Juup Stelma

Reflective practice in developing world contexts: a general review of literature and a specific consideration of an Iranian experience

This paper begins with a review of an emerging set of studies, combining a critical focus on reflective teacher development in developing educational contexts, and a greater level of authorial identification (as compared with previous studies) with the contexts being researched. Next, the paper adds to this emerging literature an analysis of a teacher development initiative in Iran, aimed at giving a group of experienced English-as-a-foreign-language writing teachers time to reflect on their practice. This analysis reveals some shaping influences that appear similar to influences observed in other developing contexts. At the same time, the analysis highlights particularities of this Iranian context. Consistent with findings in other contexts, the teachers’ reflections focused on their working conditions, but did not go very far beyond understanding the challenges these conditions constituted. The teachers also talked about their limited engagement with professional literature, and reflected on how this may have affected their ability to enact new practices. Despite these constraints, the teachers did raise their awareness of various aspects of policy and practice, they did challenge aspects of the hierarchical Iranian education system, and over time they appeared to develop a heightened sense of professional agency.

Developing Intentionality and L2 Classroom Task-Engagement.

This paper extends work on intentionality, from philosophy, psychology and education to an exploration of learners’ meaning-making in L2 classroom task-engagement. The paper draws on both phenomenological and folk-psychological perspectives on intentionality, and employs John R. Searle’s intrinsic (mental) and derived (observable) intentionality as a key analytical distinction. The empirical focus of the paper is an exploration of learners’ meaning-making using a longitudinal data set of classroom and learner discourse from a Norwegian primary English-language classroom. The analysis details the teacher’s derived intentionality for the classroom activity, and then looks at how the learners generate their own intentionality through their joint task-engagement. The focus on learners’ developing intentionality is presented as a promising theoretical perspective on meaning-making in the L2 classroom, and as an addition to the analytical toolkit available to researchers investigating the dynamic nature of L2 task-engagement.

Intentionality and Complex Systems Theory: A New Direction for Language Learning Psychology

This chapter examines the combined potential of the constructs of intentionality and Complex Systems Theory, as a new theoretical direction for language learning psychology. The chapter begins with theoretical discussion of the properties of complex systems. This leads to the definition of a Complex System of Intentions, a conceptual model for understanding intentionalities that are present at individual, small group and societal levels, as well as their interrelations. Following that, key properties of the system are illustrated by juxtaposing empirical data from two research projects in Norway and Greece. First, we document the emergence of a ‘performance intentionality’ in learners’ interaction in an English L2 classroom in Norway. Next, we discuss how a ‘competition intentionality’ in a private language school in Greece emerged from interaction with the state school system, and we document its effects on language learning activity. In both cases, a data-driven analysis is used to demonstrate the emergence of the intentionalities and their generative effects, i.e., the ways in which they recursively shaped the system from which they had emerged. We conclude by revisiting the organisational openness of the system, and the processes of emergence and morphogenesis that were traced in the data, and by connecting them to Complex Systems Theory, while exploring the implications of a complexity outlook for language learning research.