Justin B. Sperry

Fast photochemical oxidation of proteins for epitope mapping.

The growing use of monoclonal antibodies as therapeutics underscores the importance of epitope mapping as an essential step in characterizing antibody-antigen complexes. The use of protein footprinting coupled with mass spectrometry, which is emerging as a tool in structural biology, offers opportunities to map antibody-binding regions of antigens. We report here the use of footprinting via fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) with OH radicals to characterize the epitope of the serine protease thrombin. The data correlate well with previously published results that determined the epitope of thrombin. This study marks the first time oxidative labeling has been used for epitope mapping.

Complementary MS methods assist conformational characterization of antibodies with altered S-S bonding networks.

AbstractAs therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) become a major focus in biotechnology and a source of the next-generation drugs, new analytical methods or combination methods are needed for monitoring changes in higher order structure and effects of post-translational modifications. The complexity of these molecules and their vulnerability to structural change provide a serious challenge. We describe here the use of complementary mass spectrometry methods that not only characterize mutant mAbs but also may provide a general framework for characterizing higher order structure of other protein therapeutics and biosimilars. To frame the challenge, we selected members of the IgG2 subclass that have distinct disulfide isomeric structures as a model to evaluate an overall approach that uses ion mobility, top-down MS sequencing, and protein footprinting in the form of fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP). These three methods are rapid, sensitive, respond to subtle changes in conformation of Cys → Ser mutants of an IgG2, each representing a single disulfide isoform, and may be used in series to probe higher order structure. The outcome suggests that this approach of using various methods in combination can assist the development and quality control of protein therapeutics.

A mass spectrometric approach to the study of DNA-binding proteins: interaction of human TRF2 with telomeric DNA.

Human telomeric repeat binding factor 2 (hTRF2) is a protein that plays an important role in capping human telomeres to protect them from DNA damage repair systems. The ineffectiveness of hTRF2 may be linked to aging and cancer. We report the use of PLIMSTEX (protein-ligand interactions by mass spectrometry, titration, and H/D exchange) and selective acetylation of lysine residues to study the interaction of the DNA-binding domain and double-stranded telomeric DNA (repeats of TTAGGG). By increasing the resolution of PLIMSTEX to the peptide level, we localized the changes in deuterium uptake of hTRF2 as a function of varying amounts of a model oligodeoxynucleotide. From these experiments, we determined the affinity constant for binding to DNA, which is within a factor of 3 of the previously reported value. Amide H/D exchange revealed portions of the protein that have contacts with the phosphate backbone of DNA, whereas acetylation disclosed the decrease in solvent accessibility of regions containing Lys 447 and 488, which must be involved in interactions with the DNA major and minor grooves. These complementary approaches of amide H/D exchange and selective side chain modification can be employed effectively to pinpoint and quantify protein-ligand, in particular protein-DNA, interactions.

Mapping the Protein—Protein Interface between a Toxin and Its Cognate Antitoxin from the Bacterial Pathogen Streptococcus pyogenes

Protein--protein interactions are ubiquitous and essential for most biological processes. Although new proteomic technologies have generated large catalogs of interacting proteins, considerably less is known about these interactions at the molecular level, information that would aid in predicting protein interactions, designing therapeutics to alter these interactions, and understanding the effects of disease-producing mutations. Here we describe mapping the interacting surfaces of the bacterial toxin SPN (Streptococcus pyogenes NAD(+) hydrolase) in complex with its antitoxin IFS (immunity factor for SPN) by using hydrogen-deuterium amide exchange and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. This approach affords data in a relatively short time for small amounts of protein, typically 5-7 pmol per analysis. The results show a good correspondence with a recently determined crystal structure of the IFS--SPN complex but additionally provide strong evidence for a folding transition of the IFS protein that accompanies its binding to SPN. The outcome shows that mass-based chemical footprinting of protein interaction surfaces can provide information about protein dynamics that is not easily obtained by other methods and can potentially be applied to large, multiprotein complexes that are out of range for most solution-based methods of biophysical analysis.

Systematic Investigation of EDC/sNHS-Mediated Bioconjugation Reactions for Carboxylated Peptide Substrates

1-Ethyl-3-(3-(dimethylamino)propyl)carbodiimide (EDC) bioconjugations have been utilized in preparing variants for medical research. While there have been advances in optimizing the reaction for aqueous applications, there has been limited focus toward identifying conditions and side reactions that interfere with product formation. We present a systematic investigation of EDC/N-hydroxysulfosuccinimide (sNHS)-mediated bioconjugations on carboxylated peptides and small proteins. We identified yet-to-be-reported side products arising from both the reagents and substrates. Model peptides used in this study illustrate particular substrates are more susceptible to side reactions than others. From our studies, we found that bioconjugations are more efficient with high concentrations of amine nucleophile but not sNHS. Performing bioconjugations on a model affibody protein show that the trends established with model peptides hold for more complex systems.

