiogenic response in regenerating tissues to encourage re-innervation.

Programmable Hydrogel Ionic Circuits for Biologically Matched Electronic Interfaces

The increased need for wearable and implantable medical devices has driven the demand for electronics that interface with living systems. Current bioelectronic systems have not fully resolved mismatches between engineered circuits and biological systems, including the resulting pain and damage to biological tissues. Here, salt/poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) aqueous two-phase systems are utilized to generate programmable hydrogel ionic circuits. High-conductivity salt-solution patterns are stably encapsulated within PEG hydrogel matrices using salt/PEG phase separation, which route ionic current with high resolution and enable localized delivery of electrical stimulation. This strategy allows designer electronics that match biological systems, including transparency, stretchability, complete aqueous-based connective interface, distribution of ionic electrical signals between engineered and biological systems, and avoidance of tissue damage from electrical stimulation. The potential of such systems is demonstrated by generating light-emitting diode (LED)-based displays, skin-mounted electronics, and stimulators that deliver localized current to in vitro neuron cultures and muscles in vivo with reduced adverse effects. Such electronic platforms may form the basis of future biointegrated electronic systems.

Design of an In Vitro Model of Cell Recruitment for Skeletal Muscle Regeneration Using HGF-Loaded Fibrin Microthreads

Large skeletal muscle defects that result in volumetric muscle loss (VML) result in the destruction of the basal lamina, which removes key signaling molecules such as hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) from the wound site, eliminating the endogenous capacity of these injuries to regenerate. We recently showed that HGF-loaded fibrin microthreads increased the force production in muscle tissues after 60 days in a mouse VML model. In this study, we created an in vitro, three-dimensional (3D) microscale outgrowth assay system designed to mimic cell recruitment in vivo, and investigated the effect of HGF-loaded, cross-linked fibrin microthreads on myoblast recruitment to predict the results observed in vivo. This outgrowth assay discretely separated the cellular and molecular functions (migration, proliferation, and chemotaxis) that direct outgrowth from the wound margin, creating a powerful platform to model cell recruitment in axially aligned tissues, such as skeletal muscle. The degree of cross-linking was controlled by pH and microthreads cross-linked using physiologically neutral pH (EDCn) facilitated the release of active HGF; increasing the two-dimensional migration and 3D outgrowth of myoblasts twofold. While HGF adsorbed to uncross-linked microthreads, it did not enhance myoblast migration, possibly due to the low concentrations that were adsorbed. Regardless of the amount of HGF adsorbed on the microthreads, myoblast proliferation increased significantly on stiffer, cross-linked microthreads. Together, the results of these studies show that HGF loaded onto EDCn microthreads supported enhanced myoblast migration and recruitment and suggest that our novel outgrowth assay system is a robust in vitro screening tool that predicts the performance of fibrin microthreads in vivo.

Enhancing cell recruitment onto crosslinked fibrin microthreads with hepatocyte growth factor

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) defects caused by major trauma lead to loss of muscle mass, mobility, and ultimately may result in tissue morbidity. These large-scale injuries destroy native tissue structures such as the basal lamina, which serves as a regenerative template for muscle regeneration. Our approach to the regeneration of VML injuries is to use fibrin microthreads, scaffolds with similar morphology to native muscle, and modulate their mechanical and structural properties to recapitulate cues lost with the destruction of native tissue structures. In this study, we investigated the effect of adsorbing hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) onto crosslinked microthreads on myoblast proliferation and recruitment in an in vitro model designed to mimic in vivo satellite cell recruitment and found that active HGF is released for 1-2 days and is capable of stimulating myoblast migration in both 2D and 3D models. These data suggest that HGF-adsorbed microthreads can recruit myoblasts to the wound site, ultimately leading to an enhanced regenerative response in VML injuries.