Josh Wimpenny

Chelyabinsk airburst, damage assessment, meteorite recovery, and characterization

Deep Impact? On 15 February 2013, the Russian district of Chelyabinsk, with a population of more than 1 million, suffered the impact and atmospheric explosion of a 20-meter-wide asteroid—the largest impact on Earth by an asteroid since 1908. Popova et al. (p. 1069, published online 7 November; see the Perspective by Chapman) provide a comprehensive description of this event and of the body that caused it, including detailed information on the asteroid orbit and atmospheric trajectory, damage assessment, and meteorite recovery and characterization. A detailed study of a recent asteroid impact provides an opportunity to calibrate the damage caused by these rare events. [Also see Perspective by Chapman] The asteroid impact near the Russian city of Chelyabinsk on 15 February 2013 was the largest airburst on Earth since the 1908 Tunguska event, causing a natural disaster in an area with a population exceeding one million. Because it occurred in an era with modern consumer electronics, field sensors, and laboratory techniques, unprecedented measurements were made of the impact event and the meteoroid that caused it. Here, we document the account of what happened, as understood now, using comprehensive data obtained from astronomy, planetary science, geophysics, meteorology, meteoritics, and cosmochemistry and from social science surveys. A good understanding of the Chelyabinsk incident provides an opportunity to calibrate the event, with implications for the study of near-Earth objects and developing hazard mitigation strategies for planetary protection.

Radar-Enabled Recovery of the Sutter’s Mill Meteorite, a Carbonaceous Chondrite Regolith Breccia

The Meteor That Fell to Earth In April 2012, a meteor was witnessed over the Sierra Nevada Mountains in California. Jenniskens et al. (p. 1583) used a combination of photographic and video images of the fireball coupled with Doppler weather radar images to facilitate the rapid recovery of meteorite fragments. A comprehensive analysis of some of these fragments shows that the Sutters Mill meteorite represents a new type of carbonaceous chondrite, a rare and primitive class of meteorites that contain clues to the origin and evolution of primitive materials in the solar system. The unexpected and complex nature of the fragments suggests that the surfaces of C-class asteroids, the presumed parent bodies of carbonaceous chondrites, are more complex than previously assumed. Analysis of this rare meteorite implies that the surfaces of C-class asteroids can be more complex than previously assumed. Doppler weather radar imaging enabled the rapid recovery of the Sutter’s Mill meteorite after a rare 4-kiloton of TNT–equivalent asteroid impact over the foothills of the Sierra Nevada in northern California. The recovered meteorites survived a record high-speed entry of 28.6 kilometers per second from an orbit close to that of Jupiter-family comets (Tisserand’s parameter = 2.8 ± 0.3). Sutter’s Mill is a regolith breccia composed of CM (Mighei)–type carbonaceous chondrite and highly reduced xenolithic materials. It exhibits considerable diversity of mineralogy, petrography, and isotope and organic chemistry, resulting from a complex formation history of the parent body surface. That diversity is quickly masked by alteration once in the terrestrial environment but will need to be considered when samples returned by missions to C-class asteroids are interpreted.

Crustal evolution of the South Mayo Trough, western Ireland, based on U–Pb ages and Hf–O isotopes in detrital zircons