A View on the Importance of “Multi-Attribute Method” for Measuring Purity of Biopharmaceuticals and Improving Overall Control Strategy

Today, we are experiencing unprecedented growth and innovation within the pharmaceutical industry. Established protein therapeutic modalities, such as recombinant human proteins, monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), and fusion proteins, are being used to treat previously unmet medical needs. Novel therapies such as bispecific T cell engagers (BiTEs), chimeric antigen T cell receptors (CARTs), siRNA, and gene therapies are paving the path towards increasingly personalized medicine. This advancement of new indications and therapeutic modalities is paralleled by development of new analytical technologies and methods that provide enhanced information content in a more efficient manner. Recently, a liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) multi-attribute method (MAM) has been developed and designed for improved simultaneous detection, identification, quantitation, and quality control (monitoring) of molecular attributes (Rogers et al. MAbs 7(5):881–90, 2015). Based on peptide mapping principles, this powerful tool represents a true advancement in testing methodology that can be utilized not only during product characterization, formulation development, stability testing, and development of the manufacturing process, but also as a platform quality control method in dispositioning clinical materials for both innovative biotherapeutics and biosimilars.

Application of Dual Protease Column for HDX-MS Analysis of Monoclonal Antibodies

A co-immobilized, dual protease column was developed and implemented to more efficiently digest IgG molecules for hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS). The low-pH proteolytic enzymes pepsin and type XIII protease from Aspergillus were packed into a single column to most effectively combine the complementary specificities. The method was optimized using an IgG2 monoclonal antibody as a substrate because they are known to be more difficult to efficiently digest. The general applicability of the method was then demonstrated using IgG1 and IgG4 mAbs. The dual protease column and optimized method yielded improved digestion efficiency, as measured by the increased number of smaller, overlapping peptides in comparison with pepsin or type XIII alone, making HDX-MS more suitable for measuring deuterium uptake with higher resolution. The enhanced digestion efficiency and increased sequence coverage enables the routine application of HDX-MS to all therapeutic IgG molecules for investigations of higher order structure, especially when posttranslational and storage-induced modifications are detected, providing further product understanding for structure-function relationships and ultimately ensuring clinical safety and efficacy.

The Effect of Physicochemical Modification on the Function of Antibodies Induced by Anti-Nicotine Vaccine in Mice

Smoking remains one of the major causes of morbidity and mortality worldwide. One approach to assisting smoking cessation is via anti-nicotine vaccines, composed of nicotine-like haptens conjugated to a carrier protein plus adjuvant(s). We have previously shown that the carrier, hapten, linker, hapten load, degree of conjugate aggregation, and presence of adducts can each influence the function (nicotine-binding capacity) of the antibody (Ab) induced. Herein, we extend those findings and show that tertiary structure is also critical to the induction of functional immune responses and that this can be influenced by conjugation conditions. We evaluated immunogenicity in mice using six lots of NIC7-CRM, a conjugate of 5-aminoethoxy-nicotine (Hapten 7), and a single point (glycine 52 to glutamic acid) mutant nontoxic form of diphtheria toxin, cross-reactive material 197 (CRM197), which were synthesized under different reaction conditions resulting in conjugates with equivalent molecular characteristics (hapten load, aggregates, adducts), but a different tertiary structure. When tested in mice, better functional responses (reduced nicotine in the brain of immunized animals relative to non-immunized controls) were obtained with conjugates with a more closed structure than those with an open conformation. These studies highlight the need for a better understanding of the physicochemical properties of small molecule conjugate vaccines.

Editorial and Review: 28th ASMS Sanibel Conference on Mass Spectrometry-Characterization of Protein Therapeutics by Mass Spectrometry

The28th ASMS Sanibel Conference held on January 21-24, 2016 at the Hilton Clearwater Hotel in Clearwater Beach, FL was on the topic of BCharacterization of Protein Therapeutics by Mass Spectrometry.^ It was the first Sanibel Conference on the topic of protein therapeutics, and it was coorganized by Guodong Chen of Bristol-Myers Squibb and Justin Sperry of Pfizer. The conference had 192 registrants (Figure 1, the second highest attendance in the history of the Sanibel Conference), representing 11 countries, and included leading scientists from industry, academia, and government laboratories joining together to discuss the applications and challenges associated with the characterization of proteinbased therapeutics. A total of 30 oral and 83 poster presentations were given in the midst of a few days of blustery weather. ASMS provided 20 travel awards to students, for which we were grateful. Seven corporate sponsors demonstrated their newest software/hardware technologies associated with protein therapeutic analysis. The topics of the conference were divided into areas that are currently challenging the industry: Sequence Analysis and Protein Stability, Product/Process-related Characterization, Higher Order Structure Analysis, AntibodyDrug Conjugates and In Vivo Quantitation, and Biosimilars and New Directions. The Thursday evening plenary lecture was given by Michael Gross from Washington University in St. Louis. Michael set the stage for the rest of the conference by discussing a total structural assessment of biotherapeutics using both low and high resolution mass spectrometry. BNative^ electrospray ionization MS continues to be at the forefront of intact protein analysis and, more recently, to its application to protein aggregation. Michael discussed the use of new extended mass range (EMR) technology with Orbitrap mass spectrometry for the study of superoxide dismutase-1 (SOD1) aggregation, a process that is yet to be fully understood. Expanding on native mass spectrometry in terms of primary sequence analysis, he provided examples of how electron capture dissociation (ECD) yields fragment ions of intact antibodies with flexible regions between the β-sheet rich domains. These fragment ions correlated with high B-factors by X-ray crystallography. A Fab–antigen complex, a common focus point for the biopharmaceutical industry, was studied with this technique to provide information on regions of the antibody that become more rigid upon antigen binding. His second focus area related to protein therapeutics that he discussed was the use of footprinting to study higher-order structure. Hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HDX) and fast photo-