Ordovician strata of the South Mayo Trough in western Ireland contain clastic deposits that represent materials eroded from a large and diverse continental area over a time scale that spans much of the Earth’s history. Therefore, it is a useful region to use detrital zircons to construct a continental crustal growth model. Here, we report integrated U–Pb, Lu–Hf and O isotope measurements obtained from in situ analyses of 160 zircons from the South Mayo Trough. U–Pb zircon crystallization ages define three major magmatic episodes of crustal reworking in the Archaean (Lewisian), Mesoproterozoic (Grenville), and Ordovician (Grampian). These data, together with oxygen isotope data and Hf model ages, suggest that crustal growth, recorded in the strata of the South Mayo Trough, started at c. 4 Ga and continued until 1.4 Ga, with two major growth periods at 2.3–2.1 and 2.0–1.5 Ga. We find that the crustal incubation time is decoupled from the duration of supracrustal alteration processes; some zircons with very long crustal incubation times have pristine mantle δ18O signatures suggesting minimal low-temperature surface processing in their source regions. Identifying such zircons is the key for future studies in constructing realistic net continental crustal growth models unaffected by crustal recycling. Supplementary materials: Data tables for U–Pb, Lu–Hf and oxygen isotopes for detrital zircons from South Mayo Trough, as well as plots of values for zircon standards (δ18O for R33, U–Pb ages for 91500 and R33, and 176Hf/177Hf for 91500, GJ-1, and Plešovice) and reverse concordia plots of zircon samples are available at www.geolsoc.org.uk/SUP18543.

Precise Determination of the Lutetium Isotopic Composition in Rocks and Minerals Using Multicollector ICPMS

Evidence of (176)Hf excess in select meteorites older than 4556Ma was suggested to be caused by excitation of long-lived natural radionuclide (176)Lu to its short-lived isomer (176m)Lu, due to an irradiation event during accretion in the early solar system. A result of this process would be a deficit in (176)Lu in irradiated samples by between 1‰ and 7‰. Previous measurements of the Lu isotope ratio in rock samples have not been of sufficient precision to resolve such a phenomenon. We present a new analytical technique designed to measure the (176)Lu/(175)Lu isotope ratio in rock samples to a precision of ~0.1‰ using a multicollector inductively coupled mass spectrometer (MC-ICPMS). To account for mass bias we normalized all unknowns to Ames Lu. To correct for any drift and instability associated with mass bias, all standards and samples are doped with W metal and normalized to the nominal W isotopic composition. Any instability in the mass bias is then corrected by characterizing the relationship between the fractionation factor of Lu and W, which is calculated at the start of every analytical session. After correction for isobaric interferences, in particular (176)Yb, we were able to measure (176)Lu/(175)Lu ratios in samples to a precision of ~0.1‰. However, these terrestrial standards were fractionated from Ames Lu by an average of 1.22 ± 0.09‰. This offset in (176)Lu/(175)Lu is probably caused by isotopic fractionation of Lu during industrial processing of the Ames Lu standard. To allow more straightforward data comparison we propose the use of NIST3130a as a bracketing standard in future studies. Relative to NIST3130a, the terrestrial standards have a final weighted mean δ(176)Lu value of 0.11 ± 0.09‰. All samples have uncertainties of better than 0.11‰; hence, our technique is fully capable of resolving any differences in δ(176)Lu of greater than 1‰.

THE LU ISOTOPIC COMPOSITION OF ACHONDRITES: CLOSING THE CASE FOR ACCELERATED DECAY OF {sup 176}LU

Studies of Lu–Hf isotope systematics in meteorites have produced apparent “ages” that are older than Pb–Pb ages and older than the estimated age of our solar system. One proposed explanation for this discrepancy is that irradiation by cosmic rays caused excitation of {sup 176}Lu to its short-lived isomer that then underwent rapid decay to {sup 176}Hf. This explanation can account for apparent excesses in {sup 176}Hf that correlate with Lu/Hf ratio. Mass balance requires that samples with measurable excess in {sup 176}Hf should also have measurable deficiencies in {sup 176}Lu on the order of 1‰–3‰. To unambiguously test the accelerated decay hypothesis, we have measured the {sup 176}Lu/{sup 175}Lu ratio in terrestrial materials and achondrites to search for evidence of depletion in {sup 176}Lu. To a precision of 0.1‰ terrestrial standards, cumulate and basaltic eucrites and angrites all have the same {sup 176}Lu/{sup 175}Lu ratio. Barring a subsequent mass-dependent fractionation event, these results suggest that the apparent excesses in {sup 176}Hf are not caused by accelerated decay of {sup 176}Lu, and so another hypothesis is required to explain apparently old Lu–Hf ages.